4 ms·
Yet again, this seems to confirm that whatever problems the US has, as bad as those seem, are worse overseas even in Western countries. Higher inflation, more
by paulpauper 3y ago
Yet again, this seems to confirm that whatever problems the US has, as bad as those seem, are worse overseas even in Western countries. Higher inflation, more unrest, higher unemployment, weaker growth, worse stock market returns, etc.
- pphysch 3y agoIt helps that Washington has thousands of troops in those countries, and not the other way around.
- SllX 3y agoThis is true, misleading and repeated to the point of worthlessness. There was a big to do among our NATO allies about ramping up their own spending in response to the previous President threatening to pull out of NATO. They want those troops there, under NATO command and especially lately.
- pphysch 3y agoIt does matter, because it means Washington has tangible leverage over these supposedly-sovereign states and can enforce hard limits on their behavior. As an extreme example, a nationalist coup against a weak & corrupt Berlin simply can't happen with such an enormous foreign military presence. We learned from Versailles. The IRA and NS2 sabotage were really bad for Germany. But what are they gonna do about it? https://www.politico.eu/article/france-and-germany-find-ground-on-a-common-concern-u-s-protectionism/ https://www.politico.eu/article/france-and-germany-find-grou...
- fabian2k 3y agoYou're saying Germany isn't actually sovereign? And what's that about US troops preventing a nationalist coup? That sounds like an insane conspiracy theory. We're not an occupied nation. There are 35,000 US troops in Germany. Compare that with 180,000-250,000 German troops (depending on how you count them). And the NS2 sabotage is pretty much irrelevant. No gas has ever flown through that pipe, and it was exceedingly unlikely to ever happen after the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
- pphysch 3y agoCan you provide some recent (say, post-Merkel) examples where Berlin has acted in its own interest at the expense of Washington's interests? And how did Washington respond? I'm genuinely curious since you seem to know a lot about German national governance.
- fabian2k 3y agoThat is entirely irrelevant, you're the one making absurd claims about Germany not being sovereign. You're also leaving a very short timespan here, one dominated by the war against Ukraine where US and German interests align very well. There is one event, if you believe the reports. And that was Germany allegedly making US deliveries of main battle tanks a requirements to agree to Leopard 2 deliveries to Ukraine. That was not something the US wanted to do at that point, though obviously it also wasn't something they disagreed with entirely.
- pphysch 3y agoAs other commenters have remarked, the bombing of Germany's energy infrastructure by a literal ally is an extraordinary violation of sovereignty. You can do mental gymnastics to pretend that is irrelevant. It's called "being in denial". And yet Germany is now in an energy-cost-induced recession. Is that also "irrelevant"? And we haven't even brought up FM Baerbock and where her allegiance lies (the Washington-based Atlantic Council said she was "in lockstep" with them). Regarding the German tanks, it says everything that even the Scholz-Baerbock regime was reluctant to send them. If it was truly in Germany's national security interest, it would be a no-brainer. But it's not about national security, it's about politics and Washington's interests in the region. So there's clearly a strong case for Germany not really being sovereign. When I ask you to make the opposing argument, you evade.
- fabian2k 3y agoThere is no evidence the US destroyed the pipeline. Hersh's story is a fairytale with lots of alleged facts that have been specifically debunked. There is no robust public evidence on who actually destroyed the pipeline. Everything that is public is circumstancial and contradictory. You are making a very extreme and frankly just plain insulting statement here by disputing our sovereignty.
- SllX 3y agoYet our troops are still welcomed and NATO is more popular than ever. I’m not saying it doesn’t put us in an advantageous position if it came down to war with Germany or France, but it does matter that we handle trade disputes and NATO as separate matters, and it isn’t as if EU has exactly been kind to American tech companies lately given with each passing year they pass new onerous legislation that mostly affects foreign tech companies more than it affects their own domestic industry because their own home grown tech industry wasn’t worth much before we took any protectionist measures. Right now we are guests in the country with our shields and spears pointed in the direction of the East because we have overlapping interests in defending their nations with their present governments as they are against the threat of Russia. The reality on the ground now outweighs an incidental hypothetical that would be a repeat of a hundred years ago. If our presence dissuades a second rise of Nazism, that’s probably as much to Germany’s benefit as it is ours, but the market disputes are between the EU and USA, not European NATO and North American NATO and while we’re there as guests and not belligerents, we’re there to defend Germany, not impugn its sovereignty.
