7 ms·
France bans flights between cities linked by trains
- eesmith 3y agoSee also the discussion about this on HN 6 month ago, at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33846689 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33846689 linking to https://www.euronews.com/green/2022/12/02/is-france-banning-private-jets-everything-we-know-from-a-week-of-green-transport-proposals https://www.euronews.com/green/2022/12/02/is-france-banning-... .
- josephcsible 3y agoIt's sad when otherwise mostly-free countries do things like this. If you don't understand why this is bad, imagine if the people in charge had the opposite preferences and instead banned going by train between cities linked by commercial flights.
- jeffbee 3y agoThat didn't make obvious sense to me. It makes as much sense as "It's bad to regulate cigarettes. Imagine what would happen if the government regulated apples."
- josephcsible 3y agoBut cigarettes and apples aren't substitutes for each other. A better analogy would be a country banning emacs and mandating vi, or vice versa.
- jeffbee 3y agoIs emacs powered by kerosene?
- josephcsible 3y agoIt's not like kerosene has been banned completely, though, and the right solution for something that you want people to avoid using but not ban completely is a tax on it, not selectively banning certain uses.
- injb 3y agoIt's hard to imagine how that would work. Airline routes are usually based on a use-it-or-lose-it slot. So either the tax will have the desired effect and make the flight uneconomical, in which case it'll be discontinued, or it won't in which case the flight will continue as normal and the government will have an incentive to keep it going, having found some pre-existing use for the extra money that they now can't imagine not having! I can't read the original source: can anyone confirm if this bans private flights or only scheduled flights? I mean could Elon Musk still fly between rail-linked cities in France if he wanted to?
- josephcsible 3y agoThe point is that the market would decide which uses of kerosene are important enough to keep using, rather than the government deciding.
- jeffbee 3y agoI generally agree that it is better to tax emissions and let consumers decide where to spend their carbon budgets. For example, I don't support the idea that we should ban beef, because there are people who want to eat a hamburger and never burn motor fuel, and good for them. But, in this case, that logic doesn't seem to apply. There is nothing "free market" about either air or rail travel. Both exist within and only because of the structure of government, and would not exist without regulation and subsidy.
- josephcsible 3y agoI know rail is heavily subsidized, but aren't most airline routes (with the exception of EAS for really rural places) not subsidized at all?
- DirkH 3y agoA better analogy might be cigarettes or psychedelics. I believe mountains of evidence strongly suggest cigs are worse for us and cause a much worse net negative harm on society via increased long-term strain on our healthcare sector. But, just like planes, people hold onto cigarettes as a right to freedom and attach unwarranted stigma on psychedelics (just like some attach unwarranted stigma on using trains). Banning cigs in some circumstances where the other is allowed makes sense if we just think about overall human welfare, insofar as that is our goal. Same goes for planes.
- simmerup 3y agoIt's probably related to this context: https://www.sciencealert.com/france-prepares-for-4-c-rise-we-cant-escape-the-global-reality https://www.sciencealert.com/france-prepares-for-4-c-rise-we... France's national conversation seems to be increasingly realising that we're heading towards a difficult future and pre-empting it. Anglo societies seem to find this much harder to reckon with.
- jeffbee 3y ago> Anglo societies seem to find this much harder to reckon with. It's because of our astonishingly bad common law system. The worst thing that England gave to the world.
- dmichulke 3y agoWhat about the imperial system of units?
- dolmen 3y agoWhat about driving on the left side of the road?
- theonemind 3y agoWhat problem do you see with the common law system in this context? I do like the principle that all things being equal, cases should get decided the same way, and we technically have the option of amending the law for clarity if courts seem to interpret it strangely. It does seem like it can slow laws down, which seems like a possible advantage in some contexts for the stability and continuity of society, but possibly a major downside if you need to act quickly.
- simmerup 3y agoTo be honest, for the UK at least I've always thought it was because as an English speaking country we have no moat from American media. So we're way more susceptible to the propaganda pumped out by big corporations. I think our common law system is one of the best things about our country
- Semaphor 3y agoI have no strong opinion either way, but your comment sounds a bit like "imagine they made saving lives illegal instead of murdering people" and then expecting us to agree with you.
- josephcsible 3y agoMy whole point is it's not like that. Saving lives is unambiguously good and murdering people is unambiguously bad. Planes and trains are similar and accomplish the same thing, and neither is inherently good or bad.
- Semaphor 3y agoBut aren't planes unambiguously bad compared to take from an ecological perspective?
- jpgvm 3y agoThere are however measurable impacts of both. France's high speed train network is powered by electricity which is primarily provided by it's nuclear energy power plants. When viewing it through this lens then it becomes obvious trains have less climate impact. If that is what you are optimising for then one is better than the other. You have to choose some metric, this just seems to be the one they have chosen.
