11 ms·
Librem 5 USA Smartphone Provides Many Exclusive Security Features
- monarchistmaybe 4y agoI finally got my refund from these people. The solution was stop being nice and threaten to sue. Years and years (since 2017) of bullshitting me about "processing queues" with no answer as to when if ever I'd see a refund was solved in two weeks after I talked about filing paperwork with the state. Purism has burned me too many times for me to advocate for them and it's a shame because we really need a better mobile hardware and software ecosystem.
- m463 4y agoI ordered early on, it took a long time, but I got the phone and I was satisfied. It wasn't an iphone. But I could hook it to a keyboard and mouse. I later got a pine but it wasn't as good, sluggish. don't know about the pinephone pro.
- mhitza 4y agoYou're comparing a $1300 phone versus a $150 phone. I'd like to see a more recent Librem 5 video review, because in the past it used to be sluggish as well. Whereas PinePhone doesn't pretend to be anything else than an Linux ARM phone for developers of that platform. I personally considered the PinePhone at some point to hack on, and UBPorts looked rather fluid on it from video reviews I've looked at the time.
- fsflover 4y agoThe interface on Librem 5 is quite smooth. Also, it can be smooth on Pinephone, if you use a light OS like SXMo.
- m463 4y agoI'm not sure what $1300 refers to? I think I paid $599 for the librem 5 (2017), and $299 for the pinephone. Neither had the fit and finish of an iphone, even the iphone se.
- monarchistmaybe 4y agoThe Librem 5 (non USA) is $1300[0] today with an advertised 52 week lead time. The $599 price point you paid does not exist today and buying a PinePhone usually nets you a phone inside of a couple weeks where your Librem 5 probably arrived on the scale of years. It's quite the tenuous comparison. 0: https://shop.puri.sm/shop/librem-5/ https://shop.puri.sm/shop/librem-5/
- cs702 4y agoLooks promising. I'd like to be able to switch, but I'm not sure it's practical. Is there anyone here who has used or is using the Librem 5 smartphone? I have a few questions about it: * How is the the mobile version of PureOS? Do you like it? * How responsive are apps on the phone? Do they feel snappy? * Are you able to sync your email and calendar on either Google Apps or Outlook for offline access?
- The_Colonel 4y ago> Looks promising. Purism has a long history of making grand promises and not delivering them. They make sketchy things like promising a possibility to refund and then gaslighting customers that such promise did not happen.
- _cenw 4y agoPurism attempts to join the fediverse, refuses to moderate their instance, attracts some of the worst people they could, gets defederated by mostly everyone and eventually gives up all in a span of a few weeks to turn into spambot paradise is a very nice miniature version of the company's operating scheme. (For clarity: It still runs, but Mastodon from 2019.)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- seba_dos1 4y agoLibrem Social is moderated and has a CoC: https://librem.one/conduct/ https://librem.one/conduct/ It wasn't initially as the idea was to disable things like direct messages and rely on blocking (IIRC some blocking features were even improved upstream as part of the Librem One project), but that was quickly scrapped as it's not something that works with federation very well.
- _cenw 4y agoIf you care, why haven't you patched in 4 years? https://social.librem.one/nodeinfo/2.0 https://social.librem.one/nodeinfo/2.0
- r00fus 4y agoWho codes the baseband for this phone & is that open-source? $2k is a steep price but the features are pretty nice.
- blendergeek 4y agoThe modems are sourced from a couple companies and no they definitely do not run open source firmware.
- seba_dos1 4y agoThe baseband modem is a replaceable M.2 card connected over USB 2.0 and I2S for audio. No, it's not open source (the whole GSM stack on the phone itself is, but the modem's firmware that runs on the modem is a closed blob).
- TylerE 4y agoDoes it actually reliably make calls yet?
- blendergeek 4y agoVoLTE is not supported. But it can reliably place 2G calls if your carrier supports it.
- fsflover 4y agoDepending on your carrier, VoLTE can already work on Librem 5: https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Cellular-Providers https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Cellul.... Discussion: https://forums.puri.sm/t/volte-support-progress/11664/51 https://forums.puri.sm/t/volte-support-progress/11664/51.
- TylerE 4y agoIn the US, 3G has been entirely phased out and 2G is only supported by TMobile (and that’s getting turned off early next year)
- jonsger 4y agoKind of. For me (Deutsche Telekom, Germany) VoLTE does not work, so when receiving/doing a call the phone needs to drop back from LTE to 2G/GSM. Nowadays I understand the other side always pretty well, but often they don't understand me well when calling from L5. Apart from that calling is depending on modem connectivity which is still pretty bad. I don't have a stable connection at work, where an iPhone in the same mobile network, is always fine. I'm even unsure if that aspect has improved really since I received it in March 2022. Then there are some smaller bugs, like your phone hangs and keeps vibrating when you receive a call, while the L5 is locked. Edit: forgot to add that while moving fast, e.g. in a train, I would say calling is almost impossible. You just loose connection too often.
