5 ms·
Talks That Attendees See in Person More Likely to Be Cited
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cornfutes 4y ago"The mere-exposure effect is a psychological phenomenon by which people tend to develop a preference for things merely because they are familiar with them." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere-exposure_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere-exposure_effect
- ftxbro 3y agoi wonder if this concept has implications for careers of remote workers
- gitgud 3y ago> They found that for attendees who had multiple schedule conflicts with a liked talk, the probability of later citing that talk was 2.6%. But for attendees who did not have a conflict, that figure rose to 3.8%. Doesn’t seem super scientific, schedules and conflicts vary so much between people, personal events, exams, tragedy’s… pretty hard to lump these all together. This could just be a matter of, the people who went, wanted to go more, therefore they’re more interested and more likely to cite the work in the future
- rwmj 3y agoI can believe it, given the awfulness of remote conference tools. Someone will crack this problem - it might require better hardware - but the current systems are nothing like attending in person.
- Fomite 3y agoI've come to truly hate remote scientific conferences. There are a lot of things to commend them in theory, but between day-to-day distractions, the inability to really do the "I'm sorry, I'll be in $CITY" rather than "The conference ends at 3, surely you can still..." thing, fatigue from being in different time zones, etc. they just slide off my brain. I literally can't remember what sessions I even saw.
- travisporter 3y agoI often wondered why people got paid to flip signs for stores/tax services. Turns out it’s way more eyeball catching because of the way we evolved. Can’t this be something similar?
- getoffmycase 3y agoThere’s another alternative: conference talks have a higher signal to noise ratio than just pushing a paper out into the void (the background noise). To get a talk, you need to be selected, so that act of selection is the first filter. After that it’s way easier to identify the good talks from the bad.
- obblekk 4y agoThe act of physically immersing myself into something just leaves my brain with a stronger memory of the content, than only viewing the content. If some tech could close this gap, all sorts of learning rates would increase. Until then, it's a downside of being remote (perhaps balanced by many upsides for many people!)
- crimsontech 3y agoMaybe I’m odd, but when I watch talks recorded at conferences I take notes, pause to visit resources discussed by the speaker and skip back to things I misheard or didn’t grasp properly. Then I’ll save it for reference along with the notes and slides if made available. In person I’m usually feeling uncomfortable to be surrounded by so many people and can’t focus on the talk in the same way.
- ghaff 4y agoScreen and other distractions notwithstanding, attending a conference in person is inherently more immersive for a lot of people with reduced day-to-day distractions and in-person discussions about topics. Even if videos are good people are just more likely to tune out or go off and do something else.
- tikkun 4y agoEverything can be viewed as a product. A scientific paper is a product. Products need distribution and sales. Talks and 1-1 conversations are "sales" for papers.
- behnamoh 4y agounfortunately this mindset has plagued academia for decades now. when your KPI is the number of citations and your tenure depends on number of publications, you cannot expect quality teaching and even high quality research (in some fields, most research is a joke tbh, lots of papers that are not peer reviewed and are irreproducible).
- hardtke 4y agoThis is why it is dangerous to think that the best scientific theories always prevail and that science is a meritocracy. The people invited to give talks are usually well known or have connections with the program committees. There is also an element of bias since the people on the organizing and program committees will invite speakers whose research is consistent with their own work.
- dev_tty01 3y agoNot true in any field I have been associated with. Many, if not most conference review processes use blind reviews. Conferences are not full of "invited" speakers. Maybe one or two plenary sessions at the beginning, but the rest submitted their own papers and went through the blind review process. Certainly true in the best EE, CS, and ML conferences. I've served on program committees for international conferences. Around 100 papers selected typically, only two invited papers.
- mnky9800n 3y agoMost of the physical sciences have open conferences so anyone can submit without peer review. If a session has an invited speaker they are invited because the organizer knows their work.
- mathisfun123 3y agoThis is such a weird denialism. Let me ask you something: if you go look at the top 100 cited researchers do you really think their enormous citation counts come from the brilliance of their work? Or is it just possible it's something else? I'll tell you first hand, my advisor who is among those top 100, accretes citations like a black hole because he/she is famous, sits on committees (at uni and a national lab), speaks in front of Congress etc etc etc. and thus gets invited to be a coauthor on a billion papers a year (and not because of his/her brilliance). Also if you think program committees and reviewers don't know who wrote a paper when the same group has been submitting to the same top conference every year for over a decade then I have a bridge to sell you.
- 3y ago
- m463 4y agoWouldn't this correlate with people with a bias for action? (both to physically go to a talk, and to take the action of creating something that would cite it) Also, physically attending a talk shows a very strong interest in a subject, meaning you would probably already be working on some adjacent knowledge.
- uoaei 4y agoIndeed. I would suspect that also the talk goes into more detail about some of the less-familiar contributions, which helps with understanding and retention. People won't cite papers if they don't understand them well, and that could happen if they're so dry that the point doesn't come across as easily.
- jldugger 4y agoI'm not sure this is as strong an effect as the research[1] suggests. Is it not possible that, when in choosing which of two liked papers with conflicting schedules to watch, researchers are demonstrating which is the better paper? [1]: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2209.01175.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2209.01175.pdf
- pfannkuchen 4y ago“Scientists more likely to cite the work of friends. Scientists also more likely to attend the talks of friends.” Wonder if they controlled for this? I’m assuming the article doesn’t mention it (they rarely address obvious first order nitpicks).
- not2b 4y agoThere are so many factors that it's difficult to sort them out. Back when I attended conferences (have only been to one since Covid) I choose to attend talks that I'm interested in and skip those that are less interesting. Back when I was publishing, if there were another author working on the same problem as me for sure I would try to attend their talk and would probably end up citing it in a future paper.
- bookpeople 3y agoIf you tally just the papers and talks that you cited, not those you did not cite, what is the ratio of the amount of time spent on reading papers from conference talks and listening to the talks to the amount of time spent on reading papers without talks?
- not2b 3y agoNo idea. It's been a long time since I was in a research-oriented group and published frequently and I didn't track my time in the detail that would be needed to answer this.
- renewiltord 4y agoWhat would you do to control for that?
- ta8903 4y agoOnly study scientists with no friends.
- pfannkuchen 3y ago