7 ms·
'Third places': The ways losing our local haunts hurts us (2021)
- ChicagoDave 4y agoWe definitely need publicly funded non-religious spaces for kids and families. We used to have these things with monitors at school playgrounds.
- hikawaii 4y agoWe do, they're called parks and playgrounds - and no one went there even in yesteryear. Religious spaces have some extra spice, as does the local mall where middle schoolers do random shoplifting to be edgy.
- throw_away1525 4y agoI now live in a small walkable city in Europe and parks and playgrounds are packed. It is very common for my daughter to randomly meet a friend from school there and start playing, or to encounter a friend of ours there also on a walk which usually leads to grabbing a coffee or beer together. This kind of stuff just won't happen if you have to drive to your local park. Cars and car-centric city design is a huge, huge part of the problem and lack of third spaces in my opinion.
- diob 4y agoYep, I'm in USA at the moment, but after my last trip abroad to a walkable city with transit I'm planning my escape. Not my first time being over there, but I'm finally like "why am I wasting my life over in car hell?"
- hikawaii 4y agoIt can and does happen at the local shopping mall, where middle schoolers too young to drive a car play hooky and go to the mall. "Car centric urban design" is the catch all ill and if we just fixed transit it would go away. Except it won't, because all the social factors that make car centric urban design preferable will still be there.
- camgunz 4y agoYeah my partner and I moved to Amsterdam last year and it's wild how different from American cities it is. We think of it as a "NYC lite", as in you don't have the bonkers density, height, and din of NYC but you get almost all the benefits (diversity, walkability, liberalism, culture, tolerance), and there are actually children and families here (OK I know this stuff exists outside of Manhattan, don't @ me). But even compared to NYC the proliferation of parks and playgrounds is astounding. We thought we must live in a green paradise, but it really doesn't even rate (something like 14% tree cover; most major EU cities are > 20%). I think stuff like this is changing. You're starting to see far less car-centric design, and there are little programs like NYC's request a tree. I worry a little about what self-driving cars will do the trend though, but maybe it's not a big deal?
- Moldoteck 4y agoand what's more interesting, Amsterdam is not even super child friendly city because of the high and thin buildings and it still thrives. I read somewhere that Utrecht is even cooler for families(but less vibes) because of better buildings
- switch007 4y agoWe technically have some in the UK but often the local government doesn’t have funds for luxuries such as up keep and toilets. No wonder they’re not as used as much
- thriftwy 4y agoPlayground in local park was chock full of kids just yesterday. In post-Soviet countries there is a concept of non-religious "palaces of culture", which also lost their ideological content and just host arts and crafts now. Albeit, they are less useful for just hanging out than they could be. Also, libraries.
- zo1 4y agoHonestly, the general feeling I get from people is that such public places are dangerous esp for families with kids. And it makes sense. If you aren't policing and controlling bad group behaviour, then people lose trust in such a thing being possible and simply avoid it entirely. I know I would if I ever visited America or any of the immigration-heavy EU cities.
- camgunz 4y agoI can't speak for other cities but I live in a relatively immigrant-heavy area in a relatively immigrant-heavy city (Bos en Lommer, Amsterdam) and our parks are paradises. There's a nice kid pool and everything. I think it's just an issue of community. Like, evidently our community likes having nice stuff our kids can use.
