3 ms·
But ERCOT energy is also cheaper than the US national average. The reason that 25% of global PVC production was ultimately sourced from Texas was probably linke
by roenxi 3y ago
But ERCOT energy is also cheaper than the US national average. The reason that 25% of global PVC production was ultimately sourced from Texas was probably linked to those power costs.
I'd rather my regulators copied ERCOT than what they are actually doing; I pay a lot for power because of serial gold-plating of infrastructure. Then maybe Australia'd be able to afford to manufacture something in globally significant quantities.
Not "fixing" things can lead to better outcomes for most people.
- viraptor 3y agoJust to double check, you actually do mean you're happy for some people to die from cold in exchange for lower energy bill for yourself, and ignoring the required infrastructure maintenance? (hoping outages won't affect you too much)
- roenxi 3y agoNo, that would be stupid. The idea would be to save ~25% on power bills, let the grid fail once a decade and build up alternative things for dealing with disasters, like some sort of well stocked and warm community hall. That would be much cheaper, and has the added benefits like prepares the community for all sorts of disasters.
- viraptor 3y ago> let the grid fail once a decade This means people dying. To move people to a community hall you need enough transportation, clear roads, working communication, and many other things that are indirectly relying on power being available or the disaster plans working properly. (Which they sometimes won't) Also this would have to work for everyone at risk - not for the number of deaths we know about, but likely 100x that. You can't ignore the effects of that once-a-decade failure and hope things will work fine.
- roenxi 3y agoWhat, so the grid is indestructible but organising diesel for buses is an impossible task? That isn't realistic at all. Wikipedia tells me that something like 250 to 1,000 people died in the Texas power outage which was basically the worst conditions the state has ever seen. Assuming that the at-risk population was 100x that we're still talking numbers that can be managed in an emergency fashion a lot more cheaply than raising power prices by 33% across the board which seems to roughly be the gap from Texas to California. Raising power prices 33% will also kill people, they won't be able to heat their homes every year. I know people who have that problem right now, it is horrible. Even raising prices by ~10% to go from Texas to US national average will probably kill people. Someone will have to make hard choices between eating and heating if the prices go up 10% in real terms. Cheap power saves lives.
- viraptor 3y ago> What, so the grid is indestructible but organising diesel for busses is an impossible task? No, grids fail locally quite often and that's easier to manage. A large scale outage where you need to move thousands of people, and know who/where they are in the first place, with plans not fully tested for a decade at a time however is going to fail in many ways, especially when communication is also impacted. Maintaining the plans, training, supplies, etc long term is also not trivial. Community can step us locally in many ways, but not as state-wide solution. > be managed in an emergency fashion a lot more cheaply than raising power prices by 33% across the board There an assumption that it will be effective at scale. And that the price increase would be required. (I've seen quite a few sources saying proper maintenance would be cheaper than dealing with the fallout)
- roenxi 3y agoYeah sounds expensive to do right. Do you think it would cost more or less than regulations that ended up raising electricity prices by 10%? Hint: it'd be much cheaper. > Community can step us locally in many ways, but not as state-wide solution. Actually it can. Coping without power for a few days is 100% something that a local community can do. There isn't a need for state-wide coordination although that'd probably help. I mean, end of the day you're worried about a couple of hundred lives once a decade (and, for scale, hundreds of thousands of people die in Texas each year already - probably quite a few of which could be saved if power was cheaper!). The regulation is obviously not worth it, there are cheaper ways to look after cold people.
- hedora 3y agoOk, but the cost of the outages far exceeds the cost of buying antifreeze for the facilities that failed, even when averaged over the years between failures (and this has happened so often, we have that data). The reason it hasn’t been fixed is that the ercot market (which is an artificial, legislated thing) is intentionally structured so that the production facilities make unbounded profit during correlated failures. I say “intentionally” because this keeps happening and the legislature explicitly refuses to fix it. There is no better proof than that. One simple solution, assuming you don’t like legislating technical fixes, which I don’t like either, is to fine the shit out of them during correlated failures. For example (real legislation would hopefully be better): 100% of money in the market during months with more than a 10% peak outage would go to the game and wildlife service, or some other popular Texas thing, and they could establish criminal liability for intentionally curtailing production during power shortages. So, when this happens, costs go to max, and revenue goes to zero. Or, they could just legislate basic 1800’s reliability measures. Or, they could let all the idiots that voted these idiots freeze, but keep the industrial facilities online. At this point, I don’t care. (Despite the efforts of some red state politicians to detain pregnant women, the US still has open internal borders, after all). Anyway, I just want to be able to buy PVC the next time a line in my yard gets cut. Nothing makes me give a shit about grid reliability in far off lands more than, well, a literal pool of it.