9 ms·
James Webb Space Telescope reveals Fomalhaut's disk in detail
- ftxbro 4y agoalternate headline: webb looks at star known to have debris disks and suspected planets, hoping to confirm at least one planet but isn't able to confirm any of them
- jp42 4y agoIf JWST can do these amazing discoveries and detailed images, I wonder what kind of discoveries we make when starship can launch way bigger telescope than JWST. Future is Awesome!
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoBigger is one option, but more of them is another; combining the data from multiple telescopes at, say, 10km apart effectively turns them into a telescope with a 10km diameter (see e.g. the event horizon telescope that made the first image of a black hole: https://eventhorizontelescope.org/ https://eventhorizontelescope.org/ )
- rqtwteye 4y agoYou get the resolution but not the light capturing capability of a big telescope. The event horizon telescope had to do a lot of machine learning trickery to get an image. Also, as far I understand, it's much more difficult to do this at the wavelength of visible light.
- PopePompus 4y agoThe EHT has used machine learning techniques, but those were not required to get an image that shows the shadow of the black hole. Just using the "clean" algorithm for deconvolution yielded an image showing the shadow, and that algorithm has been in use for radio interferometry for over 40 years, and has nothing whatsoever to do with machine learning.
- rqtwteye 4y agoI watched a presentation by a researcher that worked on the EHT. She pointed out that there was a lot of machine learning to rule out wrong pictures. It’s not simple interferometry.
- PopePompus 4y agoI am also a member of the EHT project. I'm not saying no machine learning was used by EHT team members. I'm saying that you can process the 2017 EHT data using standard radio interferometry techniques, and get an image showing the M87 black hole shadow without machine learning or any other type of AI
- digging 4y agoManufacturing the JWST was already extremely challenging. Not saying we can't do bigger, but payload size isn't the only limiting factor.
- sebzim4500 4y agoManufacturing the JWST would be a lot easier if it weren't for the mass/volume constraints.
- digging 4y agoPerhaps, because of all the moving parts. How big is Starship though? I don't expect a telescope bigger than JWST could go up completely unfolded and expect to be perfectly resilient to launch forces. In addition, even if we had the option of a solid mirror, manufacturing such a massive mirror to perfect smoothness would be a feat. Piecemeal mirrors are probably easier in some ways because if one section is flawed, it can be replaced.
- cubefox 4y agoA Google search reveals: Starship has an 8 meter internal diameter. The Hubble mirror was 2.4 meters. The largest ground telescopes with a single mirror are somewhat over 8 meters in diameter. Though these don't have to withstand a rocket launch. JWST has a 6.5 meter segmented mirror with 1.3 meter per segment. It was folded up to fit into the Ariane 5 fairing.
- jakear 4y agoAnyone know what the black blob in the center is? It's conspicuously left out of the labeled diagram, and doesn't seem mentioned in the article either. I imagine it's the central sun in question, but isn't it odd to never mention it?
- btilly 4y agoThat's the coronagraph that blocks out the star itself so that everything else is visible. https://blogs.nasa.gov/webb/2023/03/24/how-webbs-coronagraphs-reveal-exoplanets-in-the-infrared/ https://blogs.nasa.gov/webb/2023/03/24/how-webbs-coronagraph...
- hn8305823 4y agoThere has been a lot of confusion about this but it is actually overexposed pixels deleted in software. From the lead author of the paper: https://twitter.com/AndrasGaspar/status/1655680076103716878 https://twitter.com/AndrasGaspar/status/1655680076103716878
- dylan604 4y agoBlack Hole Sun? There was a camera that "suffered" this problem, but can't remember the model to look it up.
- jmount 4y agoFilm in general used to "solarize" in some situations, which would turn some over-exposed areas black.
- dylan604 4y agoMaybe, but there was a specific video camera that would do this which earned the black hole sun moniker that I was thinking of. I want to say it was in the DV era, but I was never a connoisseur of that format so it was all just fuzzy memory from hearing/reading about it. I do remember looking at DV shooters with side-eye jealousy at their tiny camcorders while I was heaving full sized broadcast cameras on my shoulder.
- samstave 4y agoWhat does the F2300C and F2550W mean? Focal length?
- dekhn 4y agoThey are "mask" which only allow some wavelengths so you can see different structure. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coronagraph https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coronagraph
- xioxox 4y agoThey are the filters used in the observation. Telescopes use filters to select a range of light wavelength/frequency to be observed. See http://svo2.cab.inta-csic.es/svo/theory/fps3/index.php?id=JWST/MIRI.F2550W&&mode=browse&gname=JWST&gname2=MIRI http://svo2.cab.inta-csic.es/svo/theory/fps3/index.php?id=JW... to see their properties.
