14 ms·
Carbon-negative concrete
- mchannon 4y agoMaking cement releases carbon dioxide in the conversion of flimsy calcium carbonate to sturdy calcium oxide by roasting it. Reversing the process by injecting carbon dioxide in curing cement is turning sturdy calcium oxide into flimsy calcium carbonate. Every pound of CO2 you sequester this way necessitates multiple pounds of CO2 released elsewhere to get that oxide to your construction site (production + transportation). The economics and carbon footprint are similar to corn ethanol- attractive and green if you pay no attention to the total balance. A corn belt politician I’d expect this from. IEEE should know better.
- Y_Y 4y agoI'm surprised a publication aimed at professional engineers thinks it could get away with a sleight of hand like that.
- mchannon 4y agoI doubt it's intentional. It's just the modern day equivalent of a perpetual motion machine or a "machine that makes water out of air" (dehumidifier). This particular subject matter area falls in a blind spot where electrical, chemical, and environmental engineering meet, and nobody gets rich pulling the rug out like I just did. I write about this in my book Fat Gas. Plenty of modern-day snake oil salesmen out there.
- anon4242 4y ago> a "machine that makes water out of air" Isn't that just your typical air-con unit?
- mchannon 4y agoExactly. But you will find dozens of examples in a google search of people who somehow think they've solved the world's water woes by collecting condensate off a disassembled A/C or dehumidifier, and ignorant uncritical news reporters buying it hook line and sinker. Collected funding, even had a whole embarrassing incident at Cal involving the freshman engineering class a few years ago. There is definitely a need for clean water out of air, but it's got some subtle limitations: you don't need it when it's already raining, and the further you get from that condition, the less well dehumidifiers work in terms of gallons produced per kwh consumed. Below 50% RH, you're getting bupkis for condensate. Most of that energy is spent cooling off air but not quite cold enough to get it to leave its moisture behind. Here's an easy thought experiment next time you run across one of these "inventions". If a cubic foot of air at 40% humidity contains .24 mL (sorry for mixed units) of water, give them the benefit of the doubt and say their setup is 100% efficient for pulling every last molecule of water out of air. and it runs on a 28cfm computer case fan. How many gallons per hour would that be? 0.1. The reason these suck is not that they don't work in dry conditions (though they don't), but that they don't move enough air to be useful.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThey covered a few products and techniques. Which one specifically are you talking about? The CarbiCrete one for example uses CO2 to cure the concrete, but doesn't use cement. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0959652616311374 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09596... > steel slag has shown the potential to replace cement as an alternative binder if carbonation activation is performed.
- mchannon 4y agoSince Elsevier is hiding the meat in that journal article, I can only go off what I read, but it looks identically flawed. • Compressive strength of normal concrete: 25-50MPa • Compressive strength of their slag concrete with 2h CO2 added: 12MPa • Compressive strength of their slag concrete with 24h CO2 added: 24.3MPa My takeaway: Using slag instead of cement = good idea. Using slag OR cement plus CO2 = bad idea.
- Faaak 4y agoBTW: You can access most scientific articles through sci-hub: https://sci-hub.ru/https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0959652616311374 https://sci-hub.ru/https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/art...
- digging 4y agoI'm following as a layperson, can you explain how to reach your takeaway from the bullets presented? It seems like #3 is almost identical to low-end normal concrete, so "good idea". Not sure what "24h" vs "2h" refers to though.
- Beltiras 4y agoDifference is that compressive strength generally decreases over time. Here we have a product where it increases over time. Changes the equation on how you build and maintain it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- henearkr 4y agoIn this new process, it's not the cement (by its classical definition) that is cured by the CO2 in the air, it's the calcium-enriched biochar. Thus the cement part is still sturdy, and the biochar part avoids making it flimsy because this calcium treatment enhances its binding with the cement. It looks like the main problem with previous experiments with biochar added in cement was that the biochar did not bind well, making a crumbling result, but this article is about solving precisely that.
- mchannon 4y agoThe article claims "[t]his calcium carbonate strengthens the biochar" but this runs counter to my understanding and I'd like to see some numbers, particularly versus alkalized biochar that is never exposed to CO2. How important is binding in compression (which is what concrete is used for)? Not very. Carbonate doesn't strengthen, it weakens. And if forming carbonate in biochar strengthens versus standard biochar, I would imagine forming oxide in biochar would strengthen even more.
