7 ms·
Creating a sperm or egg from any cell?
- AuthorizedCust 3y ago> …explore the potentially far-reaching thicket of social, ethical, moral, legal and regulatory ramifications of the emerging technology. Oh, hi, dystopia! Nice to meet you.
- samtho 3y agoWe are already here. Modern sperm and egg banks are just the eugenics industrial complex with a few branding tweaks.
- runsWphotons 3y agoImagine how many brad pitt babies
- atleastoptimal 3y agoImagine being one of the few natural born kids starting school in 2046. Half your class is named Chris because they are literally the clones of Chris Pratt/Pine/Hemsworth/Evans. It may seem impressive, but they really are only the generic bargain bin option for genetic engineering by then. The other half, the richer kids, are hyperintelligent chimeras of every most famous, intelligent, world class athlete, celebrity and model from the early 21st century mixed into a Select Blend. On your first day, the class watches Gattaca, and your teacher, GPT-12, discusses how many things the movie got wrong and how genetic discrimination is not bad at all.
- bsaul 3y agoI keep talking to people about that scenario, of basically adopting the reproductive model of racing horses for humans, but it seems that nobody realizes how far we’ve already gone in that direction.
- samtho 3y agoThere was an attempt to blatantly push eugenics via a sperm bank[0], and it was active until 1999. Nowadays they are just more discreet about it. [0]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repository_for_Germinal_Choice https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repository_for_Germinal_Choi...
- xvilka 3y agoThere would be likely a law to keep the necessary genetic diversity for species survival, to avoid exact clones or similar copies.
- gnicholas 3y ago> People could even potentially steal the DNA of celebrities from, for example, a clipping of their hair to make babies, he says. "One law we definitely need is to make sure people can't become genetic parents without their knowledge or consent," says Greely. A new type of blackmail: (1) get some trace DNA from a rich person, (2) use it to create a baby, and (3) threaten to harm that baby if the rich person does not give you money. Or skip step 2 and threaten to make the baby if they do not give you money. Or skip step 1 & 2, merely pretend that a baby is related to the rich person, and go straight to step 3.
- yCombLinks 3y agoLoL, why are we threatening to harm the baby? Our current system would require the celebrity pay a huge amount of child support if the dna matches. No laws even look at how conception happened.
- meowface 3y agoIt seems fairly probable that if this became feasible and an actual thing people were doing, the laws would carve out an exception. Though I guess it might be kind of difficult to prove, since the surrogate mother could just insist she had an affair with the person.
- Wiki39366 3y ago[flagged]
- samtho 3y agoThis just does not happen if the donation was done with the correct contracts and paperwork. Gamete donation has been a multi billion dollar industry for many years would not exist if those donors, anonymous or otherwise, suddenly would be at risk of paying child support for anywhere from 3 to 300 children.
- 3y ago
- cjbgkagh 3y agoIf you could crest a sperm and egg from any cell, could it be from a cell from an newly created embryo? As in rapid multi generational directed evolution, the ability to highly concentrate polygenic traits much more efficiently than a bogosort type algorithm.
- runsWphotons 3y agoYes this is possible. Gwern wrote quite a lot about this several years ago I think.
- chr1 3y agoFor evolution you need to actually wait while the organism becomes an adult and see how it behaves. Without it you don't know in which direction your changes move the organism. If you could know it only from genes you could simply edit the genes without having to create embryos from embryos.
- saalweachter 3y agoHonestly I'm not sure you're even likely to get a viable embryo at the end the GPs procedure. A large -- up to 1/3 -- fraction of fertilized embryos are not viable, largely because of chromosome abnormalities. Sometimes this happens quickly, before you would really say someone was pregnant, but people don't usually talk about their pregnancies in the first trimester because miscarriages are likely for this reason. Depending on how well you can sequence the genome and forecast viability of the intervening steps, you'd just be compounding this probability each time. And as you say, without the intervening "natural selection", there's no real evolution, just an increased mutation rate. There is one interesting thing you could do, which is probably unethical under many ethical systems, which is that you could use the process to generate "many-parent" babies. Take samples from N people, and in a few days or weeks you could produce an embryo which shares all of their DNA (equally, if you start with a power of two). Sure, it would be functionally (and actually, since you have the intervening embryos) grandchildren or great-grandchildren instead, but I could imagine someone wanting that.
