7 ms·
Nintendo sued for “immoral” Mario Kart lootboxes
- racl101 3y agoThe moment Zelda does online multiplayer or does any kind of microtransactions I'm out.
- Maken 3y agoNintendo does multiplayer without microtransactions (see Splatoon). It seems they don't care about mobile market and just license they franchises to whoever can make the most money.
- fauxpause_ 3y agoWhat if the online multiplayer is fun?
- LetsGetTechnicl 3y agoYeah there's a multiplayer Breath of the Wild mod which looks really fun. Of course Nintendo threatened legal action to its creators and streamers
- MisterTea 3y agoEither they hold their ground and boycott playing the game or they don't. If something being fun is enough to tempt you to compromise your moral beliefs then you have a problem.
- derstander 3y ago> If something being fun is enough to tempt you to compromise your moral beliefs then you have a problem. My take might be naive, but isn’t pleasure in general — fun in this specific case — the chief reason that people compromise their moral beliefs? Though I don’t particularly understand the moral judgment about online multiplayer. But I am sympathetic to judgments about “always-online” single player functionality.
- fauxpause_ 3y agoI don’t think it’s a compromise of your moral beliefs to play a fun multiplayer game Or at least it ought not to be
- yamtaddle 3y agoIf it's fun, that's great. Adding multiplayer elements to otherwise single-player games or franchises usually just shits them up, though.
- kibwen 3y agoWe're all lucky that Nintendo is so technologically inept that they're perpetually 20 years behind the latest trends. Imagine what a shitshow Tears Of The Kingdom would be if it had Genshin-style gacha bullshit.
- hbn 3y agoI mean it literally does have in-game vending machines that spit out little pods with items in them! But you pay with items you collect in the game. And it's not like a collecting thing, the items are just portable fans and platforms and wheels and whatnot for building.
- yamtaddle 3y ago... and you don't need any more than you'll just stumble on for free to advance in the game, and if you're a seasoned RPG-item-hoarder you'll beat the game never having used any of them, anyway, "just in case you need them later".
- hbn 3y agoYeah I've usually just been using each one I stumble upon once to see if there's anything new in it I don't have I think I used a fan once to blow some sand, and a mirror to reflect sunlight for a puzzle in the overworld where they had mirror pods in a chest nearby!
- yamtaddle 3y agoOh shit. I had stopped really paying attention to those pick-ups (I think I've used... maybe two? In more than 20 hours?) but now that you mention it, I think one I got was a mirror—I totally could have used a mirror to turn a 15-minute puzzle I did a couple days ago, into a 1-minute puzzle.
- mcphage 3y agoI wonder if affection for capsule machines is a Nintendo thing? Yoshi's Wooly World has capsule machines, and they're even less like real capsules machines—every machine has a 10 capsules, that's it, and they don't restock. Some of the things you get are labelled "common" and some "rare" and some "super rare", but ... the chance of each capsule is exactly the same. And if you buy 10, then you get all 10.
- hospitalJail 3y agoWhy does 1 game every 4 years keep you attached to Zelda? Maybe its my gigantic backlog of games, but I don't bother with Nintendo anymore. My bro or a friend will let me borrow their Nintendo system + Zelda for a few weeks. (its not like people really use their Switch...)
- warent 3y ago[flagged]
- whywhywhywhy 3y agoReally shows how ill the "App Store" model is when a company like Nintendo who has an entire hardware empire off selling high quality non-exploitative games can't make money on it without resorting to gambling industry tactics like the other low quality apps/games on there. Sad that I had hoped some exec at Nintendo would veto this approach as "Not Nintendo" rather than choosing to tarnish the brand and take the money, like Apple did.
- Skeime 3y agoWhich Apple thing are you referring to? But yeah, the (monetization) design of Nintendo’s mobile games is quite disappointing.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoPerhaps Apple's moves to the cloud and making more services? Or even allowing loot boxes in apps on its store.
- freedomben 3y agoI am highly critical of Apple's heavy handed "approval" requirements for apps coupled with not allowing users to sideload, but if they're going to do it anyway ostensibly for protecting the user, the least they could do it is block the clearly exploitative loot-box approach.
- whywhywhywhy 3y ago>Which Apple thing are you referring to? The App Store and exploitative the models it's design perpetuates.
- mrguyorama 3y agoApple is in for 30% of the take from every single gambling and gacha games, and the take is MASSIVE. They have very strong "incentives" to not have a problem with giving kids gambling games.
