13 ms·
Do not call: States sue telecom company over billions of robocalls
- criddell 4y agoI average around 3 robocalls each weekday. They are annoying and it's made me set my phone to not ring when I'm at work. Do you do anything other than hang up when you get a robocall? Sometimes when I do answer a robocall I just ask them to hold on for a second while I get a pen and something to write on then I set the phone down and go back to work. They rarely stay on the line for more than 10 seconds and one Medicaid scammer calls often enough that he recognizes my voice and will tell me to fuck off and then hangs up immediately.
- edgyquant 4y agoI often don’t answer but when I do I set them on silent. Most times it’s immediate hang up but occasionally (less often nowadays) I’d get one that would just sit there indefinitely. My hunch is this the scanner that finds numbers that answer.
- ezfe 4y agoWith the car warranty people I would let them say their script and ask random (somewhat stupid) questions - I had a fake car/vin/address/name that I'd read to get through any of those questions. Haven't gotten one in months though...
- foobarian 4y agoHah. With some voice-to-text steps a LLM could talk to these callers for a while before they realized...
- CharleFKane 4y agoThe car warranty people always hang up on me when I tell them I want an extended warranty… …on my 1909 Stanley Steamer.
- coldpie 4y ago> Do you do anything other than hang up when you get a robocall? Yes, I don't answer in the first place. My phone may as well not have the "phone" feature, I think I use it less than once per month.
- Aromasin 4y agoI have a rule that I don't pick up unless I already have them in my contacts. If they're not and they need to contact me, they can text me or send me an email, and I'll call back.
- zirgs 4y agoHow do you handle deliveries then?
- yamtaddle 4y agoIs this an apartment thing? I don't receive calls for deliveries. US, live in a house.
- zirgs 4y agoYeah, delivery men usually call to ask if anyone is at home.
- Aromasin 4y agoNever received a call for delivery, other than take out food which I'm expecting a call from. That would be an edge case.
- dkjaudyeqooe 4y agoPeople are outraged when I tell them I have no phone in my house that rings. I'm outraged by the idea of people responding to phone rings like Pavlov's dogs.
- pnpnp 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hotsauceror 4y agoI answer it and leave the call going until they hang up. I don’t say or do anything else. It costs me nothing and it wastes a bit of their time. It’s a tiny rock in their gears.
- Clubber 4y agoiPhones have a feature where it just goes straight to voicemail if the calling number isn't in your contacts. That's useful most of the time but I have to remember to turn it off when I'm expecting a call from the plumber telling verifying the service or something.
- elromulous 4y agoI pick up and try to waste their time as much as I can, while working on some chore / mindless task. I figure every second I keep them on the phone is another second they're not scamming an elderly person. Edit: I think my record is about one hour with the "social security administration".
- tokai 4y agoI have never gotten a robocall. Are they an US phenomenon?
- davidmurdoch 4y agoThey're illegal here... But I still get about 5 every day.
- ActionHank 4y agoUK, US, CA, usually run by scammers from countries with low income and weaker currencies. They target countries with gullible, often elderly, population groups that have access to cash in a stronger currency to make the biggest profit for the least effort. Huge benefit of the robocaller is that they can sound less scammy because your first point of contact is well spoken relative to the scammer who often has a thick accent.
- evgen 4y agoNo, not a UK thing. Have had a UK phone number that I know is on a couple of public databases and at worst I get a call every three or four months with the 'we understand you have been involved in a traffic accident' robocall. A quick poke to the Ofcom fraud site to report it and I am sorted for the next few months.
- ActionHank 4y agoMy bad, I think if they required proof of identity in the US and Canada it would be far reduced.
- shmde 4y agoAre you this outspoken when your corpos outsource all labour intensive task, clothing, manufacturing to "low income and weaker currencies" countries with "thick accent" so that they can sell products at record high prices in a stronger currency country to "make the biggest profit for the least effort". I know people like you stay silent when it's time to buy the latest shiny iPhones, fast fashion clothings which are made by exploiting labour(even child labour) which pays pennies to 1 $ an hour and working in harsh conditions.
- edgyquant 4y agoWe have to start creating criminal penalties for this stuff. We wouldn’t let someone go around knocking on doors, the same door everyday and sometimes multiple times, attempting to scam people. At this point the phone system is unusable. If my doctors office needs to call me they’re SOL because I’m not answering a number I don’t know.
