4 ms·
Would love all of these people bemoaning investors natural stupidity to trade on it, given their clearly superior understanding of capital allocation. “Market
by whimsicalism 3y ago
Would love all of these people bemoaning investors natural stupidity to trade on it, given their clearly superior understanding of capital allocation.
“Market can stay stupid longer than you can stay solvent.” -> Yeah, that is called cope.
- standardUser 3y agoCan you define "cope" in that sentence?
- meghan_rain 3y agoDenying reality even after being proven wrong
- whimsicalism 3y agoI can expand: They are not actually better at capital allocation than the sum of market participants (obviously, who is?) and so when they lose money it is because the market is so stupid they are losing money, rather than some failure in their ability to model.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- im3w1l 3y ago“Market can stay stupid longer than you can stay solvent.” that is an argument for not shorting. But you can still abstain from investing, which will be sufficient to outperform those who did invest if you are right.
- vlovich123 3y agoNo one is claiming to be about you time anything which is what’s needed to actually accomplish what you’re asking for. However, if someone says “if you drive at 200 mph at night with your lights off on a winding road in the rain you’ll crash”, you’d be asking “yeah sure, but you can’t tell me which mile marker”.
- 1over137 3y agoCope in that sentence is likely https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Cope https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Cope
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mach1ne 3y ago> “Market can stay stupid longer than you can stay insolvent.” -> Yeah, that is called cope. You had me at the start but lost me here. That’s not speculation, that’s a fact. Some big shorters of the 2008 crisis almost went broke waiting for the market to catch up.
- whimsicalism 3y agoRight, but what they are supposed to be modeling is the market, so if they went broke doing so they failed at doing that. [0] > Some big shorters of the 2008 crisis almost went broke waiting for the market to catch up. At what point are you a successful predictor of the 2008 crisis vs. a guy who just shorted the economy in 2006? [0]: https://www.econlib.org/archives/2015/08/recessions_ofte.html https://www.econlib.org/archives/2015/08/recessions_ofte.htm...
- ben_w 3y agoThe adage exists as a reminder that human behaviour can make people run off a metaphorical cliff, and, just like a cartoon character, keep going horizontally until they look down. But never discount the possibly of spherical cows in a vacuum.
- sudosysgen 3y agoModelling the market is not the same as allocating capital efficiently. The former requires predicting stupid and irrational investors acting as mob.
- majormajor 3y ago" Right, but what they are supposed to be modeling is the market, so if they went broke doing so they failed at doing that. [0]" soo now we've moved from "take advantage of investors being stupid by trading against it inidivudally" to "accomplish a FAR HARDER task by modeling the whole market". Cool cool, moving goalposts for days. Calling certain investors stupid is hardly contradicting the idea that the market as a whole will sort itself out in the end.
- belter 3y agoDot-Com Bubble -> Housing Bubble -> Unicorn Startup Fad -> GameStop and Meme Stocks Fad -> Special Purpose Acquisition Companies Fad -> Crypto Bubble -> AI Bubble Like on a linked list, you can only "point" to the next big disaster!
- roflyear 3y agoRecognizing stupid doesn't mean you are able to do better or shouldn't imply you need to have a better alternative. You can criticize something without being beholden to offer an alternative.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoI mean, if you define "being right" as being on the right side of the trade - then by definition it makes sense to "trade against" something if you think you know better. In reality, it's nowhere near this simplistic. You have to time it. Timing is impossible. Manipulation happens.
- ShamelessC 3y agoThe majority of people aren’t in a position to do that.
- harry8 3y ago> Yeah, that is called cope. No that is something anyone shorting needs to understand fully and deeply. e.g. the dotcom bubble was clearly a bubble with most dotcoms absolute garbage investments. People looked at it and correctly saw it as such and decided to short. They were 100% correct and still lost big money because it took too long to be proven so. Dotcoms as they were in 2000 were ridiculous investments that have gone badly south. You couldn't buy google, you could buy Looksmart, repeat that pattern for basically every company that ended up successful. Social media was not a thing. Internet advertising was an utter joke from every level of analysis (is it still? No clue). The thing was clear and obvious and did pan out as expected but man alive it took some time.
- whimsicalism 3y agoFunny how you only get the people crowing about how it is a bubble after the fact. If everyone knew it was clearly a bubble, it would not be a bubble.
- harry8 3y agoIn a game of chicken, everyone who plays does so knowing the cliff is right there. Riding what you know is an investment bubble has a little more upside than driving toward a cliff. Same exit strategy, lesser consequence, similarly reckless in attitude. At the time people showed the necessary cashflows & growth required for profitless doctcom companies to justify their price and nobody could make it make sense. You'd have to be pretty stupid to think greater fools buying can go on forever. I'm sure some people in finance "believed" in it and others claimed to. Not many in the circles I moved in even paid lip-service unless they were in the IPO business. Plenty played. Did your experience differ?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- woeirua 3y agoHow do you explain the performance of companies like Lyft, DoorDash, Tesla, etc? People have, rightly, been calling them out as examples of companies that are fundamentally overvalued for years now. But it has only been in the past year or so that the market has actually started to value them appropriately. The market has been extremely irrational since Covid started, but was showing clear signs of that before Covid too.