- seba_dos1 4y agoYes, for years now. Some carriers allowlist the devices that can use VoLTE on their networks though, so beware of that, especially in areas where 3G and 2G are being sunsetted.
- PrimeMcFly 4y agoVery nice! I've been wanting to move to something like Graphene or e/OS but they seem set on only supporting most of their security features on Pixel hardware. I don't want a Pixel because I don't want anything Google. This seems like a fantastic alternative, and eventually Graphene will support it - in the meanwhile there is DivestOS. I barely use my phone for making calls via the cellular network anyway, and I'm always in a big city with good reception, so not too worried about some of the issues people are talking about. Everything's a compromise anyway.
- monarchistmaybe 4y agoI sympathize with your desire steer clear of Google products, but I doubt Graphene will support any Linux phones anytime soon. GrapheneOS is Google Android's AOSP with security and hardening sauce on top plus a couple apps Google has neglected/omitted from AOSP, like a camera and pdf reader. There's some opt-in glue to make it interop as gracefully and securely as possible with Google's software ecosystem, but it's still heavily dependent on Google for hardware-level fixes and Android in general. The jump from AOSP to Linux/Phosh would be an entirely new codebase. Graphene deciding on Pixel as a foundational device wasn't because of a love for Google, but because of a need for security and hardware updates on a well-worn device platform that has actual traction in the market... as optimistic as I would like to be about the Linux Phone, we're just not there nor will be we for many tomorrows.
- PrimeMcFly 4y agoYou know, I actually mixed this phone up with the FairPhone which is only really in Europe (mixed reports about it working in the US). That's what I am still planning to get. Not sure about this Librem phone, I may still consider it...but probably not. Graphene I think could work on Fairphone without too much tweaking, not sure if it's worth the effort though.
- monarchistmaybe 4y agoAh, yes that's far more likely. Graphene might support Fairphone at some point, but I kind of doubt it. I do think it'd be far more easy to fork/retrofit though, if you sincerely had the gumption. Personally, I was bummed they removed the headphone jack on their latest model[0]. If people are going out of their way to avoid the Apple/Google antics of the world, give them a damn headphone jack. Just bogus IMO, but not a deal breaker for many in 2023 I guess. They parroted a lot of Apple's (marketing) points around it and even sell their own adapter... [0]: https://support.fairphone.com/hc/en-us/articles/9836188988049 https://support.fairphone.com/hc/en-us/articles/983618898804...
- nunobrito 4y agoAny word on battery life for these devices?
- jonsger 4y agoFor me it's something between 4 and 12 hours, depending on the usage. I have the modem always enabled, but WiFi usually disabled, because it drains your battery even faster.
- nunobrito 4y agoThanks! That seems similar to what Pinephone users are mentioning too. Really wonder what is happening for a linux device to use that much power, plenty of progress to be made on that part.
- seba_dos1 4y agoPinePhone gets longer battery time when suspended, but Librem 5 wins on active usage time. But yeah, they're both in pretty much the same order of magnitude.
- Alupis 4y agoLibrem 5 - Lead Time: 52 Weeks Sounds like vaporware more than anything...
- charcircuit 4y agoThey still haven't finished shipping all of the orders from 2019. It's practically a scam. They still are trying to trick people into buying this outdated hardware. And they don't allow you to get a refund until your spot in the queue comes up (or if you report their business to the government and you get lucky).
- jonsger 4y agoThey do ship continuously, but its pretty slow. The ones who received there Librem 5's in the last days waited some 1270 days (180 weeks). Have a look at https://forums.puri.sm/t/estimate-your-librem-5-shipping/11272/1 https://forums.puri.sm/t/estimate-your-librem-5-shipping/112... that's a better prediction then Purism's 52 weeks...
- amelius 4y ago> They do ship continuously, but its pretty slow. This is what you get for "Assembled in the USA."
- blendergeek 4y agoNo. The ones that have a 1200 day lead time are the normal ones made in China. The "assembled in the USA" ones have a 10-day lead time (and a $2000 price tag).
- femiagbabiaka 4y agoSeeing the celebration from folks on receiving the items they paid for 1200+ days later was uhh, an experience.
- horsawlarway 4y ago3.5 years average wait time is pretty damn bad for a device that has a life span of not much more than 3.5 years. I'd love to try one of their phones, but I can't convince myself to pull the trigger at the price/performance/delay triangle they've settled into.
- _8j50 4y agoI just need the uber app to work, I don't need a smartphone for anything else.
- fsflover 4y agoIt should work on Librem 5 with Waydroid.
- _8j50 4y agoThank you, might just get it then.
- blendergeek 4y agoThe Uber app probably won't work in Waydroid (it requires location and Waydroid doesn't support location yet). If you only need to boom rides, you can do that from the website. I booked an Uber from Firefox on my OnePlus6 running postmarketOS recently and it worked great.
- seba_dos1 4y agoUber works from a browser.
