6 ms·
Mechanical backpack boosts the sensation of jumping in virtual reality
- kleiba 4y agoHands up, who's using VR on a regular basis, and what for? (just out of curiosity)
- rft 4y agoMy usage of VR comes and goes over time, often based on some trigger like an update to a VR game or a friend pulling me into a new game. This also describes my usage of VR: gaming. I enjoy playing Beat Saber, Until You Fall and Pistol Whip. A friend pulled me into After The Fall for a bit and it was also great. I also tried other things, but gaming, and especially the first three games, are what I come back to at least semi-regularly. Hardware: Valve Index on a Linux desktop with RTX 3080
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoThere was at least one person who did his day job as a software developer in VR, and has done for a long time. I couldn't do it myself, I have trouble reading anything in VR.
- rrdharan 4y agoYou’re probably talking about this guy: https://medium.com/immersedteam/working-from-orbit-39bf95a6d385 https://medium.com/immersedteam/working-from-orbit-39bf95a6d... I read this every few months for a certain kind of amusement. I remain utterly unconvinced of any merits…
- ohlookcake 4y agoUsing it 4 times a week with fitness apps for cardio. I prefer running but VR fitness is fantastic for when it's too cold to go out running
- qumpis 4y agoFor what kinds of exercises? Does your headset support seeing your surroundings while you exercise, or do you do static sports (treadmill, indoor bicycle)?
- yourusername 4y agoI'm not the OP but i play Thrill of the fight (boxing simulator). For anyone that thinks videogames can't be excercise i suggest you try to do 3 fights in a row on endurance in ToTF.
- blensor 4y agoMixed reality really can add value to the workout. I even prefer the open design of the Quest Pro over using it with the face guard
- blensor 4y agosame for me. Nearly daily for fitness. Although I do have a reason since we are developing our own game VRWorkout (hand tracking based full body exercises and mixed reality for safety), I still get a regular crowd of people joining me in our multiplayer workouts
- phh 4y agoI like it quite a lot for gaming as it's much more immersive than PC gaming (I don't have any other gaming console). I play both wire-free on Oculus Quest 2 itself, or (still wire-free) from a Windows VM with a RTX3070 pcie passthrough (so I can dynamically switch between ML and gaming usage). Immersive-ness doesn't only come from just the screen, but also from the fact that you can't multi-task (one could say this is a sad state of my attention). I play various kind of games. My main usage is "sport", with synthriders and beat saber. I love story telling/puzzle games, though they are quite costly (like 30€ for 4 hours of game play) so that doesn't account for a lot of play time. But I also like a small Cities Skyline (Cities: VR by the people from Cities Skyline), Deisim where you play a god, and Derail Valley, where you drive a train in a miniature world. As a software engineer I have tried using it for other stuff than gaming, but even though it feels cool, I never found it actually useful. I can keep the headset 4 hours (and probably the whole day) without any issue (assuming no frame drop, which do happen when running from Windows, not in the Quest environment), so that's not the issue. Maybe with a better display resolution it could be better, but honestly I doubt it. Just a word on the metaverse: I do think it can be pretty cool for socializing (Ready Player One is IMO not that far-fetched), though Meta's universe development still looks extremely primitive compared to everything else that exists. At this point, I think that a Meta Quest 3 with face emotion detection (and improved SoC and display compared to Quest 2), and let competing companies provide a good environment based on that hardware+OS (for instance Rec Room) would be pretty good, but I doubt that could follow Meta's bottom line.
- phh 4y agoAn addition after seeing a sibling comment: It's more annoying to setup, but I also like playing Euro Truck Simulator 2 in VR with a 1080 wheel. As someone who doesn't have a driving license, that makes me see why some people like to drive to clear their mind.
- fauxpause_ 4y agoI find it pretty crazy to see the current state of VR and conclude Ready Player One is not far off. We are nowhere close.
