6 ms·
Is it really that impressive that focusing on game design results in a better game than spending a billion dollars on a thousand artists so that every tree can
by mrguyorama 4y ago
Is it really that impressive that focusing on game design results in a better game than spending a billion dollars on a thousand artists so that every tree can have ten times as many polygons and each texture is 16kX16k? Better graphics rarely actually IMPROVE a game, and can do nothing to fix a game that was designed poorly.
AAA studios whine and cry about how expensive games are to make (completely glossing over the fact that they are 100x as profitable as they were in the 90s because videogames are no longer niche) but nobody asked them to! Linus Tech Tips water cooling a 4090 isn't the normal consumer! Most consumers want to have fun when they pay $70 for a game, not play the exact game they bought a decade ago with more detailed scenes, and more detail doesn't make a game better
- moffkalast 4y agoOften times better graphics make a game worse because they're at the expense of everything else, while also making the community smaller because most people can't run it. Yes, I'm still slightly salty about the train wreck that KSP 2 turned out to be.
- eterm 4y agoI think I'll still be fuming about KSP2 for a long time. I don't know why I let myself have any hope it'd be good given the development history but I still bought (and returned) it on launch. KSP didn't deserve that.
- cptcobalt 4y agoYeah. In contrast to the creativity applied to Tears of the Kingdom that took the framework of Breath of the Wild and extended it majestically, KSP2 is a brazen & soulless cash grab that under delivers under the guise of "Early Access".
- jjoonathan 4y agoIt never fails to amaze me how quickly the hate train starts or how fast it gets going when it comes time to blame technical artists for the shortcoming of others, even though they are arguably the best in the industry at reliably accomplishing amazing deeply technical feats that deliver joy. I'm glad I figured this out before spending much time going down that path, but I still know people who did, they're the smartest people I know, and it always frustrates me to watch critics line up around the block to take a shit on them, blaming them for problems they didn't cause and snubbing them for accomplishments that they did.
- Jcampuzano2 4y agoTo be fair, I don't think anybody is undermining the effort/ingenuity some of these technical artists/engineers have. Its moreso the overwhelming focus of AAA game studios on this over gameplay. These artists/engineers have accomplished absolutely amazing things and really pushed the limits. But somewhat ironically... gameplay/story is still king when it comes to 'games. I will say, when a game does blend the two, they are usually highly applauded, it just rarely happens nowadays that a game has both very good graphics, and very good gameplay.
- jjoonathan 4y agoYou're not being fair, you're making excuses. I was responding to a post that literally said "better graphics make a game worse." Bad writing and bad mechanics can absolutely ruin a game far beyond the ability of art to compensate -- but it's both absurd and cruel to blame this on art.
- ska 4y agoI don't think you are representing the original fairly, they said "often ... because they're at the expense of everything else," Which seems plausible although "often" may be harsh. Too high a proportion of your budget on art is rarely going to end up somewhere good, unless the art is the main point. There does seem to be a bit of a AAA arms race here, which isn't necessarily a net gain.
- moffkalast 4y agoI think you're forgetting what actually makes a game at its core. What separates the medium from others are roughly these things: interaction, objectives, mechanics, feedback, challenge. The art department can make the feedback better, the objectives clearer, the interaction easier, but fundamentally you can have a game without any art at all (see dwarf fortress, zork, etc.) and have it be a game, whereas a bunch of art assets by themselves don't a game make. Nowadays it's all about marketing material and lying to people, so having good game art is prerequisite for great prerendered trailers that will drive preorders. But when you allocate all your budget to art, you don't end up with a game, you end up with false promises.
- jetbalsa 4y agoHi-Fi Rush is a perfect example of how a game should be It had all the details you want in a game to make it look awesome but the style and art was paid close detail
- dietr1ch 4y ago(https://store.steampowered.com/app/1817230/HiFi_RUSH/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/1817230/HiFi_RUSH/)
- naavis 4y agoTo be fair, KSP2 landed in early access only very recently. No one has claimed it is a finished and polished game.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- agumonkey 4y agotypical industry cycles. money is dumb and spending money is the first lever they trigger.. causing inflation and then complaints. life, art .. is complex and you need to cultivate, nurture people caring about making beautiful complex subtle things.