- Vecr 3y agoOne of the main problems preventing human cloning is the trouble getting enough eggs. Even if you don't care about the ethical issues (females only have a quite low finite number of eggs), it's still really expensive. If a small team can get their hands on a whole lot of viable human eggs, they may be less limited by what funders of big research grants want.
- XorNot 3y agoThe number of eggs women have is far from "quite low". How many do you think they need? A woman menstruates once a month until menopause, from say age 14 till 55. So you would estimate a need for 492 total eggs. A woman is born with 1 million eggs, and has about 300,000 left by puberty. Which is to say: developing the eggs is not a limiting factor in getting them from women.
- runsWphotons 3y agoGetting eggs from women is hard because the current technology is very invasive and expensive, and there are challenges storing and maintaining the eggs. A technology that allows the creation of as many eggs as you want from skin samples totally changes all that, and removes the limitations for many reproductive technologies.
- XorNot 3y agoAbsolutely. No contention there. I'm just contesting that the total number of eggs in a woman is meaningfully finite though: the X at birth thing is thrown around a lot without thinking about the actual numbers involved.
- Vecr 3y agoActually, I'm not sure about the real situation. The organizations who fund large grants apparently claim that's a reason why they don't like human cloning, but it could be a cover for other reasons they don't want to talk about.
- solatic 3y ago> "One law we definitely need is to make sure people can't become genetic parents without their knowledge or consent," says Greely. Exactly when and how is consent given? Going down this ethical train of thought, one could argue that sexual intercourse only implies consent for sexual intercourse, not consent for reproduction. If the requirement for consent implies a requirement for a written contract, then consent for sexual intercourse does not imply consent for reproduction. If the requirement for consent merely implies a requirement for a lack of coercion and allowing people to continue on with what they have found along the path of life, then surely one should be allowed to make do with the barber's garbage. Eventually, the discussion should stop revolving around consent and start revolving around commitment. Women should have a right to expect men to decide whether or not to make a commitment by a certain deadline, and should have the power of the courts to hold men to that commitment, should it be made. And nobody should presume that celebrities are making a commitment (of any kind) to anyone who decides that a celebrity's trash is their treasure.
- gearsandbeers 3y ago> could argue that sexual intercourse only implies consent for sexual intercourse, not consent for reproduction You might also enjoy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paper_abortion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paper_abortion - I stumbled upon this last night and thought about it for a while.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sjducb 3y agoSex is not separate from reproduction. If you are a man and have sex with a woman then you're consenting to be a father. Most western countries recognize verbal and other non-written contracts. The clearest example I can see here is the UK's law about weather the genetic father is the legal father. If the child was conceived through sexual intercourse then the genetic father is always the legal father.
- samtho 3y ago
- russnes 3y agoThis will be great until we select away our natural ability to reproduce, and then the power goes out and nobody can reproduce anymore and humanity goes extinct in one generation
- chr1 3y agoWell if power goes out 99% will already be dead because of current dependence on technology. And for the remaining 1% the religious conservative groups like Amish or Hashidis will be the ones who survive.
- Turing_Machine 3y ago> And for the remaining 1% the religious conservative groups like Amish or Hashidis will be the ones who survive. Not unless the Amish stopped being pacifists, they wouldn't.
- HKH2 3y agoYou might be interested in a book called The Revolutionary Phenotype. The author goes through that scenario.
- dsign 3y agoThis is funny. It's "my son if it has my DNA" is the copyright equivalent of "it's my song if it has my chords." I can't resist: - "You got a copy of my DNA files. Then you had a child, and they look similar to one of ours. I don't care if you modified it by removing all my faulty genes, or if you wrote the DNA from scratch after looking at mine. I sue you for copyright deft, you ought to pay reparations and the kid should be terminated." ~~ SCO-genomics. - "I don't care if you breastfed it, it's not a real person if their DNA was generated by an AI." ~~ Twitter mob. Seriously though, I don't think that parenthood has anything to do with genes.
- samtho 3y ago> I don't think that parenthood has anything to do with genes. Genetic mirroring is a powerful force and the role of nature plays a far greater part than most are willing to admit.
- crubier 3y ago« I don’t think that parenthood has anything to do with genes » See, this is why 80% of people are annoyed by the « woke » and other progressive discourse: Taking minority or rare cases (Transgenderism, LGBT, Obesity, etc.) that are exception to the norm, and using them to completely and absolutely deny that any norm exists or that the norm exists for legitimate reasons. I’m sorry, but for 100% of animals and 99% of humans, parenthood absolutely has a lot to do with genes. The whole point of natural reproduction in nature is for genes to transmit. That might be inconvenient for you and you are welcome to express it, but denying it and ridiculing the vast majority who understand that makes you sound annoying.