- 4y ago
- ggambetta 4y agoI have a Quest 2, which I use to play Pavlov Shack, on the Hagenau map, in Tank TDM mode, and nothing else.
- dreen 4y agoI use it for an occasional relaxing evening in a flight simulator, usually with a pop-in window with a tv show or another simpler game like chess.
- ChicagoBoy11 4y agoI am really hoping for micro-LED devices to reach the market soon. My favorite thing to do with my Vive Pro was night flights in flight simulator... then got an Index, which is far superior in every way, but the lack of deep, deep blacks just really doesn't make those night flights feel how they used to!
- TylerE 4y agoI upgraded my TV recently to a high end OLED (Samsung S95B) and it's been a revelation. Watching good transfers in 4K of old black and white stuff is jawdropping. Truly filmic. Those inky blacks are a huge part of that (plus HDR, so you can have a few bright spots, like, say, streetlights, without all the midtones being crushed to gray.
- Frost1x 4y agoI think a lot more people use VR than they realize, the goal post just continually moves towards higher degrees of immersion. Most people use some map navigation system these days in their phones as well as all sorts of other info they access related to spatial information on their phones anymore. VR to many increasingly means full on HMDs, haptics, and full on sensory immersion. People tend to only use parts of these from sounds to visuals at a time because when used in conjunction, current degrees of shortcomings make the experiences less than ideal. I use a lot of VR aspects regularly in general data exploration, though I tend not to need so much in the form of HMD and stereoscopic rendering. Usually something semi-immersive visually gets me most of what I want. To me, the science and engineering for most the hardware just isn't there yet to make a fully enjoyable experience but I think that means we should continue pushing on those developments because someday they will be and highly immersive VR will be fantastic (and perhaps dystopian depending on how it's used).
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Most people use some map navigation system these days in their phones as well as all sorts of other info they access related to spatial information on their phones anymore. That's certainly cool, but I don't think most folks would call it VR. Not even 10-20 years ago.
- bemmu 4y agoEvery other week to play a round of Echo VR, do VRChat and check out what’s new in the store (but then not buy anything as everything feels too expensive). Used to play almost every night when I got Cosmodread, but managed to complete it.
- ChicagoBoy11 4y agoI use it for sim racing just about every other day at home. It is, by far and away, the most compelling gaming experience I've ever had. Having race high-end karts before, it is closer to the "real" feeling than I could've ever imagined -- certainly not in terms of the danger and things like that, but with high-end peripherals the driving experience, sense of competition, and mental effort required mirror it perfectly. Truly a steal at many times the cost if that's your sort of thing. I also got my pilot's license a few years ago after developing a love of flying from the Microsoft Flight Sim 95 era and beyond. In VR, while I've never had the "full controls," in higher-end aircraft software I could very accurately (literally to just about 100%) recreate my IRL flights with the exception of the feel of the yoke and whatnot. Again, awesome gaming experience. Lastly, I've played quite a bit of poker in PokerstarsVR. The thing that surprises me the most about THOSE experiences is that this attempt to create a pretty simple and at first-glance unexciting experience in VR to me revealed just how incredible VR actually CAN be. Like, yes, I get the value-add that the videogame can have for something like flying an airliner or a formula car, but wouldn't you always rather play poker with your friends IRL? Well, to me, VR showed me that that answer is a resounding 'no.' IRL poker is slow (just from shuffling and dealing, to say nothing of folks fumbling with chips), if you play poker well you'll be sitting out a lot of hands, so that can get boring, etc. In VR, however, I could see many, many more hands/hr, I could pin a TV to the virtual room and watch whatever I wanted as I'm talking with folks all over the world, could engage in side-games with the person next to me if I wasn't in a hand, etc. Just... unbelievably compelling. It made me a believer that I could EASILY see how in the near future even if I had 8 friends at home who really wanted to play poker, that I'd rather have each of us reaching out for our personal VR devices to do that in rather than reaching for a deck of cards.
- mejutoco 4y agoCould you share what sim racing you prefer?
