8 ms·
This is such an important bit of history for anyone who’s ever thought George Takei is too liberal or outspoken. His childhood was profoundly shaped by reaction
by acdha 3y ago
This is such an important bit of history for anyone who’s ever thought George Takei is too liberal or outspoken. His childhood was profoundly shaped by reactionary bigots, and then coming of age as a gay man in that era he had to face another life-altering prejudice. He was phenomenally lucky to be a talented actor and get a huge break but that also means he’s keenly aware of just how much is at stake if that kind of people regain power.
An older friend was married to someone who was held in Manzanar. I drove by with them in the 2000s and the mood was somber. His life got a lot better after the war and he was able to spend most of his retirement fishing off of the coast in San Diego but it’s hard to forget that your home country saw you as a threat even while a child.
- slibhb 3y agoAh yes, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, a well-known "reactionary bigot".
- jhanschoo 3y agoI think you're trying to make a point other than your sentence's literal meaning, but I'm too distanced from modern domestic US history to know. Can you clarify and elaborate?
- slibhb 3y agoFDR was the president who had the Japanese Americans removed to concentration camps. He's a hero of the left and one of the presidents who would least likely be described as a "reactionary bigot" in any other situation. More broadly I object to this very modern attitude wherein people in the past who did things we consider wrong today were evil bigots. Which is not to say they weren't wrong.
- Waterluvian 3y agoYou can recognize an action both being a product of its time and being objectively wrong. I think a good lesson here is that wrongness is not a monopoly owned by just one political ideology.
- nindalf 3y agoIt’s ok to praise FDR for the New Deal and also recognise that sending all Japanese people (and not German or Italian people) to internment camps was a bigoted, evil thing to do. What do you want? For us to say “ah well, that’s just how it was back in the day”? You’re the one incapable of nuance if you want to put everything FDR did into one bucket or the other.
- slibhb 3y agoPeople can praise or criticize FDR for whatever they like. I'm objecting to the name-calling, not the idea that the internment of Japanese Americans was wrong.
- BaseballPhysics 3y ago[flagged]
- slibhb 3y agoNo, the idea that almost everyone born before 1980 was an evil bigot is stupid
- BaseballPhysics 3y agoThen it's a good thing no one said that. You should probably take a break from the internet. There's enough things to get offended about. There's really no reason to start making up new ones.
- slibhb 3y agoIf you extend your "calling a spade a spade" logic, it will to lead to some ridiculous premise like "everyone born before x year was an evil bigot" where x keeps marching forward year after year.
- jjulius 3y agoWhere did OP call "everyone born before 1980 ... an evil bigot"? Where did OP single out FDR as a reactionary bigot? Yes, it was done under his watch, but there were, in point of fact, plenty of genuinely reactionary bigots who supported it at the time. You're lambasting OP for the words you've put into their mouth. Stop.
- cpuguy83 3y agoWhat they did is the literal definition of bigotry. They rounded up as many Japanese-Americans as they could and put them in prisons under heavy guard without any cause other than other people that look like them attacked a military base. It was objectively wrong then, and it is wrong through all of time.
- atlantic 3y ago[flagged]
- ok_dad 3y agoThey were not fucking immigrants! These were people who had lived in the USA their whole lives, with several generations of American citizens in these families. Anyone arguing Japanese internment was just for securing America is the same type of person who would round up trans people or musings Muslims today the same way.
- atlantic 3y agoYou don't magically stop being an immigrant after a few years. Often it takes several generations to integrate. And particularly so if you form cultural enclaves and remain attached to your country of origin, as tends to be the case with the Japanese.
- ok_dad 3y agoI believe they actually rounded them up to steal their farms in California. Japanese farms were the most productive back then, and they held almost all the best farms. During the war, they had their land and things stolen by politically connected neighbors. http://www.sfmuseum.org/hist9/harvest.html#:~:text=The%20World%20War%20II%20evacuation,%2DJapanese”%20owners%20and%20lessees http://www.sfmuseum.org/hist9/harvest.html#:~:text=The%20Wor....
- pbhjpbhj 3y ago>other than other people that look like them You yourself are describing the people rounded up as Japanese (yes, with a qualifier). They were people more likely to have loyalty to an enemy state, weren't they? It was certainly a blunt tool; and not an issue I've looked at in detail; but do you expect FDR to have done nothing? Interesting for me to consider whether UK was right to round up Germans for WWII, rather difficult when that includes the Royal Family, but they did imprison something like 10% of "Germans" living in the UK (I don't know if they were British, just visiting, naturalised, or what).
