7 ms·
Telegram deletes message against Brazil’s Bill after Supreme Court threat
- matheusmoreira 4y agoTelegram itself sent a message to all its brazilian users speaking out against the censorship law they're trying to pass. Government and supreme court ordered Telegram to delete it and to retract their words or face a 72 hour nation wide block and $100k per hour fines. They also ordered Telegram representatives to testify before federal police. They were forced to send a new message to users saying "the previous message was flagrant and illicit disinformation against national congress, the judiciary, the state and brazilian democracy" because it "fraudulently distorted the discussion and debate" in an attempt to "induce users to coerce their representatives". The "talk to your representatives" calls to action I usually see here on HN in discussions of US political matters? That's coercion now. They're making users coerce their representatives, apparently.
- crop_rotation 4y agoThis seems like democracy is dead in Brazil. If the brazilian court has such perfect monopoly on truth and can decide that much, why bother holding elections at that point. Since in any election most parties are saying different things, the court can just ban all the others for misinformation and give power to the party they agree with. Better yet, they can rename themselves "King's Council" and take one of theirs as King, since truth is already known and rest is "illicit disinformation"
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> This seems like democracy is dead in Brazil. I agree completely and I've said that here on HN many times even despite downvotes. The censorship here began with last year's elections and has only been ramping up since then. The government wants what it wants and it will corrupt, destroy or silence anyone who opposes them. We're living under some sort of quasi-communist judiciary dictatorship. It sickens me to my soul to hear the word "democracy" come out of these people's mouths. Even North Korea calls itself a democracy... > the court can just ban all the others for misinformation and give power to the party they agree with That's exactly what they're doing. They've removed from office and made ineligible politicians over "disinformation". They accuse their opponents of the crime of "fake news" and then deplatform them. These all powerful judges who never received a single vote and are aligned with the ruling party. I wonder if one of these days dang's gonna get a message from these fucking people because of my posts.
- crop_rotation 4y agoSadly people everywhere seem to support erosion of freedoms if their opponents get oppressed. All kinds of freedoms can be eroded as long as you can sell them as being used to hurt the "bad guys", whatever the bad guys means in any country.
- EA-3167 4y agoThat's just human nature, tribalism justifies everything. It's why echo chambers are so appealing to so many people, and why they devolve into meme-slinging and a lack of critical thought.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoEcho chambers and political tribalism are one thing. Government and courts using police forces to coerce your speech is quite another. Uncritical discourse is sad but it does not excuse this blatant censorship.
- crop_rotation 4y agoYeah courts unilaterally deciding what political advocacy is disinformation or not is just a monarchy in disguise. It is just like the King deciding what is good for the Kingdom .By the way your comments on the current situation in Brazil have been so eye opening to me as an outsider. I did my own research and the more I read, the more shocked I become.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoThere's plenty more in my comments and submissions history. I can make a list of links if you'd like. This is where it began: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33312582 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33312582 Other brazilians here on HN have also corrected me on points where I was wrong, I learned plenty from them even in in cases where I didn't agree.
- 4y ago
- slaw 4y agoDemocracy doesn't equal liberty. Current government was democratically elected, so Brazil still has democracy, it is just a totalitarian democracy.
- alephnerd 4y agoIt's called Illiberal Democracy. In political science Liberal/Illiberal doesn't mean socially Progressive/Conservative, it means Open/Restricted from a civil liberties standpoint. This is why you can have right leaning Illiberal Democracies like Turkïye, Serbia, and Hungary as well as left leaning Illiberal Democracies like Brazil, South Africa, and Mexico, and also why you can have conservative leaning liberal democracies like South Korea, Denmark, or Japan and progressive leaning liberal democracies like Canada, Norway, or New Zealand.
- slaw 4y agoI never heard about Illiberal Democracy. Wikipedia definition differs from yours and even Wikipedia is not sure about what it is[0] >There is a lack of consensus among experts about the exact definition of illiberal democracy or whether it even exists I would stop using left/right as a description in politics. For example ruling party in Hungary is socialist, which means it cannot be right wing party no matter what they claim. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illiberal_democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illiberal_democracy
- hsjqllzlfkf 4y ago> I never heard about Illiberal Democracy. I've heard the term from Steven Kotkin. I think it's pretty clear what the term means. It means that nominally the institutions that are meant to protect civil liberties exist, but some person or group has managed to put their hands on enough levers that they can dictate the workings of those institutions. Like Russia, for example. They have elections for government, and they have institutions that are meant to ensure that the government doesn't have a monopoly on power. In practice however one person has an absolute hold on power, to the point that people who criticize him tend to fall out of windows a lot. That doesn't happen in the US for example. You can trash Biden all you want, no one's gonna show up at your house to murder you.
