5 ms·
An important note fairly far down in the article: Today, no existing fast-charging network is making money. ... That means any missed revenue from the customer
by SoftTalker 3y ago
An important note fairly far down in the article:
Today, no existing fast-charging network is making money. ... That means any missed revenue from the customer who drove an EV to a charger only to find it broken is irrelevant. And very few incentives exist to keep stations in working order.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoTesla’s supercharger network is a cost of selling their vehicles to soothe customer range anxiety. Legacy auto never understood this (or ignored it). That’s why Tesla had to spend $1B to build the global network [1] and has a factory to churn out 10k Supercharger stations/annually [2]; no one else would at the speed needed (VW paid to create Electrify America due to their Dieselgate settlement, which dictated no VW branding, hence the EA brand). If you make the argument that profitability will arrive when utilization increases [3], it'll be kept out of reach by a combination of demand charges and having to colocate batteries (both of which Tesla and Electrify America do at some stations) to shave the demand curve (demand charges can be significant) from drawing MWs of power constantly most of the day. Tangentially, gas stations aren't a great fit for fast DC charging (who wants to hang out at a gas station while they charge except perhaps at a full service biz like Wawa or Buc-ee's?), so those stations are instead getting installed at grocery stores, malls, and other places where people will make better use of the dwell time [4]. Most people will charge at home (or work, in some cases) except high daily utilization users (taxi, livery, law enforcement, etc), heavy duty use (towing), or those traveling long distances in a day (road trips). TLDR It's a utility, not a profitable business. [1] https://supercharge.info/map https://supercharge.info/map [2] https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-supercharger-v3-factory-completed/ https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-supercharger-v3-factory-comp... [3] https://www.forbes.com/sites/bradtempleton/2022/10/26/electrify-america-chargers-are-rarely-usedwhats-up-with-non-tesla-fast-charging/?sh=71beb0ff4783 https://www.forbes.com/sites/bradtempleton/2022/10/26/electr... [4] https://www.vox.com/recode/23023671/ev-charging-network-gas-station-fast-charger https://www.vox.com/recode/23023671/ev-charging-network-gas-...
- hedora 3y agoIt's also completely non-differentiated. Each of the networks (other than Tesla) is trying to build customer loyalty via social networking features and monthly memberships, but that's destroying customer loyalty, not building it. All people care about is the percentage of time the charger works, how long it takes for the session to start / complete, and whether a stall is occupied. EA and EVGo are failing miserably on reliability and time to initiate charge, and anyone can install + operate a stall. The only network effect here is whether the charge station shows up on the map service vehicle owners use are using. In theory, they could try locking smaller providers out of being listed on maps, but maps are also a non-differentiated commodity with a pretty low barrier to entry (people can just switch to whatever map service lists all the EV chargers, and not just the unreliable monopoly-owned ones). Also, as the article points out, Ford has basically no loyalty to the charging networks, and is already weaponizing the on-board maps in their vehicles to force the charge networks to provide higher reliability services. I'm sure other automakers will follow a similar path.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- coffeebeqn 3y agoJust put a god dang card reader on the charger and you win my loyalty. Oh great I need to install yet another app and make an account and put my credit card info in manually. Oh wait I don’t have any network. As a business it’s basically a fancy electric plug. Unless someone can make a very nice lounge and charge membership or something I don’t see it being very profitable. I would pay some amount on road trips especially to have access to bathrooms, some drinks and snacks, comfy seats, TVs, etc while I charge a larger chunk
- vel0city 3y agoI've encountered a few CCS chargers which had a regular card terminal on it to start charging. Tap or insert chipped card, plug in, and it starts charging. It's how they should minimally all be, with plug and charge being an optional extra.
- akira2501 3y agoThat really doesn't make sense to me. If your margins are thin then you presumably live on service and repeat business. There's almost certainly a broader explanation for this outcome then "it's not perceived to actually matter."
- b112 3y agoI wonder, Government grants to setup chargers? Or something like that, where there mere existence means money?
- bobthepanda 3y agoLegal compliance. The Dieselgate settlement for Volkswagen in the United States required them to set up a non-VW branded charging network. If you want something done with gritted teeth, get it done via lawsuit.
- fragmede 3y agoWhat do you service though ? EV's are so ridiculously simple compared to a modern ICE car. Timing belts, PCV valve, and O2 sensors; oh my! All that is gone. there's some trickiness to regenerative braking but that's simple in comparison. There's still tires and glass and bodyword to deal with and repair, but just such a huge chunk of auto maintenance just disappears on EVs it's not even funny. Never have to take your car in for an oil service again. There is the new situation of maintenance on the battery pack, and that's a good chunk of change for the labor on it, but that's still relatively rare compared to troubles on an ICE.
- SoftTalker 3y agoI think GP meant customer service not mechanical service. Very few gasoline stations have a mechanic on duty anymore. And you overstate the mechanical maintenance needs of a modern gasoline car. Yes they need oil changes, which are quick and fairly inexpensive. For the most part they will go 100k miles if not more with little else but brakes and tires (which EVs need also). PCV valves and O2 sensors are stupidly simple devices, especially in comparison to the electronic and computer systems needed to make an EV work.