3 ms·
Money is needed to pay for common services like roads and police and government and health services and the military. Taxes provide that money. That's very ver
by IshKebab 4y ago
Money is needed to pay for common services like roads and police and government and health services and the military. Taxes provide that money.
That's very very obvious so maybe I misunderstood you - what do you mean exactly?
- porsager 4y agoThere are a lot of presuppositions in your statement. It doesn't provide an answer to "Should we tax" from first principles, but is just the current situation in a world dominated by oppressive governments.
- jasonm23 4y agoDon't forget the financial powers, which have these governments over a barrel.
- IshKebab 4y agoRight because the answer to that is even more obvious but I'll spell it out anyway. The reason we should tax is that not taxing would be far worse. Point me to one of these mythical non-"oppressive" governments at any point in history that didn't tax and wasn't awful.
- patricius 4y agoHe means that there is no good argument for getting the money needed for the things you mentioned through taxes, since taxes are theft.
- IshKebab 4y agoTaxes are not theft. They are a fee you have to pay for the privilege of living in modern society. And the argument for it is that the alternatives are clearly far worse. What more do you need?
- porsager 4y agoAh modern Society. You say not theft, but they force it from us and spend it on wars to extract whatever they can from the ones they can't tax without a fight. The alternative where we don't let the already too powerful take our property looks worse? Anyone in favor of taxation is either afraid of challenging the status quo, or of the belief that they'll ultimately get more by stealing from others than doing anything productive themselves. That's quite sad. If it was really true that it was better for society it could simply be voluntary, and not coercive. You wouldn't pay nowhere near the same amount which is taken from you now, you'd very likely shop around for a less shitty option.
- IshKebab 4y agoI'm genuinely curious what you think the alternative is. Please explain how your tax free society would work!
- porsager 4y agoOthers have done that very nicely for me, so if you really are genuinely curious I would suggest you read the following two books. Now you can start off with "Ethics of Liberty"[1] if you would like to begin with the Ethical Parts of the reasoning, but if you're more into how / why it would work (which it seems you are), I would suggest starting out with "For a New Liberty"[2]. Now these books are straight to the core, no sugar coating, so I hope you'll read them with an open mind. Now since you're on this site you'll probably also find the related book "Against Intellectual Property" interesting. If I'm going to spend the time telling my visions, I'd prefer a better platform since this thread is getting quite long. You can find a way to contact me in my profile. [1] https://cdn.mises.org/The%20Ethics%20of%20Liberty%2020191108.pdf https://cdn.mises.org/The%20Ethics%20of%20Liberty%2020191108... [2] https://cdn.mises.org/For%20a%20New%20Liberty%20The%20Libertarian%20Manifesto_3.pdf https://cdn.mises.org/For%20a%20New%20Liberty%20The%20Libert... [3] https://cdn.mises.org/Against%20Intellectual%20Property_2.pdf https://cdn.mises.org/Against%20Intellectual%20Property_2.pd...