10 ms·
The Greatest Wealth Transfer in History Is Here, with Familiar (Rich) Winners
- Bran_son 4y ago> A key reason there are such large soon-to-be-inherited sums is the uneven way boomers superbly benefited from price growth in the financial and housing markets. While their point about financial markets is valid, framing rising house prices as a benefit is incredibly dishonest. Unless one owns multiple houses, one can only realize that "benefit" by going homeless. In general I find framing the worsening unaffordability of housing/education/healthcare as a "benefit" to those that lived in better times distasteful. It is done to give legitimacy to taking those things away. Not only are things getting worse - if your family managed to protect themselves with sound financial planning, they'll be pulled down back into the crab bucket.
- oska 4y agohttps://archive.is/o6GuR https://archive.is/o6GuR
- Patxitxi 4y agoDid you know that only the rich benefited in the pandemics with the amount of Rich being almost double worldwide? In troubled times the people with the most money benefit the most, that's why the state has to (or try to) level the playing field.
- Patxitxi 4y agoDoubled*
- RickJWagner 4y agoWe don't need to hyper-focus on the inequality in bank accounts. We need to look at the difference in lives. Is the zillionaire's iPhone any better than the one owned by the guy working at the grocery store? Is a Lucid that much better than a Corolla? How much more liveable is the mansion than an apartment? Society as a whole has made great strides in making the great masses in the middle more comfortable, safer, and more long-lived. The next big gains will come when we start educating people about how to handle money.
- stavros 4y agohttps://archive.is/IFWCA https://archive.is/IFWCA
- prepend 4y ago> Mr. Pearl noted that people with only a couple of million can use “securities-based loans,” borrowing low-cost funds from banks using the value of a given investment portfolio as collateral. “You just loan yourself money,” he explained, and in many if not most cases, the portfolio’s rate of return exceeds the rate of interest on the loan. It seems like a step is missing here. Wouldn’t the borrower have to sell part of the portfolio to pay the interest on the loan? And wouldn’t that trigger capital gains?
- HDThoreaun 4y agoYou can just keep taking out more loans against your portfolio.
- lbotos 4y agoSure. But if you liquidate the loan payment every month, but the portfolio grows greater than the loan interest you are “making money” (not really until you actually covert to $) If you liquidated the full loan amount up front, you get all of the tax now, and you lose leverage Edit: Let’s make an example. You have a 10MM portfolio. You wanna buy a thing for a million dollars. You sell like 1.3MM to cover tax. Or you get a 10 year loan for 1MM with your 10MM portfolio. Interest on the loan is 7%. If your portfolio averages greater return over the life of the loan, you “make money”.
- lbotos 4y agohttps://www.wealthfront.com/portfolio-line-of-credit https://www.wealthfront.com/portfolio-line-of-credit Here is an example product. As you get higher the rates can come down a liiiitle bit, but they are very much tied to the federal funds rate as much is I’ve seen them.
- prepend 4y agoRight, that’s how I imagined it. But that’s not avoiding taxes so much as delaying taxes. Taxes are still paid but just slowly as you liquidate only enough to pay payment and pay taxes. Gaining in value isn’t an issue with avoiding taxes and, I suppose, eventually will result in more taxes being paid.
- pavlov 4y agoMeanwhile the estate tax in the US only applies to inheritances larger than $12.9 million. People with that kind of wealth also know how to start planning early to avoid the tax, so the tax is practically ineffectual. A fairer inheritance tax could go a long way to fixing the worsening wealth gap in America.
- credit_guy 4y ago$12.9 is per estate, not per heir. If someone has one spouse and 3 kids and also leaves by will some stuff to 6 other relatives, then the exemption is split between the 10. Each benefits on average from an exemption of $1.3 MM. At the highest tax bracket, they get a one time tax deduction of about half a million. When people talk about wealth gap, they mean the ultra-rich, the multi-millionaires. For someone with a net worth of $20 million, a one time half-a-million does not make such a difference. If you want to get rid of the estate tax exemption, you don't hit the Bezoses and the Zuckerbergs of the world, you hit the middle class. And by the way, you don't even need to move a finger to cut that exemption in half. It will do that in 2026. If you so desire, you can write to your representative to tell them you'd be very upset if they vote for an extension of the current levels of the estate tax exemption.
- MarkMarine 4y agoPeople in the middle class don’t have 20 million, or 10 million.
- sokoloff 4y agoThat they don't is all the more reason to not tax what they do have at 18-40% when they die and pass it to their heirs.
- standardUser 4y agoDo you have a link to a proposal that suggests taxing inheritance for fortunes under $10 million at 40%? From what I understand, if the exemption reverts to previous levels, that would sit at about $6 million (an absurd amount of money to "middle class" families) and would only apply to the value beyond that $6 million. So even a fortune of $10 million would be taxed at well under 40%.