- kar5pt 4y agoThis. I don't understand why we can't catch and prosecute these spammers. Is it that hard for the phone companies/authorities to trace who's making these phone calls?
- icedchai 4y agoGood luck prosecuting a scammer in a foreign country. We need penalties for the telecom services providing access. Right know it's trivial for someone to get a ton of numbers and starting making calls over SIP. You shut them off, they'll just go to another provider.
- edgyquant 3y agoIt should not be trivial to buy hundreds of numbers.
- icedchai 3y agoIt shouldn't be, but it is. The latest scams all involve calling people from local looking numbers (same area code), since it's more likely victims will pick up.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThe scammer in a foreign country has to have on-the-record account(s) with some foreign telecom company, directly or via some chain of intermediaries. Just shut down those accounts, and if the foreign telecom doesn't comply, then block calls incoming from that telecom. Eventually the scammers will start encountering serious resistance to obtaining new accounts and numbers. So why hasn't anyone done this yet?
- r3trohack3r 4y agoOne trick I’ve found to screen robocalls is to answer and be silent. They seem to use an automated system that dials pools of numbers and checks to see if a human is on the other side before connecting you to an agent. If it gets silence it hangs up. Real humans wait a few seconds and say “Hello?”
- superbiome 4y agoHalf of the ones I get use those apps that go straight to your voicemail to leave a message so you can’t even answer if you wanted to.
- dkjaudyeqooe 4y agoMy voicemail message is silence. I only get audible responses from live person spam. They seem to just go ahead after a few seconds regardless, probably because of a mandatory script. Then they just say "hello" a few times.
- kar5pt 4y agoI tried this and it didn't work.
- matsemann 4y agoNot so used to "robocalls" where I live, but we do get lots of scam calls spoofing a local number. I feel that should be impossible. Yeah, when I'm in some other country, that operator in that country needs to call "on behalf of me". But there is no verification. I can be connected to a tower here in Norway, and someone from a different country can call my neighbor pretending to be me. Why isn't this a solved problem?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sbarre 4y agoBecause telcos blindly trust the metadata passed to them from outside their networks, and this is by design (going back decades to when all telcos were "trusthworthy" quasi-national actors). The sheer volume of calls that go through a phone network, and the lack of a central system to locate the true source of a call, means it's somewhere between prohibitively expensive and impossible to validate and verify the metadata of every call coming into a telco's network.
- criddell 4y ago> prohibitively expensive and impossible to validate and verify the metadata of every call Isn't that what the SHAKEN and STIR protocols fix? Maybe the telco can't validate every call, but even if they at least told me when the metadata has been verified would be great. Most of my legitimate calls originate from another US number and all of those should be verifiable.
- sbarre 4y agoYes that was a first attempt at addressing this, but it's still imperfect and not universally adopted, even though both the US and Canada have required adoption since 2021. The FCC for example still exempts "small rural phone providers" I believe? Adoption is growing though, but it's hard to say how fast and by who. It's honestly a cost/benefit thing.. Changing fundamental infrastructure at telcos is super hard and expensive and most will not do it until they are forced to by law.
- dtx1 4y agoNever had a robocall in Europe in like ever. Seems like this is a problem that's very possible to completly solve
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ec109685 4y agoWhy is it so easy to spoof caller id phone numbers for these scammers? I use Verizon’s call filter app and it seems to help. I haven’t gotten robocall spam in a while.
- edgyquant 4y agoI’m also curious about this. I’ve gotten calls from people saying I’ve been calling them all night (although not since I’ve switched from android tk iOS) and once I called a number back and the lady on the other side began crying because apparently her phone had been spoofed for awhile and she was getting tons of calls.
