7 ms·
Berkshire Hathaway sells entire stake in TSMC
- tikkun 4y agoKey quotes: --- Buffet: “I don’t like its location, and I’ve reevaluated that.” “I feel better about the capital that we’ve got deployed in Japan than in Taiwan” “[TSMC is] one of the best-managed companies and [most] important companies in the world.” “There’s no one in the chip industry that’s in their league, at least in my view” “Marvelous people and marvelous competitive position and everything, [but] I’d rather find it in the United States.” Buffett said his reassessment of the company was in “light of certain things that were going on.” He had previously pointed to geopolitical tensions as a concern. --- TSMC is a key supplier of many companies, including Nvidia. Not an ideal situation. What do people expect plays out over the next few years?
- Clubber 4y agoI believe TSMC will diversify away from Taiwan and they will probably need to do it as quickly as they can. This is already happening; they are building in Arizona, but it takes a while to build a foundry and get it running. They should have started a decade ago. Hong Kong was probably the catalyst today. Companies who rely on TSMC will also need to diversify as much as possible as quickly as they can incase TSMC can't. I'm not sure if Berkshire doesn't think they can do it, or just doesn't like the risk. They seem fairly risk-averse. Once this happens China will probably feel more emboldened to take Taiwan because US industry won't be so reliant on it and less likely to intervene. I'm not saying the US won't, but they would be less incentivized economically and in regards to self interest. I don't think the populace has the stomach for a long protracted, potentially nuclear war over Taiwan. China will become significantly more isolated on the global scale if this happens, but they seemed determined to do it. They've fallen into a single-man dictatorial power structure under Xi. The China global economic experiment seems to have failed. It's a waiting game.
- methodical 4y agoWant to point out that the global economic importance of Taiwan will decrease if TSMC is able to diversify away from Taiwan in any significant manner, meaning China stands to gain significantly less economically by invading Taiwan. Most of Taiwan's importance currently seems to be directly related to their position as the primary supplier of chips for global corporations.
- Clubber 4y agoYes, you are absolutely correct economically, but they deem it to be a national honor thing. Dictators turn to nationalism when they become unpopular. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-59900139 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-59900139
- newsclues 4y agoNo. China has wanted Taiwan since before TSMC was major factor. This is about geopolitics, and fulfilling the destiny of the Party/Nation that has for decades been embarrassed that their (in their eyes) territory was held by others and supported by the West.
- methodical 4y agoSorry, I should've specified that I was specifically talking about potential economic incentives for China. I am aware to a lesser degree that they wanted the land for alternate reasons.
- randomopining 4y agoPutin showed that the autocrats mean business. Xi is cut from the same cloth.
- javajosh 4y agoThe US should offer to pay for relocation of all TSMC personnel and rebuilding of all fabs here on US soil. I'm not sure there's much of an upper limit to what this would be worth. $2B? $10B? Something like that. Of course the patriots won't want to leave - and rightly so. It's their home, and democracy is worth defending against autocracy. But the offer should be made, IMHO EDIT: Estimate is off by 100x. I also agree that Taiwan would not like to lose the leverage TSMC gives them. I still think the offer should be made.
- ThalesX 4y agoPerhaps there's an argument to be made about U.S. hegemony when such proposals concerning the strategic assets of another country are considered. What if we Europeans devised a plan to acquire all strategic manufacturing assets from the U.S. - including tech, military, and energy sectors - along with their personnel, and relocated them to the EU? Wouldn't the federal government likely have something to say about that?
- bastardoperator 4y agoWe call that Capitalism. If you don't have a plan to stop it, assume it's going to happen. I'd like to refer you back to the documentary idiocracy. There is line in that film that seems to resonate with many humans especially Americans, "I like money, you like money too? We should hang out"
- ThalesX 4y agoI'm not buying free market capitalism with regards to strategic resources of another country. If 'we call that capitalism' is all it took, the US wouldn't need the military it has. Again, this feels like a simplistic view about a country with its own vision of the future...
- bastardoperator 4y agoYou should because that's what these companies or "resources" are actually thinking. If you asked the CEO or shareholders who the company belongs to they'll claim it's theirs and that where it operates from is irrelevant. The US has the military it has because of capitalism, warfare costs tremendous amounts of money and resources and so a lucrative market was birthed.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoI tell my friends and family, "If you ever see a headline saying Taiwan is getting blockaded, or receiving airstrikes, or whatever it may be, drop what you are doing and run to the nearest Apple Store and buy everything you can afford. If you still have money, go to every Best Buy and repeat. Anything Apple, along with Game Consoles and Nintendo Switch Game Cards, will be among the worst affected. If it doesn't work out, you'll sell it for only a 10%-20% loss. If it does work out, it will be years before you can buy those products new again." Especially Apple. Apple has an extremely short production buffer. Allegedly, they have complete inventory turnover every five days. https://www.theverge.com/2020/3/13/21177024/apple-just-in-time-manufacturing-china-coronavirus-supply-chain https://www.theverge.com/2020/3/13/21177024/apple-just-in-ti...