- _8j50 4y agoWill have to try it but it needs good location data else it won't let you book a ride, but if so, game changer for me.
- blendergeek 4y agoI use Uber from the website in a browser and I don't give it location. It works for me.
- Youden 4y agoIs being assembled in the USA a positive thing for security? The USA is the only country I'm aware of for which there's publicly visible evidence of sabotage committed by the state [0]. Wouldn't it be better to be assembled in a friendly country with a better track record? Maybe somewhere in Europe? [0]: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/05/photos-of-an-nsa-upgrade-factory-show-cisco-router-getting-implant/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/05/photos-of-an-nsa...
- fsflover 4y agoIt depends on your threat model. They say China is also spying on everyone they can. Also, it's not just made in USA: it's made on Purism's own factory, so they can ensure that nobody else can tamper with it.
- anonymousnotme 4y agoI thought that I read (not too long after the snowden stuff) that the US government sometimes intercepts parcels of electronic equipment then will tamper with it so that they can spy on the recipient of the equipment. Not sure how librem can prevent that or how one would know. Also, if somebody places an order and US government asks librem to place some spyware on it via a court order (because say that have a phone tap on the individual), would any customers know about it? Now if one can go the factory and pick up it, then that cuts one avenue of attack by the government.
- blendergeek 4y agoPurism has thought of this and offers an "anti-interdiction" service to counter it [0]. This includes tamper evident seals and glitter paint on the screws (for laptops). [0] https://puri.sm/posts/anti-interdiction-services/ https://puri.sm/posts/anti-interdiction-services/
- anonymousnotme 4y agoThank you; good to know that they have that. My assumption would still be that if the intelligence services want access to your private information or communication on the device that they will get it (without it be evident); whether it is a OS zero day or other means. I also read through the link you provided on the anti-interdiction server, it only says laptop. I assume that this has expanded to the phone. (Did not go through the phone order process to find out.) Also, looks like one negotiates via PGP email on what one wants; so that is why I assume that there is no pricing on it.
- forgotmypw17 4y agoThis seems to be much closer to a general-purpose computer than any other smartphone I've seen. For anyone not clicking through to the article, here is the feature list: Secure supply chain centered on made in the USA electronics at Purism’s facility located in the USA Device assembled in the USA Publicly available schematics The Liberm 5 USA is designed for security and privacy rather than for consumerism Hardware isolation of components Bootable from SD card Removable radio modules Replaceable lithium battery Secure cryptographic removable smart card Hardware kill switches put the product owner in full control over device Private and secure operating system, PureOS PureOS is fully open source and auditable for better security and privacy No intrusive mystery proprietary code supporting surveillance and data mining apps or technologies PureOS supports private and secure apps developed with fully auditable source code Purism supports decentralized application developers centered on providing secure apps Security and privacy protection by default Librem 5 USA is supported by secure and private cellular service provided by Librem AweSIM Purism offers anti-interdiction services to ensure devices are not altered in transit Librem 5 USA supports true convergence with PC apps using a lapdock or mouse, keyboard, and monitor
- criddell 4y agoDoes it have a something like Apple’s Secure Enclave to protect cryptographic keys? Are apps strongly isolated? Do you know what the anti-interdiction services are? I’m guessing that the each of the separate components are cryptographically paired so that third parties can’t replace the modem or touchscreen (for example).
- fsflover 4y ago> Do you know what the anti-interdiction services are? https://wp.puri.sm/posts/anti-interdiction-services/ https://wp.puri.sm/posts/anti-interdiction-services/ > Does it have a something like Apple’s Secure Enclave to protect cryptographic keys? Are apps strongly isolated? https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Frequently-Asked-Questions#43-how-secure-is-the-librem-5-compared-to-an-android-phone https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque...
- markus_zhang 4y agoThe price point is daunting. I'll probably switch to Apple. I mean governments are going to track you one way or another, so Apple's tight software policies are good enough. If that's not good enough I'll use an old Nokia phone.
- fsflover 4y agoNon-USA version is a bit cheaper: https://puri.sm/products/librem-5 https://puri.sm/products/librem-5. > I mean governments are going to track you one way or another, so Apple's tight software policies are good enough. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27897975 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27897975
- Endy 4y agoI hate to continue being the lazy end-user on this, but it comes up in my mind every time that Purism or a Librem phone comes up. I don't know how to set it up as an actual phone, and it's expensive for a miniature tablet. I've never seen a thing that says, "do this to get it working on Tracfone". Until there's an easy guide for end-users to interact with so they can use it on a BYOD plan, it's of little value.
- seba_dos1 4y agoWhat kind of guide do you need? I have just put my SIM card into it and it works fine as a phone ever since. I'm certainly a power user though, so maybe I'm missing something obvious.
- blendergeek 4y agoWell, unless your carrier supports 2G calls (in the USA thats just T-Mobile), this phone won't work for you. Some progress is being made on VoLTE but it didn't work for me.
- mfdoom 4y ago[dead]