- kobalsky 3y ago
- setgree 3y agoSouth Park covered the addictiveness of microtransactions aimed at kids in 2014: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freemium_Isn%27t_Free https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freemium_Isn%27t_Free The scene in which Satan explains brain chemistry to Stan is well worth watching: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=B29YStCYorY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=B29YStCYorY
- lb4r 3y agoTo watch the whole episode for free (might not be available in all regions): https://www.southparkstudios.com/episodes/jy5lbq/south-park-freemium-isn-t-free-season-18-ep-6 https://www.southparkstudios.com/episodes/jy5lbq/south-park-...
- jchw 3y agoEven if the explanation about dopamine receptors is a bit oversimplified, the general insights here were really impressive for 2014. This episode is the first time I had ever been introduced to the concept of "whales" in the context of microtransactions. I bet it has aged fairly well.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dathinab 3y agoI hope they (Nintendo) lose big time on this, it was quite disappointment to see Nintendo approve this IMHO highly children hostile design.
- Skeime 3y agoFrom the title, I expected this to be about someone suing over the item boxes in Mario Kart 8, which would have been, um, fun.
- olivierestsage 3y agoFor anyone interested in understanding more about the context behind this, I recommend checking out this presentation [0] and HN discussion [1] from a little while back. [0] https://growth.design/case-studies/mario-kart-revenue-model https://growth.design/case-studies/mario-kart-revenue-model [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35058744 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35058744
- Maken 3y agoI did not know much about this game, but any of those dark patterns should be enough to get them sued.
- fauxpause_ 3y agoNintendo shut this loot box thing down around a year ago. So… you know, get over it. It’s already been dead a long time. No, Nintendo is not sprinting along the dark path. I’m amused that the plaintiff is complaining over $170. A tiny sum for a whale in the scheme of things.
- sp332 3y agoThey're working on a class action lawsuit. They just need a few specific people to represent the class.
- fauxpause_ 3y agoSure. It’s still small.
- behringer 3y agoDoesn't matter how small the scam is if it's still a scam.
- kibwen 3y agoNintendo still has one game on the app store (which I'll deliberately avoid naming so as not to give it free advertising) that's even worse than the Mario Kart when it comes to predatory gambling monetization. Their hands aren't clean.
- henry2023 3y ago"Nintendo shut this loot box thing down around a year ago" Not true. A couple months ago, I played MKT for a while. The loot box is alive and well.
- fauxpause_ 3y agoI’m curious of anyone can validate that? This article and others appear to claim it is gone.
- 3y ago
- gjsman-1000 3y agoWell… that’s going to further hit the profitability of Nintendo’s mobile games division. That division already has pretty mediocre-by-comparison returns. They are quite good for a mobile game, but a drop in the bucket compared to Switch products and not worth the time to focus on. Rumor has it that Nintendo is probably going to shut down that division and their mobile games soon. They are already adding the MK Tour tracks into MK 8 as part of the Booster Course Pass.
- freedomben 3y agoIt's already heavily against Nintendo's DNA to produce for platforms that aren't their own[1]. They are very much like Apple in that respect. Given that the mobile thing would have had to be tremendously beneficial to avoid the knife. So you are very right, this is probably the end for Nintendo's mobile gaming efforts. [1]: The book "Super Mario: How Nintendo Conquered America" by Jeff Ryan was incredibly fascinating if you're interested in the history and "inside story" of Nintendo in their early days. Can't recommend enough. Narrated by the great Ray Porter, and DRM free on Downpour: https://www.downpour.com/super-mario?sp=19981 https://www.downpour.com/super-mario?sp=19981
- jerf 3y agoI don't like that Nintendo does this. I don't care who does it, it's wrong. That said, of all the people doing this, it seems to me Nintendo is among the worst targets to go after. They were, to my eye, dragged into this almost against their will, and if anything they've been backing off from it. It certainly hasn't wormed its way in to their mainline games the way it is well into worming its way in to almost every other major publisher out there's games. Again, I don't say this to defend them. It's wrong for everyone. What I am saying though is that this is not a very target rich environment, and there are target-rich environments elsewhere. There are companies that seem to be entirely based not only on exploitative mechanics, but exploitative mechanics specifically targeted at children, like Roblox. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_gXlauRB1EQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_gXlauRB1EQ and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vTMF6xEiAaY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vTMF6xEiAaY, the People Make Games investigations into them, for instance. Although there is an interesting strategy for Nintendo to pursue here where they get sued, and then basically deliberately construct a precedent-setting loss to knee-cap their competition on this front. There's a lot of competition for Nintendo out there surviving on the basis of these cheap drug hits of monetary injection whose ability to develop good games on their own merits are clearly well into the process of atrophy, and Nintendo would probably stand to benefit even if they have to pay some millions of dollars in settlement payouts to impose those restrictions on them. If those mechanics were, for the sake of argument, banned, I think Nintendo would be a big winner in that scenario. Consumers too, for that matter.