- dekhn 4y agothat's just stunning
- jansan 4y agoThe most stunning and accessible comparison between Hubble and James Webb for me is still the pillars of creation images. A few weeks ago I was in the planetarium at the U.S. Space & Rocket Center in Huntsville where they faded from the Hubble image into the James Webb image. That was truly a sight to behold. In general the presentation there was one of the best I have ever seen. Edit: I think this video is exactly what they showed. Of course, in this case the bigger your monitor the better. https://youtu.be/f8q8ZIXf_Rw?t=67 https://youtu.be/f8q8ZIXf_Rw?t=67
- danparsonson 4y agoThat is wonderful - all those stars! Oh for a warp-capable spaceship and a lifetime to explore.
- tambourine_man 4y agoAs a layman I get the feeling that JWST is showing us more detailed things we'd already seen than brand new ones. I remember being moved by the Hubble deep field, where a long exposure revealed that what looked like an empty patch of the sky was anything but. Are we reaching the point of diminishing returns of what a reasonably sized (for our current rockets) space telescope can see?
- soulofmischief 4y agoJWST is an infrared scope of a magnitude never before employed. Astronomy is more about collecting data than anything else, pretty images are a welcome side-effect. JWST will be extremely beneficial for deep-space exploration. It's worth reading about!
- digging 4y ago> Are we reaching the point of diminishing returns of what a reasonably sized (for our current rockets) space telescope can see? No, not as far as I know (also a layperson). It's just that we've already seen the incredible leap of "there's nothing here" -> "there's things here". The JWST is still a massive leap in capabilities, but you aren't going to be as impressed at seeing intricate structures inside a galaxy that once appeared smooth. The JWST is truly a new era of exploring the early universe, but it might not have the same "wow" factor.
- potamic 4y agoThey did discover several galaxies beyond redshift 11 that Hubble cannot see. I'm not in the field, but venturing a guess here that they might want to prioritise getting images of known objects first, because there must be so much active research that can immediately benefit from the new detail. Over time I hope they will dedicate time for some wild hunches like Hubble did and open up something yet unknown.
- hn8305823 4y agoThe Hubble deep fields take many days/weeks/months of exposure time. The deep fields released from JWST so far have been just hours long... There are a lot of different proposals being rapidly shot in these early year(s) of the telescope. Later on there will certainly be longer exposures.
- thangalin 4y agoYears ago, for my Impacts Project, a scientific illustrator created a similar image (page 7): https://impacts.to/downloads/lowres/impacts.pdf#page=7 https://impacts.to/downloads/lowres/impacts.pdf#page=7 The middle of the disc has our star having burned away everything close by, leaving an empty area behind, which the JWST cannot show because of the blindingly bright star. Each of the rings in the illustration represents paths for our rocky planets (yet to have fully formed).
- isoprophlex 4y agoIncredible, my kids will love this..! Thanks!
- thangalin 4y agoThanks! The illustrators did an incredible job and the physical book itself is in lay flat format. https://impacts.to/ https://impacts.to/ Here's the book's bibliography, in case you're wondering about the science: https://impacts.to/bibliography.pdf https://impacts.to/bibliography.pdf
- sph 4y agoCare to name your illustrators? I love the work they have done. EDIT: nevermind, they are listed here: https://impacts.to/credit.html https://impacts.to/credit.html
- joshmarinacci 4y agoWhat is this project? It looks amazing. Will it be a printed book?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- NoMoreNicksLeft 4y agoI feel cheated... I glance at the image, see that bulge in the ring and was immediately excited that they had captured the visual image of an exoplanet (even if it was going to be a large brown dwarf). Nope, just something behind the ring.
- Synaesthesia 4y agoA visual of an exoplanet is still beyond the possibility of anything but a REALLY big telescope (100m)+
- hotshot1001 4y agoActually we've imaged many exoplanets, but typically ones that are much larger than Jupiter. Here's a famous system: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HR_8799 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HR_8799
- NoMoreNicksLeft 4y agoThank you for the link, it's wonderful.
- Synaesthesia 4y agoThey were able to detect the planet due to the observed orbital motion on the star, not that they were able to get an image of the planet itself.
