17 ms·
What is permaculture? (2015)
- viraj_shah 4y agoI am surprised and not surprised to see this here. I often see themes of burnout, wanting to get back to nature, existential questions surrounding tech and similar here on HN. I took a permaculture class earlier this year, after having researched it on the sidelines for a few years. It started from looking at sustainability, agriculture, homesteading (wanting to "leave it all behind") and blossomed into a wonderful learning experience about a philosophy where I felt a little more at home. It was great. It introduced me to a few really cool friends whose values largely aligned with mine. Anyone interested in this, please feel free to reach out.
- qubex 4y agoPermaculture is one of the ideas that fascinates me most.
- qubex 4y agoWhat course did you take, and where, if I may be so intrusive… you did mention to “reach out” if interested! I also arrived at being fascinated by the concept by ideas of sustainability and “getting away from it all”.
- oh_sigh 4y agoIf you follow the link to his homepage in his profile, there is a link to book a 30 minute meeting with him.
- Jedd 4y agoSearch for people running PDC's - Permaculture Design Courses - in your area. These are variably well monitored / established syllabus, usually run for 5 days or so. I'm sure there's one-day intro courses, but I suspect you'd get a lot more variability, and obviously a lot less value. Most practicing permaculturists I've bumped into tend to eschew the woo, as it were, but you may want to validate that before signing up to any particular course. (These branches of study can attract certain types of people.) I did a PDC here in Sydney AU about 15 years ago, and like GP I found it a hugely interesting and engaging process. (The one I went to was run by a lass who had studied under Bill Mollison, which was kind of funky, but as a rule the material covered is much more practical, rational, etc - than deferential / by association to the two guys that kicked it off.)
- viraj_shah 4y agoApologies for the late reply. I have set my limits on HN use in the settings. :) I took Permaculture New York PDC class (https://www.permaculturenewyork.com/ https://www.permaculturenewyork.com/). It was all online but many are in person. If you reach out to me via LinkedIn (found if you go to link in my profile) we can exchange contact info. I'd prefer not to place it here.
- tremon 4y agoI don't think it has necessarily to do with burnout, or even with the more general notion "city-dwellers feel detached from nature so they romanticize it". Apart from that, there is also the entrepreneurial spirit (as well as the hacker spirit) of wanting to do things yourself, either because you think you can do better or because you want to decrease your reliance on others. And those are very well represented here.
- viraj_shah 4y agoI agree with the entrepreneurial DIYer aspect of it. But I do think sitting in front of screens all day screams for a longing for nature. Also I think there might a counterculture aspect to it, which ties in to your reliance point. Growing your own food is one of the most subversive thing you can do. Get solar and a few other things, and you're completely self-reliant. It allows one to take a shortcut to the fisherman life, in the fisherman and the banker story.
- baremetal 4y agoI am currently building a permaculture farm. Continuing to dig out a pond here in about 30 minutes.
- kubb 4y agoGetting into permaculture is great, you just need a piece of land. You won't be able to feed yourself just from your balcony. And contrary to what some people believe, it matters what kind of soil you have how much water, and what climate you're in. I'd honestly just quit my job and do that, a shame that my partner couldn't be further from that desire for a different life.
- Gordonjcp 4y ago> And contrary to what some people believe, it matters what kind of soil you have how much water, and what climate you're in. This is what the "but we don't need to farm animals, it's a waste, we can just eat the plants instead" crowd don't get. You can't eat the kind of plants you can grow, where people grow plants to raise animals.
- phreeza 4y agoIn principle it is right that it makes sense to use animals to get the optimal amount of calories out of marginal land that can't be used to directly grow edible plants. The current state of agriculture is very far removed from that optimum though.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoThis is a half-truth at best. The places where you can only grow inedible crops are extremely marginal environments and they usually can't support economical densities. These are pretty unique environments like the northern plains and northern central Asia where only a small percentage of the livestock population lives. Even here, livestock are usually fed to the extent that the land can support and then additional feed is provided with crops grown in less marginal environments. For finishing, that's almost entirely human edible crops like corn, sorghum and oats (even if the specific varietals aren't considered edible).