- tpxl 4y agoA non-Brazilian company is meddling in Brazilian elections. This is exactly what happened when Russians meddled with the US elections.
- whythre 4y agoPffft, what? No it isn’t. What a ludicrous thing to say. Telegram may not be some shining paragon of freedom, but it seems pretty obvious that Brazil (like many other nations) is shifting towards naked despotism.
- PedroBatista 4y agoIt’s a bad response to a real and bad problem that I’m afraid there’s no good ( practical ) solution. The misinformation and populist propaganda is those platforms, it’s so spread out that has real world consequences. That’s why the current powers have to acknowledge the problem. The world views and “post-democracy” stuff spread by ( mostly) Russian and Chinese operations are wild!! And they are sophisticated enough to craft their message to different parts of the world. ( in Europe and the Us, is posts fomenting racial divisions) the other parts of the world as far as I can tell it’s how the West it’s bad, controls everything and turns your son gay. The solution? I don’t know. Probably none.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- abvaw 4y ago[flagged]
- matheusmoreira 4y agoNo. If Telegram was a social media company with algorithmic content recommendation systems, you could argue it was penalizing one side in favor of the other one. If that was the case I'd agree with you but it's not the case. Telegram is a messaging app, like signal and whatsapp. Its users are the ones doing the influencing, not the company itself. The election is already over anyway. This episode is just Lula and his people making good on his campaign promise to "regulate" the internet by censoring it.
- asdkjlfkasjdf 4y agothis law has less teeth than the digital millennium act, which the US had for decades. it's only for group chats. and only for things that are already illegal (racism, etc) and fake news such as defined (openly and publicly) by the courts, on a case by case. goal is to prevent another January 8th (Brazil's January 6th). ...and what is this newspaper about?!? their front page reads "Opinion: Tucker Carlson is about to revolutionize world journalism By Daniel Lopez (Opinion)".... weird content for "rio".
- crop_rotation 4y agoThe law is irrelevant compared to the bigger picture. If courts can force people/organizations to not advocate against laws, what is the point of elections and democracy. Why not just have a King? If everything is known to the great Court, why put up with the charade of democracy, since the new President might be full of "disinformation".
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> If everything is known to the great Court The great court isn't even made up of actual judges, by the way. In Brazil, actual judges are selected by rigorous testing of law knowledge in a process known as concurso which roughly means contest. It's extremely competitive, applicants tend to be disciplined people who study many hours every day. People generally don't make it to a judge position without knowing their shit. Supreme court judges aren't like that. They're just people appointed by politicians. The censorship-friendly judge who's ordering words into Telegram's mouth? He used to be the lawyer of one of Brazil's biggest drug trafficking gangs, PCC. Incidentally, that criminal organization supported the current president in last year's elections and was involved in a plot to torture and assassinate the judge who imprisoned him for corruption earlier this year. Supreme court ordered most of them released while many Brasília protesters are locked up to this day. It's surreal.
- admsmz 4y agoI'm glad the western media talked about this situation extensively before during and after the Brasilian election that ousted Bolsanero.
- doodlesdev 4y agoThe craziest thing is it's working. I live in Brazil (unfortunately, I guess) and yet the only place I even see discussion about this is on Hacker News of all places. The Telegram block is pretty good tech-wise, it's not just DNS-level like some other countries do, to circumvent it you _have_ to use a proxy. It's also crazy this is happening almost at the same time the US has the EARN IT act back. The west has some serious threats to digital freedom right now, and the solution (for now) is not more technology, it's protest and democracy (if that's even a thing nowadays). Anyway, it's a good time to teach friends and family how to use tor, VPNs, Fediverse, maybe even crypto (if your currency completely collapsing is possible). We, as an industry, should have from the start built the internet to be decentralized, secure, private, by default. It's too late for that now, the boat has sailed, but there's still time to prevent it from getting even worse. Oh yeah, and if you're reading this from anywhere in the world where this kind of thing is not a worry right now, please consider: https://snowflake.torproject.org/ https://snowflake.torproject.org/ https://support.torproject.org/ https://support.torproject.org/
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> the only place I even see discussion about this is on Hacker News of all places This is all over the news and social media but it's impossible to discuss anything in those spaces. Even here on HN people created sockpuppet accounts to call me out. Not even kidding. https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=forabolsonaro https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=forabolsonaro I wonder if they understand the fact such pseudonymous fake accounts will literally become a crime if this law passes.
- lobocinza 4y ago> Even here on HN people created sockpuppet accounts to call me out. Lots of political and financial interests behind it. For them it's existential as they can't survive in a free and decentralized space even with paid content and bots.
