4 ms·
The Structure of Scientific Revolutions [pdf]
- clbrmbr 3y agoGreat book. Influenced my thinking, but I didn’t fully grasp it in uni. On the REREAD list.
- photochemsyn 3y ago> "Scientific knowledge, like language, is intrinsically the common property of a group or else nothing at all. To understand it we shall need to know the special characteristics of the groups that create and use it." I really don't know about this - the divisions that humans have created in their study of science are pretty artificial, i.e. physics/chemistry/biology, and seem to have more to do with academic politics and funding opportunities than the natural world itself. Nature doesn't care about such divisions, not in the least. Mathematics is something of a special case, in that its results (and motivations) are as relevant to the world of art as they are to the world of science.
- Kinrany 3y agoWhere's the contradiction?
- beeneuf 3y agoI'm having trouble understanding this comment. You seem to be grasping at one of the central points the author is raising, but you've phrased your comment as if what you've said is in opposition. Nature doesn't care about divisions, but our ways of communicating and sharing scientific knowledge are shaped by them - often to our detriment.
- photochemsyn 3y agoI suppose the issue is that the text could have been named 'The Structure of Academic Revolutions' which might be closer to its intent and meaning? Nevertheless the natural world, the object of scientific study, should remain the focus of attention, and the fundamental approaches - observation, experiment, theoretical construction - haven't really changed at all since the concept was invented.
- analog31 3y agoThere must be some widespread realization of this problem, because "interdisciplinary" is a common buzzword in grant applications.
- canjobear 3y agoYou can absolutely learn a language and say a lot about it without knowing about the “special characteristics” of people who speak/spoke it. Like, do you need to know anything about Roman culture to understand Latin grammar? No.
- Swizec 3y ago> do you need to know anything about Roman culture to understand Latin grammar? No. But you do need to be fluent in Roman culture to understand Latin jokes, puns, similes, metaphors, and all the other things that go into meaning. For a more modern example: Observe how British English can turn almost any noun into an insult in much the same way that this just doesn't work in American. Or how a Californian can say "this is not my favorite" and we all know they mean "this is awful". Or how Australians can use "you c*nts" as a term of endearment, but Americans cannot. Meanwhile Americans can use motherf*cker as both a term of endearment and an insult depending on situation. And who could forget the subtle difference between "You are shit" and "You are the shit". Where does that show up in grammar? edit: oh here’s a good one! The phrase “I love you” changes meaning when you say it to family, friends, coworkers, strangers, performers on stage, etc. Some languages even use different words for those meanings, but they all translate to “love” In English. You absolutely cannot understand the full meaning of language without understanding the speaker’s context.
- canjobear 3y ago> But you do need to be fluent in Roman culture to understand Latin jokes, puns, similes, metaphors, and all the other things that go into meaning. You need to understand Roman culture to understand Roman jokes, but that is a property of Roman culture, not the Latin language. You could translate American jokes into Latin, and then a hypothetical American who can speak Latin but doesn't know anything about Roman culture would be able to understand and find them funny. Of course, you can't understand the full meaning of an utterance that someone utters in a particular context without understanding who that person is and what the context is. A Roman who somehow spoke perfectly grammatical English would still probably be hard for us to understand. But that's a property of an utterance, not the language itself.
- gattis 3y agoI remember in 2000 when journalists asked George W Bush and Al Gore what their favorite books were. Bush said his was The Bible. Al Gore said his was The Structure of Scientific Revolutions by Thomas Kuhn. Probably could have called the election right then.
- danielrpa 3y agoYes, and irrespective of our opinions on each book... Reading the Bible lets you connect in some form with the majority of your electorate, while reading Kuhn does not.
- chrisbrandow 3y agoThough this argument is undercut somewhat by Bush not actually winning a majority of the electorate. ;-)
- nonethewiser 3y agoIts not undercut at all by not winning the popular vote. 81.6% of the electorate identified as Christian in 2001 and 78% by 2012. Thats a clear majority of the electorate. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianity_in_the_United_States#:~:text=In%20a%202020%20survey%20by,members%20of%20a%20church%20congregation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianity_in_the_United_S....
- cgeier 3y agoBeing Christian probably neither means that your favorite book is the bible nor that you would rather vote for somebody whose favorite book is the bible.
- nonethewiser 3y agoNo one is saying the Bible is the favorite book of Christians nor that its enough to sway votes. The claim was saying his favorite book was the Bible connected him in some form to a majority of the electorate which it did. These seem like uncontroversial observations.