- henearkr 4y agoNo, the full quote is "This calcium carbonate strengthens the biochar and helps it bind better with cement, giving strong concrete." The binding part is very important. It holds grains between them. For example that's the difference between a hard granite and a crumbly, sandy granite rock (that's called "decomposed granite"). It's day and night. And I also believe them that the treated biochar is stronger than the untreated one. Maybe if the same process was used to treat the cement itself it would be a disaster, but here that's not the case. What do you mean "forming oxide in biochar"?? The oxide of biochar is CO2. Are you trying to make fun of me heh...
- mchannon 4y agoCalcium hydroxide is an extremely weak base in practice, and wouldn't oxidize carbonaceous materials if your life depended on it. But I could see it depositing in biochar as Calcium Oxide. A physical mixture, not a chemical reaction, is what I meant.
- blurbleblurble 4y agoWhy does it have to be either or? Aren't there plenty of use cases for the concrete with less compressive strength? Stuff like floors and walls of smaller buildings could be perfectly fine with the 25 MPa, couldn't they? Patios? Foundations of smaller buildings? If there's a good amount of stuff that doesn't need the higher compressive strengths, I'd think there could be some decent potential to offset with this stuff. Applications that really need higher strength wouldn't need to use this carbonized stuff.
- lostlogin 4y agoFor some of those scenarios, couldn’t concrete be abandoned altogether? Wooden building work pretty well, though forestry has plenty of its own problems (see New Zealand and it’s series of slash disasters).
- readthenotes1 4y agoChina, by far the largest user here, builds very tall vacant buildings with concrete. Wood can only take you so high
- hinkley 4y agoWith manufactured beams it can take you higher than you think, but building codes need to be adjusted.
- blackflame7000 4y ago[dead]
- peterashford 4y agoSlash is an issue of bad practices. It's fixable with better management and isn't an inherient feature of forestry
- tristor 4y agoThere's need, and there's expect. Unless you expect every homeowner or other property owner to do expensive and destructive testing prior to a reconfiguration, remodel, or bringing in heavy semi-stationary loads onto their property, it's somewhat critical that concrete behave like concrete regardless of its initial use case. A simple example is in my previous home when I had a section of the master bedroom closet partially walled around a Class C TL-30 rated firesafe, and the room partially reconstructed with ballistic armor in the walls and a vault door, to turn it into a safe room for valuables + home protection. The safe had a weight of nearly 9000 pounds in a footprint of 64 by 30 inches on the floor. I was only able to do this because the house was a slab on grade construction and we knew the footing depth and slab thickness of the concrete would handle the weight. If this had been some sort of "eco concrete" it would have cracked and eventually failed under that weight, and we would not have known this because the slab thickness would have been the same. P.S.: Since everyone always asks because it's hard to find actual safes (most "safes" are garbage RSCs), it was custom built by a local safe-maker and expect to pay $$$$$. The safe I had installed was $35k, and that didn't include the room tearout/rebuild or the vault door, just the freestanding safe that went into the room.
- Mystery-Machine 4y agoTransportation can be carbon neutral. So you can remove that from equation. At least there are many ways people are trying to reduce transportation carbon emissions to as close to zero as possible.
- moffkalast 4y agoIt can be. But is it? Will it be any time soon? Isn't the Tesla Semi the only EV truck on the market and isn't being produced in any major quantities yet? It'll probably be decades before any of those reach your average concrete production site where they're still using trucks from the 90s.
- zardo 4y ago> Isn't the Tesla Semi the only EV truck on the market. At this point, I don't think anyone that makes a heavy duty truck doesn't sell an EV version. Volvo started selling an EV concrete mixer this year.
- vel0city 4y agoThere are many truck manufacturers shipping trucks today. The Teslas that Frito Lay received weren't their first EV trucks, they had been operating EV trucks before they received the Teslas. https://www.teslarati.com/daimler-freightliner-ecascadia-penske-deliveries/ https://www.teslarati.com/daimler-freightliner-ecascadia-pen... https://afdc.energy.gov/case/404 https://afdc.energy.gov/case/404
- throwawaylinux 4y agoEven if you buy carbon neutral electricity, increasing the demand for it will end up increasing carbon positive electricity production (in the large scheme of things). And we'll ignore carbon to manufacture the truck and create and maintain the roads, warehouses, and other transport infrastructure.
