9 ms·
Someone tried copyrighting all the possible pop music melodies. "Most pop melodies run fewer than 12 notes. If you generated every possible melody with just the
by Animats 4y ago
Someone tried copyrighting all the possible pop music melodies. "Most pop melodies run fewer than 12 notes. If you generated every possible melody with just the eight notes of the C scale, that’d be 8^12 melodies, which is 68,719,476,736." So they generated all of them, as MIDI sequences, and stored them on a hard drive.[1][2] Arguably, all those are now public domain.
That was back in 2016. If you applied machine learning to pop music, you could probably establish a classifier for melodies that don't sound awful, and get that number down into the millions. Spotify has about 100,000 uploaded tracks. The space of listenable pop music may become fully populated. It would be amusing to have something that classifies songs as "Standard melody #67426564".
[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2020/02/whats-the-point-of-writing-every-possible-melody/607120/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2020/02/whats...
[2] https://journals.library.columbia.edu/index.php/lawandarts/announcement/view/297 https://journals.library.columbia.edu/index.php/lawandarts/a...
- bobsmooth 4y ago>Spotify has about 100,000 uploaded tracks. That seems really high and really low at the same time.
- dag11 4y agoI think they meant to write 100,000,000. I was about to say that sounds insanely low, because I have 15k songs "Liked" on Spotify and there's no way I've liked 15% of practically all songs. https://newsroom.spotify.com/company-info/#:~:text=over%20100%20million%20tracks https://newsroom.spotify.com/company-info/#:~:text=over%2010...
- chha 4y agoEven 100.000.000 isnt all songs. There is still loads of music missing, with changes hppening every now and then as labels pulls specific band lineups not covered by their agreements with Spotify. There is nothing by eg The Blues Brothers outside the two movies and their debut album. Nothing by Spocks Beard prior to Neal Morse leaving the band. Other albums are stripped of specific songs because a guest artist wasnt part of the overall deal. There are probably countless other examples as well, and as artists are moving away from physical media completely I fear that entire artist will disappear in the future because they happened to be pulled from streaming services.
- oriolid 4y agoOn the other hand, there are countless recordings of the same songs by covers bands, different recordings of the same classical pieces, etc. https://forgotify.com/ https://forgotify.com/ should give a good idea of what the long tail on Spotify is.
- adamredwoods 4y agoThey did a great Tedx talk here, and the person effectively describes the problems that Sheeran has run into: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sJtm0MoOgiU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sJtm0MoOgiU
- jcelerier 4y ago> Spotify has about 100,000 uploaded tracks. Uh... That's off by an order of magnitude. 100 million tracks according to https://newsroom.spotify.com/company-info/ https://newsroom.spotify.com/company-info/
- delecti 4y agoThat's 3 orders of magnitude.
- Lerc 4y agoYeah but 3 is less than an order of magnitude, and we have already established that within an order of magnitude is acceptable. :-)
- CalRobert 4y agoLong scale clearly.
- Eduard 4y agoThat's 3 _decimal_ orders of magnitude.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jcelerier 4y agoHmm for me an order of magnitude when talking is 10^3, but checking online it seems like it might be a french thing
- mrguyorama 4y agoSomething related that might also catch you https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_and_short_scales https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_and_short_scales
- marktani 4y ago
- frutiger 4y agoEven if the claim that most pop melodies consist of 12 notes is true (which is dubious), the 8^12 number excludes variation in rhythm or the timing between the notes which can make a significant impact on the overall feeling of the melody. If you hum/whistle some pop song you know in your head, it is easy to see that the notes aren’t all equally spaced apart in time.
- croes 4y agoTake a popular song, change the rhythm and timing and wait if you get a copyright claim.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- maccard 4y agoA copyright claim doesn't mean you've copied anything. I can submit a DMCA takedown for any video on youtube by filling out a form [0] and it's fairly likely the video will be pulled. [0] https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2807622?hl=en-GB https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2807622?hl=en-GB
- croes 4y agoThat's my point. And if your plaintiff is a billion dollar company and your resources are limited, that's pretty scarry if you're in the right.