- Vox_Leone 4y ago>I glance at the image, see that bulge in the ring and was immediately excited that they had captured the visual image of an exoplanet (even if it was going to be a large brown dwarf). I was under the same impression. Upon a second look it became clear that blob is roughly 8 AU in diameter [judging by the overall scale]
- NoMoreNicksLeft 4y agoI'm not sure that an 8AU diameter would be that absurd, if we're talking about a proto-planetary nebula, would it? But yeh, if I weren't a nitwit, the scale's completely wrong (and it should be hoovering up the ring in short order besides).
- krisoft 4y ago> The outer ring is about 240 astronomical units in diameter. That is huge. Just reference for those who don't feel "astronomical units": One astronomical unit (AU) is (roughly) the Earth-Sun distance. Distances to compare with: Pluto is ~39 AU away from the sun. Voyager 1, the furthest probe of humanity right now, is ~160 AU away from the sun. So in other words: that is mind-bogglingly large. (If you want to read more about astronomical units: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Astronomical_unit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Astronomical_unit )
- mwcremer 4y agoComparing diameter to radius is a little misleading, the ring is actually closer than Voyager, at 120 AU. On the same scale, Pluto is 78 AU and Voyager is 320 AU.
- krisoft 4y ago> Comparing diameter to radius is a little misleading Nah. It is comparing a distance with a distance. Besides I assume more people reading my comment are familiar with the concepts of radius/diameter than the meaning of astronomical units. But now, thanks for your clarification, even the geometrically challenged will have the correct mental model. You never know. > On the same scale, Pluto is 78 AU and Voyager is 320 AU. Have to disagree. You take your pocket tape measure, carefully hook the end of the tape on the Sun and slowly walk to Pluto. You read what it says. That is a distance. Then you walk to the disk, hook one end of the tape on one side (carefully, since it is made of dust) and walk to the other side. That is a distance. Where do I hook my tape measure to measure 78 AU for Pluto? Orbits are not real. You cannot kick them, you cannot lick them, you cannot hook a tape measure on them. “See where that planet is? Now imagine how far it will be in 124[1] years in a sun fixed coordinate system!” does not quite have the same impact on me as “See that blob? It is huuuge!” Doubling the number with Voyager makes even less sense. You cannot even say that you are measuring the antipodal points of its orbit, since it is not orbiting the Sun. So the “diameter” of what are you even talking about there? 1: half of Pluto’s orbital period.
- 4y ago
- pfdietz 4y agoJust think what space telescopes will be like if the Starship reduces cost/kg to orbit to 1/10th or less of Falcon 9's already low cost. They'd get very big, and it would likely make sense to assemble and maintain them in space by workers in space suits. It might even make sense to have telescopes in high Earth orbit with a maintenance station located nearby.
- dekhn 4y agothe cost of launching a scope is not the bottleneck.
- pfdietz 4y agoHigh cost of launch prevents economical repair (especially in high orbits), which requires extreme reliability. It also creates incentive for extreme weight reduction. Both these drive up the cost of a satellite. At low launch cost, there's no reason a space telescope should be much more expensive than a terrestrial telescope of the same size.
- dekhn 4y agoDo you work in the field of space? I don't mean to be dismissive but claiming that space telescopes cost about the same as terrestrial scopes if you subtract out the launch costs and can maintain them with crews, isn't really consistent with what I've heard from space telescope astronomers.
- spenczar5 4y agoNo, that goes way too far. Radiation hardening and heat dissipation are really difficult problems that remain for any space telescopes. (I'm at the University of Washington Department of Astronomy, and work on telescope software).
- pfdietz 4y agoWith sufficiently cheap launch, you get radiation hardening with shielding. The goal is to use off the shelf hardware as much as you can. If things break, that's why we have servicing, just like on terrestrial telescopes.
- isoprophlex 4y agoInteresting comment below the linked article: > Lots of asymmetries involved. The star is off-center toward the lower right, same direction as the partial arc. The major ring could be elliptical, rather than circular. It also varies in brightness around the circumference. I'm a complete layman, but could this explain the high deviation from circular orbits of our own outer planets? IIRC this was something of an unexplained issue?
- timdellinger 4y agoA side-by-side before-and-after with the "previously best" image to compare against the new image would be great to see.
