5 ms·
Agrivoltaics: A Sustainable Synergy Between Agriculture and Solar Energy
- Gasp0de 4y agoI would assume that the biggest factor in this would be that the racks and solar panels make it very difficult to use large machinery such as tractors and harvesting machines? Somehow this isn't even addressed.
- 867-5309 4y agothese look geared towards small-scale, high $/kg farming for berries, veg, and other hand-picked food. I'd imagine anything on a larger scale for high-yield grain farming would be a waste of land
- MadcapJake 4y agoYou're correct that this is limited to manual harvesting but isn't that pretty common for partial shade crops?
- Valgrim 4y agoIt's also pretty common to use solar fields for pasturing, especially where the slopes are too steep for heavy machinery.
- baron816 4y agoPartial shade crops include broccoli, asparagus, kale, carrots, brussels sprouts, peas…basically all the healthy stuff. Adding a whole second revenue stream to their production would make them more competitive with the unhealthy stuff (corn, rice, wheat).
- ianai 4y agoCorn is an absolute miracle. It probably took hundreds of years for native Americans to cultivate and domesticate corn to the nutrient crop we know. Those three crops feed humanity. They shouldn’t be shunned for what modern food processing practices. The US alone produces enough corn to feed well over 2 billion people per year.
- baron816 4y agoSure, but it’s just imbalanced in people’s diets, partially because of the cost differential.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoThe racking is either spaced to allow machinery between rows, or panels are suspended using cables and a structure above the machinery max height. Not a consideration for crops that are hand harvested. https://www.farmersjournal.ie/agrivoltaics-can-crops-and-solar-panels-be-co-located-753181 https://www.farmersjournal.ie/agrivoltaics-can-crops-and-sol... https://d3mdtxxgfz6upn.cloudfront.net/WEBFILES/000/753/181/1964818-753181.jpg https://d3mdtxxgfz6upn.cloudfront.net/WEBFILES/000/753/181/1...
- __MatrixMan__ 4y agoIf you're already putting structures in the field with the plant, I wonder if they could support the movement of smaller machines that do the same task. Instead of driving a factory over the crop, imagine a variety of smaller robots zooming around on rails or something. Like https://farm.bot https://farm.bot but huge.
- sholladay 4y agoI would also like to see that discussed. There may be enough space on the ground for more compact machinery to do a similar job. Each machine might be less productive, but they would cost less, so you could have more of them and the operation would be more parallelized.
- samwillis 4y agoFarm machinery got "big" because it enables one human to be more productive, cover more area in one unit of time. Human time is one of the most expensive resources in farming. As we automate more farming, and move to self operated machinery, we can shrink those machines down again. We can design fleets of machines to work in tandem, and operate around other structures, such as solar. The age of the tram lines is going to come to an end. This also provides opportunities for replacing chemicals with small robots, such as for weeding.
- Throw73849 4y agoOr maybe use illegal cheap labour from another country. Something like feudalism, but more modern!
- samwillis 4y agoYou joke, but there are a lot of crops that can't easily be machine picked, and probably never will be. Although I'm a proponent for legal safe immigration for sessional work with a route to permanent residency. The lack of legal routes results in unsafe working conditions and modern slavery.
- Throw73849 4y agoWhy would I joke? People are cheaper than machines. Edit: "illegal" in terms of work law, minimal salary and safety standards. Legally imported workers are probably even cheaper and easier to exploit! Until we establish socialism, human labour will always be exploited and cheaper than machines!
- samwillis 4y agoMy mistake, I usually assume someone openly proposing illegal immigration, rather than safe legal immigration, as a solution is joking.
- ianai 4y agoAh but now supplemented with a push to legalize child labor in the US.
- epistasis 4y agoSeems pretty straightforward to seeing appropriate machinery and use that instead of machinery designed for an entirely different setting.
