4 ms·
Beans are protein-rich and sustainable. Why doesn’t the US eat more of them?
- ARandomerDude 4y ago> Beans are protein-rich, sustainable, and delicious. Why doesn’t the US eat more of them? Because they don't taste as good as meat, obviously. People get excited about going out for a steak. Nobody gets excited about going out for beans.
- paulcole 4y agoYou’re not quite getting at the root of it. People are generally selfish and will generally choose to do things that benefit them over things that benefit other people.
- jankyxenon 4y agoWell sure. If one puts all their discretionary income and effort into a “pile” the vast majority would go to themselves/kin then others.
- jahewson 4y agoIf the other people are selfless it won’t benefit them either.
- imposterr 4y agoSpeak for yourself. Bean dishes are delicious and I'd choose them over steak in most circumstances.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoI totally agree, and I quite like meat.
- TeeMassive 4y ago[flagged]
- delta_p_delta_x 4y agoYou just generalised roughly about a billion people's diets. > 86% of vegetarians go back to eating meat because they get sick About half of those billion people were never not-vegetarian in the first place, i.e. Indians. They are generational vegetarians, having stuck to that diet for well over 3500 years. So either you pulled that factoid out of some unsavoury orifice, or you are badly misinformed. > Nearly all vegetarians I've seen are nearly never obese but nearly always look weak, sick and tired Also, source? Americans are amongst the most 'carnivorous'[1], but there is a massive obesity, heart disease, and high cholesterol problem in the US. [1]: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/daily-meat-consumption-per-person?tab=table https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/daily-meat-consumption-pe...
- xrisk 4y agoHuh, a majority of Indians aren’t vegetarian. Don't spread FUD.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- eyelidlessness 4y agoI don’t have a statistical interest in this dispute, but I do think it’s worth pointing out that this is an unusual use of the term “FUD”.
- SJetKaran 4y agoMajority of Indians are non-vegetarians. Indians eat way less meat than other countries, sure. Part of this is due to cultural, religious, and cost reasons, but the fact that most Indians are non-vegetarians is un-disputed. Here is one post about it https://www.reddit.com/r/india/comments/yaspf6/19_of_population_in_india_eats_vegetarian_food/ https://www.reddit.com/r/india/comments/yaspf6/19_of_populat..., but you can easily find better references online regarding the same.
- Carioca 4y agoPut the two together and have a feijoada
- carabiner 4y agoSteak is the most overrated food ever. Give me soup dumplings, tacos, neapolitan pizza, ANYTHING over a bland unseasoned slab of meat that cost $50-100 (or way more in Vegas). The romance around steak is entirely cultural and not objective.
- tristor 4y ago> bland unseasoned I found the problem. A proper steak should be properly seasoned.
- bloodyplonker22 4y agoUnless you have the palate of a child, beans and meat are two different things. Similar to comparing apples to oranges. They can both be enjoyed.
- timbit42 4y agoDoes the meat really taste better, or is it because it's buried in a sauce full of sugar?
- cs702 4y agoThey will make you -- hmm, how shall I put this? -- gassy, but otherwise, yes, beans are good for you. So, sure eat more of them, especially if you're not going to be around others.
- voisin 4y agoGassy only when introducing beans as a meaningful component to you diet. After a few weeks the gassiness disappears.
- pengaru 4y ago> After a few weeks the gassiness disappears. As someone who has gone on long stints using beans as a primary protein source, this is simply not true IME. But it does depend on the types of beans and the cooking methods. AIUI a major component of what determines gassiness is if there's a combination of fiber (especially soluble fiber) and starches/sugars which become locked up in that fiber so they pass through the small colon intact. This is a desirable situation from a health/weight-gain standpoint, since you've avoided absorbing those simple carbs. But it feeds the biome of the large intestine, producing gas. Legumes tend to have those ingredients... there's no reason to expect it to stop occurring. Ex: 100g pinto beans contains 26.22g carbs of which 9g is dietary fiber, the remaining carbs is stuff your gut can likely use to make gas.