- vanderZwan 3y agoUnless the kid also plays Roblox and has been a victim of their behavior he can't exactly sue the company behind it though, can he? Whereas if he actually has played the mobile version of Mario Kart he can.
- jerf 3y agoThe kid is not important. He is a convenient foil for the lawyers. This is not a bad thing necessarily; of such things are class action lawsuits made. But they can just as easily find someone hurt by Roblox. It wouldn't hardly take them a day.
- quadrifoliate 3y agoI find it hard why chance-based lootboxes are not banned for kids' games. They are basically normalizing gambling at a very young age, with all of the negative potential that that brings. This might be the only thing that US Sen. Josh Hawley from Missouri and I agree on, given his sponsorship of S.1629: https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/1629/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/162...
- GordonS 3y ago> They are basically normalizing gambling at a very young age I feel the same way, and it's why I won't allow my kids to play any games that include loot boxes. I never play such games myself either. I'm hoping that the EU legislates against this, which in turn I hope causes others to follow suit.
- jandrese 3y agoI completely agree, and it is also why I don't play Collectable Card Games. Not only does it normalize gambling, but it's outright wasteful.
- hospitalJail 3y agoOn the bright side, maybe these gambling things will 'get old'. I know as an adult, I never got sucked into farmvile, modern call of duty/FPS, or a serious MMO. I played these as a child/teen, I already knew how they worked, nothing interesting. Now the only things that get me going are novel games like Minecraft/Papers Please/etc... I really hate gambling and I'd love for adults to be bored of it. However I think I know better. Gambling/addictive exploitation might be bad enough to call upon government, however I doubt they will be competent enough to actually remove it.
- mrguyorama 3y agoThe fact that they only really pull in people susceptible to gambling addiction makes it worse, not better. If the games were actually fun, but some people just couldn't help but put a thousand dollars into it, maybe it would be harder to justify ending it. But making a game fun is actually not useful for taking advantage of gambling addicts. They don't get their fix from the game being fun, but rather from having something "at stake". In fact, the things you want to do to better target that dopamine rush tend to make the system a worse "game", as rewards get skewed, incentives get hijacked, and everything else gets a cost associated with it. They're only purpose is to "mine" the addicts as if they were an oil well.
- ftxbro 3y agoyou know your game has made it, when it's ruled by a judge to be immorally addicting
- OJFord 3y agoI think the 'immorally' makes it the opposite, it taints the success conveyed by 'addicting'. Like taking the world by storm with an e-cigarette product containing vs containing nicotine.
- ftxbro 3y agoi was thinking more like sinfully chocolatey
- hospitalJail 3y agoNah, the second program I ever made, age 17, was a text based rpg that was incredibly addicting. In <200 lines of python code, I made an addictive game. Random enemies of various difficulty, including one that was ultra hard, so you had a reason to keep playing for hours as you leveled up. My buddy got so hooked to it, he wouldn't move onto our next activity, lucky for me, whatever I did with my input() was bad and he caused it to error out at some point. Addicting games arent hard, fun games are hard.
- mrguyorama 3y agoIf your video game dispenses heroin every time you get a kill, is it really the game that is good? These aren't good games that people are getting addicted to. The gambling addiction thing is a brain defect essentially.
- jonhohle 3y agoDoes every business model eventually fall into vile recurring payments? Are business that sell a nice thing that you can pay a fair price for once so unattractive to investors now that beloved brands are willing to throw away their reputation nickel and diming customers?
- behringer 3y agoGood. I even wrote to Nintendo expressing my displeasure about this when I first heard they were doing it. Glad to see someone's doing something more about it.
- aceazzameen 3y agoAs someone who once worked in mobile games for a decade, I hate mobile games. I was naive to think I could change anything.
- bluescrn 3y agoBeen there, done that... It's such a shame, as the early years of mobile gaming were a lot of fun, but the market decided it'd rather have ad-ridden near-gambling exploitative F2P so long as it was labelled as 'FREE', rather than pay $1-5 or so for a small-but-complete game :( And all the games from the early years of the iPhone are gone. You can't keep a game on the App Store any more without basically committing yourself to updating it indefinitely.
