6 ms·
The Mysterious 50 Ohm Impedance: Where It Came from and Why We Use It (2021)
- jojobas 3y agoMy radiotech teacher told me it (as in half-wave antenna impedance) was just like pi or c, I didn't believe him. Turns out it's a result of a weird spacial integral. Go figure, I gave up radio.
- dghughes 3y agoI just recently started watching this guy "Why doesn't a 75 Ohm cable measure 75 Ohms?" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-8CaGOmWDU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-8CaGOmWDU
- mordae 3y agoThe article is not that good, but whatever. I am new to electronics myself and quite fascinated how has the art progressed in the past hundred or so years. There are people remembering "we were doing it wrong". Incredible. Anyway, if you are interested in signals traveling inside those cute green multi-GHz boards you make your living off, go watch Rick Hartley. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ySuUZEjARPY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ySuUZEjARPY (How to Achieve Proper Grounding) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QG0Apol-oj0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QG0Apol-oj0 (What your Differential Pairs Wish You Knew)
- bowsamic 3y agoElectronics has and likely always will feel like arcane magic to me
- al2o3cr 3y agoMy favorite bit of "electronics magic": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PD7DzTIFJdU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PD7DzTIFJdU (this has more to do with TFA and impedance-in-general than might meet the eye at first glance)
- BenFranklin100 3y agoGet this book: https://www.opencircuitsbook.com/ https://www.opencircuitsbook.com/ It’s a book featuring macro photographs of cut-aways of electronic components. It’s the first book that helped me really think of electronic components as a physical things whose function followed from physical principles, rather than an arcane collection of various bits of black magic strung together.
- CliffStoll 3y agoWindell Oskay & Eric Schlaepfer's book has brilliant photographs and insightful text ... a coffee table book to delight any techie. They slice through connectors, semiconductors, and components ... showing the wonderful microscopic world of everyday electronics. A real joy!
- NikolaNovak 3y agoI agree! I kinda know nothing about electronics since "my first electronic kit" as a 8 year old, and that book of cutaways shocked me as how many things in my computer aren't nanoscale magic!
- nomel 3y agoIt’s a beautiful demonstration of how increasing one parameter (frequency) can successively invalidate whatever model you’re using for the system, where negligible errors in the model eventually become functional circuit components.
- detourdog 3y agofrequency exposes the efficiency of transmission through a material.
- akiselev 3y agoThat's why one of the best books on high speed digital electronics is titled High Speed Digital Design: A Handbook of Black Magic [1] [1] https://www.amazon.com/High-Speed-Digital-Design-Handbook/dp/0133957241 https://www.amazon.com/High-Speed-Digital-Design-Handbook/dp...
- timemct 3y agoEspecially when you think about what electronics are made of: things mined from the earth. They made rocks compute for us!
- charcircuit 3y agoWhere else would they come from, the moon? It's to be expected that for large scale products like computers to be made from common materials.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pclmulqdq 3y agoHigh-speed digital and RF are more "magical" than a lot of other forms of electronics. It is quite a bit more approachable if you limit yourself to ~200 MHz signals at most, then you don't really have to worry about the RF properties of your circuits as long as you keep the wires pretty short.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kurthr 3y agoI like Rick. At least they got that it was the original coax cables that drove it. Then once you have lots of measurement equipment and cables, it's hard to change (even SMA is 50ohm). You can still get 75ohm BNC cables (close to 77) and 93ohms (and I think some 150/300ohm antenna cables?). Once you get over a few GHz all the inputs are balanced differential anyway and you have T networks to optimize power reflection. It doesn't mention at all that free space impedance that matters a lot to actual aerial antenna design is 377ohms. I don't know enough about it, but assume they're using transformers to balance loads (about 300ohms?).
- Johnythree 3y agoThe impedance of a folded dipole is 300 Ohms. And the impedance of a 1/2 wave dipole is 73.1 Ohms. However there are many other types of antennas see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dipole_antenna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dipole_antenna
- pclmulqdq 3y agoMany antennas are designed for a given gain and polarization, and you get the impedance you get from the materials and geometry used. Almost all of them have a matching network at the entrance to the antenna, and usually one set up based on actual S-parameter measurements. If you're really fancy, you can get custom coax cables made to match your antenna at any arbitrary impedance, and then put a much better matching circuit in your rack instead of using one on the antenna. High-speed digital signals haven't entirely settled on 50 ohm (100 ohm differential) impedance, though. SSTL, HSTL, and POD (used by different types of memory and high-speed DACs/ADCs) often use 35-40 ohm impedance instead of 50. It's also not uncommon to see drivers having lower impedance and receivers having higher impedance (eg having a 32 ohm driver and a 48 ohm receiver on a 40 ohm wire) because a little bit of reflection can actually help signal integrity here. Long digital wires like twinax Ethernet are all 100 ohm differential signals, though, since reflection is not beneficial there at all.
- kurthr 3y agoAll the medium speed stuff I see (not 64Gb Serdes or even Thunderbolt) is differential current drive/receive though they may be voltage limited on the output. Those still seem to be designed as 50ohm, but they have some fairly high resistance connection's. Even at 1Gb getting a clean eye requires lots of equalization and careful routing, if you want to go 10+ inches.
- pid-1 3y ago> quite fascinated how has the art progressed in the past hundred or so years. There are people remembering "we were doing it wrong". Incredible If you think about it, that's practically a given in any engineering field that stuffers from high iteration / experimentation cost.
