5 ms·
This type of romanticization of military production is obscene. One of my worst fears is that we might see the current military campaigns surrounding Iran and
by ilaksh 15y ago
This type of romanticization of military production is obscene.
One of my worst fears is that we might see the current military campaigns surrounding Iran and the area around it develop into another "great" war.
There is nothing stopping us from using this manufacturing equipment to build tools of creation rather than destruction.
I remember reading something in my history textbooks many years ago that suggested that although war meant massive loss of life and destruction, it wasn't all bad, because it was "very good for the economy". That line of thinking only holds water if you believe that humans are disposable or buy into a sort of 19th century Social Darwinism.
There is so much money to be made in war. Please, everyone look at a map. http://binged.it/A6U96Z http://binged.it/A6U96Z These activities in Afghanistan, Iraq, Egypt, Libya, Syria, Yemen, Saudi Arabia, etc. are not isolated instances.
This is an aggressive war of domination, resource acquisition and territorial control. It is completely insane and inexcusable.
- Mongoose 15y agoAgreed. Was disheartened to read that the machine's primary use in the coming years will be to build JSF planes instead of infrastructure for new light rail networks.
- rpeden 15y agoAt least that fact that it was refurbished and continues to be used means that when the time comes (and it will), the US will have the equipment it needs to produce most of that infrastructure itself.
- mjwalshe 15y agoWell a bus on train tracks aka a tram doesnt require realy heavy plant and train track arnt made that way.
- jws 15y agoThe JSF was just an example. With a 30 cycle per hour rate it should be obvious that JSFs can't be a primary use. They make a lot of critical parts for commercial airliners. Parts where a high strength to weight or volume ratio is critical are the candidates for such an expensive process. I suspect most of the output is in aircraft, spacecraft, turbine blades, and possibly other machine tools. The journalist had to pick one that people would recognize.
- rpeden 15y agoI think you are reading too much into this. I didn't see any romanticization of military production - just a fascinating description of a very interesting piece of engineering. The article specifically mentioned that the press is used to create parts for commercial aircraft as well.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- bluekeybox 15y ago> One of my worst fears is that we might see the current military campaigns surrounding Iran and the area around it develop into another "great" war. I am a supporter of American world domination through preferably peaceful means, and think that criticism of social Darwinism was mostly misdirected, but your fears are not at all unfounded. Back in the 19th century, Bismarck famously said, "One day the great European War will come out of some damned foolish thing in the Balkans" -- we all know what happened next.
- maratd 15y ago> This type of romanticization of military production is obscene. If you study history even on a superficial basis, you'll find that violence only breaks out in asymmetric situations. In other words, only when one side is thoroughly convinced it can kick the other's ass. The best way to prevent war is through trade. The second best is to make sure both sides engage in "obscene" military production and are evenly matched. Weapons are merely tools. If deployed intelligently, they can be used to mitigate any violent impulses and keep the peace.
- ilaksh 15y agoRight, weapons are tools for peace. Of course they are. How ignorant of me. This type of thinking and other similar viewpoints indicate a strong likelihood of another world war. Realistically, it has probably already started in a way. Does anyone own a nuclear-proof bomb shelter? Seriously, I am looking for a place to hide.
- batista 15y agoThis type of thinking and other similar viewpoints indicate a strong likelihood of another world war. Yeah, but why should they care? A war for a sufficiently advanced country such as US just means some place thousands miles away getting bombed, and a small percentage (compared to the enemy) of professional soldiers getting hurt. In other words, they have no f/n concept of what war actually entails and the toils of a country at war. Well, the budget might be hurt a little, but that's it. Whereas even the budget of the other small country will be totally devastated by a war.
- a_a_r_o_n 15y agoMaybe. But there's a certain amount of risk in two sides pointing loaded guns at each others' heads. Let's hope trade succeeds.
- trevelyan 15y agoI was under the impression that most prolonged conflicts prior to the 20th century involved well-matched opponents: Greek city states, Rome versus Carthage (except possibly the third Carthaginian war), the Three Kingdoms period in China, and practically all of European history post 1648. Then in the twentieth century alone we start with WWI and WWII (the German military did not view the war against the Soviet Union as winnable), and end up with a great number of proxy wars in the mid-East and Asia. The trade argument is strange considering that the world economy was more tightly integrated in 1914 than it is today. It is probably correct that nuclear weapons exert something of a stabilizing force, although it is disconcerting that the nash equilibrium for games of mutual-assured destruction requires random detonation by both parties in order to demonstrate irrationality and establish deterrence.
- icarus_drowning 15y agoI think you're reading into this what you want to read into this rather than what is actually there. Sure, this is being used to build JSF's, but really it is a romanticization of American production-- an antidote to the "nothing is made here" nonsense that has become popular these days. Meanwhile, I'm confused why you're so quick to start what will only be an incendiary political discussion that has nothing to do with the article at all. There are probably better forums than HN to post essays about U.S. military and foreign policy.
- sliverstorm 15y agoI find people with an agenda will do their best to warp anything remotely related to fit & promote said agenda. Man in uniform saved a kitten from a tree? Clearly pro-Iraq war propaganda. Etc.
- batista 15y agoMan in uniform saved a kitten from a tree? Clearly pro-Iraq war propaganda. Etc. Actually, sounds terribly like it. I.e not pro-Iraq per se, but pro-military in general. Those kinds of images are used all the time, especially in countries heading or involved in wars. Also the "soldiers doing cool things", "soldier playing guitar back in the camp and longing for home", "soldiers having some innocent fun between attacks", and the "soldier is a regular guy from some place back home", etc. They are used in order to make the military personnel look humanize, and in effect humanize the war effort. (Of course, that's not to say that soldiers aren't human: just that this has nothing to do with them being soldiers. Everyone is human -- but war is dehumanizing and makes you do dehumanizing things).