5 ms·
UK Police: download a file, go to jail for 10 years and pay an "unlimited" fine
- shareme 15y ago1 million Chinese download file ..no jail time ..MPAA/RIAA crickets..chirp chirp
- Intermediate 15y agoYep, that's one of advantages living in China. However, The Great Firewall delivers so many problems to me so I'm even considering moving back to russia.
- infinii 15y agowhy so racist? I guarantee you that 1 million Caucasians download copyrighted files.
- moylan 15y agoi think you can get free downloads of music from sony, warner, universal and emi using google in china. never been there but i have seen it mentioned in articles from time to time. a quick search turns up http://www.ghacks.net/2009/03/30/free-legal-music-downloads-in-china/ http://www.ghacks.net/2009/03/30/free-legal-music-downloads-...
- TamDenholm 15y agoI'm really getting sick of this, i really cant believe we live in a world where someone downloading a file, perhaps unknowingly, can potentially get more jail time than sex offenders and criminals who commit violent crime.
- publicus 15y agoShould not be surprised, we don't have real democracy after all.
- Joakal 15y agoThere is still democracy. Join the pirate party. You'll get materials, information, etc, to present to other people. If there's enough mass of people realising that the government and copyright cartels are bullshitting and using pirates as a bogeyman for economic problems, then the people will vote them out.
- iRobot 15y agoIts amazing, how many people you talk to who thinks all this is BS and the system is totally screwed, however it always translates to fuck-all votes at the polls.
- publicus 15y agoYou don't get real choices at the polls. We need to get rid of the winner take all system and replace it with a percentage based system.
- Joakal 15y agoUK has instant runoff voting for Upper House: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instant-runoff_voting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instant-runoff_voting UK rejected alternative voting in 2011 for Lower House: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_Alternative_Vote_referendum,_2011 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_Alternative_Vot... So the winner take all would remain for a while.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- smokeyj 15y agoThe Queen does not approve of such shenanigans. The peasants should know that by now.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- bobsoap 15y agoTeh internets iz serious biznez.
- DanBC 15y agoAs I understand it copyright violation is a purely civil matter unless it's down as part of trade, when it becomes criminal. That is, it's illegal, but you're not going to face arrest or criminal trial unless you're making money from copyright violations. I'd be interested to know what law they reckon someone who merely downloads (or even someone file-sharing) a file could be prosecuted under.
- Joakal 15y agoSome places in the world, there's no exemption for non-commercial copyright infringement. A grandmother sending an old wedding picture (without a copyright release) to her grandchild is liable for up to $73,500 and 5 years of jail in Australia. Also, the police have the potential to bring up non-commercial copyright infringement and seize all electronics. And I mean everything that has a CPU/RAM/etc.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoThere's no non-commercial argument (or fair use rights) in the uk either. A school for example could have licenses for a TV program do be played in a lesson but if the soundtrack includes music then they can be in breach of copyright in those songs ... if you're listening to a radio at work and someone else overhears it then it's considered to be an unlawful performance and you can be given a hefty fine (the PRS, as it was, did over several police forces on this one). You can buy a license of course for only a few hundred pounds (yes to listen to advertising-paid radio or even the BBC). UK have been considering making format shifting legal though. We'll finally be able to legally watch a movie we bought on a mobil device then; as long as you watch it alone and no-one hears the soundtrack or looks over your shoulder at the screen ...
- DanBC 15y agoAm I right to say there's no no-commercial argument in the UK; but copyright infringement without trading means the rights owners get to sue for loss of earnings, whereas copyright infringement as part of trading means the police (or some other body) gets involved. UK "Fair Dealing" (Fair Use) is much stricter than the US equivalent.
- bobsoap 15y ago"The majority of music files that were available via this site were stolen from the artists" How can UK police (or SOCA, or whoever) claim that before trial? When that notice was put on the site, the "individuals behind this website" (another loaded term right there, geez) had only been arrested. Trial hadn't even begun yet. Without knowing UK laws - aren't these solid grounds for a libel and slander claim?
- anigbrowl 15y agoNo. They can know on the basis that the files are hosted for download but that the site operators have made no revenue payments or signed contracts with the publisher/distributor of the media in question. The UK does not have the same kind of common carrier provisions in Telco law that exist in the US. Edit: downvote away, but I didn't write the law, I'm just telling you how it operates: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Economy_Act_2010#Section_17_and_18_-_Blocking_Internet_locations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Economy_Act_2010#Sectio... The government is considering alternatives: http://www.ipo.gov.uk/types/hargreaves.htm http://www.ipo.gov.uk/types/hargreaves.htm
- pyre 15y agoI don't think that the parent post was talking about common-carrier provisions[1]. The point being that the police are stating something ("these files were stolen") as fact prior to the trial. The assumption being that these facts need to be proven at trial. The same reason that the accused is called the 'suspect' and not the 'criminal' in police press reports. I'm not sure that this quite equates to something like saying, "he's a drug dealer," prior to getting a drug dealing conviction, though. [1] Actually, 'common carrier' only applies to phone companies in the US. You're thinking of the 'Safe Harbour' provisions that are part of the DMCA.
- batista 15y agoThe point being that the police are stating something ("these files were stolen") as fact prior to the trial. The assumption being that these facts need to be proven at trial. The same reason that the accused is called the 'suspect' and not the 'criminal' in police press reports. However the police does call the victim "the murdered guy" and the place the arsonist burned "the burned down building". Some things are a simple statement of fact. Similarly, the presence of "pirated files" is not something that is that difficult to examine and state as a fact pre-trial. And the other side would only win a libel trial if they could prove that this is not the case, which, I guess, it is. Else, they would be punished and counter-sued for that attempt too.
- axatrikx 15y agoI wont get this heavy a punishment if i go ransack a music store and steal all the copies..
- Roboprog 15y agoGod forbid you sneak in the back door of a movie theater. How many years should you get for that? (of course, it's harder to "scale" that sort of crime, but it still seems ridiculous, so let the ridicule begin)
- plink 15y agoThe MPAA, RIAA, and their overseas counterparts are ratcheting up the contempt with which they are viewed by society. DIY gravediggers they are.
- sciencerobot 15y agoWhen I first saw SOCA, I thought it was a parody.
- smsm42 15y agoNote that US warning quotes specific laws and specific paragraphs, while UK warning does not specify anything and pushes some recording industry alliance site (I wonder is somebody got paid for this?)
- ck2 15y agoIt's ironic a "frame" is called a "frame" - you realize why? Because you could send your enemies in the UK a webpage with a hidden frame to download a file in the background they do not know about - and send them to jail, ie. "frame" them - with no possible defense. Politicians and law enforcement are starting to turn the internet into what the TSA is doing to flying in the USA - making it terrifying and very risky.