- tomohawk 4y agoThis is the effect of the censorship-industrial complex: https://www.zerohedge.com/political/censorship-industrial-complex-top-50-organizations-know https://www.zerohedge.com/political/censorship-industrial-co...
- traveler01 4y agoWell, that's what happen when you get the extreme-left to run your country.
- prionassembly 4y agoThe interesting tidbit here is that congresspeople, both leaders and small fry types, were parroting a line that went "if we don't pass this censorship law, the Supreme Court is going ahead and dropping an even bigger hammer". The Supreme Court kneecapped Lula in the late 00s and early 10s, arrested his lead cadres and led to his party's decay -- until Lula himself was arrested. They did this by importing theories by German theorists that were never part of our law intellectual traditions, let alone our laws. Then in the late 10s they started arresting bloggers for insulting the Court -- directly, taking on police powers. Now they're with Lula, and further expanding their sweeping powers. I'm scared to even post this. I mean, much of Congress is scared -- they've got people there by the balls.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoThey're judge kings and they're running the country. Whatever whims they write on documents is law because police obeys. I'm very scared too. My own family has told me to my face to stop posting online because they fear I could get arrested. I still can't get over how fucked up that is.
- frozenlettuce 4y agoA Brazilian's day only truly begins after some bread and 2 full cups of judiciary down the throat
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zquzra 4y agoWhere's the bill so I can read it? I don't want to form an opinion based on "riotimesonline" and gossip.
- harrisoned 4y agoHere is the complete bill, it's last version. https://www.camara.leg.br/proposicoesWeb/prop_mostrarintegra?codteor=2265334 https://www.camara.leg.br/proposicoesWeb/prop_mostrarintegra... But probably, a new version will be approved, that hasn't been released officially. You can check it's status here: https://www.camara.leg.br/propostas-legislativas/2256735 https://www.camara.leg.br/propostas-legislativas/2256735
- matheusmoreira 4y agoI apologize for that news source. I used it because it was the only website covering this bit of news at the time of submission. Perhaps there are better sources now.
- ezconnect 4y agoThe big technical question here is why are we not moving to a decentralize messaging system that can't be controlled by government.
- tarruda 4y agoDo you have an example of easily installable apps that provide decentralized messaging?
- doodlesdev 4y agoSession: https://getsession.org/ https://getsession.org/ Briar: https://briarproject.org/ https://briarproject.org/ Jami: https://jami.net/ https://jami.net/
- xboxnolifes 4y agoI feel like it's telling that everytime this question gets answered, I learn about different applications. They don't seem to have much of a lifetime.
- ezconnect 4y agoThere was also Wickr but they discontinued their Wickr Me version for the masses and now just serving enterprise and military.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoTechnological solutions depend on the government having some kind of limit to their tyranny. Brazil at least has proved to have exactly zero limits. Same judge involved in this Telegram case recently ordered a politician to reveal the password to his phone -- ordered him to literally provide evidence against himself -- and came just short of holding him in contempt of court when the password failed to decrypt the phone. I assume the cryptanalysis by intimidation worked.
- cca778 4y agoA lot of opportunists in Brazil want the Internet to be a place for against-the-law speechs. It is not censorship if a court rules a social media company to delete pages/messages/whatever that violates any law. Telegram and Google, as companies, published misinformation. They did not publish their opinions or provide alternatives. They misrepresented the current law project. You are free to publish your opinion on a movie, your code, your own selfie. You are not free to publish bullying content, fake content, or anything that harms others.
- Vox_Leone 4y agoThere is a good partial solution in the ordinary law: it is enough to strengthen the codes of ethics while regulating the presence and expression in the networks of politicians with a mandate. Freedom of expression does not necessarily include the right to have your opinion amplified by powerful artificial means. Just as your right of self-defense does not include the use of nuclear weapons. The principle of freedom of expression is about the right to say what you want at the top of your lungs. Radical political leaders with an open channel to their followers are the problem. With audacity and political will it is possible to tame them.
- crop_rotation 4y agoYou make the wrong assumption that the truth on every issue is widely known and universally accepted. > They misrepresented the current law project. If criticising an ongoing bill is not allowed, how is it different from the USSR? If everyone has to agree to the government policy without exception, why do you need elections for? You can just let the Politburo (I mean the Great Supreme Court of Brazil) decide everything.
