6 ms·
Ford Will Use Tesla EV Charging, but That's Only Part of the Story
- SoftTalker 3y agoAn important note fairly far down in the article: Today, no existing fast-charging network is making money. ... That means any missed revenue from the customer who drove an EV to a charger only to find it broken is irrelevant. And very few incentives exist to keep stations in working order.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoTesla’s supercharger network is a cost of selling their vehicles to soothe customer range anxiety. Legacy auto never understood this (or ignored it). That’s why Tesla had to spend $1B to build the global network [1] and has a factory to churn out 10k Supercharger stations/annually [2]; no one else would at the speed needed (VW paid to create Electrify America due to their Dieselgate settlement, which dictated no VW branding, hence the EA brand). If you make the argument that profitability will arrive when utilization increases [3], it'll be kept out of reach by a combination of demand charges and having to colocate batteries (both of which Tesla and Electrify America do at some stations) to shave the demand curve (demand charges can be significant) from drawing MWs of power constantly most of the day. Tangentially, gas stations aren't a great fit for fast DC charging (who wants to hang out at a gas station while they charge except perhaps at a full service biz like Wawa or Buc-ee's?), so those stations are instead getting installed at grocery stores, malls, and other places where people will make better use of the dwell time [4]. Most people will charge at home (or work, in some cases) except high daily utilization users (taxi, livery, law enforcement, etc), heavy duty use (towing), or those traveling long distances in a day (road trips). TLDR It's a utility, not a profitable business. [1] https://supercharge.info/map https://supercharge.info/map [2] https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-supercharger-v3-factory-completed/ https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-supercharger-v3-factory-comp... [3] https://www.forbes.com/sites/bradtempleton/2022/10/26/electrify-america-chargers-are-rarely-usedwhats-up-with-non-tesla-fast-charging/?sh=71beb0ff4783 https://www.forbes.com/sites/bradtempleton/2022/10/26/electr... [4] https://www.vox.com/recode/23023671/ev-charging-network-gas-station-fast-charger https://www.vox.com/recode/23023671/ev-charging-network-gas-...
- hedora 3y agoIt's also completely non-differentiated. Each of the networks (other than Tesla) is trying to build customer loyalty via social networking features and monthly memberships, but that's destroying customer loyalty, not building it. All people care about is the percentage of time the charger works, how long it takes for the session to start / complete, and whether a stall is occupied. EA and EVGo are failing miserably on reliability and time to initiate charge, and anyone can install + operate a stall. The only network effect here is whether the charge station shows up on the map service vehicle owners use are using. In theory, they could try locking smaller providers out of being listed on maps, but maps are also a non-differentiated commodity with a pretty low barrier to entry (people can just switch to whatever map service lists all the EV chargers, and not just the unreliable monopoly-owned ones). Also, as the article points out, Ford has basically no loyalty to the charging networks, and is already weaponizing the on-board maps in their vehicles to force the charge networks to provide higher reliability services. I'm sure other automakers will follow a similar path.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- coffeebeqn 3y agoJust put a god dang card reader on the charger and you win my loyalty. Oh great I need to install yet another app and make an account and put my credit card info in manually. Oh wait I don’t have any network. As a business it’s basically a fancy electric plug. Unless someone can make a very nice lounge and charge membership or something I don’t see it being very profitable. I would pay some amount on road trips especially to have access to bathrooms, some drinks and snacks, comfy seats, TVs, etc while I charge a larger chunk
- vel0city 3y agoI've encountered a few CCS chargers which had a regular card terminal on it to start charging. Tap or insert chipped card, plug in, and it starts charging. It's how they should minimally all be, with plug and charge being an optional extra.
- akira2501 3y agoThat really doesn't make sense to me. If your margins are thin then you presumably live on service and repeat business. There's almost certainly a broader explanation for this outcome then "it's not perceived to actually matter."
- b112 3y agoI wonder, Government grants to setup chargers? Or something like that, where there mere existence means money?
- bobthepanda 3y agoLegal compliance. The Dieselgate settlement for Volkswagen in the United States required them to set up a non-VW branded charging network. If you want something done with gritted teeth, get it done via lawsuit.
- fragmede 3y agoWhat do you service though ? EV's are so ridiculously simple compared to a modern ICE car. Timing belts, PCV valve, and O2 sensors; oh my! All that is gone. there's some trickiness to regenerative braking but that's simple in comparison. There's still tires and glass and bodyword to deal with and repair, but just such a huge chunk of auto maintenance just disappears on EVs it's not even funny. Never have to take your car in for an oil service again. There is the new situation of maintenance on the battery pack, and that's a good chunk of change for the labor on it, but that's still relatively rare compared to troubles on an ICE.
- SoftTalker 3y agoI think GP meant customer service not mechanical service. Very few gasoline stations have a mechanic on duty anymore. And you overstate the mechanical maintenance needs of a modern gasoline car. Yes they need oil changes, which are quick and fairly inexpensive. For the most part they will go 100k miles if not more with little else but brakes and tires (which EVs need also). PCV valves and O2 sensors are stupidly simple devices, especially in comparison to the electronic and computer systems needed to make an EV work.
