6 ms·
The UK’s Secretive Web Surveillance Program Is Ramping Up
- jruohonen 4y agoWell, the widespread data retention in Europe is well-documented; most countries have even explicitly refused to comply with ECJ's decisions on the matter. To my understanding, geolocation data in particular is quite useful in investigations. Browsing and search histories and such frequently also appear in media pieces about convictions; he or she is said to have been interested in this or that. These cases certainly raise questions about the qualifications of such data as circumstantial evidence (unless someone is searching for guidance on how to build a bomb, etc.).
- DiscourseFan 4y agoI wonder about this...sure there are plenty of people who are older and less knowledgable about government surveillance; but as these programs ramp up, so does VPN usage.
- samwillis 4y agoThe currently proposed "Online Safety Bill" will potentially put significant limits or ban VPNs. I suspect (if it passes) it will be a case of VPNs that don't collect ICRs will be band, or at least prohibited from payment services, in the UK. https://www.openrightsgroup.org/blog/15101/ https://www.openrightsgroup.org/blog/15101/
- DiscourseFan 4y agoAt least it would be difficult to enforce such things, with cryptocurrencies and all. I wonder if governments will try to convince their citizens that all VPN users are criminals and pedophiles as an excuse to make their use illegal, using it as prima facie evidence of wrongdoing in police investigations as a means of increasing the state of terror, surveillance, and control over their populations.
- PrimeMcFly 4y agoThe UK already has a law that allows them to imprison you if you genuinely don't remember an encryption key and they don't believe you. Just wait till they introduce a law that allows them to imprison people for using a VPN to get around some bs accusation and they don't believe your defense.
- nly 4y agoIt's more likely they'll mandate that ISPs block traffic to popular VPN services
- worldofmatthew 4y agoHarder to ban Tor outright. No payments and snowflake bridges run on many (often) residential IPs.
- trasz4 4y agoYou do realize that using VPN makes the company you're paying for that VPN gather way more of your internet browsing history than the UK's surveillance program?
- yellow_postit 4y agoVPNs grow the security target on their backs as adoption increases.
- wolverine876 4y ago> there are plenty of people who are older and less knowledgable about government surveillance IME, younger people have given up on protecting themselves.
- freeflight 4y agoThere is a pretty decent chance some VPN providers are actually intelligence service, or other bad actor, honey pots. It's part of VPN that most users these days don't even understand, as VPN providers are heavily advertised on the claim of improving privacy. When in reality the VPN only shifts the party you have to trust from one to another, but the problem still remains the same.
- DiscourseFan 4y agoI myself cannot encrypt my internet traffic or scramble it through a variety of IP addresses around the world. You're right, we should all be using TOR if we really want to be extra-secure, but TOR simply is too slow for most general usages.
- 1827163 4y agoI doubt if any VPN is truly secure, even ones that truly don't keep logs, because of the activities of Team Cymru and other actors as well. NSA and GCHQ have been known to trace through VPNs, as far back as 2013 in the Snowden leaks. https://www.vice.com/en/article/jg84yy/data-brokers-netflow-data-team-cymru https://www.vice.com/en/article/jg84yy/data-brokers-netflow-... As one of the original posters mentioned, the Internet itself, being so centralized, is the problem. We need a new network.
- bauruine 4y agoWhen did you last try Tor? The DDoS [0] has ended and it's now pretty fast again. I'm watching a 4k youtube video over Tor right now. Also the next version implements traffic splitting [1] which should improve performance even more. [0]: https://status.torproject.org/issues/2022-06-09-network-ddos/ https://status.torproject.org/issues/2022-06-09-network-ddos... [0]: https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/core/torspec/-/blob/main/proposals/329-traffic-splitting.txt https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/core/torspec/-/blob/main/p...
- sysadm1n 4y ago> ICRs can include that you visited Wired.com but not that you read this individual article So obviously it's just DNS records they look at, unless they look at other metadata? I know that DoH encrypts your DNS queries, but still leaks the site you're visiting via the TLS handshake. There are further developments in this space which mitigate this weakspot, namely ECH[0] and Oblivious DoH[1]. Combine a VPN that you trust with these and you've essentially gone dark to this sort of surveillance apparatus. [0] https://blog.cloudflare.com/encrypted-client-hello/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/encrypted-client-hello/ [1] https://blog.cloudflare.com/oblivious-dns/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/oblivious-dns/
- echelon_musk 4y agoI asked this question here [0] and I suspect you are correct and that the simplest version of this just harvests DNS requests. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35822465 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35822465
- DethNinja 4y agoIn my opinion, most of the governments must have obtained access to numerous Certificate Authority private keys by now. As a result, they would not only be logging DNS records but also the entire unencrypted data transfer. I think lesson to be learned here is that centralized systems such as the internet, due to CAs (including Cloudflare) and ISPs, are unsuitable for private communications. It is so sad that so many people won't experience late 1980s and early 1990s era of the internet, which was devoid of extensive surveillance and censorship. Hopefully, humanity will somehow figure out a superior, decentralized communications platform to ensure privacy. However, the current internet offers no such guarantees. My recommendation at this stage is to assume that government and supranational organizations control the entirety of the internet and act accordingly as if internet had no privacy.