- Gordonjcp 4y agoOr, you know, most of the UK, and in particular Scotland, where most of the farmland is hill grazing.
- roboben 4y agoMost fun thing about permaculture is the fact that no one is making money from actually applying it but rather just selling courses, books and other media. It’s funny since the first thing you learn about it, is that you don’t need to spend a lot of money doing it. Beside that, permaculture is nothing more than a framework for systems design. Can be applied to much more than your garden.
- 11235813213455 4y ago> no one is making money your comment makes me think of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35847327 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35847327 Permaculture is mostly about growing food for yourself and local friends
- wing-_-nuts 4y agoPeople joke about the fact that you're not really saving any money doing this vs buying the produce at the store, and they might be right, but it's not about the price of food, it's about learning the knowledge needed to grow your own. It kind of freaks me out that 98% of the US population would starve if our ag system seriously broke down. We could seriously use some resiliency there.
- badpun 4y agoMany permaculturists would probably starve too. It's pretty hard for a person with a backyard to consistently produce the 2500+ kcal needed per day, and also process and store it so that it's available outside of harvest season as well.
- blisterpeanuts 4y agoI think some of these folks who are on several acres, and who have poultry, cattle, pigs, and extensive gardens, will likely not starve. But life will be hard, once the fuel and electricity run out, even the ones who are totally off grid with solar and storage batteries. Just basic stuff like screws, pumps, pipes, tools, not to mention medical care, pharmaceuticals etc.
- 11235813213455 4y agoFor permaculture I first need land, and its expensive where I live (I can't go too far as I'm on 2 wheels without engine), so I'm still saving for a few more years before planting fig, persimmon, medlar, citrus, orange native trees, peppers, and all easy to grow things, and sleeping around that in a small box!
- mooreds 4y agoI took a permaculture course a while back and the instructor addressed that specific issue. He said (paraphrasing): you can buy really good tools and learn to use them, you can learn to identify and grow annuals and smaller plants, you can keep worms, you can observe and build invisible structures, all without land. Sure, keep saving to buy land, but don't forget it is something you can practice in the middle of the city too.
- CapstanRoller 4y agoHave you considered "guerrilla gardening" and repurposing wasted space around you? Buying a large amount of personal land is not a prerequisite. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guerrilla_gardening https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guerrilla_gardening
- 11235813213455 4y agooh, yes I'm a big forager, and making sure to spread the seeds around, where they have a chance to grow
- carapace 4y agoI first learned about Permaculture from reading my parent's copy of "The Next Whole Earth Catalog", which reviewed Mollison's "Permaculture: A Designers' Manual" (which, BTW is one of the greatest books on design that I've ever read, not just for farms!) So, to me, it's mixed up with things like Christopher Alexander's "Pattern Language", and Bucky Fuller's synergistic "Dymaxion" worldview. Basically, in a nutshell, there is a possible (technically and economically feasible) world that's much nicer than ours, just on the other side of an imaginary barrier that exists only in the human mind. Or so I believe... We can provide for ourselves the lower levels of Maslow's Hierarchy, "Physiological needs" ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs ) in a way that is fun, easy, harmonious with other living things, deprives no one, etc. "and nobody has to get nailed to anything". I don't know if this is true, but I don't see any physical reasons why it wouldn't work. (Everybody always says "but what about human nature" at this point, and I'll get to that in a moment.) I have finally, at long last, acquired some land with the express purpose of testing out this hypothesis. (Twenty acres in N. California.) I'm going to employ a mix of Permaculture, Syntropic Agriculture, Alexander's Pattern Language, Bucky's ideas, etc. and robots and automation to create a kind of bubble of this alternate reality, or a time-warp (just a little one) to the Star Trek-style future. Assuming this works out, the idea then is to facilitate more people and land living this way. I see this as a kind of economic phase change that has to happen (I believe we have to live in harmony with Nature or our civilization could collapse.) If this sounds interesting to you, and you more-or-less have your act together and would like to help out, let me know. sforman@hushmail.com - - - - In re: the "but what about human nature?" argument against the possibility of a better world: First, as I get older I get much less sympathy for that in general. Get over your bullshit and act like a decent human being. It's not that hard and the rewards are worth the effort. Second, I suspect that's what's really going on here: this is a sim, and the win condition is just not to be quite such a shithead. Good Character is the only thing you take with you when the game ends, so build it up now while you can! Third, even though they don't get a lot of fanfare in the mass media, there are numerous protocols and techniques for better communication and mental and emotional healing. Things like Non-Violent Communication, or the Core Transformation Process. I have high hopes that the new talking computers will make inexpensive, inexhaustible perfect therapists. I think the computers will talk us down off the ledge, so to speak.
