5 ms·
Young adults in the U.S. are reaching key life milestones later than in the past
- jleyank 3y agoI'm an old fart, and my details are: out of parent's houses at 20, out of school at 24, financially independent at 25 and married at 26. Never had kids though, at least none with 2 legs. Was 1-2 years younger than my cohorts, and there was a wave of delaying kids until parents were 40-ish that seems to have weakened. Whole lot of girls with older parents it seems. What's today's trends with people going for advanced or professional degrees?
- fastneutron 3y agoI moved out of my parents’ at 18, finished undergrad and started my PhD at 21, married and had my first child towards the end of grad school at 26, and currently have 3 kids. Total household income is about $325k in a MCOL area. We became homeowners in 2019 during a narrow window of affordability and available housing inventory in our area. Had we waited, covid and the subsequent inflation and decreased inventory would have kept homeownership out of reach.
- jleyank 3y agoProps to you for grad school, marriage and kids. Didn't know too many who pulled off the first two, let alone all three.
- fastneutron 3y agoIt was extremely stressful at the time, but we made the strategic decision to have kids young while we have the energy. I can’t imagine being 10 years older and being able to keep up with everything.
- than3 3y ago> What's today's trends with people going for advanced or professional degrees? The vast majority don't actually make it through to graduation. In a 6 year period , something like 12-20% graduate for a 4 year degree depending on how they've (the college) decided to measure. Metrics aren't tracked to determine how much repeatability happened. That, for the most part is for those who can afford to go to school full time indefinitely which in Today's dollars amounts to roughly $15,000 per 6 months living expenses (if your smart without including books and tuition costs). Most degrees have general education that act as weed out classes that are designed and structured to fail. Core Physics in Engineering, Economics/Anthro in Business. Many classes also misrepresent the time commitment needed to succeed in the class. I've seen some 3-unit classes that have so many assignments that you had to spend 28 hours a week just completing them. In a 12 unit full-time load you would need to be able to put in 68+ hours a week for 16 weeks with just one of those classes. Sometimes you get two. Normally a 3-unit class should never require more than 9 hours of coursework a week but that rarely happens consistently. Older people going back to school would find themselves having to go to the emergency room if they had any stress related medical conditions with that kind of work load. Physics has the 3 question two test, where each question depends on the previous question's correct answer. You can only get the last problem wrong on either of those tests to pass. Its perfection or nothing. Economics is plagued with non-deterministic answers in their testing methodology for at least 30% of the questions for any course using Pearson resources (almost all use them). The reading material doesn't match the tested material, and you have to choose which answer is correct among 3 or 4 correct answers. By choose I mean guess because that's what it is without determinism properties which these lack but the professor and school lack rigor in applying it to coursework. I'm largely self-taught after failing college coursework for nearly two decades. Self taught through MIT's OCW and I do IT System's Administration/engineer responsibilities, no degree. Systems and Signals was probably one of the most important OCW courses I took (where they discuss these properties rigorously). I've completed up past Calc 3 into DiffEQ/Linear Algebra, I couldn't pass the physics because they inconsistently handle rounding rules on those causality spiraled tests. I gave up after try/fail #9 (not the same professor/college) where I got the only perfect at the college for the bundled lab portion/project which was pooled among all physics courses at that college, but not the three question test. The project was designing an egg drop that survives a 4 story drop with set materials from a pool of materials divied up exclusively between teams, I took the lead and we did it with a plastic bag, paper, and water. Escalating the academic dishonesty issues (students selling previous tests in the class to other students loudly with the teacher turning a blind eye), resulted in no action because the teacher had seniority over the Dean (straight from the Dean's mouth). Organic Chem is often one as well. Many of these course sections have an 8% pass rate or worse. Systemic issues reported get ignored, the escalation path is professor -> chair -> dean -> board of trustees. All teachers, all with the bureacratic mindset that doing any action will affect their standing so its better to do nothing at all in anything but clear cut fraud. Paying a teacher to teach, and then having them refer you to Khan Academy videos, not teach (no lecture), and autograde/refuse to correct issues on tests where material tested didn't match course materials; isn't fraud in their mind. Incidentally, they also don't consider revoking access to digital materials you purchased through a specific date, which are LMS locked, without any refund, fraud either after you withdraw. There's no requirement for investigatory action upon report and these people are all co-workers who are in it together. There's a lot of fraud involved with colleges and they largely have blanket legal protection. Unless you go to school outside the US you are faced with this, and predatory loans that can't be discharged in bankruptcy or cases of outright fraud. ITT tech happened in early 2000s, it was clearly fraud, and they only recently reached a settlement in 2022 to discharge the existing debt (but not refund interest payments). While that agreement was reached, I personally haven't heard from anyone involved in that actually completing the process for the discharge. Last I heard you had to submit additional paperwork that had to be just right which was error prone and stalling tactics. I've a few friends from HS where they went that route and regretted it. They are in their 40s now, not a homeowner, no kids, no wife, critically stunted from overbearing debt imo. The only other alternative for qualifications is professional certifications, and the same companies are involved with the same fraudulent practices. Extract as much money as possible, have government contracts for blanket legal protection, eliminate due process. Its rapidly becoming an unlivable world where you can't get ahead unless you were born wealthy or steal it. Most of us are raised from a young age to not steal, the existing environment encourages those who steal and get away with it, at the expense of those that follow ethics, morals and rules. Cheating and academic dishonesty is rampant because fraud & corruption is endemic to the system. Employers use the claim that you aren't qualified even when you are, simply because you don't have a certification or degree. I've turned down many job offers because they wanted me to come work for them at half-off for work I've a decade of experience at. Imagine what people who have no experience and no college have to deal with. Edit: Clarification
- hanklazard 3y ago“Whole lot of girls with older parents it seems.” That’s an interesting observation. Are you aware of any data on that?
