3 ms·
> So what exactly is his "warning" about? Not sure about this particular one, but in general, this sort of warning is along the lines of "If you continue expe
by lelanthran 4y ago
> So what exactly is his "warning" about?
Not sure about this particular one, but in general, this sort of warning is along the lines of "If you continue expending effort in subverting the spirit of the law, we shall tighten the regulations to such an extent that it will hurt you".
The world and their dog knew what the goal of the regulations were: if the goal is not met because "Apple has a lot of lawyers and presumably they're following the law as written." you can expect the law to be rewritten in a way that is punitive to Apple.
- chrisandchris 4y agoProbably, yes. But that will take another 5 to 10 years, so nothing to fear about. It took the EU 9 years from "advocating for a common charger" [1] until they regulated it. There's enough reason to believe that it'll take them a couple of years to adjust the law. [1] https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20210920IPR13170/common-charger-a-long-awaited-proposal-requested-by-parliament https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20210920IP...
- crazygringo 4y agoThen it's very childish. It's the responsibility of legislators and regulators to be clear and precise -- to mean what they say and say what they mean. To "punish" a company for following a law, because of something the law doesn't actually say, is not what rule of law means, and would be a shameful thing. No company should have to intuit or guess what the government "really" meant, over and above what the law actually says. The EU can go ahead and revise the law, giving companies time to adapt again. That's fine -- that's how it's supposed to work. But some kind of "warning" to "do something we didn't say in the law" is just plain wrong.
- DangitBobby 4y agoAre you arguing that Apple didn't understand the spirit of the law? Or that technicalities are more important?
- madeofpalk 4y agoOn the other hand, lots of companies could have avoided regulation if they just did the 'right' thing in the first place
- gtirloni 4y agoAll laws have corner cases that are not covered. All laws. If laws were to cover every imaginable situation, they would be huge. Some already are... you have a whole bureaucracy working to understand them. That's why you often hear about the "spirit of the law" where humans know pretty well what the legislator is trying to accomplish, even though it's not fully codified in subsequent rules.
- crazygringo 4y agoThis is simply not true. Laws can be written exceptionally clearly, and very often are. And the "spirit of the law" is a fallacy, which your sentence exposes when you write: > "the legislator is trying to accomplish" Because yes, there is absolutely intent with a single legislator. But there is no such thing as intent or spirit for a legislature (or committee). A legislature can pass a law, say 51 to 49, where every one of the 51 majority legislators has a different intent for passing it. And this isn't even the exception, it's the norm -- laws are hashed out in subcommittees as inelegant compromises because each legislator wants a different thing out of it. Legislation that gets passed has no "intent" and no, humans don't know "pretty well" what was trying to be accomplished, because it's a compromise between competing wings/individuals of a party or coalition, and the only "intent" that they could decide on was what got written in the law, and nothing else. Again, the "spirit of the law" is a fallacy. It's an illusion people would like to believe, but it doesn't exist.
- lelanthran 4y ago> Again, the "spirit of the law" is a fallacy. It's an illusion people would like to believe, but it doesn't exist. You might want to tell that to multiple judges who rule daily on the spirit of the law. TBH, I don't think that you know how the law works better than judges and magistrates do. You know what a loophole is, right?
- crazygringo 4y ago> TBH, I don't think that you know how the law works better than judges and magistrates do. TBH, I don't think you do either, but I also know that kind of argument isn't useful here on HN. > You know what a loophole is, right? Yes, it's a layman's term that has no real legal meaning, and exists only in the eye of the beholder. What one person calls a tax loophole, another person recognizes as policy that a subset of legislators ensured existed in a bill. You think tax loopholes are there by accident?
- mort96 4y agoClarifying what the spirit of the law isn't "childish". Law isn't software. Judges always take the spirit of the law into account when making decisions, and precedence is as important as the actual written text. This is true in both the US and the EU.
- lannisterstark 4y agospirit of the law is not the actual law however. "Spirit of the law" carries 0 consequences, nor does anyone have to follow the spirit.
- mort96 4y agoThat's not true. Judges consider the intent. Law is not software. I found this on Google from Cambridge: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/judgment-and-decision-making/article/letter-versus-the-spirit-of-the-law-a-lay-perspective-on-culpability/910A080D1AF2F6817589C2C79CBBD1DD https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/judgment-and-decisio... > Study 4 illustrated the importance of breaking the spirit above and beyond the letter, as individuals can incur culpability when breaking the spirit of the law even without breaking the letter
- AYBABTME 4y agoThis depends on the legal system. Not all legal systems are like the US, some have different burdens and put those burdens on different parties.
- iudqnolq 4y agoBut this isn't punishment. It's a warning. Apple is getting advance notice that they can either voluntarily comply or they might be required to comply in the future. Would you rather be surprised?
- stale2002 4y ago> But some kind of "warning" to "do something we didn't say in the law" is just plain wrong. No. Acting in bad faith is what is wrong. If Apple doesn't like it, then they can shut down their business in the EU. Companies acting in bad faith should be explicitly punished, to an extra degree, that is intentionally designed to hurt them. We have this right, to use laws, in a society, to punish bad faith actors. If you don't like it, then vote for something else (you'll lose that vote though, lol) or leave the country.
- plandis 4y ago> No. Acting in bad faith is what is wrong. Do you have explicit evidence that Apple is acting in bad faith or are we merely inferring this?
- nixass 4y agoHave you even read the article? It's right there, second paragraph
- stale2002 4y agoImplementing a USB C cable, that works better on apple specific chargers, without giving that functionality to competitors, is bad faith, and against the purpose of the law. If they end up pulling back on the plan to do this, then the warning worked.
- Dylan16807 4y agoNot for sure, but if they aren't planning weird cable locks then they can ignore the warning. And if they had been considering them but already cancelled the plans, whoever got them cancelled gets proven right.
- jasonm23 4y ago>Then it's very childish. Indeed, it is, reacting to legislation, by trying to circumvent it. Say making "Apple Certified USB-C" connectors / cables which do nothing other than force consumers to pay $50~ for a cable which costs under $1 to make. Then FUDding the community about _dangerous unauthorized cables_ from CHYNA!!!. Yeah it's childish, unethical and anti-consumer. So ya, know, Apple's SOP for quite a number of years.