3 ms·
God give me strength, this is patronising. Do you really believe only the HN cognoscenti know they're being gamed?
by ggm 3y ago
God give me strength, this is patronising. Do you really believe only the HN cognoscenti know they're being gamed?
- etothepii 3y agoNo, but I do believe that working with computers all day rewires your brain.
- lordnacho 3y agoIt's not meant to be patronizing, it's just a fact that people who spend a bunch of time reading about tech are going to hear about things before people who don't. It also makes sense that reviews would have signal. It's not like people are dumb, they were just born in an earlier world where reviews would actually have some reputation attached to them. Movies, restaurants, concerts, that kind of stuff would be reviewed by someone capable of writing and filtered through a newspaper editor. Now things have changed and it takes some time for everyone to figure it out.
- 2devnull 3y agoIf reviews “have some signal” then wouldn’t it be more clever to learn to make use of that signal rather than dismiss as entirely worthless?
- lordnacho 3y agoI said it makes sense that they have signal, not that they have signal. Like it makes sense that shaving makes your beard grow, it just turns out not be what actually happens.
- neilv 3y agoIn this particular case... HNers tend to be familiar with tech industry business models and investment models, more than the average person who doesn't work in tech. So I think it's plausible we'll tend to have a somewhat better awareness of the dynamics around reviews that are posted online. (But I don't think we're more savvy about the world in general. If anything, we tend to have STEM-like narrower exposure to the world than many, coupled with the overconfidence that comes from income level.)