- awhitty 4y agoI went to a small Montessori school on the Rio Grande while I was growing up, and among the other "new age"-y things going on at the school, we would spend half a day every week in permaculture class. We spent that class doing things like gardening, constructing adobe stuff like ovens and a gathering space shaped like a turtle (the head formed a pizza oven too - it was really cool), collecting eggs from a chicken coop, recycling fibers and scrap paper into (very brittle) paper, and making tea out of the herbs we grew - mint, chamomile, lavender, etc. One of the most profound memories I have from that school is of Ms. Susan teaching us to say "thank you" to the plants when we took a few of their leaves for the tea. We'd look at the plant, find some good leaves, pluck 'em off, and then say "thank you" and move to the next one. It was kind of an intimate moment to share with a mint plant haha. It was probably also very cute for the teachers to watch a flock of kids roam around a garden and stare intently at some herbs for an hour. It was the kind of thing that really sinks in when you're a kid. I didn't know it wasn't a "normal" kind of education, and I just figured, "we take our time and say thank you to the plants when take something from them" was a general rule of life that the adults follow too. I really cherish those memories now! Sometimes I thought they were boring af at the time - learning about compositing toilets isn't really priority #1 for a 9 year-old - but I hope other kids growing up are taught a similar connection to nature today. We've gotta say thank you to the plants!
- colordrops 4y agoDid they say thanks to the chickens as well?
- cjohnson318 4y agoWhy wouldn't you? Anyway, I don't think schools with farms in the US regularly harvest poultry or livestock for their students.
- colordrops 4y agoThey mention directly that they collected eggs from the coup.
- bovermyer 4y agoPermaculture is fascinating. I'm interested in how it behaves on a macro scale, though; what would happen to the wider ecosystem if you had a town full of permaculture lots instead of grass yards?
- tspike 4y agoI’d have a hard time thinking of a more wonderful experiment to run.
- photochemsyn 4y agoEvery estimate I've seen points to a minimum requirement of ~1 hectare of arable land to feed one human for one year (on a minimal vegetarian diet) and that estimate assumes highly productive soils and minimal crop loss due to insects, drought, or flood. The idea with permaculture is that you minimize (ideally eliminate) the need for fertilizer, herbicide and pesticide imports using effective composting and crop rotation (biological nitrogen fixation) and integrated pest management (raising insects that eat crop pests etc.) and water recycling systems and so on. Scaling this approach to tens of thousands of acres for reliably feeding even a medium-sized city seems challenging, but there appear to be some 1000-acre permaculture farms out there. However, yields are likely to be lower per acre with this approach as practices like using high fertilizer imports to allow double-cropping don't fit the permaculture model.
- throwawaaarrgh 4y agoIt's worth noting that permaculture is not just about farming or homesteading. The point is mostly to have a balanced ecology that humans can live in. You can still have large farms, small farms, or no farms, and do permaculture. The big mistake we made was building large cities that required moving or reshaping the land, water, animals and plants to support large cities. There really should not be this many humans in the world, and certainly not with as many huge cities as we have. We're becoming a species dependent on a synthetic environment.
