8 ms·
What if we tolerated diseases?
- aurizon 4y agoif we tolerated disease - as man did from time immemorial, we would allow diseases to reach a steady state. We would soon die out as a race due to population decline as we are well below the required rate of replacement in a diseased population. We would have to outlaw birth control as the current rate of replacement would not be enough if half our children died by the age of 5 - as they did in the 1700-1800's. Survivors might be more resistant, but I and many others do not feel this is a good strategy. Nature 'saw' the need for an immune system - it was that or die. About 90% of the native populations of North, South and Central America died from the diseases brought from Europe by Columbus and those that followed. This huge wave of deaths spread from the points of contact by tribal passage and preceded the later growth of hybrid populations of europeans/natives. It was only by later LIDAR surveys of large land areas that these ancient agricultural zones were revealed - some of which are now being explored - large structures - over grown by vegetation. Some were killed by older disease spreads prior to Columbus - it is not a new/unique phenomenon. So the article's premise is false - we can not back to the old ways. That said, a better understanding might allow the linked pathogen/prey relationship between diseases and their host populations to be broken - as we have done with smallpox?
- lesiki 4y ago> We would soon die out as a race due to population decline as we are well below the required rate of replacement in a diseased population Isn't there a strong correlation between birth rate & child mortality? Most rich societies have slowed down their birth rate in large part because you don't need 5 kids in order to ensure 1 makes it to adulthood. If we tolerated disease, we would probably increase birth rates to compensate for the spike in child mortality.
- tourgen 4y ago[dead]
- HelloNurse 4y agoConversely, increasing child mortality necessarily increases child care effort per adult child: a bad deal that can only be compensated by having children at a significantly younger age.
- slushh 4y ago>We would have to outlaw birth control as the current rate of replacement would not be enough if half our children died by the age of 5 We could also make rising children less of an obstacle. If you build the infrastructure around rising children so that rising 2 children is not a full-time job, then parents would get more children.
- explorer83 4y agoWe do sacrifice a lot of our time to raise children. But it's the cost of childcare that makes it really difficult imo. Unless you have a high paying job, you are quite literally going to work so you can afford to pay other people to watch your children while you're at work.
- namdnay 4y agoIf that were the main factor you’d expect to see much higher fertility rates in French families for example, which isn’t really the case (especially if you exclude families of foreign descent)
- vidarh 4y agoThere is little evidence of that. Countries with more support do not necessarily retain higher fertility rates. Look at e.g. the legal right to nursery places with capped costs, long parental leave, and subsequent financial aid in Norway. It might be it'd happen if you exceed a certain level of support, but we've not cracked that nut yet.
- explorer83 4y agoI'm not familiar with Norway's culture. Personally, if I had access to these benefits, I would have more children and faster. But I do see people who have the financial means and time to raise children who view children as a restriction of their life experience.
- vidarh 4y ago
- maxboone 4y agoThat's quite the extreme, this article doesn't remotely propose tolerating a potentially devastating pathogen. It's more about the idea that someone can be healthy, even if they carry a pathogen.
- XorNot 4y agoCould you please read the article before typing? The article is about research into non-immune system based adaptive systems of the body that reduce disease susceptibility - i.e why some animals and people can tolerate higher bacterial or viral loads without dying then others, and can we develop drugs which enhance these effects or augment them (i.e. giving glucose support to malaria infected rats which arr experiencing an overactive drop in glucose production due to natural responses to effects of malaria). It's about therapeutic agents to boost survivability without looking directly at pathogen kill paths - it is admittedly weirdly titled.
- maxboone 4y agoThank you.
- dang 4y agoPlease edit out swipes like the first sentence here. The rest of your comment would be just fine without that. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it. One of them is "Edit out swipes", and there's even another about this specific case: "Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that.""
- nkrisc 4y agoWhen I read articles like this, I can’t help but think that the author takes it for granted that humans are destined to exist.
- teekert 4y agoMaybe we aren't, but the deeply ingrained believe that we are may certainly be useful. I hate lies or partial truths, but if the full truth is incomprehensible by our intellects, the best we can do is live with and by models and mantra's that are helpful in making the now a nice place to be. Not that we should even give up the search for more truth, at least, that's one of my mantras.
