4 ms·
They didn't give an argument for the status quo, they gave an open-ended argument based on danger being bad. But the correct tolerance for danger is not zero,
by Dylan16807 4y ago
They didn't give an argument for the status quo, they gave an open-ended argument based on danger being bad. But the correct tolerance for danger is not zero, so proving something is dangerous is not enough.
For a car comparison, it's easy to argue that going faster is less safe, but that's not enough to explain why a speed limit for a road is specifically 35mph, and doesn't tell you if 35mph is correct for that road. Maybe it should be 25mph or 45mph.
The rest of their argument is making a bunch of assumptions with no evidence shown. They're assuming that the current line is exactly enough to determine the level of danger to the point that you can get informed consent. They're assuming that the current line is an exact match to what's ethical.
But maybe that's not true. Maybe the FDA is 50% too lenient. Or maybe they're 50% not lenient enough. This commenter is failing to make a case for the current regulations being just right. They're making a strawman about changing the regulations a huge amount, jumping all the way to nearly unchecked experimentation. Of course that's bad, but that's not what the neurosurgeon actually said.
- foldr 4y ago>This commenter is failing to make a case for the current regulations being just right. I don't think they're trying to make a case for the current regulations being just right. The point here is very simple: 1) X is unethical. 2) This guy said they'd do X if it wasn't against FDA regulations. The key point about X is that it's unethical. Whether or not FDA regulations are perfectly calibrated is beside the point.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThe problem is that they're making the claim that X is unethical with zero information on what X is. In this case X is undefined and could be anything that is not currently permitted. If you claim that X is always unethical, and the only fixed characteristic of x is that it's not currently permitted, then there are only two solutions: (1) You think that the current rules are a perfect match for ethics OR (2) anything that violates a rule is unethical.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> I don't think they're trying to make a case for the current regulations being just right. That's sure what it looks like to me when they say "Wanting to do early experimentation, that is currently only allowed to occur on animals due to safety concerns, on humans is definitionally unethical and especially dangerous. We banned it because it is unethical and especially dangerous in basically every case." "definitionally unethical" based on what is currently allowed. So FDA regulations are a cornerstone of that particular argument. And as I elaborated upon in my previous comment, their only other argument is a one-sided "that increases danger" argument that isn't enough because it also applies to things that are ethical.
- foldr 4y agoI’m confused. The part of their comment you quote isn’t making a case for the current regulations being just right. It’s not even saying that, let alone trying to make a case for it.
- Dylan16807 4y agoIf wanting to do something the regulations disallow is definitionally unethical, banned because it was unethical, then either the regulations are exactly correct wrt ethics or they are actually too permissive. Right? How else can I interpret that? And can you quote any argument they've made for the experiments being unethical that doesn't either: A) base the argument on current FDA rules B) assume some kind of extreme example like "so experimental we can't even explain the danger well enough for informed consent to be possible" I would be interested in a discussion of specific issues with specific possible experiments but I don't see that happening anywhere. Just someone taking the neurosurgeon's words and interpreting them in the most extreme way possible.
- foldr 4y ago>If wanting to do something the regulations disallow is definitionally unethical... Here's what they actually said: "Wanting to do early experimentation, that is currently only allowed to occur on animals due to safety concerns, on humans is definitionally unethical..." I don't know why, but you are just persistently misreading or misinterpreting the OP's comments. If you actually read the rest of the OP's comments, it's completely obvious that they don't think that the current regulations define what's ethical. They very explicitly say that what's ethical and what's in accord with the regulations are two separate things, and even give a hypothetical example to illustrate this.