- highwind 4y ago[flagged]
- surgical_fire 4y agoGood graphics don't save a lame game. It at most improves an already good one. A great game on the other hand cam have outdated graphics no problem. People will still love it.
- byby 4y agoThe budget and scale of totk is triple A. Also the amount of art in totk is triple A levels. Totk is your classic AAA game it just was programmed for older hardware. >more detail doesn't make a game better Have you played red dead redemption 2? The detail elevates the game to one of the greatest masterpieces of all time.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoAnd the control schemes drag it back down into the quagmire of unplayable mess despite all that work. An excellent example of the broader point about development focus.
- mrguyorama 4y agoThe clunky controls of rockstar games is intentional! They think it's "more immersive" for your character to just not do what you want it to do. Saints Row 4 is better than GTA 5, change my mind.
- 999900000999 4y agoFundamentally different games, Saints Row 4 is silly sci-fi. I personally enjoyed it more. I felt the actual game flowed better, GTA is all about playing in a sandbox and seeing all the various things you can do. Saints Row is more of a straight up action game.
- jstarfish 4y agoAt some point they reacted to the "murder simulator" hysteria by pivoting from action games to sims.
- byby 4y agoI played on PC. Mouse and keyboard. The controls were excellent.
- earthling8118 4y ago
- supernikio2 4y agoWhat initially "wow"s me about a game is how beautiful it is. What keeps me coming back to it time and time again, is how well put together it is as a whole.
- wheelerof4te 4y agoNot only are games with movie-like graphics expensive to make, they are often hardly playable. Even less replayable. Often, you can't tell what is that you're supposed to be looking at in order to advance or understand a gameplay mechanic. I want to play a game. If I wanted to watch a movie, I would buy or stream a movie.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI'm not sure what your point is other than complaining. It is impressive to make a great game with broad appeal. It isn't easy or trivial to do and companies that get it right should be recognized with good reputation and customers. I haven't heard other Studios whine and cry, but if they do it's not my problem so I don't care or mind if they do. Nobody is forced to buy bad games, so I don't really understand the complaint there.
- munificent 4y agoI agree with your general point but I don't think Tears of the Kingdom is a good example of it. They have clearly poured a mountain of design and engineering effort into squeezing every last drop of graphic fidelity and art out of the Switch. It looks really really good. Some of that is having the wisdom to choose an art style that works well on the Switch—a little cel-shaded, not a ton of texture detail. But, also, they really are getting as much detail and graphic complexity as they possibly can out of that little machine. This isn't some cheap 2D pixel art game that spent their whole budget on game mechanics. It's a AAA game that maxed out their budget along every single axis. They just happened to target hardware with lower specs.
- ianlevesque 4y agoYeah honestly they’ve exceeded what the Switch can do at this point and areas of the game drop to 20 fps. The game wouldn’t be worse at 60. 30 is widely viewed as the bare minimum.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 4y agoNintendo is a deeply Japanese company, and in Japanese animation, frame rate can be heavily deprioritized. If they have a limited budget, and have to choose between better art/design, or better frame rate, they'll choose the art every time. Nintendo also clings closely to its roots as a toy manufacturer - their primary goal is to build games that are fun to play. It shouldn't be surprising that their focus on creating beautiful, fun games resonates deeply with the wider populace. I do notice the framerate occasionally dip during complex scenes, but it's such a wonderfully designed game that I don't really care.
- ianlevesque 4y agoThe sales agree with you, but none of the art or design choices get worse by having hardware that won't drop frames to that degree. I realize they do this every console generation, but since they're no longer passing along the savings to the consumer, I'm not going to keep apologizing for them.
- giobox 4y ago> not play the exact game they bought a decade ago with more detailed scenes, and more detail doesn't make a game better Except in the case of this Zelda sequel you sort of are playing the exact same game you bought 5 years ago, and with little/no improvement to detail, for an even higher price (69.99)... While I've bought it and am enjoying it, its hardly some huge shift in any way (technical, gameplay or story) from BOTW, and virtually all the mechanics are identical. I still think it worthy of great reviews to be clear, but it is not some genre shaking release.