- Synaesthesia 4y agoHere's on which is a composite of the ALMA (millimetre wave telescope) superimposed with Hubble (in blue) https://www.centauri-dreams.org/2017/05/22/best-images-yet-of-fomalhaut-debris-disk/ https://www.centauri-dreams.org/2017/05/22/best-images-yet-o... Here's just that ALMA pic https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:ALMA_Explores_Fomalhaut’s_Debris_Disc.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:ALMA_Explores_Fomalh...
- jl6 4y agoIf I may take advantage of the presence of knowledgable people in this thread… The JWST is located at the L2 point. Does that mean L2 is now “taken”, or could it make sense to host multiple telescopes and spacecraft at or near that point?
- mnw21cam 4y agoThere's already multiple telescopes there, including the Gaia telescope. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_objects_at_Lagrange_points https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_objects_at_Lagrange_po...
- itishappy 4y agoIn short, it orbits the L2 point. There's plenty of room for more! Here's a 20s YouTube video that should clear things right up: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6cUe4oMk69E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6cUe4oMk69E Here's an article with additional info: https://webb.nasa.gov/content/about/orbit.htm https://webb.nasa.gov/content/about/orbit.htm
- 7373737373 4y agoAs I understand it, it's more of a region around that point in space that spacecraft try to stay close to/within
- causi 4y agoIt reveals an inner belt, akin to the solar system's asteroid belt but dustier and more extended; an intermediate belt; and a previously imaged outer belt that's analogous to our Kuiper Belt. How could something analogous to our Kuiper belt possibly reflect/emit enough light to be visible as a cloudy ring? There is no way it isn't orders of magnitude more massive than the Kuiper belt.
- cl42 4y agoI was going to ask the same thing -- maybe someone more astronomically inclined has an answer to this... If one were to take a phot of our solar system, would our asteroid belt really be dense enough to show up in any wavelengths?
- causi 4y agoThe most likely explanation to me is that the author is just wrong in describing it that way and it's a much more massive debris disc slash protoplanetary disc.
- bbojan 4y agoMaybe because it's still gas and dust, whereas if the same mass coalesces into large objects it's much less reflective?
- danparsonson 4y agoAt a guess - very long exposure times. Even if it's only sending one photon per second in our direction, if we stare at it long enough then eventually we'll have an image.
- eimrine 4y agoAre there any previous images of the same object from a superexpencive telescops of previous generations to compare James Webb's advance from other telescops?
- coldpie 4y agoWikipedia has a number: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fomalhaut https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fomalhaut Hubble: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:NASA%27s_Hubble_Reveals_Rogue_Planetary_Orbit_For_Fomalhaut_B.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:NASA%27s_Hubble_Reveals_R... ALMA: https://www.eso.org/public/images/eso1216a/ https://www.eso.org/public/images/eso1216a/
- Haga 4y ago[dead]
- casenmgreen 4y agoCan't view. Stuck in the Cloudflare verification loop.
- quakeguy 4y agoIt’s a brave new web.
- platz 4y agoMaybe there's a Ruined Portal there
- anonymousiam 4y agoI don't understand the use of "ruined" in the NYT headline. I guess they don't understand that this is a very young star, and it's likely that our own sun had similar rings before they coalesced into planets.
- whatshisface 4y ago>The intermediate belt is also where exoplanet hunters once thought they had seen a world they named Fomalhaut b. But in 2020, Dr. Gaspar and his colleagues proposed that what other scientists had once thought was an intact exoplanet was actually an expanding cloud of debris created by an epic collision. A problem with this idea was that this part of space looked vacant, so it seemed unlikely that two objects had managed to crash into each other. The team’s discovery of the intermediate debris belt has now proffered a solution. “We now know there’s stuff there,” Dr. Christiansen of the NASA archive said. “OK, so it’s a collision — we can finally put that to bed.” Cataclysmic melees are not just transpiring close to the star. What looks like a vast maelstrom of dust within the outer belt may be the ghost of another gargantuan impact. “That’s just cool,” Dr. Christensen said. “What is it? It’s very tantalizing.”
- ph0rque 4y ago"... She eats and wipes her mouth and says, ‘I’ve done nothing wrong.’"
- frob 4y agoWho is the adulterous woman here? Edit: the above quote is from NASB Proverbs 30:20. This is the way of an adulterous woman: She eats and wipes her mouth, And says, “I have done no wrong.”
- ph0rque 4y agoNot adulterous per se, but planetivorous perhaps. Just seems wrong to eat your planets...
- 10g1k 4y agoI've read this book, and it doesn't end well for humans.
- vrglvrglvrgl 4y ago[dead]
- utst859 4y ago[flagged]