- ChicagoBoy11 4y agoto me, it's hard to beat iRacing in terms of the quality of the matchmaking and sheer density of available heats. The fact that you constantly find elite level IRL drivers on it I think is a nice endorsement that the overall experience is pretty good. It certainly can leave you wanting in terms of visual niceties and things of the sort, but from a pure racing experience, I think it is hard to beat. Is expensive at first, though :-(
- asynchronous 4y agoGaming, Half Life ALYX is the best experience I’ve had in a video game (using Index) hands down, across all my years of gaming.
- andybak 4y agoYes. I work on https://openbrush.app/ https://openbrush.app/ almost every day. Currently building a realtime scripting API for it: https://docs.openbrush.app/alternate-and-experimental-builds/runtime-scripting https://docs.openbrush.app/alternate-and-experimental-builds...
- vlunkr 4y agoI was for gaming, but dropped off pretty hard after a couple of months and went back to other consoles. It's just my personal tastes, but there are tons of games I want to play that don't make me sick or require that I put something on my face (or a mechanical backpack now lol).
- Arrath 4y agoSeveral times a week for me, primarily Beat Saber and VTOL VR (the best flight sim out there, imo)
- GenerocUsername 4y agoWow. Looks terrible
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- birdyrooster 4y agoYeah the timing is horrendously off and it’s essentially just a piece of metal sliding back and forth poorly in time on someone’s back. It’s examples like this that help me to realize that some ideas are just for the theater of innovation and are quite poor examples of utility. They are obviously not doing anything useful with their time but they were so oblivious to it they posted this piece on it. I don’t want that to happen to me. This post is a warning to all of us.
- birdyrooster 4y agoI don’t know why I was so cynical here but it’s still kinda true. Sorry lol.
- Animats 4y agoFrom decades ago, the last try at this idea: The Aura Interactor backpack-mounted subwoofer.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aura_Interactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aura_Interactor
- fardo 4y agoI’m glad to see work like this. Haptic interactions in general always felt like the weak point in VR applications. I’ve always found it incredibly uncanny navigating through 3D environments in VR without any kind of force feedback, or any sensation of weight or touch.
- KineticLensman 4y ago> Haptic interactions in general always felt like the weak point in VR applications It's a big weakness of proposed VR applications for training, e.g. for any manual skill where lifting and manipulating (heavy) objects is important, or different materials have very different mechanical properties. E.g. training paramedics where moving patients is important and where skin, fat, bone, muscle, etc have different 'feels'.
- rabf 4y agoRelated work that will be opensourced: https://exitsuit.com/ https://exitsuit.com/
- romusha 4y ago[flagged]
- ikekkdcjkfke 4y agoScrew metaverse and VR, we want exoskeletons!
- euroderf 4y agowith throwable nukes! Heinlein would dig it.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoA giant helmet, a backpack, gloves... You're going to need a full suit to appreciate VR in full. Rather a large barrier to entry.
- causi 4y agoor landing harder Is that a thing people want? It seems to me when I jump in a VR headset the feeling of jumping is just as intense as it needs to me. Walking in VR is such an enormously more pressing issue.
- jschveibinz 4y agoWell, then you need to check these out! https://ektovr.com/ https://ektovr.com/
- causi 4y agoWoof, lot of red flags on that page. Promo images have 3D-printed parts, the boots have totally pointless LED mood lighting the user can't even see with a headset on, and the only video on the page shows the boots not functioning for the core feature of letting you walk without moving. Also the demo has the guy shambling like an ASIMO robot.
- mrguyorama 4y agoI agree. They also claim "lightweight" but give no numbers. Looks like they spent more on the web page than on product development. It also doesn't even have integrated tracking (see the vive trackers)
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- mywacaday 4y agoVR needs to be combined with this https://youtu.be/gSDtNkKPiDg https://youtu.be/gSDtNkKPiDg.