- samwillis 4y agoIf they had compromised root keys, then they still need to MITM the connection in order to provide a fake certificate. This would be detectable, and there has been no evidence of it happening, so I'm sceptical its happened in any significant way. If it was widespread, and not just very targeted, we would know about it. A government agency using a root key, and getting spotted, would be disastrous for everyone, themselves included. So, if they do have them, and I think you are probably right to assume they do, they would only use them as a last resort in incredibly extreme cases. It would not surprise me if they have have them but have never used them.
- jjoonathan 4y agoYes, and they don't need to decrypt everything because of how good metadata is. Remember: we kill people based on metadata.
- tailspin2019 4y ago> ... they still need to MITM the connection ... and there has been no evidence of it happening Because the parent you're replying to seems to be talking about any/all governments rather than just the UK, and I'm guessing your statement here was 'scoped' to the UK only - I think it's important to point out that this absolutely HAS happened on multiple occasions outside of the UK. https://en.greatfire.org/blog/2013/jan/china-github-and-man-middle https://en.greatfire.org/blog/2013/jan/china-github-and-man-... https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2011/05/syrian-man-middle-against-facebook https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2011/05/syrian-man-middle-agai... https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2011/08/iranian-man-middle-attack-against-google https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2011/08/iranian-man-middle-att...
- quazar 4y agohttps://archive.is/keLfj https://archive.is/keLfj
- mistermann 4y agoImagine how different the world would be if some equivalent of this existed prior to the American Revolution.
- Logans_Run 4y ago... or concurrent to it
- crimsoneer 4y ago... do you think the redcoats couldn't intercept and read your post?
- data-abuse 4y agoThe redcoats couldn't see the travel of every single person. They couldn't stop every person carrying a letter that had met with a certain person. They couldn't arrest everyone that had read a certain article or newspaper. The tyranny possible today is far worse than the tyranny of a few hundred years ago
- wolverine876 4y agoNote their argument: > Haidar of Privacy International says that creating powers to collect more of people’s data doesn’t result in “more security” for people. “Building the data retention capabilities of companies and a vast range of government agencies doesn't mean that intelligence operations will be enhanced,” Haidar says. “In fact, we argue that it makes us less secure as this data becomes vulnerable to being misused or abused.” What's most important is what they don't say, and that they don't say it: It's a threat to the minority's freedom and safety, their right to hold unpopular views, dissent, and protest. That is the definition of freedom. Saying something 'acceptable' is allowed with or without free speech. As Isaac Asimov (supposedly) said: "Politically popular speech has always been protected: even the Jews were free to say ‘Heil Hitler.’" But they've given up on that argument, which means they implicitly communicate that they don't believe it, and support the notion that the majority is all that matters. The only way to defeat these authoritarian, anti-free movements is to stop accommodating them (and thus signaling acceptance of their rule) and to talk assertively and confidently and knowledgeably about universal freedom.
- account-5 4y agoIs it secretive if everyone knows they're doing it? We known what they store and how long for, it's stated in the article. The only thing we don't know is whether much use is made of it or whether the companies are providing it. Safe then to assume you're being monitored already. Which is actually the case in relation to private US multinational companies.
- manquer 4y agoSecretive could mean the non transparent government process and oversight of the whole program not necessarily that that program itself is unknown
- uconnectlol 4y agowho actually thinks internet communications need to be policed? did phone calls need to be policed in the payphone days? no actually, explain h0w that works i dont know a single person these days who thinks that the police need to monitor chat and shit online, yet the police keep adding more and more of this around the world. is it just like in software where one autist is given power over a project and masturbates adding new features to it every day at the cost of anyone who needs to verify the code, because he has nothing else to do? like in governments do legislators just hire some kid with no idea what hes doing out of school and he just creates shit law for the rest of his life and thats the sole way this shit works?
- nly 4y agoThis is why I've been using VPN services for 10 years. In the very list it's a significant extra hoop someone has to jump through to correlate and read my ICRs
- PrimeMcFly 4y agoWhy not use SSH forwarding instead? Less suspicious and more control over the server, for less cost.
- noonething 4y agobandwith costs?
- PrimeMcFly 4y agoFor sensitive information you're not normally downloading large amounts of data...obviously there are exceptions and people might need to access big archives and stuff...but generally for just looking up information it's not a lot of data.
- alecco 4y agoI suspect several VPN services are government run. They did it in the past.