- Dudeman112 4y agoWhat do you mean? Looks to me like you are reacting to the title instead of the article I expected the standard anti-medicine fare from the title, but got neat biological investigation/hacking instead. That was an interesting read
- ragingrobot 4y agoIf I read your comment right, I fully agree. We take it for granted, we believe that we have the right to exist. At every turn we're trying to defeat death and illness. Trying to defeat nature's (and the planet's) mechanisms of a form of population control. Then on the other hand, we sort of complain about overpopulation. Don't get me wrong, I don't want to see people die, but on the other hand I fully understand that we must die. Me must get ill.
- Dudeman112 4y ago>I don't want to see people die, but on the other hand I fully understand that we must die Those are not mutually compatible Well, unless you take some esoteric interpretation where one can be absolved from the immediate implications of what they think are the most desirable states for the universe If one considers it necessary for people to die, one wants people to die. It's part of the whole considering death necessary
- maxboone 4y agoToday in "it's a bit of both". I guess this is a very Dutch thing, but usually the GP here sends you home with the advise to take some rest, an antipyretic and call again if it gets worse or it doesn't go away after a week. Still, interesting read - good this is thought and discussed about.
- braymundo 4y agoYup, paracetamol being prescribed for everything is a bit of a meme here.
- AstralStorm 4y agoThese days it tends to be ibuprofen.
- salad-tycoon 4y agoOr both, “studies show that both taken together is just as good if not better than opioids and narcotics!” Yep! I’ll save you all the rant about opioids.
- cnity 4y agoI would like to sign up for the opioid rant.
- refurb 4y agoYes, they work better used together, but except for a few specific types of pain (e.g. dental) they are far inferior to opioids.
- User23 4y agoI had a severe muscle pain once, like so bad that I literally could not stand the pain. I had to hold on to someone or something to move. The doctor prescribed an opioid and it did nothing. Then he suggested I try 800 mg tylenol for arthritis and it got me to the point where I could at least walk. Analgesia is pretty weird.
- konschubert 4y agoI think the article says: "Some scientists think that sometimes it may be better to tell your immune system to take it slow, such that you have fewer symptoms caused by the immune response". We are already doing this, no? Every time we take medication that lowers our fever during an infection (antipyretic ), we trade a bit of immune response for a much more comfortable illness. The other aspect of this is that carrying more pathogen, for longer, increases the chance that you will infect others.
- giantg2 4y ago"increases the chance that you will infect others." Or that it could do more damage, depending on the type of infection. For example, HPV os though to only lead to cancer for those who have a persistent infection for a few years.
- chrisan 4y agoYa, you aren't suppose to take an OTC pain reliever around the covid vaccine as it could reduce your immune response
- gautamdivgi 4y agoNot sure why you got downvoted. But I believe you’re right. I did read that you should not take the otc pain reliever before the shot but can do so when symptoms develop after the shot.
- wholinator2 4y agoOff topic but I'm curious. I've seen lots of people telling others they've been downvoted. How are you able to tell? Are you using a specific app or just the website, is there a number like reddit or just the slight greying seen in soon to die posts. Just curious since i have no ability to see downvotes
- throwawayadvsec 4y agocomments get progressively more greyed out then hidden when they receive downvotes
- BulgarianIdiot 4y agoWe've already reached a point where medicine, in some cases, is doing more damage than good. Plastic surgery is clear example of this. Followed by surgery like gastric bypass which is largely ineffective long-term, but of course they don't track it long term. People return to old habits, and the body tries to adapt, but now with newly crippled digestive system. "Everything in moderation" is something we've not learned yet, as a culture.
- robertlagrant 4y ago> Plastic surgery is clear example of this. Lots of plastic surgery is done to restore features. I think that practice does far more good than harm.
- enkid 4y agoPlastic surgery is one of those things you are much more likely to notice if it's done poorly then well. This, ironically, makes people think most plastic surgery is "bad" when really most plastic ic surgery that you notice is bad.
- nik_s 4y agoWhile I agree with the general sentiment of your message, there are quite a few meta-analyses on pubmed on the long-term safety and efficacy of gastric bypass surgery. They mostly show that while some patients do end up back obese, the majority do improve on many markers of health (weight, diabetes, ...). Here's an example of a study if you're interested [1]! [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29340676/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29340676/
- jacquesm 4y agoThere is elective plastic surgery for fashion reasons and there is reconstruction after trauma or to correct birth defects, you should probably not toss the two into the same bin.
