4 ms·
> “The Court here uses unambiguous language to eliminate an oft-used point raised in fair use analysis. Simply adding ‘some new expression, meaning or message’
by ryandrake 4y ago
> “The Court here uses unambiguous language to eliminate an oft-used point raised in fair use analysis. Simply adding ‘some new expression, meaning or message’ does NOT, in and of itself, create a transformational use. Period.
It seems weird to have judges and lawyers critiquing artwork like this. Seems like a bit of an increase in the scope of their jobs. Isn't "transformational" like beauty, in the eye of the beholder?
- ethbr0 4y agoThe US Congress passed copyright laws. Reality raises questions on edge cases. The courts clarify edge cases. In this case, the courts' clarification just happens to be on "What sort of artistic transformation is sufficient to qualify for that copyright exception?" This essentially clarifies that pasting (adding) something on top of a copyrighted work isn't sufficient. (Notably, there are other exclusions besides transformation that a work could also qualify for)
- freejazz 4y agoHave you read the opinion at all? It's not what they are doing