- c00lio 3y agoWhere Europe is protectionist about tech, the US did the same about steel, aluminium, aircraft and certain foods. I guess the tech sector is just more present in the minds of HN readers.
- SllX 3y agoI didn't forget about that, but I felt no need to double-down on the both-sides bit when the one I replied to already mentioned the IRA, and it's irrelevant to the point that trade including disputes and NATO are separate threads to the Trans-Atlantic relationships between America and our European allies. We can go tick for tack for all I care on trade—I mean I do care to the extent that I think it's dumb and we shouldn't but it also isn't a political priority for me—whereas NATO is severely more important independent of where we stand on the balance of our trade relationships at the end of the day because keeping Europe free and independent of Russia matters a great deal more. That even includes ensuring they have the freedom to pass screwball legislation that screws with our tech companies and moves the needle closer to re-evaluating their European operations as a priority. I'm not hearing any Europeans outside of Russia chime in to say they would in fact prefer the opposite outcome or an inverse set of priorities where we give them better access to American steel, aluminum, aircraft and food markets but dissolve NATO and pull out of their respective countries. It's a complicated series of military, trade, diplomatic and personal relationships with both profits and losses on both sides of the Atlantic, but on balance is still beneficial for Americans and Europeans.
- matkoniecz 3y ago> It does matter, because it means Washington has tangible leverage over these supposedly-sovereign states In case that someone is genuinely confused: Poland put quite significant effort into using far-away and much more reasonable and friendly USA to decrease risk of invasion of nearby, brutal and evil Russia. Main leverage that USA has in Poland is risk of *withdrawing* military support. Because getting invaded by Russia is extremely bad, war worse than average invasion results.
- qwytw 3y agoHow? Also do you think US would not remove their troops if the host countries actually wanted to?
- WalterBright 3y agoThe US removed its presence from France at their request.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoWait, doesn’t it actually help those countries?
- latency-guy2 3y agoGermans are invited to invade the United States of America. I hope to see your 5,000 helmets faring well.
- ComputerGuru 3y agoThe economic benefits of NATO for the USA wouldn’t change much today if Germany had its own troops instead of the US troops stationed there. Of course, if the troops were never there in the first place, that’s a different matter. The biggest actual difference isn’t US troops stationed in NATO countries but rather the extent of the US as a global reserve currency and the power of the petrodollar. The concerns over these are well-founded as the powers that be have willingly traded the latter in exchange for upping the US’ position in the current brinksmanship with Russia, when Russia was never the economic juggernaut to be reckoned with and certainly not worth giving up those cards for.
- kurthr 3y agoLosing half their gas supply and a huge amount of electrical as well, didn't help... but England and Italy will quickly follow, France and Spain with longer delay. The failure of China reopening was also a big hit.
- throwbadubadu 3y agoYeah, one has to admit that the US quite cleverly pulled at least some strings and got its win-win-situation while Europe is in no other position as to pay and still loose.
- arez 3y agoS&P is up 3% from one year ago, Dax is up 12% so stockmarket wise it's not true
- hef19898 3y agoAnd so far nobody tried to overturn election results in an European country, for now.
- rvz 3y agoIt is down almost 12% since the November 2021 all time high [0] and since the market crash happened [1] as I said before. [0] https://www.google.com/finance/quote/.INX:INDEXSP?window=5Y https://www.google.com/finance/quote/.INX:INDEXSP?window=5Y [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29508238 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29508238
- super256 3y agoThe DAX40 is a piece of German financial engineering, aka not fair to compare to the S&P500: the DAX40 excludes a large part of public German corporations + as a price index it includes distributed dividends, which causes an unfair advantage when compared to a price return index like S&P500.
- curiousgal 3y agoUnless those problems are, you know, things that matter, like life expectancy for one.
- it_citizen 3y agoEducation quality, political polarisation, inequality, poverty index, happiness.
- joemazerino 3y agoSeems more West specific. Related to money printing and lockdowns during COVID.
- Levitz 3y agoWell, yes and no. Even if inflation or unemployment get worse, it's a whole different deal for the average citizen to deal with those when you have socialized healthcare or unemployment benefits.
- paulpauper 3y agoDoes the US not have unemployment benefits or other programs? During and after Covid, trillions was spent on various stimulus and aid programs for affected Americans.