- itronitron 4y agoJapanese Cowboy by Ween. Listen to the song in it's entirety before visiting the wiki page :) https://youtu.be/-WJ7NMQyK2E https://youtu.be/-WJ7NMQyK2E https://www.ween.wiki/wiki/Japanese_Cowboy https://www.ween.wiki/wiki/Japanese_Cowboy
- telotortium 4y agoSeems pretty easy to identify the song it's based on to me (and the original composer even threatened to sue). The rhythm's also pretty similar though.
- quijoteuniv 4y agoPeople fish in the ocean and think that the fish is theirs. Huge companies do that and they act and profit as the fish is theirs. But isn’t the (now depleted) fish something that belongs to humanity. For popular music is so much you can pull out of the pond, in my opinion it can hardly be somewhere own property. Maybe a too advanced thought? When the white man landed in America they said this is ours, the aborigines reply. Yes, meaning this belongs to everyone and it is yours too. Can we transcend this ownership thing?
- jnsaff2 4y agoWhy would fish belong to the humanity? They are fish in their own right and belong to no one.
- rizky05 4y agoBelieve or not, ownership system is only applied to humanity.
- febusravenga 4y agoSearch for territorial bevahiors in animals.
- aksss 4y agoThe cat pissing on my front porch post this evening would beg to differ.
- jnsaff2 4y agoThe cat is the hoMEOWner.
- apeescape 4y agoWell, there is Tree That Owns Itself, and Son of the Tree That Owns Itself. See the Wikipedia entry: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tree_That_Owns_Itself https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tree_That_Owns_Itself
- bandrami 4y agoNote that "standard melody #3473" was literally exactly how European medieval church music was (and still is) categorized. There are 7 notes in the scale and certain rules that eliminate some possible sequences, but the space of possible canti firmi was finite and studied as a closed space by medieval music theorists.
- Sander_Marechal 4y agoGot any more information on that? It sounds enormously interesting!
- bandrami 4y agoOy... medieval music theory is such a huge subject that I couldn't begin to do it justice in a HN comment. The short version is that some time in the 9th century monks developed neumes, an early form of musical notation, to write down the chants they chanted at different times of the day. Medieval music theorists classified those chants according to the last note (what we now call the "tonic") and the most common note (what we now call the "dominant"). There were 262144 theoretically possible melodies (8 notes long, 6 possible notes, but some were rejected for music-theoretic reasons so the actual space was rather smaller) which could be indexed by their sequence in a collated list of melodies ("on the Sunday after Pentacost sing the 7th chant in the Lydian mode" or whatever). If I had to pick a "best-of" reading list, I'd say the 9th-century "Musica Enchiriadis", Berno's "Prologus in Tonarum", and Boethius's "De Institutione Musica". These all assume a familiarity with Platonic music theory, so at least skim through Plato's "Timaeus" first. There will also be more references to astronomy than will make sense to somebody in the modern age, because music and astronomy were believed to be essentially the same thing. Also more recent research has found that actual musicians of the time seem to have completely ignored the theorists. Some things never change.
- HeckFeck 4y agoNot quite the same, but related. In the 18th Century Presbyterian Church, they only sang Biblical psalms set to simple (but distinct) tunes and without any musical accompaniment. This was known as exclusive psalmody. The psalms weren't the prose-style you'll find in any print Bible though, they were their own translation called the Metrical Psalms. Its 1650 edition proved very long lasting. Many of these psalms were set to common metre, meaning that if you found such a psalter and tried singing it to some well-known tune it will very likely 'fit' the lyrics. You could try Psalm 23 set to the tune of The British Grenadiers, or Amazing Grace, or even The Star-Spangled Banner: https://thewestminsterstandard.org/psalm-23/ https://thewestminsterstandard.org/psalm-23/ This was actually how the psalms were practised by congregations in my home country. The psalm lyrics were considered too sacred for practice, so they set the same tunes to other (sometimes comical) lyrics and practised those during the week. Then on Sunday the minister would say something like 'we will now sing Psalm xx to the tune of lilies', and the congregation would know the tune even if they hadn't memorised the psalm lyrics.
