6 ms·
Vint Cerf’s career advice for engineers
- gundmc 4y agoI appreciate the sentiment of "You can learn something from virtually everybody," but the anecdote doesn't exactly prove it out. Fun story though!
- Stratoscope 4y agoI think it's a great story, about a man who retired from his job as CFO of one of the largest insurance companies in Chicago, got bored playing golf, and decided to drive a limo three times a week to meet interesting people. In a remarkable coincidence, I heard the same story today about two other people during my visit to the Gilmore Car Museum in Michigan. https://gilmorecarmuseum.org/ https://gilmorecarmuseum.org/ I was talking with one of their volunteers, a fellow named Paul, who told me how the museum got started and why it is in Hickory Corners, in the middle of nowhere. Donald Gilmore was CEO and Chairman of the Upjohn Company in Kalamazoo. When he retired, his wife Genevieve Upjohn Gilmore told him he had better find something interesting to do. They had a summer home on a lake near where the museum is now. Genevieve knew that Donald loved to restore old cars, and she suggested they buy a farm near their lake home and turn it into a museum. And then Paul told me that when he (Paul) retired, his wife told him the same thing, and that's why he now volunteers at the museum. He gets to tell interesting stories and meet interesting people.
- sgtnoodle 4y agoThere's a man named Chuck Hutchins who pioneered computer numerical control machining over many decades. He started his career as the first bonafide engineer at a machine tool manufacturing company. He took the job even though the salary was lower than his other offers; the deal was that he got to shadow every other employee in the company for a week each, from the shop floor to management. He is quite old now, but he published a book a couple years ago describing his experiences in the industry, founding a scrappy startup in the early 60's and growing it to a highly profitable business with thousands of employees. If you like engineering non-fiction, it's called "Hot Tech Cold Steel".
- andromeduck 4y agoWish there was an audiobook!
- fnord77 4y agowas hoping for something meaty, but the advice is just platitudes
- hgsgm 4y agoHe was a working Engineer decades ago but his current job is Evangelist.
- unsui 4y agoI got the opposite gist than you did. That he focused on things you consider "platitudes" may have more to do with the significance of these platitudes (primarily those having to do with "soft skills" ) than any more technical advise he may have given.
- m00x 4y agoOne day you'll get to a point where you realize these are more helpful than you think.
- intelVISA 4y agoin terms of technical beef: Vint's gone Vegan since Google
- teaearlgraycold 4y agoVint’s a solid guy in my book. Right after I joined Google last year I sent him a message on Chat. He actually responded to me (by email)! It was clear he actually gave me a few minutes of thought given his response. I saw him later by the Googleplex but didn’t want to cause a scene as he was quietly making lunch at the salad bar.
- grose 4y agoWhat’s up with the sol.int email addresses on the whiteboard? Seems to be related to IPN/DTN but I can’t find anything concrete on the naming scheme.
- sph 4y agoYeah it looks like some planning and brainstorming for some kind of interplanetary and galactic DNS scheme. Pretty cool, though it needs another TLD than .int, which is already used for international entities.
- ggm 4y agoMy advice, (for what it's worth) is to value liberal-arts degree holders far higher than I find many engineers do: People misplace trust in the hard science side of study and neglect what the humanities can bring to the workforce. I value their input more and more highly. Oh, and I value the input from Lawyers too. I might discount it, but I listen. (late stage career, moving out. Not as late as Vint. I can't afford his snappy three-piece suits, and boy does he carry them off well. He's like America's answer to Bill Nighy)
- anonylizard 4y agoOh, liberal arts is valuable, but the degree isn't. I've seen plenty of programmers who are very educated in history, philosophy, economics etc. The problem with the actual degree. 1. Liberal arts degrees have terrible economic returns, almost always negative, especially for men. Because... 2. Liberal arts is ill-suited for mass-market higher education. Can you really teach liberal arts with underpaid teach assistants grading essays on strict rubrics? 3. The degree introduces indoctrination. When you have to please the professor, when your opinions have to please your employer, you end up self censoring, initially consciously, eventually subconsciously, and transform into a drone, incapable of original and piercing thoughts. That's lethal when the whole selling point of the degree was to produce 'original thinking'. When you have an otherwise normal job, you are free to think, not needing to please anyone else, but your own judgement and conscience. Indeed, I find it extremely questionable, why a liberal arts degree is needed at all in the age of the internet. I obsessively read over history, and its extremely cheap and available online, full of endless high quality material, perspectives. And because its free, its a lifelong hobby with no monetary investment, and its pure fun and no downside.
- totetsu 4y agoI disagree with point 3 there. A well taught arts education requires you to use critical reasoning to make sure what you are writing or arguing for can be supported by sound arguments. Maybe you have some experience with some institution or department where there were individuals who only accepted work from their students that argued for the views that agreed with, but this not my experience at all.
- stakhanov 4y agoThis career advice sounds more like what someone would say who asked themselves "Hmm... What sort of career advice would make me look good if I gave it?" It having anything to do with his actual experiences, beliefs, and opinions seems kind of optional.
