3 ms·

Has anyone done an in-depth comparison between Locutus and Bluesky? https://github.com/freenet/locutus https://github.com/freenet/locutus

by ilaksh 4y ago

quaintdev 4y ago
Examples of what can be built on Locutus include: - Decentralized email (with a gateway to legacy email via the @freenet.org domain) - Decentralized microblogging (think Twitter or Facebook) - Instant Messaging (Whatsapp, Signal) - Online Store (Amazon) - Discussion (Reddit, HN) - Video discovery (Youtube, TikTok) - Search (Google, Bing) Bluesky is just a decentralised social media.
- bovermyer 4y ago
  ...email is already decentralized, though.
  - gkbrk 4y ago
    Email is federated no? Can't really email you if gmail bans you or goes under, or your domain is taken down somehow. But maybe with a decentralized email it's possible to email pubkeys directly.
    - geekodour 4y ago
      gmail email is centralized. hosting your own email server would make it decentralized? I am not sure what makes things "federated".
      - gkbrk 4y ago
        Because if you host your own email server, the email address has a domain or possibly IP address to point at your server. But getting domains, or getting IP addresses are both centralized. If you gave your email address to someone, you cannot change it on their devices. Your domain registrar with DNS for the domain case, or your ISP for the IP case, can stop email deliveries to you or redirect them somewhere else. With a decentralized email, people email "you". Not "your username" on Google's service, or your username on a domain you rent from others, and not your username on an IP you rent from a centralized authority.
        checkyoursudo 4y ago
        How do you prove your you-ness without some sort of centralized authority in this case? Or, alternatively, how do I know how to send an email to only you?
      - Xelynega 4y ago
        I think they mean from a user perspective. As a user I can create an account with a provider(be it google or myself), but I can't migrate that account without leaving a forwarding address at the original address. The alternative would be storing the user data on a distributed data structure(like a pki network or distributed hash table) so that it's not tied to a single provider.
        deleted 4y ago
        [deleted]
- wesleytodd 4y ago
  It is my understanding that the at protocol has the building blocks for alot of these use cases as well. So while yes bluesky the app is just a micro blogging social media, the protocol should be able to do the rest.

Has anyone done an in-depth comparison between Locutus and Bluesky? https://github.com/freenet/locutus https://github.com/freenet/locutus

by ilaksh 4y ago

Has anyone done an in-depth comparison between Locutus and Bluesky? https://github.com/freenet/locutus https://github.com/freenet/locutus

quaintdev 4y ago

Examples of what can be built on Locutus include: - Decentralized email (with a gateway to legacy email via the @freenet.org domain) - Decentralized microblogging (think Twitter or Facebook) - Instant Messaging (Whatsapp, Signal) - Online Store (Amazon) - Discussion (Reddit, HN) - Video discovery (Youtube, TikTok) - Search (Google, Bing) Bluesky is just a decentralised social media.

bovermyer 4y ago
...email is already decentralized, though.
- gkbrk 4y ago
  Email is federated no? Can't really email you if gmail bans you or goes under, or your domain is taken down somehow. But maybe with a decentralized email it's possible to email pubkeys directly.
  - geekodour 4y ago
    gmail email is centralized. hosting your own email server would make it decentralized? I am not sure what makes things "federated".
    - gkbrk 4y ago
      Because if you host your own email server, the email address has a domain or possibly IP address to point at your server. But getting domains, or getting IP addresses are both centralized. If you gave your email address to someone, you cannot change it on their devices. Your domain registrar with DNS for the domain case, or your ISP for the IP case, can stop email deliveries to you or redirect them somewhere else. With a decentralized email, people email "you". Not "your username" on Google's service, or your username on a domain you rent from others, and not your username on an IP you rent from a centralized authority.
      - checkyoursudo 4y ago
        How do you prove your you-ness without some sort of centralized authority in this case? Or, alternatively, how do I know how to send an email to only you?
    - Xelynega 4y ago
      I think they mean from a user perspective. As a user I can create an account with a provider(be it google or myself), but I can't migrate that account without leaving a forwarding address at the original address. The alternative would be storing the user data on a distributed data structure(like a pki network or distributed hash table) so that it's not tied to a single provider.
      - deleted 4y ago
        [deleted]
wesleytodd 4y ago
It is my understanding that the at protocol has the building blocks for alot of these use cases as well. So while yes bluesky the app is just a micro blogging social media, the protocol should be able to do the rest.