3 ms·
>It was necessary to give Stalin something to think about. I really wish this meme would die. There's no evidence the US dropped the atomic bombs on Japan as a
by krapp 4y ago
>It was necessary to give Stalin something to think about.
I really wish this meme would die. There's no evidence the US dropped the atomic bombs on Japan as a show of force to Stalin, yet people constantly state it as if it were proven fact. All of the existing documentary evidence from the time points to the purpose of the atomic bombs being to force a surrender from Japan and avoid the cost of an invasion of the main islands.
People need to accept that sometimes the straightforward explanation is actually correct. It isn't always a smokescreen of propaganda hiding a nefarious motive or conspiracy. Yes, the US was concerned about dealing with Russia after the war. No, not to the degree that they were willing to nuke two Japanese cities just to spook him.
- CamperBob2 4y agoYes, the US was concerned about dealing with Russia after the war. No, not to the degree that they were willing to nuke two Japanese cities just to spook him. Agreed, and I edited my comment to clarify. It's funny how it had that effect, though, isn't it? War might change, but Russians never do. They respect force and violence, nothing else. My response was to coldtea's snark: Or how Hiroshima and Nagasaki were so much better with the advent of nuclear fission technology? Since technology basically just makes us richer and safer and everything! Yes, in fact, it absolutely did make Japan "richer and safer and everything," by ensuring that the country didn't become the scene of an epic, likely-endless battle with Communist forces for control of the Pacific. For an additional gedanken exercise, contemplate the likely effect on the net well-being of North Korea's population over time if MacArthur had been given a free hand by Truman.
- krapp 4y ago> It's funny how it had that effect, though, isn't it? Did it, in the long term? We know Russia had spies inside the Manhattan Project. They knew what the US was doing, and it seems as if their plan was to get their own nuclear arsenal as soon as possible. In hindsight they don't seem to have been deterred at all.
- CamperBob2 4y agoCertainly they were inspired to build their own nuclear arsenal as soon as possible. But Japan was firmly under US hegemony by the time they succeeded, and no longer in play.
- hakfoo 4y agoThe standard assumption seems to be that the US had two options: shock-and-awe by dropping the bombs or engaged in a protracted invasion of the home islands. Were there other options? By the last months of the war, they had largely lost control of the naval and air spaces. Japan was an import-dependent economy to begin with, and had consumed everything that wasn't nailed down for the war effort. Couldn't they just be blockaded? Either they end up an isolated novelty that occasionally scrapes together enough scrap iron to launch a low-grade weapon, sort of like the DPRK is seen today, or it "starves out a surrender" by allowing domestic conditions to collapse, potentially nudging a coup towards a new regime who's more willing to negotiate. That might take 5 or 10 years to reach endgame, but it seems like a less direct, but still viable way to complete the war.
- CamperBob2 4y agoThat might take 5 or 10 years to reach endgame, but it seems like a less direct, but still viable way to complete the war. This plan would have killed more people, and caused far more net suffering, than simply nuking a couple of cities. As a similar example, it's true that letting MacArthur use nukes would have been a monstrous act of evil that would have put the US up there with the Nazis in the annals of infamy... but it's also true that more North Koreans would be alive and well today if we had. We could hardly have done more damage with our bombs than the Kim family did with ideology. Of course that's a simplistic assessment that ignores the consequences of normalizing nuclear warfare at a time when its destructive capacity was ramping up at an exponential rate. But it is entirely fair to apply it to Japan at the end of WWII, when the lesson was relatively cheap to learn.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoLet’s not forget the Soviet’s. We didn’t want them to invade Japan first, we needed to end the war before they could have an excuse to do so as our ally (which was already coming undone by the end of WW2).