5 ms·
> And the internet used to be more work to experience. Today, it’s more work to avoid. Since the author likes analogies, I'll add mine: the internet now has be
by JKCalhoun 4y ago
> And the internet used to be more work to experience. Today, it’s more work to avoid.
Since the author likes analogies, I'll add mine: the internet now has become roads, bridges, towns. The internet used to be forests, rivers to ford, camps.
There used to be an exploration-aspect to the internet, not sure what you would find if you took this trail or that one. Now we all seem to travel the few, well-worn roads to the same handful of destinations.
I do like the internet-as-reference-book internet where I can quickly solve a programming problem that is stymieing me. I would keep Wikipedia, the Internet Archive, Stack Overflow.
Outside that though I do prefer roads less taken.
- chrbutler 4y agoI like that analogy!
- htag 4y agoI'm also fond of the internet-as-public-square paradigm. All news worthy events are posted in it. There's sections of the square dedicated to classifieds and vendors. There's a spot with chess sets. Yes, there's also some people on soap boxes yelling into the crowd. I can usually ignore them just fine.
- fsflover 4y ago> The internet used to be forests, rivers to ford, camps. https://wiby.me https://wiby.me
- gspencley 4y agoThat's a good analogy. I like technology and modern cities in the abstract. They provide people with easy access to certain things that were historically scarce. Some of those things are life saving, like cutting edge medicine. But I can't live in a city. I hate the noise, the crowds, the people, the crime, the pollution and the vast majority of the time I'm not in any sort of immediate need for what they provide. Fine for the odd Saturday adventure one or twice a year. Any more than that and no thanks. I always come away feeling stressed out, anxious, tired and worse off for the experience. Ironically, online shopping and remote work is what has made living in a city unnecessary.
- gonzo41 4y agoI describe it as, the internet of books and text became the internet of videos and music. Not better or worse just different.
- reaperducer 4y agoI describe it as, the internet of books and text became the internet of videos and music. Except that the internet never was books, and was only text due to technological limitations. When we started networking all the computers together, we (myself included) had this vision of an information utopia where everyone would be able to access all of the information previously locked up in books, magazines, and newspapers. But that never really happened. Instead, people started making new content — the faster, cheaper, and lower quality, the better. The old content remained locked up in libraries. Some of it managed to move behind paywalls, but the vast majority of the information — and lessons — learned in the last 500 years has been forgotten because it's not free and easy to access. We had this naïve vision that with everyone online, people would rally around the best of what humanity had to offer, and we'd all be exposed to the planet's best art, literature, music, and knowledge. Instead, we got mostly the exact opposite of what we set out to build.
- ghaff 4y ago>the vast majority of the information — and lessons — learned in the last 500 years has been forgotten because it's not free and easy to access. I guess I don't really agree with that. Yes, a lot of very detailed information (and primary sources) about things is in research libraries, at least some of which are not open to the general public. But that doesn't mean all that information is lost. A lot of historical information is accessible to the (admittedly relatively small percentage of) people willing to put the effort into digging it up.
- pixl97 4y ago> had this vision of an information utopia where everyone When it comes to new technology and the impact it will have people are almost always wrong. The printing press not only made better books, it created oceans of shitty ones. We didn't have https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law at the time to warn us.
- moffkalast 4y agoIn that sense, HN at least feels like a village up in the mountains. With lots of trails leading into less travelled forests around it...
- chrbutler 4y agoI like that, and you're right. I find that discussions in the comment of HN articles almost always tell me something I don't know. Sometimes it feels like secret knowledge :)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- StrictDabbler 4y agoI recently googled something like "modal fabric weave diagram". On my phone I was given five places to buy modal clothing and a message that "x other similar results have been omitted". I persisted, I rephrased. I was asked if I was a robot, I clicked on CAPTCHAs, and now Google is willing to give me some results that are relevant to textile design but I still haven't been able to find out what weave patterns are common in modern modal fabrics. On my work computer Google knows I'm an engineer so it gives me papers on visco-elastic properties of the fabric but it's not actually processing my query well and giving me weaves, it's just saying "I guess you're fancy and technical, huh?" In 1997 there would have been a text/image website with forty diagrams of various weave patterns and it would have come up in the top twenty results. I would like a little more 1997 in my internet, please.
- Minor49er 4y agoYou might have better luck using a search engine like Fireball https://fireball.com/ https://fireball.com/
- pixl97 4y agoIn 1997 there wouldn't have been 50,000 spam responses in the query. In 1997 there would have been some place that made it, or someone interested in it that would have made the site for their own interests in spreading the information. Today there are countless entities looking to scrape a penny from your view in any way possible, and will create an ocean of spam in order to capture that revenue. At least with search engines we cannot go back. That internet is dead. Any new system you create to bring back the old internet will attract the previous group because your system would be valuable, and like parasites, they will steal value from your system.
- marcosdumay 4y ago> In 1997 there wouldn't have been 50,000 spam responses in the query. If what the GP wants exists, and none of the given options are any bit similar to it, why do you think the amount of spam is relevant? If Google couldn't find a real thing between a mountain of invented low quality content, you would have a point. But Google keeps pushing unrelated results instead.
- visarga 4y ago> I would keep Wikipedia, the Internet Archive, Stack Overflow. I'd be very sad to lose YouTube. It's the jewel of the internet.
- bsder 4y agoExcept that it's not. YouTube is a giant hole of suck that brings everybody else down to their level. YouTube being subsidized has driven any competitor out of the space. Since YouTube has a monopoly, your content will get copied and posted over there even if you don't give permission. Since YouTube is backed by Google, they are larger than lawsuits which could bring them to heel. If you wanted YouTube to improve, split it out from Google again.
- visarga 4y agoMaybe splitting YT is a good idea, but even with all the junk YT still is a jewel. There are incredible things in there - art, lectures, philosophy, so much value packed inside.
- specproc 4y agoI don't disagree that YouTube would be better off away from Google, nor that it's a monopoly, but in terms of content it is magnificent. Vintage films, tutorials for the most niche practices, 4K videos of exotic locations, a better music selection than Spotify: all at your fingertips on one site.
- selfhoster11 4y agoYouTube is the modern-day video library of Alexandria. Yes, there are many negatives to it running the way it is, but it's undeniable that such a powerful gathering of information resources is available only on their platform.
- bheadmaster 4y agoThese days, the internet is more a city from a cyberpunk movie where everything is covered with ads, everywhere. So much that some of use filtering glasses to hide ads from us. Tracking devices are everywhere and your every move is recorded and stored in a database of a company that produces very realistic sounding androids. Oh yeah, and anyone with enough holodeck processing power can make an artificial video of you saying and doing anything they want.
- agumonkey 4y agoIt's always like that. New space is .. new space. It's unknown, sometimes almost empty, sometimes dense.. you never really know what to expect. There was a natural aspect to it, that people who wished to spend time would discover wild things, and not organized boring monetized stuff. Of course people wish for a little bit of help, then someone provide it (Google, later facebook) and the magic starts to fade away. No more strange shores.. it's urbanized, with robbers and scammers, fluff and administration to "protect".