- Vrondi 4y agoThis is simply not true. I grew up in a family of multiple generations of lifelong bean eaters and the gas never goes away no matter how you cook them.
- cratermoon 4y agoHigh-protein diets induce gas. You can get the same effect eating meat.
- astrange 4y agoThe meat sweats are more of an issue I think. (And generally, that it makes you smell like cooked steak.)
- jez 4y agoI’m sold, anyone want to share their favorite bean dishes?
- Fluid_Mechanics 4y agobeans with beans
- paulcole 4y agohttps://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1023371-sheet-pan-feta-with-chickpeas-and-tomatoes https://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1023371-sheet-pan-feta-w... - I like this one a lot during the winter. For a weeks worth of lunches: 1. Pot of quinoa 2. 2 bunches of kale, torn up and steamed on top of the quinoa while it finishes cooking. 3. Stir in a can of pinto beans 4. Add a couple of shredded carrots 5. Pour in however much dressing you want. I use some store-bought Green Goddess flavored stuff.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoLook up almost any Indian recipe with lentils/legumes/pulses. You can also sprout moong beans by soaking them in water overnight, draining them in the morning, and leaving them covered with a damp cloth in a dark area like the microwave for 24 to 48 hours. Once sprouted to your desired level, you can just eat them, or make a sprouted moong bean salad with bell pepper, cucumber, tomato, lemon juice, black pepper, and salt.
- jahewson 4y agoSo tasty. Dal Makhani is my personal favourite. India has great vegetarian food!
- SOLAR_FIELDS 4y agoI live in Texas and my wife is from Northern Mexico. This is a classic, extremely easy, 5 minute refried beans recipe: - 1 can of pinto beans, already cooked - 1 heaping tbsp of lard (olive oil can be substituted if you are vegan or vegetarian) - salt to taste. We almost never salt the beans because we eat them with other fairly heavily salted foods, but it depends on how you cook obviously. Open can, empty about the top 1/8 of liquid from the can. Again this is to personal preference, but usually using all of the liquid from the can in the saucepan results in too runny beans. Bring beans to boil in saucepan with the liquid from the can. Once beans are boiling, add lard/oil and simmer on medium low heat until lard has completely melted or oil has dispersed. Stir and mash beans. We use a potato masher in our house. Very low tech. I’ve even used the back of a spoon in a pinch, but it’s a bit of a pain to do that. Serve hot. The longer you wait the thicker the beans become. So if they come out a little runny just wait a little while and let them cool, they will thicken. The only thing that can save completely watery beans is more beans, however.
- PrimeMcFly 4y agoPeople don't need that much protein as it is, something like 40 grams/day is sufficient for an adult male who isn't trying to gain muscle. Beans are good, but not a replacement for meat (too many carbs), they should just be part of a varied diet. Meat shouldn't be eaten every day anyway, 2, maybe 3 times a week, and rarely red meat. I mean, that's if health is a concern at all, which for most it isn't.
- nradov 4y agoThat is largely misinformation. While 40 g/day may be sufficient to avoid acute nutritional deficiency, it is hardly optimal for long-term health and athletic performance. https://peterattiamd.com/donlayman/ https://peterattiamd.com/donlayman/
- PrimeMcFly 4y agoI'm going to trust Cronometer and USA recs over some random doctor's blog
- nradov 4y agoThat is hardly a random doctor's blog. It is an interview with Dr. Don Layman, one of the top experts on protein metabolism, and includes links to multiple relevant research papers. You should educate yourself before spreading misinformation. Chronometer is junk. It is not a valid source of scientific information.