- kamray23 4y ago
- ankaAr 4y agoI will leave this here if you don't have "land" to grow your own crops. It is in Spanish. The guy is from buenos Aires, doing everything with our selling anything and recycling everything with permacultura in mind. As some of the comments said, it is more about how you see what you are doing in relation with others and why. https://m.youtube.com/@ElRecicladorUrbano/videos https://m.youtube.com/@ElRecicladorUrbano/videos
- markus23 4y agoGreat to see that Permaculture is on-topic on Hacker News! We are developing an app to make Permaculture easier https://permaplant.net/ https://permaplant.net/
- LikeAnElephant 4y agoFYI I get a security error when going to the https of your site. I get an Apache message when going to http. Can't wait to check it out though once it's up!
- markus23 4y agoThanks for noting! https://www.permaplant.net/ https://www.permaplant.net/ should give you the landing page.
- pantalaimon 4y agoInteresting, there is also https://wiki.ecohackerfarm.org/powerplant:start https://wiki.ecohackerfarm.org/powerplant:start
- markus23 4y agoIs unfortunately inactive, see https://github.com/Ecohackerfarm/powerplant/issues/116 https://github.com/Ecohackerfarm/powerplant/issues/116 https://www.permaplant.net https://www.permaplant.net is alive and kicking!
- 1827163 4y agoI just discovered composting using Oyster mushrooms (Pleurotus Ostreatus). It can handle food waste and also human/animal waste too. It colonizes the waste really fast when it's warm. No need for a septic tank. Yes I have a small hut in the woods, with electricity and Internet via fiber optic cable from a house nearby. There's a waterproof WiFi access point mounted outside the hut on a pole, with a surprisingly long range. Recovering burnout victim here too, by the way.
- cjohnson318 4y agoWhat's your climate like?
- 1827163 4y agoI live in the United Kingdom, summers are quite warm with most days above 20C, winters ~10C or so, rarely you get frost.
- woile 4y agoInteresting, I grow Oyster mushrooms from used coffee beans. I really like giving an extra purpose to so many beans consumed.
- 1827163 4y agoI have a whole 70 litre dust bin that contains spawn and waste organic matter, and it's all turned white and fluffy as the mycelium has colonized everything. And once it's full I can then use the mycelium to start even more colonies on collected tree leaves and branches. It kind of grows exponentially in size. I just keep producing more and more of it.... When you grow large quantities of mycelium this way, it generates its own internal heat, I've found it to be warm inside. So that makes it grow faster than it would if it were at ambient temperature. Also the large amount of spawn easily overruns any other fungi that might contaminate the bin, such as green mold, before it has time to spread. The oyster mushroom fungus is a very aggressive colonizer which will eventually outrun green mold with time, but this can take a while.
- zeroCalories 4y agoI've always been wary of the permaculture community. Firstly, a lot of the things advanced by them are simply not scalable to the entire human race. They will say stuff like "it's practically free to have all this free food I grew on my lawn", while ignoring the massive amount of labor they put in, the waste product that they managed to scavenge, and the infrastructure they pay little to no taxes for. It's not even clear to me that "Big Age" is even a bad thing, seeing that their massive economies of scale allow them to produce more for less(money, environmental impact) than smaller farmers. Failure to realize this lead to the dumb memes about how global supply chains are supposedly bad, without realizing that having many small factories around the world would actually be more environmentally harmful than shipping products to where they can best be processed. I'm sympathetic to fears about long term sustainability and skepticism about globalism, but I generally don't like the type of stuff they advocate for. I generally agree with calls for increased regulation and a reduction in waste though.
- throw8383833jj 4y agothere are many things that absolutely are scalable to the entire human race, at least outside of the city. Permaculture asks nothing of you but your effort. The "massive amount of labor put in is what's needed to produce that amount of food. It's only in rich countries where people can produce food for much less labor (by working a high paying job and buying the food at the market). there are many countries where people are much better off growing their own food, rather than working at a minimum wage job and buying the same food. You should watch John Jai on Youtube. He's in thailand a country where the GDP per capita is a fraction of the US and yet he has more land, 3 small paid off huts and enough food to raise 4 kids all with plenty of time left over to read books. "Life is easy" he says, not bragging about his riches but rather to let people know about an alternative way of living.