- reaperman 4y agoI suspect the temporal order will be reversed. From what I hear, China will have to spend months amassing troops and material near the coast, in a way which cannot be hidden, giving the world at least 3 months to "prepare". I expect speculators will deplete Apple Stores' JIT stocks well before any belligerence begins. Some of those speculators may place their bets too early and lose money.
- themodelplumber 4y ago> What do people expect plays out over the next few years? China fantasy version: China takes Taiwan and TSMC and everybody minds their own business. China miraculously converts this move into de facto monopoly. America can't get chips and tries to negotiate with China's tight new ally Mexico, losing California in the process! Holy sh*! Maybe more real: China takes TSMC like a chess piece, tries to put it back on the board like in Xia...Shogi (sorry, my Japanese is better here). Except somehow (sanctions, brain drain, sabotage, etc) the piece metaphorically crumbles to ash. Buffett is still so very glad to be out. Another one: Taiwan and foreign partners with lots to lose like US, Japan, and SK successfully turn Taiwan into a meat grinder. TSMC becomes a godforsaken piece of charred land. Miraculously a very-TSMC-like corporation appears split between those countries with some kind of Taiwanese stake as well. Lots of possibilities to think about. Could happen in the next 5-20Y rather than a few though. WW2 for example had a very long build up from expeditionary moves to the bigger strategic conflict stuff if you look from the Japanese perspective, and this pattern has a lot of benefits to China given factors like US administration churn, etc.
- reaperman 4y agoInteresting how none of these imagined scenarios involve China not attacking Taiwan. Like, for example, Xi dies slightly earlier than expected and the next, younger, head of state doesn't have the "Oh god I need to cement my 'legacy' before I turn 90 years old" problem and can indefinitely kick the Taiwan can down the road.
- cromwellian 4y agoThat would be a great scenario but people were hoping that about Putin and unfortunately it didn’t happen in time to save Ukraine. Also we don’t know if whoever follows Xi will be better or worse.
- randomopining 4y agoThe fact that Putin and Xi are close and Putin made a move unthinkable a few years ago shows that these autocrats mean serious business. It's not some fiction novel story anymore.
- antoniuschan99 4y agoHearing from Chinese from China ppl they think western media likes pushing the narrative of using force. They think most likely scenario is through political means. Kuomintang is already Pro Beijing.
- dehrmann 4y agohttps://apnews.com/article/china-fighter-jets-harassment-taiwan-9156541b4138cfa3865b7232ee6a8970 https://apnews.com/article/china-fighter-jets-harassment-tai... > China’s military flew 38 fighter jets and other warplanes near Taiwan, the Taiwanese defense ministry said Friday, in the biggest such flight display since the large military exercise in which it simulated sealing off the island earlier in April. I'll buy that Chinese in China have that view, but flying 38 fighters near Taiwanese airspace is China actually using force. At the same time, I do see China's larger gripe. Between Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, The Philippines, and Singapore, China's access to the open seas is boxed-in by western allies. Russia has a similar gripe with a warm-water port in Crimea and NATO slowly closing in on Russia by growing the alliance east.
- ttepasse 4y ago> Russia has a similar gripe with a warm-water port in Crimea … Russia has multiple ports on its own black sea coast and before 2014 was building them out, especially Novorossiysk, to host the Black Sea Fleet, for when the lease of Sevastopol runs out.
- antoniuschan99 4y agoYea I totally agree. That’s literally the thing I thought about as a rebuttal. This Johnny Harris video elaborates on it as well https://youtu.be/VNZ0so0LCoM https://youtu.be/VNZ0so0LCoM But at the same time. You would think that if China does in fact believe Taiwan is theirs, then why would they bomb their own (eg. valuable TSMC, etc) infrastructure vs play the long game and take over politically. Also, their sorties are more like a dog barking. It’s showing force, like North Korea doing those parades and launching missiles.
- rasz 4y ago
- ballenf 4y agoInteresting to think about the "bus factor" of this segment of the semiconductor industry.
- dehrmann 4y agoFor as much as people have been hating on Intel, they're not that far behind.
- alexb_ 4y agoDo you think Apple will stop using TSMC sometime in the future? Berkshire does own 1/20th of Apple, and I wonder if sentiment from one of their largest investors that TSMC is not a safe investment might sway them working with other chip manufacturers instead. Or maybe even furthering Apple's vertical integration by having them make the chips too (we're talking far, far future here, obviously they can't set up chip manufacturing within even a decade)
- re-thc 4y agoApple has always had a multi supplier strategy. They also used Samsung at 1 point (and still do). It's whatever works at Apple so no difference. They'd eagerly switch as needed.