- sbarre 4y agoThe simplified answer is that phone networks were designed and built 100 years ago and have a fundamental assumption of trust built into the interoperability model between telcos. Back when every telco was a quasi-governmental national operation, they could all more or less trust each other to do the right thing, so when one network operator receives information from another (for example, caller ID info) it just blindly trusts it as correct. We've layered tons of modern digital services on top in the last decades but fundamentally there's still that very old network with very basic capabilities underpinning it all. And so in today's world where every telco offers wholesale access to resellers (who then have sub-resellers and sub-sub-resellers) it's almost impossible to police this stuff. There's so much traffic going through these networks, it would be very expensive to stop and validate/verify every call's metadata, even though there have been proposals on how to do that put on the table by various parties for years. But telcos are competitors, and getting them together to agree on how to handle this kind of thing is hard. No one can agree on who should pay for it, and no one wants to go first. Every telco basically passes the buck. So if you are on Verizon and you get a fake caller ID spam call, Verizon will say "we're just forwarding the call from X, go complain to X". There has been some legislation passed in the last few years as the problem has gotten worse, but don't expect telcos to move on any of this until forced to by law. source: I work for a telco.
- yamtaddle 4y ago
- ekanes 4y agoWe need to redirect these calls to an AI that will ask great questions and seem almost quite interested.
- toastercat 4y agoI eventually resorted to installing NoPhoneSpam[1] on my phone, and setting it to block all phone numbers not on my contacts list. At first I had doubts that it may prove disruptive, but it was surprisingly easy to adjust to after adding my doctor's number to my contacts list (which I should have done before). Most people end up texting you if they can't reach you, anyway. [1] https://f-droid.org/en/packages/at.bitfire.nophonespam/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/at.bitfire.nophonespam/
- ralmidani 4y agoWhy do consumers get prosecuted for circumventing DRM, even if just to claim back their ownership of content and devices they bought, but companies get away with actually malicious circumvention (spoofing) on a much wider scale? Also, technically speaking, how can big telcos make sure they route a call to the right phone, and also claim to be helpless against spoofing?
- sbarre 4y agoI answered that here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36058724 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36058724 And I go into a bit more detail here if you're interested: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36058560 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36058560
- tombert 4y agoAbout two years ago, someone named Alnar (a man I do not know) requested information about health insurance. For whatever reason, either as a mistake or otherwise, he gave them my Google Voice phone number. I was getting, without hyperbole, more than 150 calls per day, about 100 of which were Robocalls, all of which were trying to sell me healthcare. When I would get humans, they were always asking for Alnar. This went on for about three months, until I just decided to no longer have my Google Voice number route to a "real" phone anymore. I still get about 40 calls a day, most from robots, but they're manifested in the form of transcripts on Google Voice. I hate Alnar, I hope he steps on a Lego block, but even more I hate that it must be at least a little profitable to do this phone spam. They're making the phones largely unusable.
- kar5pt 4y agoI've been getting calls and texts for "Victoria" for literally 5-6 years now. She apparently has been going through forclosure, so I get spam calls trying to buy the house. I know no one named Victoria and have never owned a house.
- yamtaddle 4y agoI have a first-initial-last-name gmail address. Over a period of years, it became basically unusable. A dozen or more people with the same first-initial-last-name have typo'd my email address into enough systems that the volume of crap coming in—some unsolicited stuff that gets through gmail's increasingly-useless spam filters, some technically solicited, just not by me—is high enough that keeping up with it's just not worth it.
- tombert 4y agoYeah, I have a similar problem; I have [firstname][lastname] as a Gmail, and I do get a good chunk of emails targeted to people who are not me. Fortunately my last name isn't terribly popular in the English-speaking world, and my first name (Thomas) isn't super popular in Germany, so it's not a huge deal. Still, it was annoying enough to where I eventually just bought [lastname].app and set up an email for that.
- diyftw 4y agoAdd SIT (aka intercept tones, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_information_tone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_information_tone) to your voicemail greeting. Send robocalls to VM. After a few months, they've dropped to zero for me and mine. Automated systems hear them and identify them as "invalid" numbers. YMMV
- FredPret 4y agoReminds me of this gem: https://www.lennytroll.com/ https://www.lennytroll.com/ "Lenny - The Telemarketing Troll - is a chatbot which answers your home telephone and plays pre-recorded messages interacting with Caller-Id spammers while recording the call for your pleasure and to easily share with the larger Lenny community."
- exabrial 4y agoPlease do CANSPAM next. You're sitting on a gold mine of free tax revenue. I can forward you all the emails from YouTube recently "announcing important changes to my account" that were really Google marketing announcements and nothing changed on my account.