- jimnotgym 4y agoWouldn't it be easier just to generate the notes onto a stave? Anyone trying to sue for breach of copyright will produce sheet music. But using the defence that a melody is public domain surely also invalidates your own copyright?
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoThe defence would be that you copied from the public domain to make a derivative work, the other aspects -- timing, lyrics, repitition, instruments used, etc. -- would be where your copyright lay. You couldn't successfully sue someone for using that sequence of notes on your melody (common ancestor) but could if the result shared your timing or other aspects; provided those choices passed the bar for making a creative work.
- BrandoElFollito 4y agoI think nobody linked to Axis of Awsome's 4 Chords Song yet. A good example of chords vs. songs: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pidokakU4I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pidokakU4I
- bmitc 4y agoI think this ignores what actually makes a pop song popular and a hit. It isn't the chord progression or melody, at least primarily. It is the marketing. Plus, I assume that major studios have already been using stastical-based software for decades to help craft songs to fit the current vogue. There's a reason why many songwriters and producers write songs for Kpop and state those songs could never be released in the U.S.
- CPLX 4y agoIt’s not the marketing. I worked in the business for 15+ years and was involved in a lot of campaigns for artists and music you’ve heard a lot. Everyone says this but once you get in the actual music business you end up seeing the vast amount of stuff that gets the exact same amount of marketing, checks all the boxes, has all the right people and money behind it, and goes absolutely fucking nowhere. You realize very quickly it’s not really about the marketing. People get to decide what music they like, and do. That doesn’t mean bad music doesn’t get popular. It does. You just don’t like the taste of the massive number of people that enjoy it. I get it I can’t fucking explain Pitbull either. I want it to be a conspiracy.
- idiot900 4y agoIn other words, marketing is necessary but not sufficient. What percentage of non-marketed artists hit it big? If equal to the marketed artists, why spend the money marketing?
- lebuffon 4y agoStandard rules of business normally apply to anything sold. 1. Product gotta be good enough to compete with other similar products 2. Price low-price, middle or premium, but it needs to fit the category 3. Place make it easy to find and purchase 4. Promotion tell the people who need this thing, all about it If any of these are wrong you don't get market success. But there are a lot of non-linearities. Old Marketing joke: "I know half of my budget is not working, I just don't know which half"
- 4y ago
- aksss 4y ago> “But Riehl and Rubin’s point, they say, is not actually to obtain legally sound copyrights, but to illustrate that there are a finite number of ways to combine notes to create pop melodies, and these combinations existed before any songwriter actually put them to paper. All of these melodies can be generated and represented mathematically, suggesting that writing the melody for a pop song is, in some ways, a lot like selecting and portraying a pre-existing—and non-copyrightable—mathematical fact.” Some deep concepts right there. Would the same thing apply to any sequence of things? The AACS cryptographic key? The words in a book? Is there some breakpoint in number of permutations where human creativity and memorable history allow for copyright?
- denton-scratch 4y agoA melody has rhythm and emphasis; it's not just a permutation of a group of notes.
- PinguTS 4y agoEmphasis is regarded as an interpretation of the notes. Interpretation doesn't invalidate the claims of the original author according how copyright is currently applied. It's like interpreting Shakespeare. You can emphasis this sentence over that one, and this word over that one. It is still Shakespeare.
- SideQuark 4y agoThat ignores rhythm and chords which are important and distinct. Also given current court rulings stating such non-creative computer generated things are not copyrightable, it's irrelevant to copyrighted music.
- happymellon 4y agoJust because they aren't copyrightable doesn't mean that we can use them as prior art if we publish them all, does it?