- newsclues 4y agoDo we have electric tractors? Are they viable given that weight is a serious issue for machinery on fields? Having lived on a rural farm, with solar panels on the barn, if you can use the harvested power on the farm, great, but once you start trying to distribute it, the problems start to show up because rural infrastructure isn't good, and there isn't enough demand in the local grid.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoSounds feasible. You’d need battery storage or less batteries and orchestration to charge farm equipment during solar production hours if no grid connection available, but micro grids are a well worn path at this point. Very popular in Australia’s western geography and their Northern Territory, where there is not much transmission infra to speak of. https://electrek.co/2022/11/23/caterpillar-demonstrates-first-battery-electric-792-large-mining-truck/ https://electrek.co/2022/11/23/caterpillar-demonstrates-firs...
- worldsayshi 4y ago> infrastructure isn't good I've heard this enough times that I might assume this is the bottle neck of a green transition of our electrical generation. What is being done about this? Is it an area where innovation or disruption can still happen? Are there any interesting things on the horizon for taking big leaps on fixing the electricity infrastructure? As a Fullstack/Cloud/Data engineer where could you put your feet down to contribute to solving this problem?
- newsclues 4y agoDecentralized power isn't what the power companies want. The innovations aren't being pursued because of economics and greed.
- worldsayshi 4y agoSo let's decentralise (human) power (over the grid)? But how?
- 4y ago
- mirpetri 4y agoPlants love sun, why would I put them below a panel into shade. Article mentions blueberries which I grow and those which get the sunshine only half of the day (partly in shade) don't have the same sweet taste as other in better sunny spots of my garden.
- olddustytrail 4y ago> Plants love sun No. Some plants love direct sunshine and others don't.
- cellularmitosis 4y agoUnfortunately the article just hand-waves on this point, leaving it at "certain crops": > However, certain crops are better suited for this system due to their ability to thrive under partial shade.
- voisin 4y agoYou can get bifacial panels that let light filter through. Not sure what is filtered, but perhaps the remainder is sufficient for certain crops?
- Mistletoe 4y agoHere is a chart of DLI (daily light integral) needed for lots of common crops. https://www.horti-growlight.com/en-gb/typical-ppfd-dli-values-per-crop https://www.horti-growlight.com/en-gb/typical-ppfd-dli-value... Here is a map of DLI in the USA by month. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Maps-of-monthly-outdoor-DLI-throughout-the-United-States-Source-Mapping-monthly_fig1_242551992 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Maps-of-monthly-outdoor-... So there is some wiggle room maybe. Looks like about 30 is good DLI and the USA gets 40-60 in the summer. My gut feeling though tells me that the best performance is panels that use all the light or plants that get full access to it.
- r00fus 4y agoPlants can also get too much Sun just like they can be overwatered. That’s where agrivoltaics and irrigation can help.
- sholladay 4y agoThe writing style of this article is very repetitive and drawn out. Maybe AI generated? > Reduced Greenhouse Gas Emissions > Agrivoltaic systems can also help to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in agriculture. Traditional farming methods rely heavily on fossil fuels for irrigation, transportation, and fertilizer production. These activities contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions, which contribute to climate change. > They can also help to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by generating clean energy from solar panels. By using renewable energy, farmers can reduce their reliance on fossil fuels, which can help to lower their carbon footprint. Additionally, Agrivoltaic systems can reduce the need for conventional electricity, which is often generated from fossil fuels."
- seu 4y agoHuman or AI generated, it's clearly SEO optimized. I think that's the real problem.
- samwillis 4y agoReally I blame Google for this, obviously any online publication needs to optimise for traffic, they need to pay the bills. But Google's latest algorithm changes quite clearly prioritise longer prose, and so bulking out text in articles has become the norm. It's a shame, and Google have the resources to do better, but unfortunately not the incentives. Most of the pages have some amount of Google ads on them.
- friendswdorthy 4y agoEdit: oh okay just downvote because of an observation. Nice community here!
- hammyhavoc 4y agoThat there isn't an author listed other than the site name should be a giveaway that there's something funny about it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jackmott 4y ago[dead]
- jmartrican 4y agoHaving solar panels might be a good way to hedge your bets against a bad harvest. I imagine it can get quite sunny during a drought.