- methodical 4y agoNot sure how many producers have the available long term supply to meet Apple's demand. Samsung might already have contractual obligations for their short term supply with other manufacturers so it might not quite be as straightforward as just switching overnight.
- re-thc 4y agoIntel has already puts its arms up for ARM production as well.
- RistrettoMike 4y agoProbably not at the process sizes or quantities Apple's buying up anytime soon, though.
- methodical 4y agoI'd probably lean towards Apple making their own chips, it would definitely seem to be a logical continuation of Apple's agenda, and they are certainly among the few companies that have the capital to make it happen. They already seem to be close to running into issues in terms of securing chip supply (e.g. having to purchase 90% of TSMC 3nm process ahead of time), so I suspect they already have plans to expand into chip production in the long term future.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoDupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35961844 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35961844
- honkycat 4y agoI have a buddy that works at Intel. It is shocking how poorly they treat their employees. No wonder they are lagging: They can't keep people on the floor because they are poorly compensated and treated poorly. The amount of middle manager bloat is STAGGERING. 5 bosses for every person actually doing work. As my friend put it: "What if we retained employees instead of running a strategy where we expect 20% turn-over every quarter?" I bring this up because I see Intel as TSMC's primary competitor, and I don't see how they can hope to compete with how inefficient and incompetent they are.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoTSMC is pretty famous for working their researchers 80 hours a week and making them work night shifts. They might have more autonomy and less bureaucracy but I don't think most would consider them a company that treats employees great. Their advantage is that they've made themselves into Taiwans entire national security strategy so they're able to push an idea of working yourself to death as a selfless patriotic act.
- rnmmrnm 4y agothose poor bastards.
- ThalesX 4y agoIt's quite peculiar to encounter such simplistic perspectives about the Taiwan situation on this platform. Makes me doubt this platform's main ideology as a whole. As a European, I confess my understanding of the issue is quite rudimentary, yet I'm taken aback by short-sighted projections such as: Suggestions that seem to disregard Taiwan's autonomy over its own affairs, as if U.S. interests can dictate decisions like purchasing all of TSMC and relocating them and their personnel. The assumption that China's primary interest in Taiwan is solely due to TSMC, with claims like 'China will lose interest once TSMC ceases its operations'.
- Clubber 4y ago>Suggestions that seem to disregard Taiwan's autonomy over its own affairs Fair, but this autonomy seems to be tenuous at the moment and grows more so as time passes. You must be aware what the US is willing to do when it comes to national interest. Chips are on par with energy/oil, possibly regarded as even more important economically and militarily. I'm not sure if the US regards Taiwan's fall as inevitable or how they would act if they deemed it so. Regardless, a war over Taiwan would significantly slow chip production. >as if U.S. interests can dictate decisions like purchasing all of TSMC and relocating them and their personnel. I'm sure there will be a carrot and a stick, but if this happens, an offer will be made that TSMC can't refuse. TSMC seems to be more than interested in moving their fabs off Taiwan land, so I don't think this would be necessary. >The assumption that China's primary interest in Taiwan is solely due to TSMC, with claims like 'China will lose interest once TSMC ceases its operations'. Yes you are correct about this. China's current interest in Taiwan goes well beyond TSMC.
- ThalesX 4y ago> Fair, but this autonomy seems to be tenuous at the moment and grows more so as time passes. You must be aware what the US is willing to do when it comes to national interest. Chips are on par with energy/oil, possibly regarded as even more important economically and militarily. > I'm sure there will be a carrot and a stick, but if this happens, an offer will be made that TSMC can't refuse. I comprehend this U.S.-centric viewpoint. However, from the perspective of an independent nation state, this narrative sends a cautionary message: 'Beware of creating a product that becomes too integrated into the U.S. supply chain, because you will get rich but risk forfeiting your right to self-determination.' It is somewhat disappointing to see that, on this forum where more nuanced discussions are expected, this is the default (and appreciated) perspective.
- k8si 4y agoDoes anyone know of a good piece of writing about what has made TSMC so successful, what makes their management so good, etc.? Seems like an operational exemplar I'd like to learn more about.
- vfclists 4y agoWhat info does he have on the latest PLA troop dispositions? Is someone out there not sharing?
- stuckkeys 4y agoInsider trading...nothing to see here. When you got that B to your name, everything is legal + and you have friends in the government.
- senko 4y agoHow's that insider trading? What inside information did Buffet act on? The fact that Taiwan is in a geopolitically unenviable position?
- stuckkeys 4y agoThat rock must be heavy on top of you. Pushhhhhh! I mean if China invaded right away they would have lost money, so clearly the know something that the public does not. If I had that kind of intel, I would pull out also (that is what she said)
- known 4y ago[dead]