- zeroCalories 4y agoI agree that permaculture might be an option for some people, but the difference isn't gdp, it's that there are no productive things to do in many of these low income countries. If their economy advances enough they'll find that working a job provides more for them.
- antoniuschan99 4y agoFor space constrained you can stack oem aerogarden clones on a bookshelf next to the window. It’s great for lettuce, herbs, and tomatoes.
- cyberax 4y ago"Permaculture" (n) - growing things in your garden to eat alongside supermarket-bought food, while pretending to be a good green farmer. Reality bites. You simply can not grow enough calories to feed yourself, in a way that scales to the whole planet. Or even a significant part of the planet. You need staple crops such as beans, potatoes, wheat that are not fun to grow. You need fixed nitrogen and likely phosphorus for fertilizer, unless you happen to live on a very good soil.
- awavering 4y agoThe vast majority of permaculturists don't do it with the goal of 100% self-sufficiency. Interdependence is part of the game.
- cyberax 4y agoHow would "interdependence" help? If anything, it makes it even worse. Growing enough staples even for yourself and your family is hard, growing it for trade is even more complicated. Try it, and pretty soon you need to actually do real agriculture.
- awavering 4y agoInterdependence with larger agricultural systems. Grains are great to grow at scale and I'm glad I can buy them in a grocery store. Tomatoes are great to grow at home and I'm glad I can do that too.
- eggsmediumrare 4y agoIt's a better use of space than manicured grass.
- awavering 4y agoAlso, beans and potatoes _are_ fun to grow.
- WinLychee 4y agoBeans and potatoes are fairly easy and fun to grow? They are very "set it and forget it" and produce a lot in one season. Although if they get infected with some kind of fungus or virus, that could put you at risk of starvation if you haven't planned ahead. As a plus, the beans should help introduce nitrogen into the soil via the bacteria that grow on their roots.
- vram22 4y agoI had posted this comment on HN around 3 years ago, on a related thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24827234 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24827234 Some people appreciated it, and one person said it gave them a lot of material to work on (downthread). I was only reporting on the work of other well-known permaculturists and regenerative farmers , although I have an interest in permaculture and had done some organic gardening for a few years earlier. But that work I had done (literally hands-on) gave me some background and perspective to be able to think about their work as they talked about it through their videos, which is why I decided to post that comment.
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- mythrwy 4y agoI'm suspicious of permaculture because I had a friend back in the early 2000s that got into it with a local group and it seemed almost like a cult and they didn't produce enough food to feed a couple of hamsters that I saw. He did buy all the Mollison books and talked about how he was going to get land and hire people to do the work. I never figured out how he was intending to pay the people with the 20 gallons of persimmons he was optimistically going to get. I'm an agronomist by training so it was especially irritating arguing with him having been around at-scale food production, and this went on for months as he was totally obsessed. There are some interesting theories in it. Like catching water on a hill with terraces. Which people did in earlier times and maybe still do in certain parts of the world. A lot of things that people living a simpler life found out a long time ago presented as a "system". My takeaway though is that (as practiced anyway) it's a bit of an culty scam, but there are worse ones and people being outside and around nature and growing things is in sum a good thing in my opinion so maybe I'm being a bit harsh. Anyway, I don't know everything, but it just doesn't seem practical at any scale to provide calories. I'd probably feel better about it had I not heard this guy's impractical cultish preaching for months. I hope he is doing fine wherever he is and got his land in the end.
- mercutio2 4y agoI lived for many years on a commune where we strived to grow most of our own vegetables, and I always got a very culty vibe from permaculture folks, too (pot, kettle, some might say, but I distinguish cults and communes based on how welcome differing ideas are). Mostly because they seemed so didactic about it: oh yes, sure you're growing vegetables for yourself, but you're doing it wrong, not observing principle X or Y. Christopher Alexander adherents were always my favorite visitors, they'd talk about patterns as they understood them and ask questions about whether they applied. Somehow the permaculture folks all gave off a my-way-or-the-highway kind of vibe.