- lobocinza 4y ago> Telegram and Google, as companies, published misinformation. They didn't. > You are free to publish your opinion on a movie, your code, your own selfie. You are not free to publish bullying content, fake content, or anything that harms others. You're misrepresenting the current law project. Have you read it least? The 1st big problem is who will have the say in what is/isn't fake? The people backing this bill often spread lies and have zero commitment to truth and honesty. Fake news is everything that is inconvenient. Clearly, they have no issues with fake news when it supports them. There is no place for a ministry of truth in a democratic system. I don't want my country to follow the Chinese example. > It is not censorship if a court rules a social media company to delete pages/messages/whatever that violates any law. What is being removed didn't violate any laws. Opinion and free speech is a constitutional and international right. The court orders were nonsensical and legal only because they came from the supreme court which is above everyone else so they can interpret things as they wish. It's insane to have a supreme court overruling the legislative and the executive branches in a weekly basis. The supreme court actions are undemocratic and create dangerous precedents. It's slowly becoming a judicial dictatorship. Even elected representatives are afraid of them.
- e12e 4y agoNon-paywalled (Different/AFP) source: https://www.macaubusiness.com/brazil-court-makes-telegram-scrap-censorship-message/ https://www.macaubusiness.com/brazil-court-makes-telegram-sc...
- lrvick 4y agoMost communication is seen as dangerous by someone, and thus all communication done on centralized platforms that can be censored or monitored eventually will be. Signal, Telegram, Whatsapp, and all the other centralized "secure chat" communications services are fundamentally the same when you zoom out a bit. Free uncensored communication is more important than caving to friends demands. Use and promote decentralized communication solutions if you believe in democracy and free speech.
- NoFakeNews 4y agoYou all bite smth too fast. I live in Brazil, am a lawyer, work with technology and could not be happier the country is working towards a legislation that fights fake news spread and hate groups. Hate and fake are NOT free speech. Come on guys and girls - read beyond headlines
- richbell 4y agoWho decides what is "fake news" or "hate speech"? In Canada there is a very real scandal involving our Prime Minister accepting money under the table from China, as well as him knowing about foreign interference in our elections and doing nothing. According to him it's all anti-Chinese racism and hate speech.
- crop_rotation 4y agoYes, everyone needs a "Ministry of Truth". Finally the great works of political scientist George Orwell are being appreciated and adopted by governments. /s
- matheusmoreira 4y agoDo you realize that this law makes fake sockpuppet accounts such as yours illegal?
- rektide 4y ago> Come on guys and girls - read beyond headlines Once your perfect world comes, hour old account, we won't have to read beyond the headlines, will we? The government will decide what is true or not & will keep us safe from any potentially fake news.
- lobocinza 4y agoIt would be funny if it wasn't sad and scary. Those supporting this bill are doing everything the bill was supposed to be against.
- elforce002 4y agoWell, be careful what you wish for.
- crop_rotation 4y agoIt is so sad to see many people defending laws against fake speech. Do you all really want a "Ministry of Truth". Do you want the Government to decide what is true unilaterally, and block everything else as "illicit misinformation". How is this different from the USSR? By this logic the Stasi was just punishing people who spread "disinformation". How do you contest an election in such an environment, if criticising government policy means "spreading disinformation". Telegram opposed a bill and they were forced to share the below message to their users: "By determination of the STF, the company Telegram communicates: The previous message from Telegram characterized FLAGRANT and ILLEGAL DISINFORMATION offensive to the National Congress, the Judiciary, the Rule of Law and the Brazilian Democracy, because it fraudulently distorted the discussion and debates on the regulation of social network providers and private messaging services (Bill 2630), in an attempt to induce and instigate users to coerce parliamentarians"
- kornhole 4y agoThe same gagging is happening to all the internet media companies in Brazil including Google and Meta, but we are not hearing about it because we are not allowed to hear about it except through side channels like this. Glen covered it in the later part of this episode.https://rumble.com/v2looka-system-update-79.html https://rumble.com/v2looka-system-update-79.html New Law Sought by Brazil's Lula to Ban and Punish ‘Fake News’ And ‘Disinformation’ Threatens The Free Internet Everywhere. Many Nations seem poised to abandon the core lesson of the Enlightenment: no human institution can or should be trusted to decree Absolute Truth and punish dissent from it. (G. Greenwald. Feb. 25, 2023)
- frozenlettuce 4y agoAnother related interesting news: A Whatsapp board member has joined the current government in Brazil https://www1-folha-uol-com-br.translate.goog/mercado/2023/05/novo-no-2-de-haddad-sai-do-whatsapp-para-a-fazenda.shtml?_x_tr_sl=pt&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en&_x_tr_pto=wapp#:~:text=Escolhido%20como%20novo%20n%C3%BAmero%20dois,das%20Fake%20News%20no%20Congresso https://www1-folha-uol-com-br.translate.goog/mercado/2023/05.... At least for me, this raises serious questions about Whatsapp integrity - why would it have such a close relationship white a government that is walking towards a totalitarian path and censoring competitors left and right? My guess is that it is much more prone to comply with government requests than the others
- matheusmoreira 4y agoYeah, I'm starting to have doubts about WhatsApp's integrity too. Thanks for bringing this up.