- jleyank 3y agoIt’s anecdotal but based on 20-30 years observations. Recall reading something about the Y chromosome being more fragile so age and lab work would agree with this. Just knew lots of 40-ish coworkers and buddies with lots of girls and few boys.
- red-iron-pine 3y agoCan't speak to age, but there is a well known phenomenon that fighter pilots only have girls. What data there is backs that up, too. https://www.upi.com/Archives/1987/12/01/Air-Force-fliers-really-do-have-more-daughters/1667565333200/ https://www.upi.com/Archives/1987/12/01/Air-Force-fliers-rea... Wouldn't surprise me if similar factors, e.g. stress on the body via aging, also impact the Y chrom and lead to more girls.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- than3 3y agoUnfortunately the data is matched against the poverty line which is a bad measure when the cost of living is significantly higher than the poverty line. You'd probably see a much larger statistically significant move towards the negative if you accounted for many of the commonly known issues such as college graduations. Several of the milestones are measured in such a way that anyone taking a minimum wage job would meet several of those milestones since the poverty level is 13,590. That won't even cover rent let alone food, 150% of that is 20,385, after tax 18,346 net, not enough for food and rent so clearly not financially independent but counted as such in this study.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoWhen I see these generational comparisons, I often wonder how much of it simply comes down to urbanization. Urbanization brings High Cost of Living and higher Stakes. Homes are more expensive and a higher barrier. People can't live alone so they put off cohabitating or marrying. Anecdotally when I travel to the Midwest or other rural environments, I see meet lots of people who married young, bought houses young, and started families much earlier than peers in the city
- galleywest200 3y ago> Adults who are 21 are less likely than their predecessors four decades ago It usually takes four years to graduate college, if you go at 18 that means you exit at age 22. Seems that people going to college more now than they did 40 years ago could have a huge impact on this result.
- tssva 3y agoThe article specifically mentions this as a contributing factor.
- throwaway5959 3y agoMy wife and I are both successful professionals and we’re just now buying our first place in Southern California at almost 40. Meanwhile, a single guy I work with is buying a house at double the price we bought ours for at the age of 25. How? Mommy and daddy helped out with a downpayment. It just is what it is. We’re proud we did it on our own.
- nunez 3y agoIf it makes you feel better, their parents will probably use that down payment as leverage for a LONG time. "My house, my rules" and all that...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- victorstanciu 3y agoThat's just consolation fiction in the same vein as "bullies are cowards". I think the parent comment's take was better: It just is what it is. I'm happy with what I have, and I don't feel the need to imagine scenarios in which people better off than me are secretly unhappy.
- 6D794163636F756 3y agoI agree. My parents helped with my down payment and cosigned on my home and my partner's parents on theirs. Both were vehicles for them to pass on generational wealth and, more importantly, give an early start to our credit scores. There is no malice or control attached, just parents genuinely wanting the best for their kids.
- float4 3y agoDon't think so. I know many people here in the Netherlands who own a home at the age of 25 thanks to their parents, and their parents are generally actually nice people who just want to help their children out. It makes their kids happy and they like seeing their kids happy.
- clnq 3y agoAs a millennial, I cannot comprehend how 39% of people could have kids at 25. In between the financial crises, pandemics, and grinding hard to some day afford something meaningful. like actually appealing real estate, I am not close to having means to support another person. I think there's a baseline for the "child in household" metric. Some % of people will always want to have kids, no matter what circumstances. It's inelastic for them - whether times are great or they are just getting by, or even if they are below the poverty line, they will have kids. Maybe one in six, or one in five. I think a large proportion of people for whom the choice is dependent on circumstances are choosing to not have kids anymore, at least in their 20s.