- vel0city 4y ago
- manojlds 4y agoCould you give some links on claim on ethanol mixing not being a great alternative?
- mchannon 4y agoFirst one's on me, the rest you can pay for, or google: https://e360.yale.edu/features/the_case_against_ethanol_bad_for_environment https://e360.yale.edu/features/the_case_against_ethanol_bad_...
- rch 4y agoI don't immediately see any claims that this material is fit for all purposes regular concrete would be. The first application that comes to mind for me is an alternative to styrofoam-fill insulating concrete forms. Biochar sounds like an improvement vs even waste diverted styrofoam.
- cultureswitch 4y agoWhy do you write like Yoda?
- xchip 4y agoSpot on, and add you say, IEEE should know better
- krick 4y agoWeird to assume IEEE or any other large enough organization that has people being paid money to write posts on the internet (i.e. PR dept) is somehow different from "corn belt politicians" and won't be pushing the same agenda. The main point of doublethink is that people that are not good at it, are not allowed to speak publicly anyway, so it's kinda besides the point if some random engineer has problems evaluating how come that worse concrete is better concrete.
- hosh 4y agoIt would be interesting to see if: - this concrete formulation is self-healing like Roman concrete - Whether that absorption property is dependent on other factors like heat (our cities create a heat island effect) - Whether adding in things like rebar give rise to any unexpected interactions
- photochemsyn 4y agoThe best options appear to be replacing the heat source that drives the calcination step for making cement from limestone with either an electric plasma arc furnace or green hydrogen, both sourced from solar/wind inputs: https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/11/the-road-to-low-carbon-concrete/2/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/11/the-road-to-low-carb...
- hannob 4y agoReplacing the heat source only solves around 1/3rd of the problem. Most emissions come from the calcination, aka the conversion of CaCO3 to CaO and CO2.
- photochemsyn 4y agoCapture the CO2 from the calcination and make diamond out of it?
- cptskippy 4y agoMaybe it's my misunderstanding but isn't concrete usually prepared local to the construction from ingredients like cement that are shipped in from remote locations? > To get around that problem, the duo first treated the biochar with waste water that was produced during concrete production. Is the waste water from biochar-cement based concrete suitable for use in creating subsequent batches of biochar-cement? How feasible is it to capture this waste water from producing the concrete and ship it back to the cement factory for producing cement?
- ThorsBane 4y agoThis is really amazing news. This in addition to rapid global adoption of renewables at the present rate are remarkable and encouraging breakthroughs.
- dylan604 4y agoHate to burst your bubble of excitement, but just today (or over the weekend) Texas is in the news for the wrong reasons (yet again, and no guns involved in this particular news). Legislation is being pushed to encourage natural gas and slowing down wind/solar. New regulations to place annual permits on wind farms because of the blight on the scenery type excuses. The people are gas lighting the public (pun intended) to the point that they blame renewable energy for the failures of the gas plants during the '21 freeze and the public is accepting it. So in Texas, discounts for fossil fuels, extra fees for renewables.
- palata 4y agoThis, plus the fact that nothing remotely competes with fossil fuels. The simple fact is that after fossil fuels, we will have less energy, and there is no silver bullet: we need to start doing less with less energy, and stop hoping for a technological breakthrough that will save us. Bad news is that we still have enough fossil fuels to finish screwing up the climate.
- gregwebs 4y ago> Finally, he adds, biochar is made from “biomass that otherwise will be landfilled where it releases carbon dioxide, or methane, which is a stronger greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide.” I thought biochar is a carbon stable form that is in demand as a soil amendment?
- Sharlin 4y agoBiochar is simply charcoal with some specifics as to how it's made, and charcoal is just pyrolysed biomass.
- waldothedog 4y agoYes. The quoted line is saying that NOT using the materials to make bio char would mean losing the 100 years of carbon stability, and instead generating methane if dumper into landfill.
- dumpHero2 4y agoHere's a VOX video about this problem, pretty cool! : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=asLWBGtAhZk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=asLWBGtAhZk
- betimsl 4y agoBOOM! -- with ONLY one move, world is getting better and better everyday! I know this sounds idealist, but, They should make this patent free to all.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- clnq 4y ago> A startup called CarbiCrete is also developing carbon-negative concrete. Instead of cement, the company uses waste slag from steel-making in its concrete mix, and uses carbon dioxide captured from industrial plants to cure the concrete. One downside is that the concrete has to be pre-formed and cannot be poured and set on site. What a big obstacle to adoption — too many building techniques rely on on-site pouring, I hope they can engineer some solution.