- tempsy 4y agoIt is sort of interesting how Gen X is screwed here. Also the children of Gen X eg under 18s and younger Gen Z today.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 4y agoThe Gen Z chart I think is particularly misleading. My kids are (young) Gen Z. When plotted on that chart, their likely inheritance is $0, because the later of the date of death of my wife and I is very likely be after 2045. So, it looks like they're screwed, but it's because the peak of the Gen Z chart is cut off on the right.
- nappy-doo 4y agoGen X has always been screwed. There's never been enough of us to matter demographically. The boomers have us boxed in before us, and Gen-Y/Millenials after.
- Clubber 4y agoIt will probably be good for GenX during retirement. Nursing homes, elder care and such will be much less burdened than they are now for the baby boomers.
- jlokier 4y agoAs far as I can tell, retirement for many gen X who didn't manage to get a property and won't inherit means poverty and homelessness unless they can miraculously keep high-paying work to cover the cost of rent until they die. Their too small pension won't cover the rent by then because rent has risen and is still rising much faster. Nursing home? They can't afford long term stay due to lack of assets, but what about the decade or two after retirement age when a nursing home wouldn't be appropriate anyway? Seems to me the renting-class gen Xers approaching retirement are just going to have to keep working long past retirement age, while it gets more and more difficult, and their housing stays precarious because they can't get a mortgage due to age. I think this is a hidden, underappreciated issue because people tend to think of property-owning gen Xers with a paid-off mortgage, and don't realise how many gen X never made it onto the property ladder.
- wslh 4y agoI think we should understand that new generations are currently shaping the future in general. See [1] and the same could be applied worldwide: if it is politics or finances. IMHO the issue in the context of wealth is if would serve a purpose that benefit some part of the society or not. A lost of opportunities are lost when you don't see beyond your nose. Indeed is the human history but since these generations are more linked to global issues we will see if it is a naïveté or a force of change. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35937862 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35937862
- thriftwy 4y agoIn Russia, if you are born in Moscow and inherit a granny's flat¥, it gives you an enormous boost. You are free to choose any occupation and dabble in any kind of weird lifestyles or rent it out and live abroad with very modest effort. Meanwhile, if you did not inherit one and don't work in IT, expect to work hard and spend the majority of earnings on rent/mortgage. This applies nontheless even if all of your ancestors were lower middle or working class. ¥ Which she got from the state basically just for being there.
- thejackgoode 4y agoWell, that's about to change for the midterm perspective, but that's also not good news for everyone, if you know what I mean
- thriftwy 4y agoI was hoping to buy an apartment from under some porrige fleeing from Russia as the war progressed, but apparently the Rouble-denominated¥ prices only shoot up. I bought the old one on very good terms at the height of Covid uncertainity, though. ¥ USD is considered to be too volatile to price property in it, so property prices are usually expressed in roubles
- Throw73849 4y agoThat is kind of outdated for Russia. Many new buildings, salaries increased. Rent is reasonable with cheap energy. And metro goes everywhere.
- thriftwy 4y agoProblem being, any wage growth in Moscow caused prices to appreciate, because real estate is most/only reliable vehiche for long term worth storage in middle class. If you have spare cash, you buy an apartment. Indeed, the great amount of constructions works to limit this effect.
- Throw73849 4y ago
- rayiner 4y agoIf you taxed boomer-> millennial inheritances at just 25% you could completely eliminate the black-white wealth gap in the next couple of decades. There’s a reason that affluent white people are talking about DEI, and not raising our absurdly low inheritance taxes.
- Bran_son 4y agoA 25% inheritance tax, i.e. lose everything your family worked for in just four generations. That's ignoring inflation. The logical conclusion of the idea that where you are born is just an "accident", and you have no legitimate link to your ancestors.
- rayiner 4y agoThat’s incorrect—you’re ignoring growth during each lifetime.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoI think you need to go back to eighth grade math.
- Bran_son 4y agoFine, lose (1 - 0.75^4) = 68% of everything. Plus what is lost to inflation. Thank you for such meaningful criticism.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoIMO the government is responsible for more than 25% of the vast majority of people's savings, so a 25% inheritance tax sounds fair. Maybe a few people really were innovative enough to have earned more than 75% without the government but that number is small enough to not matter. Your comment suggesting that losing 68% after 100 years is similar to keeping 0% is very strange to me, those don't seem similar at all. And then the 68% doesn't even account for growth, which has always been greater than inflation in the past. Generally the idea that people 100 years from now should be able to live off the labor their ancestors did 100+ years ago seems absurd to me. Those people did nothing to deserve that wealth.