- SideQuark 4y agoNot generally. Prior art works like that for patents. For copyright the courts generally allow copyrights on things created independently of an existing item. So it's likely the whole exercise is worthless at affecting any future copyrights.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoIt's a neat idea, but copyright protects against copying, if someone copies your work, even if your work is derived from the public domain, then you have reasonable grounds on which to sue. You'd have to have added something creative to the public domain melody, however. In short copying from the public domain does not make one's whole work public domain. This maybe helps against specious claims? It may be useful to consider how Pantone's copyright on shades of colour relates; they don't get to sue people for using those colours (in general).
- topper-123 4y agoYes. A good example of this is “Love me tender” by Elvis Presley. It’s melody is from the mod 1800s.
- soco 4y agoPantone doesn't get its money from copyrighted nuance names. They get it from putting together and selling all the processes and chemicals which deliver you the exact same color over all thinkable media. How would this translate in the musical world?
- aikinai 4y agoLive shows.
- zzbzq 4y agoMy only nitpick is I don't think you need AI or machine learning for automatic music generation. Instead, we've allowed tastes to be so dumbed down you could achieve success with MIDI, a RNG and a couple of if/then statements.
- brookst 4y agoThis doesn't seem to account for rhythm and rests. I'm not good enough at permutations to get the right answer, buy it is a lot more than that. The notes C-D#-G-D are a totally different melody with each note varied between 32nd and whole note, with rests between them, and using triplets. I don't disagree with the point; independent constriction and collision are inevitable. But the math underestimates the space.
- lloeki 4y agowith a 4/4 (which is most of music is these days) there's only so much slicing you can do to have relative times between notes differ. There are also a number of things that change the expression but not the melody. eg Hallelujah vs Zombie: - have different melodies but use the same chords - can be sliced and diced both with various rests and palm mutes and arpeggios and strumming yet still have them individually identifiable (and sometimes very close, possibly even overlapping in some sections, but that's perfectly normal and how one does a good mashup) Even the time signature doesn't mean much, one could play Zombie on a blues shuffle and it would still be distinctively Zombie-esque. Throw in music theory and keys and I IV V and chords and whatnot which I still don't master but I get the idea, it severely reduces what one ought to do to compose something enjoyable. With that you can mathematically reduce you problem space to some extent. In any case it's all completely moot because fundamentally the creation process is a) ingest ideas, b) digest, c) excrete ideas, which ultimately come from a mixture of a). Everything new looks like something else to some extent, and there's a fundamental reason why artists are told (or themselves tell) they're "influenced by" this or that other artist. If we were to truly strictly enforce copyright nothing would ever get created anymore. So I don't know if copyright itself is right or wrong, but I feel copyright enforcement is truly fucked up these days (and not just in music) As a beginner composing in my living room I'm truly scared (on top of fear of inadequacy) to push something out there I put my heart and soul into and get sued to oblivion (or at the very least have it destroyed and claimed by some entity that is not even involved in creation)
- mrWiz 4y ago100,000 tracks seems like an awfully low estimate, how did you arrive at that number? Just as a spot check, I've liked ~6500 individual tracks, and it would be very surprising if that represented 6% of their total catalog - I'd expect that actual percentage to be orders of magnitude lower.
- bitdivision 4y ago[0] seems to suggest they have over 100 Million tracks. Perhaps OP meant to include a time period, like 100,000 tracks per month or something? 0: https://newsroom.spotify.com/company-info/ https://newsroom.spotify.com/company-info/
- gmiller123456 4y agoSo they generated all of them, as MIDI sequences, and stored them on a hard drive.[1][2] Arguably, all those are now public domain Not really though. If this were accepted as a creative work, then it also violates the copyright of every modern song. But, as exemplified the the story in the OP, where the author gets the idea from is really important. So, you could look a jury in the eye and say you were just browsing through a hard drive full of melodies and picked one that seemed good, but that likely isn't going to fly.