3 ms·
Yeah, no. Once it's known that it's possible to achieve, some enterprising company will quickly replicate it. Unless, of course, it needs unobtainable levels o
by cyberax 3y ago
Yeah, no. Once it's known that it's possible to achieve, some enterprising company will quickly replicate it.
Unless, of course, it needs unobtainable levels of power.
- gpm 3y agoIf it needs unobtainable levels of power, that means it's not efficient. If it's efficient you can use a diesel generator in place of your diesel engine and obtain the same amount of power.
- cyberax 3y agoNot quite. It might be efficient, but only if you need megawatt-level propulsion power. This is not uncommon in engineering in general. There are many, many examples of devices that are highly efficient but only at higher power levels/speeds.
- marcosdumay 3y agoWell, people are talking about 90% efficiency up-thread. You can't need unobtainable levels of power and still have 90% efficiency, as people move boats around every day. Also, about the need for a coolant, well, the fixed costs for it are on the order of a few $100/m on most cities nowadays. If people start to use lots of it, the fixed costs will fall to zero. (The variable cost isn't high, but it also doesn't dictate the boat size.)
- Avamander 3y agoYou can absolutely have an energy requirement cliff that has to be exceeded for a thing to work before you can even measure it's efficiency. Trying to push something from standstill vs. keeping it moving.
- marcosdumay 3y agoYes, there exist stuff that behaves like this. MHD isn't one.
- c_o_n_v_e_x 3y agoThe government can and does lock down intellectual property for national security reasons. The US government effectively locked down Juliet Marine Systems' IP, and gave the inventor no compensation for doing so. Took about more than 5 years for the inventor get any relief. https://www.boatblurb.com/post/the-us-military-ghost-ship-is-for-sale https://www.boatblurb.com/post/the-us-military-ghost-ship-is...
- cyberax 3y agoThe US government won't be able to lock down a company in Sweden or Turkey. It's not like the principles of MHD propulsion are in any way secret. It's just that we now have much better superconducting magnets.