3 ms·
Nuclear power plants still heat up cooling water (like coal plants), causing damage like killing thousands of fish in rivers in France recently. This is a real
by amelius 4y ago
Nuclear power plants still heat up cooling water (like coal plants), causing damage like killing thousands of fish in rivers in France recently. This is a real problem. And also water is getting too hot to cool plants.
- TehCorwiz 4y agoHow do do you think we harness the heat from a coal fired plant? We boil water! The steam turns a turbine and then the water is cooled in a tower and then expelled. Nuclear replaces the first step, heating the water. The other steps are the same.
- amelius 4y agoYes, if you insist on comparing to coal plants.
- skissane 4y agoIf you need guaranteed power at any time of day, fossil fuels and nuclear can provide that, solar and wind can't – while batteries can smooth over the intermittency, the amount of battery storage required to provide the same power availability as a coal or nuclear plant is cost-prohibitive. So, if we are comparing apples to apples, coal plants vs nuclear is a legitimate comparison, wind and solar aren't. Pumped hydro does better than batteries, but building new dams causes massive ecological damage, and in some parts of the world fresh water is a rather scarce resource. The heated water from a nuclear power plant arguably does less environmental damage overall than a big new dam does.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- genocidicbunny 4y agoCoal and Natural Gas also use plenty of water for cooling purposes, so it's not a problem inherent to Nuclear.
- shakow 4y ago1. Because they were not built with cooling by evaporation tower; easily remediable. 2. How do you think other thermal powerplants (gas, coal, ...) work? They, too, need to heat water and dispose of it afterwards, so that's definitely not nuclear-specific.
- bee_rider 4y agoHow big of a problem is this for fish populations in the grand scheme of things? For example we eat billions of fish per year. But maybe these thousands of French river fish come from a very rare species or something.
- Georgelemental 4y agoConflating freshwater fish with open ocean is like conflating chickens and frogs
- bee_rider 4y agoWe also eat millions of pounds of catfish, which are freshwater I think, right? I mean, I’m legitimately asking. Was it a big ecological problem? Thousands of fish doesn’t sound like a ton of fish.
- HPsquared 4y agoSometimes the weather is unsuitable for wind and solar, too. More often, in fact.
- Fezzik 4y agoWarm water is an easy fix though, while the substantial pollutants and global warming from fossil fuels are not. Every time this topic comes up I encourage people to look at The Oregon Garden - all the water that cycles through The Garden is treated city waste water that, after being zapped with UV light to sanitize it, is too warm to reintroduce directly to the water system. So it is pumped up to The Garden where it filters through a man-made wetlands system, cools down, and then goes back in to a natural stream. This wetlands system is also teaming with plants and animals. It’s pretty awesome.