- willbudd 3y agoWow, I don't think I've ever seen anyone dial a strawman argument to 11 quite like you just did. Nobody was talking about FDR until you hamfistedly brought him up in a reply to a post (indirectly) lamenting a period of history rife with racism. Prejudice was rampant all across the "political spectrum", but prevalence is not a measure of justice or humanity. Nor does any individual's competency in one area somehow ameliorate their flaws in other areas.
- MSFT_Edging 3y agoFDR is an example of how a politician can be called a Socialist in the United States while also being extremely reactionary and push racist policies. If nothing else, this goes to show how far the scale is tipped in favor of right wing ideas and policies in the states and still is. The fact Biden, a fairly conservative politician, can be called a "Communist" with a straight face is an indictment of the American education system. The labels don't even mean anything after a while. You can actively be enforcing fascist policies and still be labeled a socialist due to a population wide inability to understand what words mean.
- justin66 3y ago> He's a hero of the left and one of the presidents who would least likely be described as a "reactionary bigot" in any other situation. those people have a pretty hypocritical and one-dimensional way of looking at history > More broadly I object to this very modern attitude wherein people in the past who did things we consider wrong today were evil bigots. but not me, I'm awesome
- blululu 3y agoThe issue is combing reactionary and bigot. The internments were done the watch for Franklin Roosevelt and the New Deal coalition - a left leaning political movement that laid the foundations of the modern American welfare state. There were definitely many blatant examples of bigotry in the policies of this movement but they were far from reactionary. Social issues change over time but the also correlate with otherwise unrelated social/political/economic issues so trying to apply political issues from 80 years ago into the modern era is going to lead to some incongruous positions.
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoThe modern American welfare state was also reactionary and bigoted towards black people and minorities. It’s important to recognize that much of the social programs explicitly excluded people of color and then used their understandeable lower quality of life due to lack of safety nets as a justification for further racism. Black people have bad neighborhoods, but of course black people didnt get government housing assistance to repair anything, because the federal programs for that explicitly excluded them.
- George83728 3y agoThe same FDR signed Executive Order 8802, forbidding ethnic and racial discrimination in the defense industry and federal government.
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoAnd yet the federal housing administration continued to explicitly respect racist homeowner association laws (btw homeowner associations were originally created to enshrine into bylaws that no black people may rent or purchase a property), continued to offer lesser or worse terms, or would broadly consider black people too risky, until congress passed the fair housing act of 1968, decades later.
- George83728 3y ago
- bgun 3y agoHistory can be "profoundly shaped" by more than whoever was President of the United States at the time.
- femiagbabiaka 3y agoYeah actually: https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/roosevelt-japanese-internment https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/roosevelt-j.... There were anti-racist people at the time, even in his own cabinet, who resisted the calls for internment.
- Loughla 3y agoIt is a difficult thing for some people to understand. But sometimes good people can do bad things. Were most of his policies based on the betterment of the oppressed? Absolutely. Did he oversee one of the most objectively bigoted things that happened in 1942? Absolutely. Was Roosevelt a bigot? I do not know. But, is it fair to say that he was a reactionary bigot? Maybe. That's the thing about people. They're very, very rarely one thing to the exclusion of all else. Violent racists can be outstanding community members on a very local scale. Extremely inclusive pacifists can be assholes to the people in their lives.
- lapcat 3y agoWould be it any better to say "non-reactionary bigot"? I think "reactionary bigot" is just a commonplace phrase often said perfunctorily, but I'm not sure the meaning of the original comment would change if the word "reactionary" was deleted. The argument over the word seems pedantic in the context. The original point is that Takei faced multiple forms of bigotry in his life.
- jakelazaroff 3y agoWhy would it be better? Internment was a reactionary policy! GGP is raising an objection over labels that are accurate.
- lapcat 3y ago> Internment was a reactionary policy! The definition of reactionary is "opposing political or social liberalization or reform". Whereas internment was a reaction, indeed an overreaction, to the war with Japan, based on the bigoted fear that Japanese-Americans were loyal to Japan rather than to America. Not exactly the same.
- Loughla 3y agoYes, if you are exclusively pedantic, then it is not an exact fit in the meaning. I would argue that the common use of the word reactionary = person who reacts to something inappropriately. But getting lost in pedantry instead of just moving through common usage when in regular human discourse is useless. There is no reason to walk down that road, other than to obfuscate any point the other person is trying to make behind a smoke screen of pseudo-intellectualism. Sort of like I tried to do with those last two sentences.