- userbinator 3y ago300 ohms is also very common in applications which use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin-lead https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin-lead
- myself248 3y agoFor even lower loss, ladder-line is available in 450 ohms.
- kmbfjr 3y agoWhich is the only replaceman open-wire feeder at 600 ohms. They don’t make it any longer, you’re on your own to construct it or make-do with ladder line.
- howard941 3y agoYes you can definitely build your own ladder line. The insulators are available. But it's probably easier to use window line [0] instead. [0] https://www.trueladderline.com/blog/window-line-open-wire-feedline-or-ladder-line/ https://www.trueladderline.com/blog/window-line-open-wire-fe...
- topspin 3y agoThe most common impedance in actual practice for the sort of transmission line you have in mind is 75 ohms, not 50. Most of the cable TV network, and thus cable Internet, runs on this. That's why RG-6 and RG-11 grows on trees. There is no big secret behind all of this. Transmission lines by definition have some impedance. Practitioners long ago adopted a handful of standard values that suit the common use cases given prevailing constraints, mostly driven by cost.
- wkat4242 3y agoFor things that transmit to the air (antenna feeds), 50Hz is the standard, not 75.
- fxtentacle 3y agoJust a quick comment on the product, since this it effectively an ad for Altium. They typically present themselves as the most popular solution, but they also very clearly out-price any hobbyist at $10k for a perpetual licence. Their "hobby" version CircuitStudio lacks critical features and has 0 support and 0 updates and the forums are just crickets. But KiCad is free, open source, and looks similar enough that I had a great time following the Altium tutorials by Rick Hartley with it. In my opinion, that also invalidates their claim that Altium is the most commonly used PCB design software, because there likely are 100x more hobbyists using KiCad than people able to spend $10k on a hobby. It seems to me like Altium is developing like Eagle. They used to court the makers and hobbyists and then greatly profited when those people started working. But now both of them are mostly in the business of milking companies who have existing data in their proprietary file format.
- 0_____0 3y agoWhat has your experience with Altium been like?
- quailfarmer 3y agoIt’s the best layout software I’ve used. Nevertheless, I’ve started preferring KiCAD for personal projects for the reasons mentioned above.
- shadowpho 3y agoKicad also did a GIGANTIC leap forward in the past two years.
- jjoonathan 3y agoYep. Altium started content marketing like mad right around the time KiCad became good enough and got the glitches / crashing under control. KiCad version 6 was a huge jump in quality. I don't mind the content marketing, I just wish they had a plan that I could rationalize paying for as a hobbyist and they simply don't.
- 3y ago
- Ahmad498 3y agoGreat work to learn from.. thanks for this series.. please do more follow up on such tool layout of complete antenna design!! I would recommend some sort of time lapse capture of antenna design in background with timestamp to jump to the explanation..
- wkat4242 3y agoInteresting, I always thought 50 Hz was just picked for the sake of it at some point in the distance past and then just continued as legacy. The same way with mains voltage of 50Hz (Europe) or 60Hz (US). Higher frequencies would be much better for transformer efficency (though transmission radiation loss is higher too) and is also much safer for humans. For the former reason they use 400Hz on airplanes. But early mains generators could not reach that kind of frequency.
- roelschroeven 3y agoThe article is about the 50 Ohm impedance of coaxial cables, not the 50 Hz frequency of the power grid in many countries.
- ta1243 3y agoOf some coaxial cables. Back in the 90s I just accepted every terminator was 50hz, and the only coax I really dealt with was ethernet. In the 00s I got into television and almost every terminator was 75Hz, with 50hz being specially marked. I can't remember the last time I saw a terminator. I still deal with plenty of coax, but it's from one piece of active equipment to another and they self terminate. (thinking about it I do see some specialised terminators on N type connectors on spectrum analysers, but I don't really do satellite so never deal with them)
- wkat4242 3y agoI know that, I'm a HAM radio operator. I was just using the 50 Hz as an example of something that was chosen pretty arbitrarily. I always thought the 50 Ohm was also chosen like that. I had no idea there were serious technical considerations in choosing it. I should have written 50 Ohm, not Hz in the first sentence of my post though, that was a mixup. But I'm very aware of it.
- nullc 3y agoThere is some 1930s bell labs paper on coaxial cables that considered available materials and concluded 30 ohms was best for power handling, 77 ohms was best for low loss, and 50 ohms was selected as a manufacturable compromise. The publication I'm thinking of would have been by Espenschied most likely. Edit: ah, I see the fine article also says this-- in any case the name might be helpful to someone looking up the citation.
- qwertox 3y agoI wouldn't be surprised if this article got posted because of the video "Why doesn't a 75 Ohm cable measure 75 Ohms?" [0] which the recommendation algorithm has picked up some days ago. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-8CaGOmWDU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-8CaGOmWDU
- krmblg 3y agoTook me right back to my education and I never really thought about impedance values and why they were chosen. We used to build 10base2 BNC terminators ourselves with empty connectors, a soldering iron, crimp tool and some hot glue using 47ohm resistors albeit with low tolerance values. According to my boss they outperformed the industrially produced ones. Back then, the network problems I was facing was either on the software/configuration side (wrong IPX/SPX network id) or simply faulty pc power supplies (I.e. getting shocked by mains voltage when touching ground, frequently happening after thunderstorms; also the terminators would be hot to the touch in such cases).