- hbn 3y agoNintendo's dip into smartphone apps has been disappointing. At the beginning they were doing some interesting stuff, like Miitomo which was a simple social-media-like app where you and your friends basically just answered questions if I recall, I had fun with that for a few months. They released Super Mario Run which wasn't really my thing but it was at least a one-time purchase that got you all the content. But apparently not even Nintendo can overcome the enshittification of mobile app stores, and we have Mario Kart Tour which is just pay-to-win garbage that uses every dirty trick in the book to get your money. They infamously make you do races with fake online players that look like they've been spending money to make you see what you're "missing out on". Even worse, Tour has infected Nintendo's actually good Mario Kart offering on Switch, with recent DLC packs including courses from Tour which are the most bland, uninspired, and boring courses in the game cause it's always just generic city streets with some Toads standing around in the audience. Obviously they do it because they already have moderately high-quality models of the maps that they can just drag into the game from Tour, as opposed to recreating something from e.g. Mario Kart 64 or Super Mario Kart (SNES) to bring it up to modern standards. Or making something new entirely.
- bil7 3y agoWhile I agree that their monetisation strategies are garbage, I think the Tour maps ported to Switch are quite good and novel. I prefer them to the rehashed SNES maps.
- hbn 3y agoI find them really badly telegraphed on where you need to turn. They have these transparent walls with arrows that are kind of non-obvious, and sometimes you have to turn at the wall itself, and sometimes the wall is further back from where the road ends and you need to actually turn. I've never had this issue with any other tracks in the game except for the Tour ones, but I'll constantly be driving along and just run into a wall because I didn't know I was supposed to turn. It's even worse if you're playing split-screen multiplayer with 3 or 4 people and your screen is 1/4 of the TV that's on the other side of the room. It's probably not an issue in Tour where you've got a high-res screen right up close to your face, but it doesn't work on a home console.
- shp0ngle 3y agoWhen loot boxes came to Overwatch (the old one), I thought "hm what a great idea, it helps monetise the game, while offering just un-important cosmetics", it did not affect gameplay, you did win them through actual gameplay too (and it was not that hard to win them, just play the game). The good old days of Overwatch 1. Now they killed the game with the battle pass stuff and I just refuse to take part in that. Bring back loot boxes!
- omginternets 3y ago>Yes, but: A similar lawsuit filed early last year against Take Two Interactive over microtransactions was sent to arbitration last October in a partial win for the game-maker. Honest question: what am I to make of the fact that binding arbitration is a for-profit business, and that the accused are their clients?
- elif 3y agoIf nothing is done, lootboxes will become larger than traditional gambling due to the size of the video game market, if it is not already [0]. Taking on Nintendo is the best way to strike the belly of the beast and will set a better precedent than targeting adult-centric games (which are actually played by teens). [0] US gambling ~$100B, video games ~$60B. But in Vegas the house takes 0.5%-10%, and in loot boxes the house takes 100%
- OJFord 3y agoIt's not really gambling at all though is it, since as you say 'the house takes 100%' - there's no expectation of (any chance of) profiting from it. It's dumb yes, but it is just paid entertainment; we don't say paying Netflix is gambling ('some months we don't even find something we want to watch!') for example.
- p_j_w 3y agoIt's not technically gambling, but it's every bit as insidious and preys on the exact same elements of human nature, except we allow it to happen to children.
- elif 3y agoI mean, many lootboxes contain things that can be resold for profit... It's just that game devs don't have to "pay out" the winnings, more consumers do. CS skins are the most obvious. Gacha is definitely gambling even if profit isn't the primary motive. You could argue that profit isn't even the primary motivation of many poker players, but rather being seen as smarter than the next guy or more able to call bullshit.
- Adrox 3y agoIt’s not even close to Netflix . You paid a 5$ monthly FIXED fee and can watch everything. Loot boxes on Netflix would be, you have no movies when you start: You pay 2$ to add Random 3 movies to your library. Wanna watch Breaking Bad? Pay 2$ until you get “lucky” (and maybe get only Season 3). Ah, and maybe because it’s premium show, there is only 0.5% chance of getting it in every “loot box”. So you might spend thousands of dollars, and not get what you want… Because usually there is not even a way to spend 10$ to buy it like a movie on Aplle/Amazon, you have to gamble!
- giantg2 3y agoSeems like a sad reflection of our society today. More and more it's about shortcuts, easy money, and just buy what you want instead of working for anything. There's little pride in earning or creating something, and it's just used as a status symbol to 1-up. And of course others a ready to take advantage of this by creating systems that promote this pay to win lazy attitude.