- PrimeMcFly 4y agoCronometer isn't junk. They rely on on USDA recs and have their own experts. You could stand to educate yourself a little as well before spreading misinfo. The doctor's theories to which you linked are not consensus, and I'm going to stick with what is consensus so far. Consensus is 0.8grams of protein per kilogram of body weight.[0][1] [0] https://www.mayoclinichealthsystem.org/hometown-health/speaking-of-health/are-you-getting-too-much-protein https://www.mayoclinichealthsystem.org/hometown-health/speak... [1] https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/how-much-protein-do-you-need-every-day-201506188096 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/how-much-protein-do-you-...
- teucris 4y ago> Beans are protein-rich, sustainable, and delicious. Why doesn’t the US eat more of them? Because they don’t actually have that much protein. Cooked black beans are about 9% protein and 25% carbohydrates, whereas chicken breast is about 30% protein and has virtually no carbohydrates.
- bsder 4y agoHe's not wrong, people. When people talk about their program for Massive Big Gainz(tm), nobody mentions "beans" for good reason.
- mr_toad 4y agoWhat proportion of the population are making Big Gainz? And what proportion are just getting fat? Because excess protein will just end up as fat.
- nradov 4y agoIt's nearly impossible to choke down enough protein to get fat on that macronutrient. I mean I'm sure someone has done it but that's just not a practical concern. The issue with gaining adipose tissue is typically caused by consuming excess carbohydrates and (to a lesser degree) fats that come along with the protein.
- tired-turtle 4y agoMost Americans consume more than enough protein and engage far too little exercise. Beans and some walks would do them well.
- zaptheimpaler 4y agoThe right metric is protein per calorie. Beans are very high up on that list, just below meat and cheese. Not to mention most people aren't protein-maxing, so even a medium protein food is very good.
- 4y ago
- xwkd 4y ago[flagged]
- msla 4y agoSo you aren't paelo, I take it?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mtalantikite 4y ago> ... in the US, where the average person eats only around 7.5 pounds of beans per year. Wow, that's surprisingly low. Maybe people haven't had good beans? I was going through at least a pound per week of dry beans from Rancho Gordo [1] during the pandemic when I was cooking all the time. I guess most people just eat crappy canned beans? They're really missing out if so. [1] https://www.ranchogordo.com/collections/heirloom-beans https://www.ranchogordo.com/collections/heirloom-beans
- ablyveiled 4y agoThe protein in beans is not nearly as bioavailable as the protein in meat. Further, it is not complete - it doesn't contain all the amino acids we need. Not to mention that meat contains over fifteen identified micronutrients that aren't found in any plants. There's a good reason that meat is tasty and desirable, and beans less so. Meat is simply much more nutritious. It seems to me that vegetarian thought like this is based out of a self-denial. Perhaps self-denial is a valid strategy when your mind and desires are addled by malnutrition and drug-foods like bread and refined sugar.
- roywiggins 4y ago> it is not complete - it doesn't contain all the amino acids we need. This is disputed (see the "criticism" section). And besides, nobody thinks getting all your protein from beans is ideal. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protein_combining https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protein_combining
- tired-turtle 4y agoBit of a straw man. It is as easy (and common) to eat (refined) crap as a vegetarian as it is to do so as a meat-eater. A well-balanced vegetarian diet does not leave your mind addled by malnutrition. Refined sugar is not necessary either. The “bread” in the grocery store (actually cake) is bad for you, yes, but what is the harm in freshly baked boules and loaves? Like many things, moderation paves the path to joy and happiness.
- atchoo 4y agoI for one find bread incredibly addictive and freshly home-baked bread doubly-so, so it's not the additives. It's not just the overeating, when I eat it, it puts me into a blissful haze and wanting to sleep. I am near certain it switches on my opiate receptors because it's absolutely a drug experience I have to abstain from because I can't moderate. Your "moderation is joy" comments highlights that you don't realise some of us are not wired like that. I don't eat sugar because I have zero interest in eating say one donut. It would be a painful tease, an irritant, an actual bad experience. Instead I want to eat 12 donuts. Only that will hit my "donut complete" satisfaction. Given the side-effects of 12 donuts, I accept 0 donuts as the happy compromise. Thankfully beans/legumes/tubers/meat/fruit don't trigger this junkie behaviour.