- jerrre 4y agoInteresting way of looking at it, and I actually think it applies to a lot of advice.
- _a_a_a_ 4y agoI can't see anything that would remotely justify that. Looks like excellent advice all round. HN cynicism again I guess.
- atleastoptimal 4y ago> What sort of X advice would look good if I gave it? True for almost every public figure or anyone courting fame. It's all about appearances, not being useful.
- davidgerard 4y agoIt's bizarre to suggest Vint Cerf has anything to prove in such a manner at this point.
- stakhanov 4y agoNot suggesting that at all. Just suggesting that the man is doing a fine job. While pointing out that "be a public figure who people can look up to and make Google look good by association" currently is his actual job description.
- stakhanov 4y ago> I tell my engineers that if they know I’m about to do something stupid, they have to tell me, so I don’t do it. My career advice: If your boss tells you to not be afraid to disagree with them, don't do it. It's a trap. I've been suckered into this one numerous times, and there was not a single occasion where it didn't backfire. People like to think of themselves as being that enlightened, but rarely (in my personal experience: never) are.
- emodendroket 4y agoI think it depends a lot on your approach. Raising some concerns in a one-on-one and allowing them to change course or not will go over better than just shooting their idea down in a big meeting with many people.
- stakhanov 4y agoI've tried many times, with many different approaches and many different people over the course of a 20-year career. The variation in outcomes was absolutely zero. To anyone who wants to believe that bosses are fundamentally capable of tolerating independent thought among their underlings, I would recommend the book "Disciplined Minds" by Jeff Schmidt [1]. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Disciplined-Minds-Critical-Professionals-Soul-Battering/dp/0742516857/ref=sr_1_1?keywords=disciplined+minds https://www.amazon.com/Disciplined-Minds-Critical-Profession...
- emodendroket 4y agoI guess theoretically I could have had a career that's gone even better than the one I have had, but I haven't had any real problems with my approach so I think I'll stick with it.
- stakhanov 4y agoWere you trying to say "My success proves me right"? Because the other reading is: You're not good at independent thinking, therefore you've never had those independent thoughts that made your bosses dislike you, and that explains why you had a good career. So, your success proves me right. Now enter into some introspection. Do you dislike me, now that I've suggested this? Or do I get brownie points from you for being an independent thinker and voicing my disagreement? Because I genuinely believe that there's a valid and interesting thought in what I just said that we can all learn from. Also: If you were my boss, I would have just killed my career prospects.
- holografix 4y agoThe implicit messages here are really interesting. Eg: People are _resources_. Use them to your advantage, make the most of the opportunity: “if they knew and didn’t tell me, that’s going to be reflected in their end-of-year fitness report.” “get help, and preferably from people who are smarter than you are.” “You can learn something from virtually everybody.”
- hamdouni 4y agoWhat a nice bubble to live in ! Boss thankful to be corrected by subordinate, smart people around you happy to help and retired top level exec driving limos.
- smitty1e 4y ago> if they know I’m about to do something stupid, they have to tell me Summarizing the rest of the comments: "No good deed goes unpunished." However, "tell" takes many forms. One point I like to make is that I'll dig in on a substantive technical point, but strive not to bikeshed technical questions. Package the feedback as a question: "I'm not seeing the motive for using a JSON database when we're really going to need an RDBMS," rather than "This idea is stuck in foopid."
- chasd00 4y agoand "about to do something stupid" is bit of an exaggeration. Professionals rarely do things that are flat out stupid. It can be intimidating to disagree with people up the food chain or with a reputation for always being right or celebrity. It takes courage and tact to disagree with someone in a productive way. Going in hat-in-hand, looking at your shoes, isn't going to get you far but nor is calling someone's idea stupid and berating them one-on-one or in front of others. Packaging feedback as a question like you put it is a good tactic and one i use. I also like to open with an understanding of where the person is coming from. This shows you've actually thought about it and understand, and who knows, maybe you don't and so you open the opportunity to get better informed on the decision. Something like "I see where you're going, you chose X because of reasons Y and Z, do i have that right?". Then once confirmed, you go into "well have you thought about A, B, and C? It seems to me this is a better choice because of <reasons>". The "it seems to me" is important because you've opened the door to admitting you may be wrong as well. "it seems to me" is a lot more disarming than "well everyone knows the right decision is X". There are certainly personalities that will say this is overly worded and emotional and it's better to just say "you're wrong, i'm right, do X". When it works great, most of the time it won't and it just breeds resentment or at the very best breeds fear.
- bjornsing 4y agoThis is great advice if you’ve been lucky enough to get your name stamped on TCP/IP and can say “my engineers” in passing. For the rest of us, not so much.
- negamax 4y agoEverything depends on where you are. There are no rules that fits all organisations and all individuals.
- yakorevivan 4y ago[dead]
- musicale 4y ago"Personally I recommend inventing TCP and working with the inventor of Ethernet to develop TCP/IP."