4 ms·
If you taxed boomer-> millennial inheritances at just 25% you could completely eliminate the black-white wealth gap in the next couple of decades. There’s a rea
by rayiner 4y ago
If you taxed boomer-> millennial inheritances at just 25% you could completely eliminate the black-white wealth gap in the next couple of decades. There’s a reason that affluent white people are talking about DEI, and not raising our absurdly low inheritance taxes.
- Bran_son 4y agoA 25% inheritance tax, i.e. lose everything your family worked for in just four generations. That's ignoring inflation. The logical conclusion of the idea that where you are born is just an "accident", and you have no legitimate link to your ancestors.
- rayiner 4y agoThat’s incorrect—you’re ignoring growth during each lifetime.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoI think you need to go back to eighth grade math.
- Bran_son 4y agoFine, lose (1 - 0.75^4) = 68% of everything. Plus what is lost to inflation. Thank you for such meaningful criticism.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoIMO the government is responsible for more than 25% of the vast majority of people's savings, so a 25% inheritance tax sounds fair. Maybe a few people really were innovative enough to have earned more than 75% without the government but that number is small enough to not matter. Your comment suggesting that losing 68% after 100 years is similar to keeping 0% is very strange to me, those don't seem similar at all. And then the 68% doesn't even account for growth, which has always been greater than inflation in the past. Generally the idea that people 100 years from now should be able to live off the labor their ancestors did 100+ years ago seems absurd to me. Those people did nothing to deserve that wealth.
- xyzzyz 4y ago> IMO the government is responsible for more than 25% of the vast majority of people's savings OK, how about this: I pay zero taxes in my lifetime, and then government can take 25% of the estate after I die. What do you think of that?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- HDThoreaun 4y agoI think income taxes should be zero. The government should be funded mainly from land value tax, since land belongs to society as a whole and not some individual who was passed it by someone who never had the right to claim it in the first place. VAT and Pigouvian taxes are good options too. In the end the government has to be funded somehow, the only question is how? Taking money from those who did not earn it seems the best option to me.
- loeg 4y agoYou're ignoring any growth in invested value during inheritors' lifetimes.
- dctoedt 4y ago> lose everything your family worked for You're assuming your family is entitled to keep forever everything that it happens to have received in its economic activities. Elizabeth Warren famously said in her first Senate campaign, "There is nobody in this country who got rich on his own. Nobody. You built a factory out there—good for you! But I want to be clear. You moved your goods to market on the roads the rest of us paid for. You hired workers the rest of us paid to educate. You were safe in your factory because of police forces and fire forces that the rest of us paid for. You didn’t have to worry that marauding bands would come and seize everything at your factory, and hire someone to protect against this, because of the work the rest of us did." [0] In his book The Economists' Hour, NY Times economics columnist Binyamin Appelbaum argues that free-market icon Milton Friedman "celebrated drivers and took roads [and cars and gasoline and ....] for granted." [1] Some would doubtless argue that the "free market" takes care of all this via pricing. But the "free market" really isn't; companies strive mightily, and often successfully, to seize pricing power and use it to extract rents. [0] https://newrepublic.com/article/95247/elizabeth-warren-class-warfare-taxes-rich-public-investment https://newrepublic.com/article/95247/elizabeth-warren-class... [1] https://www.amazon.com/Economists-Hour-Prophets-Markets-Fracture/dp/031651232X https://www.amazon.com/Economists-Hour-Prophets-Markets-Frac...
- Bran_son 4y ago> You're assuming your family is entitled to keep forever everything that it happens to have received in its economic activities. That would be ignoring income taxes and VAT. And I'm well aware of the failures of the free market. But they do not make inheritance illegitimate, as this article tries to frame it. It's that framing that is most offensive, more than a reasonable (i.e. much much less than 25%) inheritance tax: that taxation is not a compromise between property rights and free trade on one hand, and the public good on the other, with both being desirable values that are sometimes in opposition, but that it is a punishment for unearned wealth. With the hate for the wealthy expanded far beyond the 1%, to everyone that bought a house before the housing market explosion. I'm sure if the target of this hateful rhetoric was some other group, you'd quickly see its danger.
- tptacek 4y agoPeople advocating DEI programs overwhelmingly support increased inheritance taxes; it isn't even close. The argument you're attempting to make here is farcical.
- rayiner 4y agoNot in any meaningful way—as evidenced by where they spend their political, social, and institutional capital.
- tptacek 4y agoNo. The issue you're advocating for is coded in literally the opposite way as you suggest it is. The opponents of DEI are the principal opponents of inheritance taxation. Well-educated and/or top-quintile professionals are also drastically more likely to support inheritance taxation (as a consequence of 21st century educational polarization). I don't think there's any meaningful connection between institutional DEI and economic justice, but you can't just make things up to drag DEI into unrelated arguments.
- rayiner 4y ago> don't think there's any meaningful connection between institutional DEI and economic justice DEI is how the upper quantile has co-opted economic justice rhetoric while entrenching itself in economic sectors (finance, tech) and behind policies (immigration) that deepen economic divides. It’s Wall Street’s brilliant makeover (in response to 2008), which has created a national conversation wherein being a racist plumber in Michigan is somehow worse than working in private equity. It’s immaterial what educated professionals purport to believe in. Politics isn’t just about supporting this policy or that policy. It’s about how you spend political capital to construct a majority coalition that can manifest policies. Upper quantile professionals have spent their political capital to create a majority capable of enacting their preferred social policies. When they wage trench warfare to make sure kids learn about race in history class, that’s political capital they didn’t spend making sure kids learn about the history of the labor movement. These are choices. And as a result of those choices, upper quantile professionals have created a Democratic Party that includes Wall Street, but excludes much of the working class (and excludes most of the white working class). As a result, that coalition is wholly incapable of addressing economic inequality.
- freejazz 4y agoBy this logic, you go around here posting about the perversion of western societies in comparison to asia, only because you yourself are a pervert and are trying to hide that fact.
- Clubber 4y agoDo you have any indication it won't be spent on say, military budget, drug enforcement, domestic spying, or projects benefiting lobbyist at the detriment at the population?