4 ms·
The Waymo approach has proven itself. Targeted testing, running the driver in hard mode as much as possible, is better than the Tesla approach. Tesla’s plan was
by jeffbee 4y ago
The Waymo approach has proven itself. Targeted testing, running the driver in hard mode as much as possible, is better than the Tesla approach. Tesla’s plan was essentially “machine learning underpants gnomes”. Collect ten billion miles of data from guys driving down 280 -> ??? -> profit. Didn’t work and now Tesla is recognized as being dead last in the game, behind dozens of no-name Chinese players.
Now what I wonder is whether Waymo has a durable lead over Cruise, or if Cruise succeeds alongside them.
- zaroth 4y agoWhat does “running the driver in hard mode as much as possible” mean? Why do you think Tesla’s approach “didn’t work and they are now dead last in the game?” Maybe that’s just an opinion because you provided nothing to back it up - but I can tell you not only does AutoPilot/FSD Beta work, the latest FSD Beta stack (I’m driving 11.3.6) works extremely well. Tesla has orders of magnitude more passenger-miles driven than any other solution, which is one quantitative way to gauge success. Tesla’s latest FSD Beta safety record on city streets is also excellent - 10x fewer accidents per mile than Cruise for example. This is another huge win for Tesla but it’s important to note that this is accomplished in part by requiring strict driver oversight (enforced through gaze & attention tracking in the cabin camera). So the significantly lower accident rate is not an apple-to-apples comparison of two L4 solutions, but it convincingly shows that their L2 solution is actively making the city and highway roads safer for the driver and the cars & pedestrians that they are sharing the road with.
- dilyevsky 4y agoTesla approach is to grief their customers into paying for feature they have no concrete plans to ever deliver on (in the absence of lidar/radar sensors it’s a crapshoot) -> profit. Worked pretty well
- sidibe 4y ago> Collect ten billion miles of data from guys driving down 280 -> ??? -> profit. It's actually Profit -> Collect ten billion miles of data from guys driving down 280 -> ???
- hnburnsy 4y agoThe baby steps makes sense, but you gotta admit Phoenix has to be thr easiest metro area to test with: Little inclement weather, little terrain change, newer infrastructure, streets mostly laid out in an east-west, north-south grid with consistent naming and numbering.
- paxys 4y agoWaymo and Cruise have also been operating in San Francisco for a while, which is quite the opposite.
- jeffbee 4y agoMost of Waymo's hours are in simulation anyway, and that can be as hard as they want it to be. Waymo's meatspace test track is also nothing but edge cases. I understand that Tesla also learns in simulation.
- rvnx 4y agosimulation -> production
- bagacrap 4y agoHard mode would be anywhere that has snow.
- ra7 4y agoThat's probably the hardest problem. But I think you severely underestimate just how hard getting it to work in a place like SF (in rain and fog) is. To get to where they are is a serious accomplishment.
- ilaksh 4y agoI have always been a huge proponent of Waymo and obviously Tesla doesn't have something comparable to them now. But if you look at videos of recorded Tesla autopilot drives on Youtube you will see a huge amount of success in terms of getting people to their destination without crashing or killing anyone. And there is constant gradual improvement. If Tesla can get another 2-3% improvement, they may actually be able to launch a robotaxi service. The trick will probably be that you need to have a driver's license and sit in the front seat at first. But after X months they will probably allow sitting in the back, especially for certain vetted trip regions.
- gamblor956 4y agoTesla's advanced-driving systems (AP and FSD) lead the world in terms of deaths. It's not even close: Tesla has more fatalities than every other advanced-driving system in the world, combined. Even massaging the data in the light most favorable for Tesla, a Tesla is still 3x more likely to be in an accident resulting in injuries than the next worst advanced-driving system, and is more than 50x more likely to be in an accident causing injuries than Toyota's or GM's advanced driving systems. A 2-3% improvement still means that Tesla is the most dangerous advanced driving system on the roads.
- surfpel 4y agoDo you have a source for these claims? > Toyota's or GM's advanced driving systems What advanced driving system? Do you mean lane assist with adaptive cruise control? That’s not even remotely comparable.
- gamblor956 4y agoIt doesn't matter what advanced driving systems you compare; Tesla is the world's worst in terms of accidents, injuries, and fatalities. For sources: NYT and WaPo both have a series of articles covering this; the NHTSA has released a report documenting over 100 Tesla advanced driving accidents.
- 4y ago
- xnx 4y agoNot only that. Tesla thought they could do it (better!) with an inferior sensor suite.
- gonehome 4y agoThe argument was more that to do it generally you need vision to work, lidar will always be a narrow solution and redundant when you have vision. It might end up that solving the narrow city problem with high res maps is valuable enough to tackle anyway, but it could still be true that will never solve the general case. Of course, it could be true that Tesla was be unable to solve it also. Though at some point attaching some general intelligence to vision can probably do it. Likely will be bigger issues then though.
- unionpivo 4y agoJust because humans can generally do it without lidar and other sensors, does not mean that lidar and other sensors, would not improve human driving, if we could somehow integrate them seamlessly (and well reduce their price). A car equipped with more sensors, will always be better at handling more situations, than the one without them, no matter how "smart" their drivers become.
- fastball 4y agoI think the overlooked part is "seamlessly integrate". Signal to noise ratio is important, and it is not trivial to "just add sensors". I think the analogy of "too many cooks in the kitchen" applies here.
- fallingknife 4y agoLast based on what metrics? I've never seen anything better than the Tesla FSD except for the LIDAR robo taxis, but they are solving a very different problem with different constraints. Most recent cost estimate I can find shows a cost per vehicle of $130-150K for Waymo vs the Tesla system that needs to go in a vehicle costing $40-50K which makes using a Waymo style sensor suite impossible. Would be interesting to see how the Tesla software would perform with the sensor input of something like the superior Waymo suite, but we won't ever find out unless costs come down by a massive amount.
- xnx 4y agoSensors are following a really great learning curve, rapidly getting both more capable, more reliable, and cheaper. It's reasonable to expect they could be a few hundred dollars per unit soon.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoYour numbers are very outdated. Exact figures and targets aren't usually announced, but both Waymo has talked about their upcoming vehicle being designed around a cost/mile ratio lower than consumer vehicles. That's not possible without very reasonable production costs. Cruise has also announced a target production price for their vehicle of $50k at scale, which is around the price of a new Tesla. That's not apples to apples, but it's close enough.
- surfpel 4y agoTesla announced a 25k car. All of the numbers so far from every company are just speculation, though. We’ll see how things actually pan out.
- redox99 4y agoProven in what way? As a way to lose money? It's no surprise that it's easier to get to Level 4 if you have a 50-100k sensor suite, HD maps and a geofence. However, I wouldn't be shocked if, even if Tesla robotaxis arrive many years later, Tesla achieves profitability before Waymo does.
- sidibe 4y agoTesla's FSD had been very profitable for a long time already. To most of us that is not as impressive as operating actually robotaxis at whatever cost