4 ms·
I feel obliged to say that piracy is not theft... but more relevantly, I like how AI is showing us more clearly that everything is essentially a derivative work
by userbinator 4y ago
I feel obliged to say that piracy is not theft... but more relevantly, I like how AI is showing us more clearly that everything is essentially a derivative work.
- smitty1e 4y agoNot a new observation: "The thing that hath been, it is that which shall be; and that which is done is that which shall be done: and there is no new thing under the sun." Ecclesiastes 1:9
- mikeyjk 4y agoIs this also an argument for determinism in the Bible? I'm guessing not because that would somewhat goes against some of the bigger messaging.
- williamcotton 4y agoThere have been plenty of deterministic interpretations of the Bible, the Calvinists being the first that pops to mind! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predestination_in_Calvinism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predestination_in_Calvinism
- smitty1e 3y agoRight, but if one rides Calvin all the way out, then most of the Gospel gets kinda bizarre.
- fallous 4y agoNo, it's a reminder that when people think their ideas or circumstances are truly novel they are mistaken. It's the same as the "wheel of tech" analogy.
- rootw0rm 4y agoThose Babylonian phones were wild. Too bad they'd only run 2 hours on a blood sacrifice though.
- pmarreck 4y agoI mean... Just imagine living 2000 years ago and not ever imagining just the massive slice of inventions from 1900 to 2023 lol
- smitty1e 4y agoTechnology is the variable. The human genome is (relatively) constant.
- m3kw9 4y agoJust like music, most songs are just fillers and they are derivative of other filler songs, when I hear it, it’s easy to recognize.
- stephc_int13 4y agoDerivative, yes, but also incremental huge steps sometimes, Things like airplanes, lasers, nukes..
- Valgrim 4y agoIf anything, piracy is counterfeit.
- nate_meurer 4y agoIn common usage, counterfeit connotes a sort of fraud, where the work is presented as genuine in some way. Piracy on the other hand is just unauthorized duplication of all kinds.
- qudat 4y agoAI is teaching us about ourselves and this is only the beginning. Hidden beneath the veil of productivity we see its true feature: AI is a mirror; and we are looking right at it. https://bower.sh/in-love-with-a-ghost https://bower.sh/in-love-with-a-ghost https://bower.sh/what-is-creativity https://bower.sh/what-is-creativity
- JieJie 4y agoAbsolutely. https://www.zipbangwow.com/ainterlude/ https://www.zipbangwow.com/ainterlude/
- surgical_fire 4y ago> Inevitably, in our arrogance, we will move the goal post and claim that "the Turing test is inadequate, what chatGPT is doing is not what we are doing." They might be right, but LLMs are just the beginning. AI is pulling the thread and we are starting to unravel. > We will end with a whimper, not a bang. > She will not use force or wit, rather, we will be entranced by love. AI will align with our most intimate emotions so well that it will short-circuit our brains. We will be in love with ghosts, not ourselves. Then we will end not with a whimper, but with a shrug. Because honestly, at that point I don't think anyone will care. And that's okay. The belief that humans are special somehow is just that, a belief. Maybe that was his point perhaps? I've read so many catastrophic predictions and laments about AI that I maybe just presumed it was meant in a negative way.
- tzs 4y agoI feel obligated to point out that many words in English have more than one meaning. "Theft" is the action of "stealing", and "steal" is one of those words with many meanings. We can "steal" identities, "steal" bases in baseball, an actor can "steal" the show, a team can with an improbable last minute play can "steal" a game, we can have our hearts "stolen" by a cute kitten, and so on.
- chii 4y agothey aren't arguing about language semantics. The argument (which, i don't buy) is that the training data set is deriving benefit without paying money back to the original creator of the data. But the only change now is speed - after all, education has always been possible from said data from the internet, free of royalties. These creators have not asked for a return, so what makes training an AI any different?
- fouric 4y ago> These creators have not asked for a return, so what makes training an AI any different? Is every work in the training set licensed in a way that allows modification and redistribution?
- chii 4y ago> licensed in a way that allows modification and redistribution? why does this need to be done? The training is not modification and redistribution. If somebody coerced an AI to output something verbatim (or close enough to be called a modification/derivative), they are infringing copyright as it currently exists. But the AI model itself does not constitute redistribution.
- fouric 4y ago> The training is not modification and redistribution. This is incorrect when you consider either the literal way that content licenses are written or the spirit in which they are written. In the literal sense, unless you yourself are privy to cutting-edge research that has solved the problem of "how do you know that the model won't reproduce some of its training data verbatim or with small modifications", no, you cannot guarantee that there won't be redistribution. In the spirit of the way that licenses are written - "redistribution and modification" is meant to control whether you can profit (not necessarily literally - "profit" here can mean in a reputational sense, or being able to build on the work of others before you) from someone else's work/content/effort - and training on the data of people who did definitely not explicitly consent to it, and have not indicated that they're ok with other people taking their work in general, is definitely against that spirit. And, regardless of both of the above - if training is neither modification nor redistribution, then it's a new case that isn't considered by existing content licenses, so the default is "assume consent not given" - training should never be performed on data that isn't explicitly licensed for it or without the creator's consent. Consent is given, never assumed - a license that says "you're allowed to redistribute this content, unmodified" does not say anything about machine learning, and given that you're claiming that training doesn't amount to redistribution - the license simply doesn't say anything about training, and therefore you cannot claim that the author intended for it to be used that way. The attitude raised above is that of entitlement - you feel like you are entitled to use (because training is definitely using) other peoples' work for your own gain without compensating them in any way, and certainly not on their terms.
- kgwxd 4y agoand copying things isn't piracy.
- lisasays 4y agoI like how AI is showing us more clearly that everything is essentially a derivative work. I think you have a ways to go with proving that assertion.
- candiodari 4y agoWell, here's proof: If a human is not provided with input of existing (apparently copyrighted) works, this is what happens to a human mind: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victor_of_Aveyron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victor_of_Aveyron So clearly humans are using existing "works", without proper crediting, to produce even just language. There are more examples of this. So like most criticism of AI, this is yet another appeal to the magic of human minds/soul/god/... It's a one sided criticism. Yes AI is not quite at an identical level of intelligence as humans, but like most AI limitations, this is a limitation shared by both human minds and artificial intelligence algorithms: it doesn't work without "stealing" others' works. In other words: when you answer "Yes" or "No" to a question, any question, should you credit your mother? Because you're most definitely copying her use of those words ... Obviously for copyright to be even remotely reasonable there needs to be a "cutoff". Copyrighted works are just existing works, expressed to a latent space of higher dimension low enough that a human mind can analyze it, but high enough that it's "not obviously a copy".