- hedora 3y agoFor me, the big news is that they’re providing an adapter for their old cars. Can I use the adapter with a non-ford EV? How long until third party ones or jailbreaks exist?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- yakz 3y agoTesla’s charger knows the car that is charging, they can ban individual cars from the network. I don’t think a jailbreak of the adapter will get around the authentication.
- hedora 3y agoBut, does it know the adapter, or does it know the car? If it just knows the adapter, how does the adapter know what car it is talking to? Assuming I can buy the adapter, then I can physically tamper with it, so now we're in the realm of mod chips, etc. If video game consoles are any indication, it'll be a matter of weeks before someone hacks the dongle.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Symbiote 3y agoI'd assume they have something more like a smart card (credit card, EMV) chip inside. Hackers are not modding credit cards to change the account.
- MBCook 3y agoI’d imagine it works a fair bit like plug and charge. The adapter (directly or indirectly) reports the car serial number and then Tesla would just say “No”. It’s also possible that the adapter doesn’t do much besides the physical, and a software update in the Ford handles the rest. At which point it would be 100% useless to non-Ford vehicles.
- sokoloff 3y ago> I suspect that at least initially, Ford will add the Tesla connector alongside CCS/J1772 in its new generation of EVs. That would allow it to say, “Not only can you charge your EV at any charging site in the U.S., but . . . you can do it without carrying a single adapter." That's not that impressive of a feature as a selling point, nor is it even accurate. Such a car still couldn't charge at a CHAdeMO charging station. (That's the beauty of standards; you have so many to choose from.)
- yakz 3y agoI think that the reality is the only major reason you wouldn’t use a Tesla charging station once you have access is because all stalls are occupied. Pricing and charging speed may in some cases be a reason to choose an EA station but at least currently, it seems rare. I have an adapter for my M3 “just in case” but I have never even considered using it over several years of ownership.
- hedora 3y agoYeah; the article says that Ford is doing this mostly to force EA and EVgo either be competent or go out of business. Biden tried to force them to be competent by adding availability requirements to the inflation reduction act, but, from what I've seen, it hasn't worked (yet). Hopefully adding one decent charging station provider to the market will work a bit better, and force the others out of their current "good competitor" monopoly mode.
- vel0city 3y agoOr, maybe you'd use a CCS one because they're closer to you. There's several CCS locations within a few miles of me, all in shopping centers I'm likely to frequent. The nearest Tesla supercharger station is on its own off a highway over 12 miles away. The same is true for visiting family elsewhere, there's a few CCS locations really close and around shopping areas by but the Tesla one is on its own in an otherwise empty lot of the highway many miles away.
- cptskippy 3y ago
- MBCook 3y agoAs a Ford EV owner I’m conflicted about this. I don’t like that this is reopening the “charger wars” when CCS seemed settled on (by all non-Tesla brands), even if it’s kind of cumbersome. also having less cars at CCS chargers means less incentive to provide/fix them. At the same time I understand why they’re doing it. I’m very curious to see how they do this in the new vehicles. Do they go 100% to the Tesla connector? Or will there be two ports: one Tesla and one CCS. Would those be side-by-side or in different locations? Maybe CCS by the driver (where they have it today) and the tesla port on the passenger front bumper or rear driver side bumper similar to a Tesla so cable length isn’t an issue? I am glad there will be an adapter. However I am also a little worried that I may end I with some kind of “non-Tesla tax” where are Tesla chargers cost me more than they would a Tesla even though Ford is partnering.
- turtlebits 3y agoI blame it on the fact that essentially all non-Tesla DC fast charging stations are wholly unreliable. (L2 chargers are generally fine.) Electrify America fast chargers are the most common in my area, yet fail often and are commonly out of commission for weeks at a time. I've also had poor experience with EVgo fast charging as well.
- cptskippy 3y agoMy neighbor got the new i7 and the first time he tried to DC fast charge at an Electrify America station it threw a bunch of codes on screen and put his car in Limp mode. The dealership had to clear the codes and ended up flashing the firmware and erasing all of his settings and reverting the car to how it was configured at delivery. It's probably BMW being overly cautious and not that the charger could actually harm the car, but I can say I have never had a Supercharger disable my Tesla requiring a tow. I have only ever successful DC fast charged my Leaf about five times, I have however tried to DC Fast Charge it at least a dozen but the chargers are broken more often than not.
- cptskippy 3y agoI have been machinating on this for a couple days and I think I've decided this is a good thing. CCS Combo 1 and CCS Combo 2 are not interoperable and removing all the AC bits from both doesn't yield a compatible or smaller connector. So there's no real benefit to universal adoption of CCS if there's still two incompatible standards. NACS however is very capable and a much smaller connector than CCS. It has a robust and hardened charging network. And any competing network supporting NCAS instantly expands it's customer base to every Tesla owner, and Teslas dwarf every other EV combined. I have two EVs, one being a Model 3 and the other a Leaf. I initially wanted two EVSEs and had my home spec'd with two 240v outlets in the garage. One of those outlets remains unused because I found a Tesla to J1772 adapter for $100 that works perfectly to charge the Leaf. To add a J1772 charger to my house would cost me at least $500 for a breaker, outlet, and EVSE. I can stow this adapter in my Leaf's glove box and have access to every Tesla destination charger for free in addition to the J1772 network.