- blensor 4y agoNot exactly the same but going in the same direction: https://youtu.be/DeLgSDb-Bww https://youtu.be/DeLgSDb-Bww And yes, it was a lot more fun than I should admit
- fauxpause_ 4y agoI’ve always thought a suit or even just patches with tubes that could inflate to apply pressure could work.
- babel_ 4y agoI saw this presented at CHI, and I think it's a ingenious and elegant sensory illusion that could make jumping in certain VR games actually feel immersive with haptic feedback and the ability to more closely match the height the avatar jumps to the perceived sense of physically jumping. Very neat. Of course, the funny thing is humans don't jump in real life anywhere near as much as they do in video games, and this has seemingly affected VR with few having purpose-built jumping mechanics (and many just using a button press instead), so maybe things like this closes the gap somewhat and make it something explored more in design. On another note, there was another presentation by what I believe was the same research group, which was haptic feedback on the hands without covering the palm or underside of the fingers (and non-invasively). That was a particularly interesting, as the XR possibilities actually open up when you don't have bulky gloves covering that highly sensitive region (palm, finger tips, etc), and instead only have electrodes on the back of the hand, meaning you can overlap the sensations without damping by gloves. And this is not just for VR stuff (though they showed things like climbing in VR), but with AR/XR utility too! Need to do precise soldering work? This would let you have the full physical feedback, and then overlay it with helpful haptic feedback so you get nudged towards the right area and then don't stray (so you don't accidentally knock something off, perhaps). So this would be actually useful XR without any headset. Given the bulky setups that existing approaches use, I found it surprising this wasn't covered in the article, especially as part of a "here's other stuff the research group is working on for VR/XR" shortlist.
- thomastjeffery 4y ago> On another note, there was another presentation by what I believe was the same research group, which was haptic feedback on the hands without covering the palm or underside of the fingers (and non-invasively). Got a link? That's definitely interesting.
- _vk_ 4y agoI believe this is it: https://spectrum.ieee.org/finger-haptics https://spectrum.ieee.org/finger-haptics >This method depends on what’s called “referred sensation,” where stimulation of your body in one place gets felt in another place—it’s like when you accidentally bash your elbow against something but can feel tingling up through your fingers, because the signal has traveled along your nerves up through your hand. In some places, including in the fingers, referred sensation can be targeted with a reasonable amount of precision. With a signal electrode on the top of a finger and a ground electrode closer to the wrist, it’s possible to stimulate individual parts of each finger, creating 11 separately controllable tactile zones across five fingers and the palm. >However, just zapping fingers doesn’t provide a way of getting those signals to show up just on the bottom (palmar) side of the fingers, rather than the top (dorsal) side, which is where the signal is originating. Fortunately, the asymmetrical way that the nerves in our hands are set up makes this possible. The backhanded stimulation technique works because your palm and finger pads are way, way more sensitive than the backs of your hands, thanks to about 60 times more mechanoreceptors on the palmar side. So, if you use an electrode to stimulate the back of one of your fingers, the sensitivity on the front is so much higher that you’re going to feel it there much more strongly, even though the electrode is in direct contact with the back side. The researchers were able to find a stimulation intensity that was enough to trigger nerves on the finger pads, while staying below the detection threshold on the back side of the fingers, neatly solving the problem.
- ChatGTP 4y agoWhat about just going outside and doing something?
- dylan604 4y agoIn a couple of weeks, going outside where I am located means it will be 100°+ with a high humidity level, so no, I won't be going outside and doing something.
- ChatGTP 4y agoDo you live on Venus or something ?
- huehehue 4y agoThere are hundreds of cities in the US alone that could fit this profile: https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/monitoring/monthly-report/national/202208/supplemental/page-6 https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/monitoring/monthly-report/n... Regardless, just because "outside" is available doesn't mean we can't have things inside as well. Going a bit further, AR was getting people outside en masse during the Pokemon GO craze, so these two things are in no way antithetical.
- dylan604 4y ago>during the Pokemon GO craze, and what are people doing now that this fad is over?