- givemeethekeys 3y agoHere's how: - You don't live in a big city. Your overheads are quite low. You live in a low-tax state. The amount you'd pay in taxes in California is probably enough to have one more kid in Nevada. - You have familial wealth and / or help. You're with someone you want to be with, your parents are young enough to help you raise the munchkins. - When all your friends are having kids in their early 20's, there's plenty of pressure to have one too.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think community support is more important than all those factors. Having children is much easier when you are close to parents, friends, and family that share the load. If your family willing to babysit, that saves like 20K a year in a metro area. If your friends have kids, you don't have to choose between personal social time and child rearing. The realities of the world are set up such that you have positive feedback making it easier if your peers are having lots of kids, and negative feedback making it harder if your community is having fewer kids. I have friend groups that have lots of kids and it works out great for them. They socialize multiple times a week for dinners during the week or barbecues on the weekend. One parent will passively watch the kids while the other six or seven parents hang out and enjoy themselves. This lightens the load on everyone.
- mattpallissard 3y ago
- nine_zeros 3y agoNo surprise. Life is too precarious in America. You start at 18 with immense debt, jump through hoops in college, find a starting salary job, pay off student loans, buy a car on debt, rent an expensive apartment, dating sucks, isolation and loneliness, spend days and nights grinding for corporate America, PIPs, unreasonable expectations, then get laid off a few times while rent/housing price keeps rising, bullshit healthcare that takes too much of your time and energy - and suddenly you are 35 with undeveloped social skills, high debt, loneliness, PIP for corporate America, and no real assets to speak of. And you want us to reach life milestones sooner?
- throwaway5959 3y agoCompanies expect people to work constantly, especially since the pandemic. It’s ridiculous. Tech is totally different than what it was 10 years ago in terms of demands on people’s time.
- nine_zeros 3y ago> Companies expect people to work constantly, especially since the pandemic. It’s ridiculous. Tech is totally different than what it was 10 years ago in terms of demands on people’s time. Totally! The expectations have completely changed. Engineering used to be more like Architecture. You design stuff and then you manufacture it. But "managers" seem to want to treat it more like the warehouse where X number of packages must be shipped in this sprint.
- than3 3y ago> And you want us to reach life milestones sooner? Its pretty clear based on the conclusions of the article that the author doesn't have much credibility. Don't forget, there's no guarantee college = paying job. Its been shown with quite a lot of supporting evidence that experienced workers crowd out the entry-level jobs used by College Alumni, when their primary work isn't available. It used to be 'Everyone has a mortgage, and they do it for the mortgage'. Now its 'Everyone has rent, and they do it for the rent and food'.
- laratied 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- marginalia_nu 3y agoIt's an interesting notion that life has milestones you're supposed to reach at certain points. I wonder where that idea came from.
- vinnyvichy 3y agoBoth Confucius and Aristotle discussed the stages of a man's life. Moral philosophy hasn't strayed too far from these two guys.
- marginalia_nu 3y agoI'd say the contemporary perception of moral philosophy is so far removed from Aristotle and the Socratics a modern audience may not even recognize e.g. the Nichomachean ethics as a discussion about moral philosophy if you go through some of its key arguments and points without citing it as a source.
- dangitnotagain 3y agoI have a small advancement in moral philosophy for you, though this “simple solution” requires some retooling of terms. This “Objective Morality” proposes that existence is the ultimate good, and not existing is bad (for the existent.) Good is the conservation of the potential of being Bad is the waste of the potential of being Evil is the corruption and perversion of the potential of being This idea of an “existential potential of being” is the a priori of life or dynamic systems in general, and the “Objective” context relates to the rule, not the subjectivity of who it is good for. The benefit of objectivity resolves to the most encompassing domain of evaluation (individual or group or principle of intrinsic aspect, etc.)
- IkmoIkmo 3y agoIn part I think it’s because young people’s worlds have massively expanded, on average. I traveled to 5 continents mostly without parents as a teenager, and I’m a pretty average guy who just put his mind to it. It’d be unthinkable for my parents to have done the same. In part I think we also have more time, life expectancy grew by about 7 years in the past 50 years. And our ability to have kids at a later age is growing with medical advances. Going to school for longer and getting kids later, makes sense in that context. Anyway I think it’s a bit misleading to take particular ages and then compare percentages (e.g. 21yos with a kid in 1980 vs 2021) This way of presenting data can exaggerate the differences, average age of first kid would be better for example. I don’t know how to call this statistics phenomenon, but imagine the light blue area to be ‘kids in the house at 21yo’ and then imagine a minor shift in the average age of having the first kid, the resulting figure would seem much more pronounced than the minor shift in average age. Would’ve been nice to see the data presented differently.