- mattbrewsbytes 4y agoGenerally speaking, a lot of Nintendo's IP games are rehashing the same play concepts/stories in different ways over the last 3 decades. There's nothing wrong with that, just pointing out that this is their MO. They are in a "forever" business for gaming, company has been around since 1889. So the new Zelda game being similar to the N-1 Zelda game is exactly what they do. I remember defeating similar enemies in the original Zelda game, finding shrines to build health up, wandering a forest looking for hidden stuff. Its fun but the game concepts haven't changed much.
- bluefirebrand 4y ago> While I've bought it and am enjoying it, its hardly some huge shift in any way (technical, gameplay or story) You have got to be kidding. The ability to build machines by connecting basically anything to anything is a very impressive mechanic both from a gameplay perspective and from a technical perspective. The fact that they built this to run this nicely on an 8 year old tablet is frankly incredible. The fact you can jump from the sky and dive to the underworld without pause is impressive as heck too. Even the little ability to jump through a ceiling to travel upwards to the nearest place to stand is incredible, considering you can do it anywhere that has a ceiling in range. That mechanic is honestly mind blowing from a technical perspective imo.
- giobox 4y ago> You have got to be kidding. Why? play the two games side by side - there is a truly enormous amount of gameplay and visual overlap. > The ability to build machines by connecting basically anything to anything is a very impressive mechanic both from a gameplay perspective and from a technical perspective. The fact that they built this to run this nicely on an 8 year old tablet is frankly incredible. Many reviews (and myself!) find this addition to be cool but shallow? Also, while cool, its not technically mega avant garde here- "Banjo Kazooie nuts and bolts" attempted similar thing back in 2008. > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banjo-Kazooie:_Nuts_%26_Bolts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banjo-Kazooie:_Nuts_%26_Bolts > Even the little ability to jump through a ceiling to travel upwards to the nearest place to stand is incredible, considering you can do it anywhere that has a ceiling in range. That mechanic is honestly mind blowing from a technical perspective imo. I found this to be the least impressive of all Link's new abilities personally, and fail to see it in terms of being some unreal technical breakthrough? It's literally just a jump through the surface directly above the player's head.
- JKCalhoun 4y ago> spending a billion dollars on a thousand artists so that every tree can have ten times as many polygons and each texture is 16kX16k Absolute realism is a tedious goal.
- slmjkdbtl 4y agoRecently I found good stuff actually sell the most in game industry, you have stuff like Elden Ring and Legend of Zelda, in indie space you have stuff like Pizza Tower, all selling huge. I wonder if big studios that makes safe copy 3As will actually think about innovation as an element to maximize profit. Also realistic graphic != good graphics, we need more stylized graphics like these recent 2 Zelda titles! It's a shame we already lost the great graphics of the 3ds era Pokemon (which I think is peak cell shading aesthetics) to a generic 3d look of recent titles.
- hendersoon 4y agoGraphics don't impact gameplay, but this game really does look flat-out bad on a full-sized TV or monitor. Using FSR1 upscaling the realtime shadows (required for dynamic time of day) all "crawl", like a constant flicker in any motion, and it's really distracting. Level of detail "clicks" in when you're 20 feet away from objects, also extremely noticeable. And beyond the visual issues, it also suffers from a poor framerate in many areas. It can't even hit 30fps all the time. It's true that gameplay trumps all, and it definitely didn't push me off the (excellent) game, but the Switch hardware really _substantially_ impacts the experience.
- pl4nty 3y agoI play ToTK on an emulator at 60fps ultrawide, and the experience is night and day vs the Switch. Definitely an incredible game but I think the Switch is its biggest flaw
- alex_lav 4y agoThis is a false dichotomy. Many games “focus on game design” and do not achieve success.
- pentagrama 4y agoThe other day I was playing Super Mario World, I didn't play since the nineties, and wow, they where capable to do so much with so little, from the graphics to the sound, the game feels so good, I was in love
- HellDunkel 4y agoI just wiped the dust of the SNES and an old tube tv today and played Super Mario World. It is such a masterpiece!
- HellDunkel 4y agoImagine AAA studios investing all their energy on creative ideas, gameplay innovation and fun experiences for a second. What would that do to indie developers and small studios?
- pl4nty 3y agoSure graphics gives diminishing returns, but I've played ToTK @ 60fps on an emulator. It's significantly better than a Switch @ 30fps, and personally I think the Switch's hardware is ToTK's biggest flaw