- yetihehe 4y agoI've used a lot of prefab concrete blocks for my house. For foundations - big concrete bricks, for ceilings - big prefabricated long strips with rebar. Of course, not all, but it's most of concrete used in my house. You could also make small pavement bricks from that, it doesn't need to be poured in place and uses noticeable amounts of concrete, it's used a lot in Europe.
- Sharlin 4y agoMost multi-storey buildings are made from prefab elements at least where I'm from. Making those carbon-neutral would be a big deal, even if the concrete couldn't be used for bridges and whatnot.
- tastyfreeze 4y agobiochar != charcoal Charcoal is black carbon produced by incomplete combustion of ligneous material. Biochar is charcoal that has been filled with nutrients, bacteria and fungi.
- jdmichal 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biochar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biochar > Biochar is the lightweight black residue, made of carbon and ashes, remaining after the pyrolysis of biomass. Biochar is defined by the International Biochar Initiative as "the solid material obtained from the thermochemical conversion of biomass in an oxygen-limited environment". You may be thinking of biochar specifically as a soil amendment, where it is sometimes loaded with probiotics and such: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biochar#Soil_amendment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biochar#Soil_amendment > She pointed out that when pre-charged with these beneficial organisms, biochar promotes good soil and plant health.
- tastyfreeze 4y agoCharcoal has been the word used for "the solid material obtained from the thermochemical conversion of biomass in an oxygen-limited environment" far longer than the word biochar has existed. Biochar is a portmanteau of biological charcoal. It also looks like the quote from the biochar wiki page is a near copy from the charcoal page. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charcoal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charcoal There is plenty of confusion over the word "biochar" even among gardeners that use it. It is always pre-charged before adding to soil. Adding raw charcoal will rob the soil of all nutrients and kill plants. Yay pedantry!
- throw0101b 4y agoVox recently had a good video on the topic: * https://www.vox.com/videos/2023/4/20/23691222/cement-carbon-emissions-concrete-net-zero https://www.vox.com/videos/2023/4/20/23691222/cement-carbon-... * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=asLWBGtAhZk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=asLWBGtAhZk
- mbfg 4y agoFor those wanting to know more about concrete and cement, Veratasium has a newish video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rWVAzS5duAs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rWVAzS5duAs
- hannob 4y agoIt seems that there is now an increasing number of startups and researchers trying some form of completely unusual cement production to lower the carbon footprint. This is in principal a good thing, but... I can't help to think that such overhyped reporting isn't helpful. Concrete will not be caron-negative any time soon. This is very early research. It's good that it's being done, but it should also be clear that this is very far away from an industrial process that can be used for real.
- dheera 4y agoWhat if the lifetime of the building is considered? Don't concrete buildings presumably last much longer in the face of fires, tsunamis, and other disasters? Whereas entire towns of wooden houses get ravaged by fires every year in California? Speaking of which, is there any possibility of making a brick that is 80%+ carbon (for the purpose of sequestration) and non-flammable? Like some sort of low-cost carbon fiber brick?
- MobiusHorizons 4y agoCorbin fiber != co2. Carbon fiber is unburnt carbon. It is pretty heat resistant, but is still flammable under the right conditions. I’m not sure how you would use that for sequestration. Ideally you would want the co2 to bind to a solid chemically so you get better density of co2 storage. I suppose you could just fill cavities in a brick with co2 gas, but that would store very little carbon dioxide and runs the risk of leaking back out.
- stronglikedan 4y agoIf Veritasium is to be believed, we use more cement than any other substance apart from water, so imagine the impact that lowering the carbon footprint of concrete, even just a little, would have. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rWVAzS5duAs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rWVAzS5duAs
- porkbeer 4y agoHe is not.
- broguinn 4y ago> Biochar is made today by heating waste materials like wood chips, rice husks, or *water-treatment sludge* at high temperature in a low-oxygen environment. Holy shit.
- hinkley 4y agoI don’t see if they way where they source the biochar. I think ultracap people switched to bamboo biochar for superior structure. There’s probably a different trade off for structural materials. Say poplar or Osage orange.
- AgentOrange1234 4y agoI love the privacy policy. We will do whatever we want, we don’t respect DNT, you cannot opt out. No thanks IEEE.