- weinzierl 4y agoOne of the incentives the article doesn't mention is property tax. Where I live, agricultural land is taxed much less than other property. The moment you put solar on your meadow you pay the regular rate. I think it would be fair if property kept its agricultural tax status if it is used in an environmentally friendly way.
- konschubert 4y agoBut in turn, this means that solar plants will be developed to have pretend-farming below it.
- weinzierl 4y agoNot at all. My opinion is that you should be taxed the same way no matter how you use the energy that falls on your soil from the sky. It shouldn't matter if it goes through chlorophyll or silicon.
- konschubert 4y agoSo you’re saying that solar farm land should be taxed like farmland? That would remove the bad incentives. Personally I agree.
- agumonkey 4y agoHow difficult would be to have some checks for actual farming taking place ? If this allows for more solar farms AND give people incentives to also grow more food locally I'd say it's a win-win.
- seydor 4y agoPVs are always raised off the ground. This is not some new invention, people just planted some stuff under the PVs. You can also get some goats to clean the weeds in the place before that. They will appreciate the shaded area (but hopefully not the cables)
- pfdietz 4y ago> PVs are always raised off the ground. Not true. https://www.erthos.com/ https://www.erthos.com/
- lpapez 4y agoAgrivoltaics seems like a cool idea but one of the things I rarely ever see mentioned is how chemicals from the panels interact with the crops. Steel can rust and if rust gets washed away into the earth and then the plants... well that cant be beneficial right? And I bet steel is the least toxic element of the panels.
- hosh 4y agoThere are plants that can do soil remediation on soil with heavy metals, though you can’t eat them and you still have to find a way to process or sequester the heavy metal. Cilantro (coriander) is an example.
- kibwen 4y agoIron is often used as a fertilizer, so rusted support beams aren't a problem, either for the plants or for humans. And all the interesting parts of a solar panel are under glass, they aren't being washed away by rain.
- hannob 4y agoRust is just iron oxide, which in small quantities is a relatively benign substance. And probably there's more rust coming from old farming equipment than from the (likely high quality, because they are built for expensive solar panels) steel structures here. The solar cells themselve are mostly made out of silicon, which also isn't a dangerous substance. I don't think this is an issue.
- sigstoat 4y agothe solar facilities i'm familiar with use aluminum beams for the structure. it is more than strong enough, lighter so it is easier to install/ship to site, and requires no special treatment to survive the environment for more than the life of the installation. the panels themselves do not contain steel, either. > And I bet steel is the least toxic element of the panels. perhaps, but nothing on the panels comes off. they're solid objects largely impervious to all forms of precipitation. more of your house washes away in a storm than comes off a panel.
- tuatoru 4y ago
- hosh 4y agoThis is a specific application of a broader design pattern found in the permaculture world: planting combinations of plants at different canopy layers, ecological functions, and yields. The solar panels would be taking the place of an understory or shrub canopy layer, while there are herbaceous, ground cover, and root zone layers you can work with. While solar panels have an yield useful for humans, it would be even better if it can participate in the ecological system. Planting instead say, a palo verde would yield edible beans, with the tree itself acting as a nitrogen fixer. A sea buckthorne tree also acts as a nitrogen fixer, with roots propogating (more sea buckthrone trees pops up on its own) and yields high vitamin-c berries. What ecological function can a solar panel contribute to?
- Rhapso 4y agoHow do solar panels interact with condensation?
- hosh 4y agoI don’t know. But that gets into the broader design pattern of engineering a microclimate, whether that is changing local humidity and temperature levels. Perhaps, the structure itself can also provide some other functions. The pylons, for example, can double as a way for deep root watering.
- mrDmrTmrJ 4y agoProviding shade and lowering peak temperatures - allowing sensitive plants to survive in a broader range of climate & light conditions.
- hosh 4y agoThat’s a result of occupying a certain canopy layer. Any other plant that occupies that canopy layer can do the same.
- agumonkey 4y agoBut 1) they don't generate electricity 2) they might require care to avoid spreading or attracting bugs (i'm speculating) The idea to benefit from an energy source at the ecological layer is the main idea IMO.
- vrglvrglvrgl 4y ago[dead]
- CopperWizard 4y ago[flagged]