- freerangebat 3y agoIs the book in public domain now?
- malodyets 3y agoNo. This edition is (c) 1970 and thus firmly under copyright for a long time to come (2065 I think). Rules here: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_domain_in_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_domain_in_the_United_... Extended copyright harms the public domain, but the only realistic solution is for authors or publishers to believe in the common good more than their own profits. That does happen: Wikipedia for example is licensed under CC-BY-SA. But then you have Jimmy Wales pleading for donations regularly. Authors and publishers depend on copyright for well deserved income. In the US the balance of interests has swung so far away from the common good toward the author’s and publisher’s interests that for example interesting parody literature like The Wind Done Gone (a parody of Gone with the Wind having the same characters) are suppressed. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions is one of the best books I ever read.
- jknoepfler 3y agoOne of my favorite ideas in Structure is Kuhn's observation that contradictory evidence seldom suffices to overturn a scientific theory. Contradictory evidence is the norm. What's required to overturn a scientific theory is both contradictory evidence and a better theory - and even then adoption is often grudging and uneven. I've found that idea to be very valuable when navigating disagreements at work (and in life generally). Refutation is seldom constructive in isolation - you also need to bring a constructive alternative if you want to keep things moving forward. I guess that sounds like common sense, but I'm surprised by how often people cleave to exclusively negative argumentation (particularly in political discussions).
- andsoitis 3y agoCouldn’t agree more. Dissent alone is usually not helpful, you should also want to collaborate on solutions. Be solution-oriented.
- ggm 3y agoThis is precisely where the antiVax mob failed: they simply wanted to deny the science behind the epidemiology to refuse to vaccinate, and they had no alternate theory beyond lizard-people. Most of the "but there is no good evidence" arguing is not actually arguing in good faith. AGW isn't much different. People leap on 0.1C differences and say AHA fail without contextualising it and then argue anyone who contextualising is "lying" or "altering the data" its a bizarre reductionism, based on autodidact understanding of science. "Because I believe this is the scientific method all the other scientists are not scienting and this is not scientific therefore its trash therefore my theory based on lizard people wins"
- oilchange 3y ago> One of my favorite ideas in Structure is Kuhn's observation that contradictory evidence seldom suffices to overturn a scientific theory. That's not Kuhn's observation. Evidence immediately overturns a theory. What evidence doesn't do is get the scientific establishment to accept the new evidence. It's why paradigm shifts are rare and take a lot of time to happen. In many instances, society simply has to wait for the old to die and the new to gain power. > (particularly in political discussions). That was kuhn's point. Science operates more like politics and religion than science. Many times there is no reason, evidence or argument to change poeple's minds. You have to simply wait for the old guard to die off so that the new guard can usher in a paradigm shift. It's how einstein went to the grave believing "god does not play dice" regardless of all the evidence. And his death moved physics from the deterministic to the nondeterministic world ( paradigm shift ). For all the praise einstein gets, he was wrong about the most important and fundamental aspect of physics.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 8bitsrule 3y agoSee also: Personal Knowledge - Michael Polanyi, 1958. "not only that there is knowledge that cannot be adequately articulated by verbal means, but also that all knowledge is rooted in tacit knowledge...." Against Method. Paul Feyerabend, 1975. "there no such thing as the scientific method and we should not impose a single methodological rule upon scientific practices."
- ggm 3y agoRichard Rhodes is fascinating on Polyani. He viewed the physicists as modern day guildsmen: you achieved merit as a journeyman scientist by proving to other scientists you could do good work and then.. you were one. He also hung with the economists, it's interesting to read stuff from the early years of the LSE. People get hung up in Hayek but Polyani was hanging out in the same rooms.
- kevinpet 3y agoI find a software parallel here. When building new systems in poorly understood domains, you can't proceed as if you already know the paradigm. Instead you have to poke around and try things until you find a working paradigm.
- nonethewiser 3y agoI started reading it a long time ago but stopped. Good book. All I can essentially remember is the claim (which seams fair) that scientific progress is not linear. And doesn’t necessarily build off itself. Sometimes new paradigms emerge and we completely discard the previous scientific consensus.
- gwern 3y agoApropos of a posthumous collection of his unpublished writings, there was an interesting book review of Kuhn's life and context around _Structure_: https://archive.is/Yr4B9 https://archive.is/Yr4B9 It was all quite different than I had expected, and sorta illustrates the challenges of intellectual theorizing when it goes 'viral', so to speak.