- senectus1 4y ago> Beans are protein-rich, sustainable, and delicious. Why doesn’t the US eat more of them? Many of us can't eat them. those with IBS or Fodmap sensitivities will have a very bad time eating most beans.
- senectus1 4y ago[flagged]
- pengaru 4y agoSurprised to not find "refrig", "shelf", or "storage" occur once in TFA. One of the major advantages to beans is they're a healthy protein source you don't even have to refrigerate/keep frozen to store. Sacks of dried beans will last a very long time provided you keep them dry and away from vermin. I've cooked decade-old dried black beans found in a "kitchen stuff" box after emptying a storage unit and they were perfectly fine.
- bombcar 4y agoBeans and rice in sealed containers are perfect "forever" food, all you really need is a source of water.
- pengaru 4y agoYeah, it's incredible, as if nature evolved a way for the seeds of life to endure decades of drought or something...
- crgwbr 4y agoThe main issue with beans from a “prepping” standpoint is the amount of energy (fuel) required to rehydrate and cook very old, very dry beans. Lentils are way better in this regard—they keep just as long but cook much faster.
- Incipient 4y agoI mean plants definitely are more intensive than a lot of farming, but I'm not sure space is the only consideration? Eg we farm cattle in Australia on land that's not particularly usable for any cropping.
- brippalcharrid 4y agoLast I heard, the subset of beans that have been somewhat developed for human consumption are nonetheless still full of antinutrients like glutamates and lectins that function as a defence mechanism and which mean that the nutrients that they do contain (and that survive processing) have a very low bioavailability relative to components like starches. I for one prefer the use of regenerative pastureland as opposed to intensively farmed monocrops that rely on artificial pesticides, oil-derived fertilizer and air freight transport (!). Advocacy articles like this tend to a paint a skewed picture of land-usage-per-unit-of-nutrition and nutrition-per-unit-of-food with graphs like these, as well as other assumptions that they're implying about pastureland being suitable for agriculture (it often isn't).
- adrianN 4y agoRegenerative pasture land is nice, but it's not productive enough to satisfy our hunger for meat. Most meat calories are produced by feeding animals intensively farmed monocrops.
- brippalcharrid 4y agoAgain, I'm not sure that's so clear once you factor in bioavailability, and even if you were to use nitrate fertilizers and to cover the hillsides in legume monocrops to then feed then to ruminants, that would still end up being objectively better for human nutrition, as a use of natural resources. They're a state-of-the-art technology for intelligently transforming low-value biomatter into high-value animal fat and protein on an industrial scale; we aren't anywhere near that level of sophistication, and we dismiss it at our peril and to the detriment of human health. Besides that, "Our hunger" for any resource will always grow to be arbitrarily large if there are enough of us (and our consumption of them are typically governed by things like market economies, private property and borders), and we're all welcome to develop our own innovative technologies and methods of production that can feed (or house, or entertain, or occupy) an arbitrarily large number of people to the level that we're capable of. So by all means, people should develop new foodstuffs and build multistory subterranean megastructures, and develop new power sources to pursue their own nutritional vision if they're motivated to solve future problems as they see them.
- dgloria 4y agoI don't know why the US doesn't consume more beans, but I understand the UK doesn't. They only know the canned bean that is horrible. A friend once asked me why would you cook beans. I can't explain, you have to try.
- sigsergv 4y agoCanned beans must be cooked properly, without that they are bland. I usually buy cans of beans without any sauce, species or tomato, then use them as an ingredient in cooking with meat, vegetables and proper seasoning. Also they are great in salads.
- jeisc 4y agohave you seen Blazing Saddles of Mel Brooks?
- baerrie 4y agoI grew up eating pinto beans in the Southern US. When covid hit, we ate beans every week and were happy and healthy