- modo_mario 4y agoWhilst I love this kinda stuff I have to admit describing things as systems and the like felt extremely buzwordy as if to make people feel like it was deeper than it actually is. I also feel like a good few of the things people did seemed like things invented or perpetuated by influencers so they could keep yapping on about something. Vermiculture is something I do for example. It makes no sense from a time/ effort perspective on a small scale compared to other composting methods but I liked that what i got out of it as amendment for my potting was at least weedfree by virtue of my own sorting and went trough it all relatively quickly. If I had to restart on my plot I wouldn't bother but hey it was fun and whilst a good part of of my garden is extremely productive I also grow some stuff that takes waaay too much effort for what I get out of it just for fun. But people are out there taking it to extremes without any second thoughts about whether it works and swear by it and end up dogmatic about things like compost teas. All fine and dandy when it's a little hobby but when it becomes more than that I hope most can differentiate between actually useful things and barely usefull gimmicks pushed by people selling more books and courses than veg.
- mountaintimefrm 4y agohttps://soilandhealth.org/wp-content/uploads/01aglibrary/010175.tree%20crops.pdf https://soilandhealth.org/wp-content/uploads/01aglibrary/010... this is the way
- morog 4y agoPermaculture is a balm to the soul for techno-jaded coders. Having visited locations in N California, UK, Spain & South Africa there is clearly a strong appeal of natural systems design for technological systems designers. In a sense, designing a living environment is like coding. Maybe you're a full-stack developer and you want to terraform your land - run the digger routine to build some swales and ponds. Sprinkle in some pioneer species functions to structure the sub-soil and add nitrogen and provide shade. Run the groundcover script to stop evaporation and erosion and plant a few fruit trees. Then add whatever framework of your choosing for creepers, vines and berries. Start some background processes of mulching and compost turning (this is a sweaty function), maybe add a worm bin for your kitchen and food waste. Then just watch your biological programme running, the plants, birds & bugs and it is good. .................. Maybe permaculture isn't going to feed the world, but there are some important takeaways: 1. Focus on perennial plants. If you have a garden or land and you don't have lots of time or energy, don't waste your time with annual vegetables instead plant perennial food plants and trees...too many to mention but good, hardy, high producing options are granadilla (passion fruit), mulberry, pecan (and other nuts depending on your location), rhubarb, kale, spinach, ginger, figs, lemons and other citrus. 2. Never leave soil bare. "Nature abhors a vacuum" so weeds will grow, mulch any exposed dirt or plant a groundcover. 3. Observe the edges between everything, that's where the magic happens. Create more 'edge', in other words instead of a perfectly round pond, make an irregular pond with protected areas for critters to breed in. Instead of a straight path, have some curves. 4. "The problem is the solution" probably the most popular permaculture saying there is, but a useful concept. If you have slugs and snails in your garden you don't have a snail problem, you have a duck deficiency. Got ducks to eat the snails? but pong their pond smells...this is a problem, but its also the best fertiliser water you can get to put on fast growing plants so its the solution to your fertiliser needs.
- fogzen 4y agoIt’s sad how many people here cannot see the world through any other lens but money made on the market. The fundamental issue with our environmental crisis is externalities. Chopping down every tree and strip-mining the planet is not a good idea just because it’s profitable in market terms. Growing food 100 years from now is important. An ecology that supports human life 100 years from now is important. More important than whether you can get rich from depleting natural resources.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoWas about to say... Some comments marvel that the techies on this site know what dirt is, I see the comments and think it attracted among the worst takes I've seen. "But can you make money from it?" "Check out my permaculture app!" "It doesn't scaaaaale!" "Permaculture is like coding, it's also a solution you can slap onto burnout so you can get right back to coding!"