- josephcsible 3y ago> When viewing it through this lens then it becomes obvious trains have less climate impact. > If that is what you are optimising for then one is better than the other. Yes, if the goal is to minimize climate impact at the expense of everything else, then this is logical, but that's not all that governments are supposed to care about.
- jpgvm 3y agoI guess that really depends on what their analysis was. If their analysis says something along the lines of "if we don't optimise for climate we all die" then I think it becomes pretty obvious what you optimise for. However we don't have this information, we can only speculate.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- DirkH 3y agoIt's not a preference though is it? Isn't this a data and evidence-based decision based on what policy-makers believe is bad for environmental and economical reasons? Imagine if all evidence pointed to train travel between cities being much worse than air travel. Then yes, banning the trains could be the right call.
- jrpt 3y agoInstead of banning things you don't like, pass a carbon tax then to account for externalities. As a bonus, it could be revenue neutral so that your average person actually ends up ahead (while frequent fliers or polluting industries end up paying more).
- Timon3 3y agoDoing so would increase negative feelings in the population about these things being reserved for rich people only.
- raffraffraff 3y agoExternalities never really get covered because there isn't somebody using that money to actually capture that CO² and reverse the damage. It's just a hairshirt that affects the poor most. Rich people still won't care. You could quadruple the price of a flight and affluent people wouldn't notice. Moderately wealthy people would, and they'd bitch about it, but still fly. Actually, if carbon taxes kept poor people off planes, rich folks could network! "Hey, I'm Jonathan. I work for one of the big four." How about allocating carbon credits to people, annually? No trading. You have to budget. From the poorest hobo to Jeff Besos, everybody gets the same. But even that doesn't work. People will use their carbon! It would be like allocated PTO: none will be left on the table at the end of the year. So by setting a budget you are simultaneously ensuring that it becomes the minimum carbon emissions per person, unless you let people cash in unused carbon credits! The hobo gets a Christmas bonus from the CO² man! But the whole system would be impossible to track and police. This thing the French are doing, works.
- DirkH 3y ago
- michael1999 3y agoWait until you learn about GSM.
- thiht 3y agoThis is not just a matter of preference though. Nothing to do with freedom either, I know Americans have trouble defining this notion but don’t be ridiculous.
- rsynnott 3y agoAnd imagine if people with the opposite preferences, instead of banning smoking in restaurants, made it MANDATORY! This isn't really a great argument. "Good regulation is bad actually, because if the opposite of the good regulation was done, that would be bad" isn't particularly coherent. This isn't a preference thing.
- BulgarianIdiot 3y agoSo now it's faster to take a longer flight and travel back to your real destination by cab. Or take two connecting flights passing through a city not connected by train from the two endpoints. You know some people will do that. Enforcing policies in spirit is not as easy as banning things in letter. That's always the issue. Also what happens to medical patients, say after surgery? Travel by train? That would've probably killed my grandmother. Only time she travelled by airplane in her life by the way.
- jeffbee 3y ago[flagged]
- josephcsible 3y ago> Also what happens to medical patients, say after surgery? Travel by train? That would've probably killed my grandmother. Only time she travelled by airplane in her life by the way. Indeed, and this rule is so ham-fisted that there basically can't even be exceptions, since there wouldn't be enough of them to make a flight economical to fly.
- Freak_NL 3y agoIt's not like travel by car is outlawed. You can't travel by air anywhere unless you happen to live right next to an airport; there is always travel to and from the airport. If a medical condition mysteriously doesn't allow for train travel, but going by car and plane is fine (odd), than travelling for 400km by car is fine too. Most people live quite a distance from the nearest commercial airport in any case (200km in my case, and that's in the tiny Netherlands).
- josephcsible 3y agoMedical conditions that preclude train travel also preclude long-haul car travel.
- TheCoelacanth 3y ago
- vlod 3y agoI wonder if the government will follow these rules or it's just for regular people. It would be hypocritical otherwise. (Maybe it says that in TFA, but unfortunately I can't speak French).
- stragies 3y agoOne responder inquires about the "Le Touquet" destination, which is less than 2.5 hours from Paris. And according to Google, a bunch of goverment officials live there. But the law only seems to talk about Lyon, Nantes, Bordeaux et Paris-Olry
- themoonisachees 3y agoThe law isn't just about these destinations, the summary just lists them as examples of routes that are getting cancelled.
- 908B64B197 3y agoWhat's interesting is that trains are government-operated in France but airlines aren't. With this regulation, this effectively removed the only competitors to the state-operated monopoly. It was always puzzling to me how operating expensive, fuel hungry airplanes could be cheaper and faster for the consumer than fast electric trains. But that's due to the intense competitive landscape in Europe for carriers (where any company from any European country can operate in any other country. Think Singapore Airline operating JFK-LAX). Now the state monopoly effectively regulated away competition. They don't need to offer a better, faster product. Guaranteed consumers. > I wonder if the government will follow these rules or it's just for regular people. The Président de la République is notorious for never taking the train, instead flying on a private wide-body A330. These laws are just for regular people.
