3 ms·
The lesser of what two evils? It seems illogical to me too for "taking a long time to decommission old plants" to be a lesser evil compared to other power gene
by Dylan16807 4y ago
The lesser of what two evils?
It seems illogical to me too for "taking a long time to decommission old plants" to be a lesser evil compared to other power generation at the same time that new nuclear plants are a very large evil compared to other power generation. Those two things should be pretty close to each other. Either both should be wildly unacceptable, or both should be lesser evils, or one should be a somewhat lesser evil and the other a somewhat greater but not enormous evil.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoIf you believe every nuclear power plant is a latent Chernobyl, reducing their absolute number is the priority. In that world, given a choice between a fixed and declining number of old plants, or, a potentially-rising number of new plants, the first is safer. (If you never build new plants, the upper limit is known. If you permit new construction, even with demolition, the limit is unbounded.) Of course, as you point out, treating all plants equivalently like this isn’t substantiated by the data. But within that toy model, the conclusion holds.
- Dylan16807 4y agoYes the first is safer but it's still wildly unsafe in this model. If you're not advocating very hard for rapid shutdowns then you're not being consistent. The choice isn't between old nuclear and new nuclear. If those are the "two evils" then that's missing some important options.
- reaperman 4y agoReplacing existing reactors costs billions of dollars that can be spent on saving people from other issues like heart disease or put towards fusion development (we don't even really need fusion research anymore, SPARC/ARC are nearly proven). Replacing costs more per expected life saved than not building in the first place. Replacing is like 5 times more expensive than building alternatives in the first place. The extra money can save people/environment in other ways.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThat's not the question. The question was: If we take it as given that we shouldn't build new reactors because they're extremely dangerous, shouldn't we just as zealous about shutting down existing reactors? If solar is cheaper than new nuclear plants that's cool and all but doesn't change the danger levels.
- reaperman 4y agoYou’re not understanding. This is a discussion about baseload power. Situation: We need more baseload power. Option 1) Build a nuclear fission plant. Costs $10 billion. Option 2) Build a combination of pumped water storage, solid oxide fuel cells, or battery storage to store excess wind and solar. Costs $12 billion. Option 3) Tear down existing nuclear plants ($5 billion PER demolition), continue paying on their existing loans, and then build $12 billion of energy storage plus billions more additional wind and solar installation. Cost: $20 billion For expected x lives/farmland saved, it may be reasonable to spend $2 billion more but not spend $10 billion more for the same effect. That’s not internally inconsistent, your view just doesn’t encapsulate the ability to spend the other $8 billion or so on medical advancements or environmental rehabilitation efforts or fusion development. Or it fails to acknowledge to difference in cost between decommissioning vs not building in the first place.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThat all makes sense from a construction cost perspective. But you were making an argument about how unholy dangerous nuclear plants are as a reason not to build them, barely even mentioning cost. If that danger is real it should be more important than those billions. There's also a fourth option of tearing down nuclear plants and replacing them with a mixture of wind solar and coal, to mitigate that enormous danger at a reduced cost. If the danger isn't actually enough to motivate plan 3, then you were massively overselling it. Even more so if it's not enough to motivate the cheaper plan 4.
- reaperman 4y ago