- jjulius 3y agoI don't think it's fair to take what was obviously a phrase that was being spoken in a broad sense, inject your own words into that phrase, and then attack that person for the words you inserted.
- tootie 3y agoHe caved to the bigots out of a sense of pragmatism. Same way Abe Lincoln said he'd let slavery continue if it would preserve the union. Or, more recently, Bill Clinton signing the Defense of Marriage Act. He disavowed it later in life, but signed it because he didn't think he had a choice.
- acdha 3y agoJust to echo what other people said, the people who put American citizens of Japanese descent into prison camps were unambiguously bigots, and a lot of that was based on people wanting to assert that the United States was for white people (contrast with the much softer treatment of American citizens who were ethnically German and Italian). The fact that some of the political leaders who approved that did other things doesn’t mean we shouldn’t hold them accountable for a venal act – I would argue the contrary since they’re otherwise praised and it’s important to remember that our heroes are not perfect and should not be copied without improvement. One can make similar statements about how, for example, programs like social security or the GI bill were both good for many people of lower class backgrounds but also carefully designed and implemented to benefit black people less than white people.
- mixmastamyk 3y ago> softer treatment Those countries didn’t attack directly in full force like the IJN did, by orders of magnitude. European Axis sunk a few American supply ships in international waters aiding their enemies. There’s also the Niihau incident, which directly informed the response. Truth is folks then had a tiny fraction of information that we have today—including hindsight. It’s unclear you would do any better in the same circumstances.
- acdha 3y agoYes, Japan struck first - nobody’s arguing that. My point is that after the United States was formally at war with all of the Axis powers, every American citizen of Japanese descent was forced into prison camps and significant financial loss. That didn’t even happen to all of the German or Italian citizens in the United States at the time, much less American citizens with roots in those countries. (Also, a few supply ships is whitewashing somewhat – hundreds of Americans traveling on civilian vessels were killed by the German navy and there were dozens of American flagged ships sunk prior to Pearl Harbor. No, not what the Japanese navy did but more than enough to have served as grounds for war if the US wasn’t trying so strenuously to stay out.)
- 3y ago
- rayiner 3y ago[flagged]
- wahnfrieden 3y ago[flagged]
- tekmate 3y agoplease elaborate where op drew false equivalencies to attack political opponents
- zo1 3y agoI read it that way too, even if he didn't explicitly say it. Probably because Takei is known to be very vocally anti-Republican or anti-right or pro-left or pro-liberal, not sure of the exact dynamic there. But the comment also said Takei is "liberal" and knows what it's like if "that kind of people" regain power. To me, it's clearly an anti-Republic or anti-conservative jab, implying that "those people" shouldn't be allowed to regain power, else some poor minority will get put into camps. Using the argument that if Takei says so, it's because he's lived through it, so we should listen to him. Ofc, not to detract from what he went through, it's horrible.
- dragontamer 3y ago[flagged]
- dragonwriter 3y ago> These bigots never disappeared. They just are being courted by the Right / Republicans today. Normally, I’d respond to this with something addressing the chain of events starting with the signing of the 1964 Civil Rights Act and subsequent electoral strategy, but just to mix things up I'll go simple: This is the reason that when you see rallies of overt racists, or people storming a government building waving confederate flags, or people arguing about, how, akshully, slavery in America was good for the slaves and their descendants should be thankful rather than resentful of it, in the 21st century, they aren’t backers of the Democratic Party.
- 35997279 3y ago> it’s hard to forget that your home country saw you as a threat even while a child. And it’s the inability to forget that kept a citizenship question off the 2020 census[0], a reminder of the long lasting impact the internment still has on the US. [0]https://www.npr.org/2018/12/26/636107892/some-japanese-americans-wrongfully-imprisoned-during-wwii-oppose-census-question https://www.npr.org/2018/12/26/636107892/some-japanese-ameri...
- junon 3y agoThe article doesn't actually state the question, just links to a very large document that probably has it in there but I couldn't find it. What was the question in particular?
- eschewingmycud 3y agoThat's not at all true. The citizenship question was removed from the 2020 Decennial Census by the Supreme Court in Department of Commerce v New York (2019) which held the Department of Commerce failed to provide a genuine justification for the decision to add the citizenship question (as required by the Administrative Procedure Act), instead providing a contrived and pretextual explanation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Department_of_Commerce_v._New_York https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Department_of_Commerce_v._New_...
- jscipione 3y agoThe difference you can speak and be heard. I cannot.
- acdha 3y agoI’m not sure what you mean by that. Why can’t you be heard?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]