3 ms·
Friends who worked for google seemed to be rewarded for new groundbreaking stuff, but were penalized for maintenance or saving money or anything having to do wi
by m463 4y ago
Friends who worked for google seemed to be rewarded for new groundbreaking stuff, but were penalized for maintenance or saving money or anything having to do with the present.
but "shipping the org chart" really explains a lot of tech good and bad.
When sj was at apple, product was well-integrated software and hardware (as he ruled the org chart, which left no space for rivalries and fiefdoms)
with every sh*tty iot device that phones home, marketing in the org chart makes for a monetized, not-private mess for customers.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ethbr0 4y agoIt seemed like Jobs at Apple and Gates at Microsoft avoided a huge amount of organizational bullshit via a technical fleet-in-being doctrine. [0] Even if their time and attention were finite, they inspired a credible worry throughout the company that they might suprisingly appear and demand answers on why a team is @$&@ing up tech / UX, as PMs/VPs rightly asked themselves "Do I want to be explaining my behavior to X?" Which seemed to tamp down on the amount of inter-fiefdom rivalries and wasted time. I don't get the impression many people are worried about Pichai breathing tech/ UX fire from on high in the same way. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fleet_in_being https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fleet_in_being
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoI think it's that what Microsoft had in the 90s and what Apple had in the 2010s (and to some degree now) was an existential clear mission. Forking off into idiocy was obviously discouraged by leadership but also the profit and survival and success motive was clear: ship improved iPhones and make revenue on them, improve and ship Office or Windows, etc. That's the source of revenue, that's the clear mission. Google's consumer products lack that. Google has an ad machine that just produces seemingly infinite cash. The hardware and consumer facing stuff is a sideshow. So it escapes project discipline.
- hnfong 4y agoAt least OSes and phones have intrinsic value, and the leadership can lead with that mandate alone. For Google, it's hard to pretend to be the Good Guys when your main (and only) business is monopolizing internet ads.
- crazygringo 4y agoThat's not the problem at Google -- Google's issue isn't tech/UX competence at all (when they want to, they're stellar at it). To the contrary, Google culture (including, presumably, Pichai's views) is explicitly to try lots of competing ideas within Google and to disrupt from within. What other company would have Gmail and (previously) Inbox, multiple music services, a gazillion messaging apps, and so on? This isn't a failure of management or accountability, this is consciously chosen policy at the highest levels. Resources go towards self-disruption by launching more new things in the same category, rather than choosing to focus on one and committing to it. This is why people are promoted for launches rather than for maintenance and support. The upside is that Google launches way more products and could dramatically up its odds of success in a category. The downside is products fail because they don't get the support to see them through, consumers are totally confused by redundant products, and Google gets a reputation for cancelling products which might actually hinder future adoption (at least in some tech circles). Obviously Google still seems to think the upside outweighs the downside... while many on HN come to the opposite conclusion. :)
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoThey're just rolling the dice over and over again trying to repeat the blow-out self-sustaining revenue success they had with AdWords. And it will never happen.
- ethbr0 4y agoHistorically that's was Google's approach, but now it seems like a weird Frankenstein mash of that+strategy. E.g. the topical buying Nest, but then force folding it into Google Home That's the opposite of letting the best solution among competing options win. The broader issue is that it doesn't seem like there's a CEO who shows up in the Google Home's team meeting and live demos the broken and missing features, shows them on Nest, and then demands answers for why this wasn't done before they forced migration. As has been quipped on here, Pichai seems to act more like a Google advocate who avoids rocking the internal boat, versus the rabid user advocate that Gates / Jobs / Bezos reportedly were. And when there's no one you're afraid of at the top... of course the organization devolves into petty fiefdoms and bickering, at the expense of users.
- marcosdumay 4y agoFrom the outside, Microsoft seems to have a complete undivided focus on the customer. It may be on helping, or it may be of fucking the customer, but it's on the customer. That makes it impossible to ship their organogram. Apple seems to have escaped it mostly by centralizing power, but I don't think they are currently keeping it.