5 ms·
China’s first domestically made passenger plane completes maiden flight
- quantum_state 3y agoThis company soon will be on the long list …
- ChatGTP 3y agoI'm really excited to see competition from China, congratulations to the team behind this milestone.
- K0balt 3y agoThe team behind this milestone is mostly the Chinese espionage apparatus.
- ChatGTP 3y agoI used to care now I couldn't care less. American tech companies spy on people and target them constantly, companies that pray on teenagers attention and now $MS/ClosedAI have taken so much IP, used it to train "models" that are closed source and then sell the data for a profit without attribution ? We're under surveillance, just surveillance capitalism. Ask Snowden and Assange. Honestly, I don't care if China took some inspiration and built a plane, stealing IP is a first class business in 2023 in the west too. If we want China to stop playing shit games, we shouldn't play shit games either. We should lead by example and build trust within our own populace, then talk about what China can and can't do. So yeah, used to care, couldn't give a shit anymore. I'm personally tired of being whacked over the head by the Chinese and Russian boogeymen it's getting tiring. Until I see some proper improvements here from a policy perspective I'll say it again... Good luck to them for having their own airliners.
- hakfoo 3y agoTBH, that's a valuable skill. It's delusional to point and scream about IP-- the knowledge exists and will eventually flow broadly. Singing and dancing around with legal frameworks to try to pretend it belongs to one specific company or country who got their first is just wasting effort trying to unring a bell. The secret to staying the market leader isn't hoarding patents and copyrights, it's about iterating faster and the quality of execution. But that's hard and requires constant effort, so businesses would rather whine and demand sanctions to try to keep competitors out of their market. Maybe if the Western world gets bootlegged hard enough, it will force a long-needed reality check about this. We've been able to keep up the global IP charade because the "important" economies agreed to play and imposed various reciprocity treaties on the rest. When you're seeing countries with a historic looser attitude about it achieving economic sovereignity, the sparks are going to fly.
- FridayoLeary 3y agoThe Faa will never grant approval. Even if China's notorious lack of transparency could somehow be overcome, for political reasons the plane would never be allowed to compete in the market. I think this plane will only ever be used domestically and by third world countries coerced into buying them.
- capableweb 3y ago> The Faa will never grant approval So? Who cares? FAA doesn't decide what flies in China, and obviously this plane is made for the Chinese market and related markets, not to sell the plane specifically to the US. Such a unrelated statement... I for one is happy to see competition to Airbus and Boing, we need more planemakers from more countries as it's getting very stale out there.
- FridayoLeary 3y agoWhat goes for the US goes for Europe as well. I'm more concerned by the lack of diversity in light aircraft and helicopters. That should be far more open then it is currently. Nobody doubts the future will be flying cars the reality is that it's impossible in the current regulatory climate.
- jpmoral 3y ago> Nobody doubts the future will be flying cars Lots of people do.
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoSorry, flying cars does not give anything of value compared to helicopter. You will still need a pilot license. You still need to communicate with traffic control. They still be noisy as helicopter is. And on top of that, any minor fender bender on a parking lot will automatically revoke their flight-worthy status.
- JoeAltmaier 3y ago
- spypigeon 3y agoIt's important for China and other countries to build a fleet that the US can't sanction.
- lloydatkinson 3y agoHow exactly is stealing designs and IP and then building some variation on that sustainable or even reasonable?
- throw3848493 3y agoMaybe it can kickstart their own industry, like when Samual Slater stole British textile technology and brought it over.
- HKH2 3y agoThere is a clear asymmetry they can take advantage of and it won't be dealt with any time soon, so it's sustainable, and who defines what is reasonable?
- ChatGTP 3y agoSo interesting to read this thread after all the LLM threads where people were violently arguing that it's fine for ClosedAI/M$/SD to train models on data without giving attribution because it's just "inspiration" and then on selling for money. Many other HNers claiming copyright is a big stupid rent seeking exercise stupid face that can go to hell because it's holding back progress...but now...China build a plane and...they turk our juubbzz. I hate to say it but we can't have it both ways...
- HKH2 3y agoYou're equating data that is publicly accessible and that which probably isn't.
- _2z1p 3y agoThe tone of your comment implies that sanctions against the CCP would somehow be unjust. They should be sanctioned for their treatment of the Uyghurs alone, not to mention Tibet, reneging on their promises around Hong Kong, and the fact that their sloppy laboratory practices most likely unleashed a global pandemic. Their cruel zero COVID policy resulted in the death and suffering of millions. The CCP are not the good guys. I really just can’t wrap my head around HN’s sympathy for such an evil regime.
- K0balt 3y agoTo absolutely no one’s surprise, this seems to be largely a result of the theft of existing designs and technology, and is hardly a Chinese engineering accomplishment. I guess the good news is that if they copied enough, well enough, maybe it won’t fall out of the sky on a regular basis. To wit: (From the Wikipedia article on the C919) Chinese cyberthreat actor Turbine Panda, linked to the Ministry of State Security’s Jiangsu Bureau, penetrated a number of the C919's foreign components manufacturers including Ametek, Capstone Turbine, GE Aviation, Honeywell, Safran, and others and stole intellectual property and industrial process data with the aim of transitioning component manufacturing to Chinese companies.[26][27][28][29] The report stated that the operations involved both cyber intrusion and theft as well as HUMINT operations, in most cases using a piece of code custom written for this industrial espionage operation.[26][27][28][29] On October 15, 2018, ten Chinese nationals, including intelligence officials, were indicted by the US for allegedly working with COMAC to allegedly steal the secrets of thirteen foreign aerospace companies working on the C919.[51] As of 2019, four people have been arrested in the US as a result of investigations into this economic espionage and theft of trade secrets.[29] In November 2022, a federal jury in Cincinnati convicted Yanjun Xu, 42, on counts of conspiracy to commit economic espionage, conspiracy to commit trade secret theft, attempted economic espionage and attempted trade secret theft. The US court found that Xu played a key role in a plot to steal trade secrets from western aerospace firms, for the purpose of helping the C919 commercial airliner program. He was sentenced to 20 years in prison.[30]
- hotpotamus 3y agoI wonder if it really is largely a result of theft. To my eyes, it looks like any other modern cargo plane that could have been made in the last 50 years; I'm not sure how much advance there really has been on the airframe. My sense is that most of the really hard tech advances have been in the engines (and the gains are somewhat marginal, but important to carriers), and the article says they're still buying those. I suspect the hard part of putting together a plane like this is getting the entire assembly line/industrial ecosystem bootstrapped, and there's not a whole lot that spycraft can do to actually build out that industry.
- 3y ago