- Moldoteck 4y agoit's quite the opposite: a nicely designed park/other place is more secure due to 'public control' (it's harder to do illegal stuff where there are many people watching and are against this). If public space is poorly designed, it'll be uncomfortable for kids/parents/teenagers and will attract marginalized people, like a space that looks shady, hard to reach and has design for gathering of drinking people Also it depends of city strategy> having marginalized only buildings/areas is a bad idea, that's why in states like baltics, social apartments(the new ones) are not separate full buildings, but just apartments spread evenly across the city, contributing to diluting concentration of marginalized people in one spot and 'social control' keeps these regions safe
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoThe pandemic definitely hit me where it hurts, in terms of social groups. For over 20 years, a small circle of friends had met at a coffeehouse to play games. For a long time, it was Magic: the Gathering, and then in later years it was gin rummy, Clue, Sequence, and all sorts of other board and card games. We met in a large, very social local coffeehouse, then when that closed down we moved to a Starbucks right on the main drag, and then I found a very cute college-oriented teahouse, off the beaten path, and it was there where we whiled away the hours in the before-times. Then the lockdowns hit, and of course we could no longer meet. Unfortunately, our circle of friends had stabilized with me and two elderly folks, and one of them wasn't savvy enough with Zoom for us to feasibly meet online and do our thing. For a while, I tried to play online games with the other friend, but it definitely wasn't the same. We couldn't see each other and we couldn't even text-chat while the games were being played, so it really defeated the social purpose of playing the games over a table and a cup of tea, just to solve all the problems of the world. I still chat with that one friend over the phone, and I share links with her and whatnot, but our social group never recovered from the lockdowns. In fact, the teahouse shut down, never to return. We went our separate ways. I was also dismayed at how church handled lockdowns. That fateful Easter 2020 was a livestream from a small chapel, with none of the faithful allowed to partake. Bishops around the world essentially canceled every public Mass and told us all to stay home. This was known in earlier days as "Interdict", and Interdict is traditionally wielded as a punishment against nations and rulers who are hostile to the Church. Interdict, or withholding the sacraments from the faithful, is intended to elicit a cry of rebellion from them, that they rise up and demand their religious rights. This is exactly what happened in Mexico in the Cristero Wars, when the atheist government expelled priests and forbade them even to confer baptism. It took a while, but church did recover, at least my local parish did. They restored the picnic tables and chairs, they put back the holy water, they restarted Masses and allowed us to sing, they began holding public events and even serving food. I'm thankful that the lockdowns did not last forever, for them. Unfortunately, for me, several social options have evaporated. I work from home now, although the nature of my remote work would allow me to hook up anywhere that has WiFi. I have gone to the library once in a while, when there's an issue at home. I really think libraries are great third places, and kudos to the municipalities that strive to make them welcoming and useful to taxpayers.
- Animats 4y agoBrought to you by the alcohol industry. No mention of gyms, or sports, or hobbies. All three photos show boozing.
- paganel 4y agoAttending sports events is becoming more and more expensive, even here, in Europe. Going to the gym is also not cheap, and, even so, we're not all late 20s - early 30s people, us people in our 40s or in our 50s also need a nice place to hang out without getting physically exhausted in the process. As for the hobbies, most of the "community" ones also require relatively more money to be spent, and, again, it pertains to a certain demographic.
- switch007 4y agoWe have low cost gyms in the UK circa £20 a month which seems like a fairly good deal to me. What does it cost where you are? Also my local gym is very popular with the 50+ crowd. There seems to be a large social aspect to it for them. Don’t knock it!
- paganel 4y agoI'm not a gym person but my partner is. I can say that around here in downtown-ish Bucharest the annual subscription for a popular gym varies between 500 to 800 euros per yer, depending on the chosen plan/options, but you really do want to get the more expensive plans/options that are between 700-800 euros. That is if you pay all in advance, if you pay month by month or 3-months by 3-months (it's all so complicated) the costs are between 80 to 100 euros per month. I agree though that all this may vary. As a man you may choose to "cheapen out" a little and choose less expensive gyms that are located further out or who attract a different kind of clientele, but that option may not be available for many women (as my partner is), unfortunately.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Moldoteck 4y ago
- secretsatan 4y agoPubs have been closing down for a long in the UK, long before the pandemic, fuelled by other factors eg: https://www.companydebt.com/articles/pub-closures-in-the-uk/ https://www.companydebt.com/articles/pub-closures-in-the-uk/ Although, people may drink less, I think one factor get's regularly missed out of these reports, house prices in the UK have kept well ahead of wage increases for ages, and younger people can no longer afford to go out, but this is always phrased as people preferring staying in more.
- adwi 4y agoHighly recommend dog runs for a “third place”. Generally caring, welcoming are people drawn there and unlike, say, a gym, people have nothing but free time to socialize. The best way I’ve found to make meaningful relationships post-college.
- Doxin 4y agoTo add on to this: see if you can offer to walk someones dog sometime. I swear it's like walking around with a big "talk to me!" banner.