- DanHulton 4y agoThere is also elective plastic surgery to help address body dysmorphia. And even "fashion reasons" aren't as frivolous as some would think. A lot of people will judge you based on "fashion reasons," and being able to address that can potentially measurably improve you life. There are plenty of studies that have shown that people perceived as "more beautiful" are more respected and have an easier life. The inverse is also true, and being able to address that is powerful.
- sylware 4y agoWe would be batmen.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoLike the plague? Together with the Swedes it killed 85% of the inhabitants of my hometown.
- feintruled 4y agoThat 'survival of the fittest' interpretation is not the angle the article is coming from, I think. It's saying 'if you can control the symptoms, why worry if you have the disease?' Or rather, what if you were sufficiently tolerant to a pathogen you didn't display any symptoms.
- vrglvrglvrgl 4y ago[dead]
- ryanbrunner 4y agoThere's absolutely viruses that we tolerate currently and take basically no effort to fight, because in the vast, vast majority of the population they're benign. I had an organ transplant a couple of years ago, and as part of that I now have to do monthly blood screening for some of these benign diseases (CMV and BK) since they aren't as benign for someone on strong immunosuppressants. Maybe this is a selfish thought, but moving towards tolerating diseases objectively increases risk for people like me who can't tolerate diseases to the same extent as others, and others tolerating them more increases the odds that I'll catch them, so this isn't a medical advancement I'm particularly excited about.
- fovc 4y agoCMV is also strongly associated with pregnancy complications
- PaulKeeble 4y agoA lot of these benign viruses are turning up in diseases we go on to develop later in life, they might not be benign they just don't kill us right away.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoYes, supposedly quote-on-quote benign not actually proven in fact.
- gameshot911 4y agoFYI just in case you didn't know, it's "quote unquote", signifying the starting and ending quotation marks.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoSince HN has a large number of English language learners in the reader-base I figure this spelling is less likely to induce confusion.
- iamcasen 4y agoIllness is largely a function of overall health. As a society, we generally lead very unhealthy lives: eating mountains of processed food, working too much, sitting indoors and staring at screens. We have a failed concept of the nuclear family, which means very little support with child-rearing, and soaring costs around everything involving the home and family. All of this stacks the deck against the majority of Americans. Is it any wonder our bodies cannot fight off disease naturally? When you also add in that we have an absurd fear of illness and death, our behaviors get more and more neurotic, which then adds to the stress, which then further compromises our health.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y ago> Is it any wonder our bodies cannot fight off disease naturally? You need to prove that we could previously. The various plagues and epidemics (Athens, Antonine, and Black to namea few) are excellent proof that returning to unprocessed food won't much help. > When you also add in that we have an absurd fear of illness and death The Momento Mori rose in response to the Black Plague, so that's not new either.
- chrisdhoover 4y agoI’m not sure that you understand the meaning of nuclear family. It is a family composed of mom, dad, and kids. This differs from single parent households. You may want to rethink what you wrote.
- mvdl 4y ago"And vaccines work because they teach immune systems to recognize — and so more effectively resist — pathogens before the actual bug is encountered." Is a bold claim that has yet to be proven empirically.
- jrussino 4y ago> a bold claim Isn't that just the definition of a vaccine? "A vaccine is a biological preparation that provides active acquired immunity to a particular infectious or malignant disease." ... "The agent stimulates the body's immune system to recognize the agent as a threat, destroy it, and to further recognize and destroy any of the microorganisms associated with that agent that it may encounter in the future." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vaccine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vaccine
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoWhat proof do you require? The first vaccines for smallpox were literally teaching the immune system to fight it by using the less dangerous but very similar cowpox. If you were infected with cowpox you were much less likely to be sick with smallpox. What are you taking exception to there, and if you are taking exception, please describe in detail what proof you'd require.
- msla 4y agoTolerating disease means dooming some people to die. I know that's popular among some political groups, but it is still inhuman.
- 11235813213455 4y agoI help merchants sell fruits, eat many, forage also in my area, people are always a bit shocked when I directly eat tomatoes, kiwis (with their skin), dates, peppers without washing them, but I don't get ill at all, my immune system is probably stronger than theirs after decades of a forager lifestyle, it sorts what needs to be, digest correctly
- lamontcg 4y agoThis is exactly what the SARS-CoV-2 vaccines do. The neutralizing antibodies aren't durable, so protection against infection and mild illness wanes, but the T-cells that protect against hospitalization and death are likely permanent.
- frankreyes 4y agoThis is how it already works. Vaccines are just a learning experience for the immune system, which is the one doing the actual work. Vaccines per se do not cure diseases.