2 ms·
The EU should be blocked from the greater internet until they can fix their laws to be compatible with an open internet. The fact that it is illegal to link to
by charcircuit 4y ago
The EU should be blocked from the greater internet until they can fix their laws to be compatible with an open internet. The fact that it is illegal to link to third party sites is ridiculous. I much prefer an internet where sites can freely link to other sites and they can freely do analytics to improve their services. Having to get consent has made the web annoying to use because now every site needs to get your consent.
- chrismorgan 4y ago> illegal to link to third party sites It’s not. > now every site needs to get your consent No it doesn’t. You’ve been conned. Look at what they’re trying to get your consent for, and you will find that you would almost always prefer that they not do it.
- charcircuit 4y ago>It's not It is if you are linking to a site hosted in the US because if the browser preloads it you send your IP to a US server which is not allowed. The referenced lawsuit used a <link> tag, but an <a> tag can result it a browser sending a request too. >No it doesn’t It does if they want to follow the law. >and you will find that you would almost always prefer that they not do it I don't mind companies having analytics using data they have collected from me.
- chrismorgan 4y agoAh, I take it you’re referring to the Google Fonts case, then? That’s completely different from linking to a third-party site: that’s loading resources from a third-party site. For a hyperlink, any fetching is user-initiated and you’re obviously not on the hook for that. (The one arguable exception is if you explicitly cause prefetch or prerender on, say, link hover. That would then obviously be on you, because you made it happen.) > It does if they want to flow the law. No, they can just not do it. Simplifying very slightly: they’re trying to get your consent precisely because they don’t have to do it, therefore they’re not allowed to without consent. I would also note that the sort of consent they solicit on public websites is practically always for storing stuff on your machine (ePD, from 2002) rather than for processing (GDPR, from 2016). But I lack energy to get further involved in this aspect; suffice it to say that their tracking is basically never in your interests at all, and routinely not even in their direct interests.
- charcircuit 4y ago>that’s loading resources from a third-party site Which is what browsers can do for link tags. Some browser scan for links on pages and speculatively load them so that if you were to click on them it loads instantly. You as the website author can't prevent this functionality. >No, they can just not do it But they want to do it and may have business reasons to do it. >their tracking is basically never in your interests at all The tracking likely either improves the service based off analytics which is in my interest or it makes ads more relevant which makes the site more financially viable which is also in my interest if I am gaining value from that site.
- chrismorgan 4y ago> Some browser scan for links on pages and speculatively load them so that if you were to click on them it loads instantly. Anything like that is user (the browser acting as their agent). You’re obviously not responsible for that. You didn’t ask it to do that automatically, unlike <link rel="stylesheet"> and <script> and the likes.
- charcircuit 4y agoHow is the link tag any different? It's also a link which is optional to access. One's user agent could choose not to request it. script tags are optional too.
- chrismorgan 4y agoThey’re radically different. Things like <link rel="stylesheet">, <script> and <img> are subresources: instructions to the browser to fetch and use the specified resource, so that the page can be rendered properly. As you say, the user agent can choose to ignore these instructions (and text-mode browsers will generally ignore all three of these subresource types), but the page will probably be materially compromised, and the developer placed the subresource there with the expectation that it will be loaded. A hyperlink is a reference to another page altogether, that it’s up to the user to access if they choose to. It’s not a subresource.
- derefr 4y ago> Having to get consent has made the web annoying to use because now every site needs to get your consent. I don't understand why it wasn't immediately obvious to browser vendors that this was going to be how web developers responded to GDPR; and that the browser vendors could/should get ahead of this degradation of the quality of the web-browsing experience by giving the user a way to do GDPR consent at the browser-chrome level by e.g. ticking a box in the browser preferences that will set a request header. (It didn't work for Do Not Track, but Do Not Track is a "request" to a malicious adversary; while "I consent to cookies, so stop prompting me" isn't.) I can only guess that browser vendors don't like GDPR, and so are avoiding implementing such a GDPR quality-of-life feature in order to ensure that users get just as annoyed by the cookie prompts as they should be, and eventually demand the law be changed.
- dustyharddrive 4y agoI don’t think we should give fingerprinting scripts another bit of entropy.
- derefr 4y agoBrowser vendors seem to think it's perfectly fine to add a bunch of new "low-entropy" Client-Hint request headers. Where the difference between high- vs low-entropy seems to be literal: if the header is just one bit, then the browser vendors don't consider it to be a problem for deanonymization purposes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]