- jonp888 3y agoSNCF is not a monopoly any more. European regulations also prevent this(although admittedly the French government delayed implementing them as long as the possibly could). There is already competition on the Paris - Lyon - Milan route, and more will follow.
- photochemsyn 3y agoThey really should have two exceptions, one for electric airplanes and the other for planes fueled entirely with atmospheric CO2-sourced fuels (CO2 + H2O -> renewable energy -> jet fuel). Neither of those options are all that economically viable just yet, however.
- nradov 3y agoThe government shouldn't pick winners in terms of specific technologies. They have a terrible track record for doing that and usually fail to anticipate innovations. Plus we end up with a whole new department of highly paid government bureaucrats writing and enforcing rules without doing anything productive. If we want lower CO2 emissions then just tax those and let the free market sort out specific solutions.
- photochemsyn 3y agoA ban on coal-fired Stanley Steamers makes a lot of sense, from the perspective that governments should promote transport technologies that reduce smog and other air pollution. Extending this to diesel trucks (affiliated with a lot of childhood asthma) - assuming you have electric trucks available is reasonable.
- jeffbee 3y agoThere should also be an exemption for magic carpets, since those exist to the same extent.
- turbo_fart 3y agoMagic carpets don't need to be exempted since they wouldn't fit into any category
- Ancalagon 3y agoBoiled down to one exception: carbon neutral flights.
- 3y ago
- pier25 3y agoWhile I agree it's better to travel by train, the way to implement this should have been with carbon taxing. Most people wouldn't fly if the ticket price was like 2x compared to the train.
- wyager 3y agoThe negative externalities of a plane ticket absolutely do not double the cost of a plane ticket. They are not significant - certainly smaller than the taxes already levied on flights. What this tells you is that flights, as they exist, are a net positive even including negative carbon externalities. Neither banning these flights nor making them absurdly expensive is a net benefit for society. When we consider the marginal negative environmental externality compared to rail travel, it is even smaller or perhaps negative.
- pier25 3y ago> The negative externalities of a plane ticket absolutely do not double the cost of a plane ticket I'm sure you will reconsider in a couple of years once the effects of emissions are more obvious.
- ravi-delia 3y agoI doubt very much that the marginal external costs of plane travel is lower than train travel! It's possible that the net value is still worth it (depending on how much people value convenience), but objectively the marginal cost of one more person riding a plane is [externality of flight]/[capacity of flight]. One train trip over the same route has 10x the denominator, and considering that the power comes from the grid not much worse of a numerator, if indeed it is not lower. Does a train really consume that much power?
- themoonisachees 3y agoOops is out of their mind. A train running on 70% nuclear energy from the grid with 90+% efficiency cannot possibly have similar externalities to a plan running on highly transformed fossil fuels. The only way this is even close is if you count the track the train runs on to be dedicated exclusively to that train.
- aatharuv 3y agoI presume there always are people always flying in from overseas into one of the larger airports and catching a connecting flight domestically. It'll become annoying if they suddenly have to grab their bags, go to the train station and catch a connecting train. Even if there are exceptions, the flights just might become unprofitable and go away.
- keiferski 3y agoMost of the major airports in France have train stations built-in. For example, you can fly to Paris airport then take a train directly to Lyon; no need to go into the center of Paris first. It’s really not much different from changing flights.
- renaudg 3y agoParis CDG and Lyon LYS are the only airports in France I can think of with a built-in mainline train station. And the schedules are much less convenient than those in city-centre stations.
- keiferski 3y agoThis hasn’t been updated in nine years but it seems to confirm that there are only two: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Airport_railway_stations_in_France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Airport_railway_stati... But I suppose the majority of overseas travelers coming into France by air with the intention of connecting to a smaller city do so via Paris or Lyon. As European travelers seem to enter by car or go directly to their destination. At least that’s my impression from reading a few articles about tourism in France.
- renaudg 3y agoYes and no, IIRC the second busiest airport in France is actually Nice (NCE) on the French Riviera.
- 3y ago
- rasz 3y agoSome time ago (10 years?) it was cheaper for me to fly to Norway and back to Poland than take a 300km train ride.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoPrivate jets too?
- utucuro 3y agoJust guessing: no.
- renaudg 3y agoThe sad part is that this move is hailed as a major win but really is a drop in the ocean. I've read somewhere that Germany closing its last nuclear power plant will raise Europe's CO2 emissions by more than all of the country's air travel emissions in a year.