- troad 3y agoWhile I appreciate there's a lot of new debates to work through, the possibility of a child with two same-sex parents would be revolutionary for gay and lesbian couples. It's striking how many commenters here thus far default to treating this as a college ethics question, concocting contorted hypotheticals.
- contrl 3y ago[flagged]
- troad 3y agoI don't know what you expect to achieve by calling those selfless women who choose to do surrogacy prostitutes. The surrogacy sector in the United States is highly regulated, and surrogates are highly protected (https://health.ny.gov/community/pregnancy/surrogacy/surrogate_bill_of_rights.htm https://health.ny.gov/community/pregnancy/surrogacy/surrogat...). Yours is an ignorant, misogynistic stance.
- runsWphotons 3y agoMost surrogates are not selfless--- they get paid for what they do...in the US often $60,000. Some jurisdictions do require that women choosing surrogacy have to do it altruistically, receiving only reimbursement for medical expenses. This causes a shortage of surrogates compared to market demand. People looking for surrogates often then travel to jurisdictions where the laws are different to obtain them (I know people personally who have done this). The US is not the only destination, and there are less protections in other markets than in the US. Surrogacy is certainly not prostitution, but poorly regulated markets exist and pose similar issues.
- troad 3y ago> Poorly regulated markets exist and pose similar issues. Right, but this sort of applies to anything though. Labour markets, for example. Does the fact that Bangladeshi clothes factories are exploitative of their staff make hiring staff intrinsically immoral in the United States? > Most surrogates are not selfless--- they get paid for what they do...in the US often $60,000. Including the lead-up and recovery period to take the whole process to a year or so, and accepting your very high estimate of $60k in surrogate compensation, that's hardly a windfall for the average American woman. There's far easier ways to earn $60k in an entire year in the US than carrying someone's baby. For American surrogates, there's usually an element of selflessness involved.
- foreigner 3y agoNevermind the human applications, use this to bring back Dodos!
- batch12 3y agoA lot of discussion around theft or blackmail so I'll go another way. People could more easily stud themselves out. Imagine if 15% of the babies of 2036 were related to the sexiest social media model. Talk about designer babies. You'd begin to be able to tell when someone was born and how rich their family is by who they (do or don't) resemble. People could sling their own genes on online marketplaces where consumers pick a genetic partner (or two) like one would build a Mario kart. Edit- And then there'd be the fraud. People buying knockoff celebrity DNA..
- DonsDiscountGas 3y agoTrue, although if we actually can design babies the need for a "stud" drops a lot. Two people (or one person I guess) wants a kid, so they start from their DNA, and modify it as they please.
- Pigalowda 3y agoA few years ago i wrote up some questions related to this. Cool it’s on NPR now Question: Can an adult somatic cell be de-differentiated into an induced pluripotent stem cell and then re-differentiated into a working/healthy germ cell. Can this germ cell undergo meiosis and produce spermatocytes and oocytes? Can one of these induced gametes fertilize another induced gamete and produce viable offspring. Can this system be applied to humans? Can a somatic Cell from an XX female be de-differentiated and induced to become a functional sperm by re-differentiation (and placement into reconstituted testis) If sperm can be induced from the somatic cells of an XX female, can these sperm be used to fertilize an oocyte? (Whether it is an induced oocyte from a somatic cell or naturally occurring oocyte) Objective: If possible, I want an induced sperm from an XX female somatic cell to fertilize a natural oocyte (or induced) and produce viable offspring capable of reproduction. The purpose is not to create a clone, such as seen in nuclear transfer, but to have a female derived sperm cell fertilize a female derived oocyte
- DonsDiscountGas 3y agoThe short answer to all of these questions is "Yes". Already in mice, and there's no reason to think it wouldn't be possible in humans someday. Although I think it's a ways out; we can induce pluripotent stem cells and do some differentiation into other cell types but I don't believe we're at fully functional germ cells in humans.
- TexanFeller 3y ago> Creating a sperm or egg from any cell That word "any" in there makes me nervous. How long will researchers resist trying this with a cell from a 100yo person or a cancer cell.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoThe obvious tongue-in-cheek follow-on - combine with lab-grown meat to get 'long pork' made of anybody you want. An enemy. A pop star. And so on.
- johnross99 3y agodoes anyone have any idea on the timeline to make this available for humans?