5 ms·
Not supported by neuroimaging. Promoted without evidence or sufficient causal inference. https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/right-brainleft-brain-right-201708
by westurner 4y ago
Not supported by neuroimaging. Promoted without evidence or sufficient causal inference.
https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/right-brainleft-brain-right-2017082512222 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/right-brainleft-brain-ri... :
> But, the evidence discounting the left/right brain concept is accumulating. According to a 2013 study from the University of Utah, brain scans demonstrate that activity is similar on both sides of the brain regardless of one's personality.
> They looked at the brain scans of more than 1,000 young people between the ages of 7 and 29 and divided different areas of the brain into 7,000 regions to determine whether one side of the brain was more active or connected than the other side. No evidence of "sidedness" was found. The authors concluded that the notion of some people being more left-brained or right-brained is more a figure of speech than an anatomically accurate description.
Here's wikipedia on the topic: "Lateralization of brain function" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lateralization_of_brain_function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lateralization_of_brain_functi...
Furthermore, "Neuropsychoanalysis" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuropsychoanalysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuropsychoanalysis
Neuropsychology: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuropsychology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuropsychology
Personality psychology > ~Biophysiological: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personality_psychology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personality_psychology
MBTI > Criticism:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myers%E2%80%93Briggs_Type_Indicator#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myers%E2%80%93Briggs_Type_Indi...
Connectome: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connectome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connectome
- haldujai 4y agoAgree I'm not a neuro subspecialist but I've listened to some talks at conferences out of interest and I don't think anyone still believes in this anymore. Anecdotally the few fMRI's I reported as a trainee didn't support this either.
- jorgeortiz85 4y agoYou are talking about the popular narrative of “left brain” thinking being more logical and “right brain” thinking being more creative. You are correct this is unsupported. The post you are replying to is talking about the small subset of individuals who have had their corpus callosum surgically severed, which makes it much more difficult for the brain to send messages between hemispheres. These patients exhibit “split brain” behavior that is well studied by experiments and can shed light into human consciousness and rationality.
- mcguire 4y agoYour response doesn't seem to be directly related to the previous poster's split-brain comments, but rather the popular misuse of the lateralization idea.
- ethanbond 4y agoThis is not relevant to GP's comment. It has nothing to do with "are there fixed 'themes' that are operated in each hemisphere." It has to do with more generally, does the brain know what the brain is doing. The answer so far does not seem to be "yes."
- haldujai 4y agoSays who? There is actual evidence to support that our brain doesn't "know" what it is doing on a subconscious level? As far as I'm aware it's more that conscious humans don't understand how our brain works. I think the correct statement is "so far the answer is we don't know"
- ethanbond 4y agoThe split brain experiments very very clearly indicate that different parts of the brain can independently conduct behavior and gain knowledge independently of other parts. How or if this generalizes to healthy brains is not super clear, but it does actually provide a good explanatory model for all sorts of self-contradictory behavior (like addiction): the brain has many semi-independent “interests” that are jockeying for overall control of the organism’s behavior. These interests can be fully contradictory to each other. Correct, ultimately we do not know. But it’s actually a different question than your rephrasing.
- westurner 4y agoGiven that functional localization varies widely from subject to subject per modern neuroimaging, how are split brain experiments more than crude attempts to confirm functional specialization (which is already confirmed without traumatically severing a corpus callosum) "hemispheric" or "lateral"? Neuroimaging indicates high levels of redundancy and variance in spatiotemporal activation. Studies of cortices and other tissues have already shown that much of the neural tissue of the brain is general purpose. Why is executive functioning significantly but not exclusively in the tissue of the forebrain, the frontal lobes?